Lost: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best
The show peaked with Ben Linus. End of story.
Remember when Lost was a thing? A cultural, worldwide phenomenon that got everyone in colleges, offices and parties talking about their theories and how they thought the show would play out.
We've seen this take form in the likes of Game of Thrones and Breaking Bad - a series so enriched with twists and turns, that if you were a fan of the show and you encountered another fan, you could be locked in a conversation that could span hours, just debating and discussing ideas.
Ask any fan of the show today what they think of it and they might roll their eyes and sigh over how bad the finale was, but I would bet that a revision of the show might stir up reasons for why so many people loved the show to begin with.
The characters were well-rounded and creative, and the story was certainly a unique one - albeit with no direction. But within its six season run, there was something to behold about a show that went from plane crash survival, to saving the world from an unstoppable, immortal monster made of smoke.
For everything in between, there were peaks and valleys. And while it could be construed as one collective tale, each season had its own themes and arcs.
Without spoiling too much of the series, here are all six season of the show, ranked from bad to best - let's hope it can stir up some nostalgic support for the series.
6. Season 6 - "The One With The Alternate Timeline"
Best Episode Of The Season: Episode 09 - Ab Aeterno
After the previous season's finale saw a nuclear bomb detonated in the heart of The Island, the show led itself down a rabbit hole where audiences were no longer given flashbacks, but flash-sideways into an alternate timeline where Oceanic Flight 815 didn't crash, and the interference of Jacob and Richard Alpert had never occurred.
The sixth season had so much anticipation built up behind it, the ambiguity of the show and how it would end sent internet theories into overdrive. What made the final season so deflating was the show appeared to write itself into a corner, and then tangled itself up in absurd conclusions.
The origins of Jacob, The Smoke Monster, Richard and why the survivors were so important, should have been scattered across the whole series, instead a lot of these loose ends seemed to come out as unexplained payoffs. In hindsight, the mysteries of The Island should have stayed unexplained, but this was 2009 and audiences were desperate to know how and why events occurred previously.
In the end, the Afterlife reveal, and realizing the show boiled down between a conflict of light verses dark (good vs evil) just didn't land as well as it should have. Perhaps the show should have just been cancelled, and fans could have imagined their own ideal ending?
5. Season 5 - "The One With All The Time Jumps"
Best Episode Of The Season: Episode 08 - LaFleur
After Season 3's shocking revelation that some of the Survivors had made it off the Island, and Season 4 revealed how and why that occurred, it was the fifth season's task to present to audiences how the Oceanic Six would return to the elusive land.
Ben Linus' bold move of literally moving The Island sets half of the fifth season's storyline up as a time-jumping escapade where those left behind to wander through the greatest hits of the Dharma Initiative and The Others' history. An immediate criticism of the fifth season comes in the form of the show splitting its time between the present day and the past in unnerving fashion.
The left-behind storyline on the Island is arguably the better story in the season, and Jack's attempts to rally the Oceanic Six together feels like a poor heist movie that doesn't pay off as well as you'd hope.
The second half of the season does pay off with a few good character developments - turning Sayid into a vengeful child-killer, Sawyer uses his con-man charm to rise up as a leader, and even Kate steps up as a less-than one-dimensional hero for once.
But in the end, the fifth season is still a weak one. And could have done with a few good writers.
4. Season 3 - "The One That Spent A Lot Of Time On The Others"
Best Episode Of The Season: Episode 20 - The Man Behind The Curtain
The third season of the cult series had a lot to follow on. The infamous Hatch that had consumed the entire previous season had imploded, three of the main leads had been captured by The Others for unknown reasons, and Claire was still wandering around with her baby and being useless.
The writers of season three did have an advantage, and that was to slowly sneak away from character-driven plots, and focus more on the mythology of the Island itself and who its previous inhabitants were. Finally, audiences were given insight into who The Others actually were, and why the Island was so significant to some.
Admittedly, the crazy cliffhangers didn't stop, and it seemed Lost was devoted to doubling down on the weirdness. Desmond's clairvoyance, the introduction of Jacob and the scattered conflict between the Survivors and The Others made for an interesting season in which two factions go to war.
But the third season is definitely loaded with faults - with a number of episodes being ultimately forgettable, with one in particular serving to kill of two characters that audiences just did not gel with. It was this season, that the cracks in the show started to appear.
3. Season 2 - "The One With The Hatch"
Best Episode Of The Season: Episode 07 - The Other 48 Days
As bizarre as the first season was, the weirdness of the second hit new heights when the premise involved the characters keying in a series of numbers into a computer every one hundred and eight minutes - failing to do so could/would cause the world to end.
While that might sound strange, it's not half as weird as where the second season did go, whilst still keeping the train firmly on the rails. The second season got a chance to flesh out its diverse characters a little more - with the flashbacks not only giving us even more insight into the heroes, but also branching out with new characters.
The introduction of the "Tail Section" characters was a neat idea, albeit pointless since audiences were still trying to get to grips with the main crew. And while half of the new characters ended up either dead or ensnared by The Others, it was the introduction of characters like Desmond Hume and Henry Gale (sorry, Ben Linus!) and also paved the way for the infamous Dharma Initiative - the elusive plot narrative that consumed later seasons.
Overall, the second season might be the last time the show had sanity. After its cataclysmic season finale, the show lost its mind from then on.
2. Season 4 - "The One With The Freighter"
Best Episode Of The Season: Episode 05 - The Constant
"Not Penny's Boat" was a chilling end to the show's third season, as the reveal that a supposed rescue party was coming to The Island for more nefarious reasons.
The fourth season showed a fraught tension amongst many factions on The Island; with The Others, the crash survivors and a new branch of characters revealed a mission to capture the show's secondary antagonist Ben Linus.
With audiences asking how Jack and Kate (and eventually Sayid, Sun, Hurley and Aaron) got off The Island, the tension in the fourth season escalated as mercenaries, recruited by tertiary antagonist Charles Widmore, laid siege on the survivors. The fourth season might be an indicator of when the show started falling off the rails, as time-jumps and overblown set pieces asked even more elaborate questions than before.
It was also the season that proved heroic characters like Jack, Sawyer and Kate weren't the most interesting leads, and instead audiences found themselves drawn to more three-dimensional figures like Desmond, Ben, Locke and even the scientists on board the freighter.
Genuine emotional beats flocked the fourth season - with Michael Emerson acting the heck out of watching his daughter be executed by Keamy, and Henry Ian Cusick bringing all his emotions to a scene where he is reunited with his beloved Penny (twice!) and audiences felt that feeling with him.
1. Season 1 - "The One That Started All The Hype"
Best Episode Of The Season: Episode 01 & 02 - Pilot
Of course the best season of the show, would be the one that pulled audiences in and got them addicted to fan theories for over six years.
The launch of the series was an event - with it's two-part introduction episodes becoming one of the most talked about thing happening in 2004. Every episode of the first season seemed to crank out more and more absurdities and oddities - to the point where explaining the show as simply about the survivors of a plane crash was damned near impossible.
Perhaps what tipped audiences off about how crazy a show Lost would be, was when the rumblings of a monster in the jungle set off that this wasn't simply going to be Lord of the Flies but with adults. From that point, audiences were treated to magical healing, ghosts, castaways, infiltrating inhabitants and outright weirdness in between.
Compared to where the show went in later seasons, the first season was still pretty simple and while it did ask way too many questions that were (sort of) answered in later seasons, for anyone who never watched the show when it first aired, I would recommend the first season at least just to get a whiff of what the craze was all about.
Watch Next
The Ultimate LOST Superfan Quiz