Jack Bauer vs Walter White: Who's The Most Badass Character?

Everybody's favourite meth kingpin takes on the world's unluckiest government agent. Let the battle commence!

It's time for the showdown to end all showdowns, as two of the most popular characters in the history of TV - in the history of entertainment, even - face off to determine who is the most badass of all. With many decades and thousands of characters to choose from, it has come down to 24's Jack Bauer (Kiefer Sutherland) and Breaking Bad's Walter White (Bryan Cranston) and while each has a fair case as to why they're more badass than the other, it's to be decided (totally objectively) in this article. We're going to run down all the key areas, ranging from body counts to slippery escapes and awesome one-liners, and though Bauer might appear to have a head-start given how many more episodes there are of 24, we can't forget the massive impact Walter White had in his briefer 5-season run on our TV screens. As always, whether you agree or not, I'd love to hear your feedback and I look forward to arguing with you in the comments! So without any further ado, let's crack on.

10. Arch Enemies

Jack: It's basically Jack's life's work to create mortal enemies for himself and then dispatch them as creatively as possible. Season 1 saw him facing off against terrorist Victor Drazen (a preposterously-accented Dennis Hopper), before the finale revealed that Nina Myers was actually a mole, and she would be his true nemesis until her demise in season 3. Other than that, notable foes include two Mexican drug kingpins in the Salazar Brothers, a terrorist played by The Mummy, a rogue former buddy played by Robocop, and the corrupt President Nix-I mean Logan. If that's not enough, Jack has even had to bring down his own brother and father, as well as his old buddy and former colleague Tony Almeida. Walt: Tuco Salamanca was Walt's introduction into the violent meth world, and taught him a thing or two about the Hell-raising nature of the business. Walt's most famous and fierce enemy, however, was certainly Meth lord and fried chicken entrepreneur Gus Fring, who was not only a physical force to be reckoned with (due to his loyal army of cronies), but an extremely discreet, cautious and savagely intelligent foe. Season 5 saw the positioning of Lydia and Uncle Jack as primary antagonists, and of course, who can forget about Ted Beneke, who screwed Walt's wife Skyler and fell from grace so spectacularly? WINNER: It's a tough one, because Jack has clearly had more general foes to wipe out, but the deviousness of characters like Gus Fring (including Fring's longevity on the show) allowed the (anti)hero-villain dichotomy to be better built up. After all, each 24 season almost guaranteed to introduce a new villain, whereas characters like Gus hung around for multiple seasons, amping up the unpredictability, whereas it was almost always certain that Jack would come out on top. This one goes to Walt.

9. Body Count

Jack: According to those bothered enough to scan through every episode and count, Jack Bauer has killed 268 people on-screen throughout 8 seasons and a TV movie of 24. Though the vast majority of these kills are with conventional firearms, some of his more creative kills include the use of scissors, a hacksaw, explosive fests, a fire axe, a fire poker and even some good old fashioned fists. Walt: Breaking Bad has less than 1/3 the number of episodes that 24 has, yet Walt has still managed to rack up an impressive number of kills, even if it is on a technicality. Walt began the show as a man totally averse to killing, and was introduced to it when he was forced to strangle Krazy-8 with a bike lock in self defense. The real kicker came in Season 2 though when Walt became indirectly responsible for two planes crashing, by allowing Jane to choke on her own vomit, which in turn made her father Donald fail in his duties as an air traffic controller. All 167 aboard both planes died, and though it would never hold up in a court of law that Walt was responsible for the deaths, his actions in failing to save Jane resulted in a direct line of causation towards the crash. WINNER: If Jack's kills were almost always in the name of the bigger picture, Walt's were instead largely for his own survival, such as allowing Jane to die, or running over drug dealers, or ordering Gale's death. Still, the numbers speak the loudest, and Jack wins, but not by as much as you might expect.

8. Intelligence

Jack: Jack may be best known for his gun-toting and terrorist foiling, but he's also an extremely accomplished intellect, holding not just a degree in English Literature but a Masters degree in Criminology and Law. In addition to this, he speaks half a dozen languages, can fly helicopters and planes, operate any weapon thrown at him, and due to his 15 years of experience in the Army, is a master strategist as far as warfare goes. Walt: On the other hand, Walter White is a graduate student of Chemistry at the California Institute of Technology, and some of his work helped a team to win a Nobel Prize in Chemistry. Granted, agreeing to sell his share of Gray Matter for a measly $5,000 wasn't too smart, but under his pseudonym Heisenberg, he has created his own (evil) genius legacy, a master cook whose talents cannot be matched by his contemporaries. In addition to this, his constant manipulation of Jesse demonstrates extreme intelligence (or is it just a testament to Jesse's lack thereof?), poisoning Brock to ensure that he could kill Gus, a very clever move indeed. However, Walt can also be very hot-headed, and doesn't always think things through - leaving the Leaves of Grass book in the bathroom for Hank to find, for instance, was pretty careless. WINNER: Walt may appear to be the more fundamentally academic of the two, but he's also more unpredictable and liable to screwing things up. Jack may be the more unrealistically dependable of the two, but that's TV, so he wins.

7. One-Liners

Jack: "You probably don't think I could force this towel down your throat, but trust me I can. All the way. Except that I'd hold onto this little bit at the end. When your stomach starts to digest the towel, I pull it out. Taking your stomach lining with it. Most people probably take about a week to die. It's very painful." "I'm gonna need a hacksaw." "Damnit!" "The only reason that you're conscious right now is because I don't want to carry you." "You are gonna tell me what I wanna know, it's just a matter of how much you want it to hurt." Walt: "I am the one who knocks." "You're goddamn right." "If that's true, if you don't know who I am, then maybe your best course... would be to tread lightly." "I'm not in the meth business. I'm in the empire business." "I did it for me. I liked it. I was good at it. And I was really - I was alive." WINNER: A tough category, but Jack's quotes tend to be a bit more throwaday in terms of badassery, whereas Walt's best lines stem from years and years of mythology building over the course of the show. It has to go to Walt.

6. Survival

Jack: His string of military decorations include a Silver Star, the Purple Heart, and the Legion of Merit, in addition to racking up the rank of Captain in the Army. What's more, in season 2, Jack survives parachuting from a plane mere minutes before it drops a nuke into the Mojave Desert, and survives his heart being stopped for several minutes in the very same season. Oh, and he kicks a heroin addiction in a mere 24 hours in season 3, initiates an international incident with the Chinese in season 4, gets kidnapped by the Chinese at the end of season 5, and apparently doesn't crack despite being tortured for 2 years straight. As it stands presently, he's on the run from the Americans and Russians, apparently lying low in London. Walt: For starters, Walt begins his epic journey diagnosed with Stage IIIA lung cancer, being given 2 years to live. Walt is totally out of his depth at the start, getting in deep with gangsters far more au fait with the whole drug dealing thing than himself. By season 2, Walt's confidence grows, and to boot, his tumour shrinks by 80%. Following this, he is kidnapped countless times, but manages to survive until the final scene of the show, surrounded by all of his meth-cooking equipment, as was really the only way for him to go. WINNER: By default, by virtue of still being alive, this one really has to go to Jack. Not to diminish Walt's battle with cancer while he was still alive, but again, Jack's near-superhuman hardiness leaves him about one step away from being a very limber zombie.

5. Family Values

Jack: Work-life balance has always been a problem for Jack, and it in part is what resulted in his own wife, Teri, being murdered at the end of 24's first season by evil double agent Nina Myers. For an extra kick in the Jack Sack, she was carrying Jack's baby, too. Still, Jack's jailbait daughter Kim survived kidnapping in season 1 to become lame damsel in distress in season 2 (facing off against a crazy man she babysat for, a cougar, and a survivalist played by Johnny Drama), implausible CTU employee in season 3, and eventually becoming estranged from Jack, the only thread holding them together being Kim's daughter, Teri. Still, Kim has enough love for Daddy Bauer to donate some of her stem cells to him at the end of season 7, implicitly saving his life. But this is just the tip of the iceberg. Jack's own brother Graem is the villain of season 6 (the season everyone pretends never happened), as well as Jack's father Phillip Bauer (incredulously played by James Cromwell rather than Donald Sutherland). Jack ends up torturing his brother and killing his dad. Then there's his great loves post-Teri - Audrey Raines was left in a vegetative state the last time we saw her (though is reportedly returning for Live Another Day), and Renee Walker ended up dead. As for being one of Jack's friends, it's nothing short of a death sentence - just ask Michelle Dessler and ex-President David Palmer. Basically, do so much as serve the guy a skinny latte and you're on borrowed time. Walt: When Breaking Bad begins, Walt is a dedicated family man, married to Skyler, and once the meth business kicks off, he lies to her about it, until she finds out and is embroiled in his scheme by running the car wash as a fiscal front. They have a teenage son, Walter Jr., a total innocent who finds out the extent of Walter's antics at the very end of the show. Walt also has a young daughter, Holly, who is born at the end of season two, and who he ends up "kidnapping" at the end of the show, essentially helping to paint himself as a monster that ultimately allows Skyler to be let off the hook. He also misses Holly's birth in order to cook meth. Walt's other family includes Skyler's sister, Marie, who he essentially bereaves in accidentally causing her husband, DEA Agent Hank Schrader, to catch a bullet from Uncle Jack. It can be said that Jesse is something of a surrogate son to Walt as well, and though it seems touch and go as to whether Walt will wipe him out for his own benefit, in the end he saves him with the help of a mounted machine gun. WINNER: Walt does at least cast suspicion away from Skyler and incriminate himself in that climactic phone call, and ensures his family's future by blackmailing former partners Gretchen and Elliot into giving $9.72 million to Walt Jr. Jack has just left various family members in the ground, so reprehensible though Walt's method was, he has to win this one.

4. Toughest Dilemma

Jack: In season 3, Stephen Saunders realises that CTU hardass Ryan Chappelle is getting too close to his plot, and orders he be executed. Jack takes Chappelle to a trainyard, hoping that Chase Edmunds' raid to capture Sanders is successful. It isn't, and Jack is forced to go through with shooting Ryan through the back of the head in the quest for the apparent "greater good". It stands as one of the most devastating moments in 24 history, one that caused significant debate among fans at the time, and still does today. Walt: Walt's relationship with Jesse has been complicated over the years, going from student-teacher to, well, cooking crystal meth together. At the behest of Skyler, Walt eventually crumbles in season five's latter half and decides that Jesse is more trouble than he is worth, and a hit must be taken out against him. When Jesse and Hank trick Walt into believing that his money is about to be burned, he frantically urges Uncle Jack to take Jesse down, unaware that he is in league with the DEA. It is Walt at his most desperate and deranged, and something he only really atones for by saving Jesse from Uncle Jack in the series finale. WINNER: It's gotta go to Chappelle's execution. Jesse had an acute idea that he might get killed one day in the meth game, but a pencil-pusher like Chappelle is typically safe from a grisly end. Well, not in the 24 world, I guess...

3. Most Badass Moment

Jack: It's tough to choose just one, so here's a few highlights - when Jack thinks Kim is dead at the end of season one, he goes berserk, cleaning house as a one-man wrecking crew. Then there's him killing Nina, hijacking a plane single-handedly, surviving a nuclear bomb, cutting a guy's head off, biting a guy's throat out, and cutting Chase's hand off, because who likes Chase anyway? Walter: Walt's badassery was a little slower coming as it required a transformation, but his throwing of an explosive crystal of fulminated mercury in Tuco's office after he beats up Jesse and steals his meth is certainly up there. Then there's the events following Tomas' death, where Walt saves Jesse from certain death by running the dealers responsible over with his car, and executing the surviving one with a gunshot. Oh, and rigging up Hector Salamanca's wheelchair with a bomb in order to reduce Gus Fring to skeletal goop. Genius and awesome. WINNER: Jack is so badass that it seems effortless for him, whereas Walt's ascent to badassery seemed to mean a little more, such that when we saw him mow down those two dealers and pop a cap in one, we couldn't quite believe what we were seeing. This is the toughest category yet, but it just barely goes to Walt.

2. Least Badass Moment

Jack: At the end of season 3, exhausted from his toughest day yet and still coming down from the effects of smack withdrawal, Jack starts crying like a little baby in his car, resulting in the lamest final scene to any season of 24. Then there's the time he shot Curtis Manning, one of the show's best characters, dead without even trying to kneecap him first. Oh, and there's that time he basically converted to Islam, in yet another attempt by Fox to say, "We're not racist, honest!" Walter: On the other hand, Walter had a great gig going with Gray Matter Technologies, but strapped for cash, he ended up selling his shares for $5,000 and became a disenfranchised, downtrodden high school chemistry teacher. If he's not walking around the desert in his pants, he's trying to kiss his boss, assistant principal Molina, who then suspended him. And the whole letting Jane die thing, which in effect caused the plane crash... just really not badass at all. WINNER: Now, we have to use the word "winner" lightly here, because if you win, you're basically losing points on the badass-o-meter. It's fair to say that Jack's breakdowns over the years have primarily been a result of extreme trauma or tension, whereas Walt just places himself in hilariously embarrassing situations because he's more of a human being and less of a cartoon character than Jack. So, if Walt has suffered the greatest indignities, then the point has to go to Jack, who I'm pretty sure we're never going to see trotting around in white y-fronts anytime soon.

1. Conclusion

The scores at the doors give 4 points to Walter and 5 points to Jack, making Mr. Bauer the overall winner. Now, it's right to argue that it wasn't really a fair fight. While neither show is rooted too deeply in reality, 24 borders on the fantastical from time to time, whereas Breaking Bad is far more down-to-Earth and gritty. Jack is capable of more badassery simply because that universe gives him a lot more leeway; if Walter White went through what Jack did, the fans would have called bull**** a long time ago. Still, it's up to you to make your own minds up. What do you think? Did I miss any stupendously lame moments from either character? Or some kick ass one-liners? Let me know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.