Lost: How It Should Be Re-Cast In 2021

If Lost got new faces, who would they be?!

Lost Recast
ABC

J.J. Abrams' Lost was one of those shows that felt years ahead of its time. Just before the golden age of TV hit the world and streaming platforms became the most accessible medium for content, series shows were considered a lesser form of storytelling when compared to cinema. But, this epic, mysterious and constantly evolving show about the survivors of Oceanic Flight 815 was an early example that it could be more than that.

There were plenty of elements that went into the success of Lost, such as the unique concept, solid visuals and writing, but it was the characters who took home the bacon for bringing viewers back every season. The ensemble cast was teeming with notable figures and compelling conflicts, and it's safe to say that the casting was spot-on.

However, just as Lost always begged the question of what was really going on, so too shall this list ask what would have happened if it were done differently. The best way to do this is to ask who would have taken these iconic roles if Lost was made now?

14. Claire Littleton - Emily Browning

Claire Littleton Emily Browning
ABC/StudioCanal

Being stranded on a deserted island is hard enough, but surviving that whilst being pregnant is even worse. Sadly, that's what poor Claire had to deal with, but she still was a bright light in the show.

Other than giving birth to and raising young Aaron, Claire also dealt with heartbreak, romance and a growing sense of autonomy in the group. So, she'd need an actor who could capture something complicated while still warming everyone's hearts, and Emily Browning is the perfect candidate.

She's proven her worth in projects like Legend, American Gods and more. As someone who rose to prominence as a child star - best shown in A Tale Of Unfortunate Events - she could naturally capture the youthful vibes that Claire needs.

Also, since her last two major credits have been in TV roles (The Affair and American Gods), she'd certainly know how to carry a character through a series. Plus, let's not forget that as an Australian actor, she'd no doubt bring Claire's iconic accent to life easily.


13. Ben Linus - David Dastmalchian

Ben Linus And Polka Dot Man
ABC/Warner Bros.

One of Lost's first big mysteries were the terrifying "others", a group of island inhabitants who seemed to have it in for our heroes. This sense of Us vs. Them took up the first few seasons, but eventually, the lines became blurred, especially in their leader, Ben.

Ben has two major qualities that need to be captured; the first is a sense of villainy. Although he's not the most conventional-looking bad guy, Ben is a manipulative liar who is a master at influencing others, meaning the actor would need to be creepy and unsettling. However, at the same time, they need to convince the audience that they can eventually redeem themselves, meaning there's a likeability required too.

So, who better than The Polka Dot man himself, David Dastmalchian? This actor has proven that he's capable of being a terrifying and unsettling creep (just see his small role in The Dark Knight for that), but has also shown a lighter and more sympathetic side.

He's currently riding high thanks to The Suicide Squad, so he'd be a perfect fit in this major antagonist-turned-uncertain ally.


12. Desmond Hume - Colin Morgan

Desmond Hume And Colin Morgan
ABC/Chanel 4

Desmond was a character who debuted in the premiere of the second season, so he was given a prime slot. Eventually, he'd become an invaluable cast member, with a tragic backstory and premonitions galore. Thus, you'd need to cast someone who can be effectively troubled whilst also charming.

One great option for the role would be Colin Morgan, a young actor known for his roles in projects like Merlin, Humans and Legend (alongside Browning). He's a very competent actor with a dual sense of grittiness and neatness. He's proven to be very versatile in his array of characters, so he'd no doubt capture the multi-faceted complexity of Desmond with ease.

Now, it is important to note that Morgan's origins lie slightly southwest of Scotland, in Ireland. Still, he's very dependable when it comes to accent work, and the character could work just as well as an Irishman, so this shouldn't be an issue at all.


11. Michael Dawson - Lakeith Stanfield

Michael Dawson Lakeith Stanfield
ABC/Universal Pictures

Which of these sounds tougher: being stranded on a desert island or having your son taken away from you, only to be returned once you've moved past the loss? Unluckily for Michael, he had to deal with both matters simultaneously, and it drove him to some wild places.

When it comes to casting this unfortunate dad - who transitioned from hero to sympathetic villain to hero again - you'd need someone with plenty of experience, skill and a deep sense of nuance. There's one guy who could do that very well, as he's been a fast-rising star in the past five years, even earning himself an Oscar nomination.

Lakeith Stanfield has been working since the early 2010s but shot into popularity thanks to his performance in Get Out. From there, he took notable roles in many big movies (like Knives Out and Judas and the Black Messiah), so he's got plenty of experience in his back pocket.

As someone who captures both youth and experience, he'd make a great troubled father, turned suicidal victim, and finally, tragic hero.


10. Jin-Soo Kwon - Steven Yeun

Jin And Steven Yeun
ABC/AMC

Lost was hardly a show starved for redemption stories. There were plenty of characters who showed off their worst qualities at first, before eventually growing and becoming better people. Of all these characters, Jin was one of the best, as his domineering hand over his wife instantly painted him in a bad light, but eventually, he became a beloved member of the survivors.

While Steven Yeun might seem a little young to be playing the role, it's easy to see that he's grown a lot since playing his formative role of Glenn in The Walking Dead. He has proven that he's way more than a one-trick pony and even earned himself an Oscar nomination for his role in Minari, proving that he could take on more mature characters.

He'd certainly get the goofy and likeable side of Jin right, but seeing him tackle the dark and dangerous initial side of the character would be a fascinating way to expand his repertoire and show that he can be intimidating too.


9. Sun-Hwa Kwon - Ji-so Jung

Sun And Ji So Jung
ABC/CJ Entertainment

Let's move from one half of the Kwon family to another, in Sun-Hwa Kwon. This character began the show with seemingly no autonomy thanks to her husband but eventually grew into a prominent member of the survivors. She was innocent, brave and intelligent, which made her a welcome presence in the series.

Picking someone to take the role in the modern age is tough, but the actor Ji-so Jung would be an inspired choice. She has made a few appearances in Korean movies like Daughter and The Tiger but amassed her most considerable success in 2019s runaway hit Parasite as the young daughter of the family - Da Hye.

Thanks to her youth, she's excellent at playing young delinquents. So, moving onto a more mature role like Sun would be a great descision for her. She'd easily capture the earlier stages of Sun that make her seem like a victim, but there's a fire and strength behind Jung that would help her carve out the more prominent side of the character as she progressed.


8. Hugo 'Hurley' Reyes - Josh Gad

Hurley And Josh Gad
ABC/20th Century Fox

When it comes to picking out the fan-favourite characters in Lost, the list will be longer than the time it took for viewers to find out where that Polar Bear came from. Still, there's one name that plenty would put at the top, and that would be Hugo 'Hurley' Reyes.

This loveable character ticked all the boxes, as he was an easy piece of comic relief but also had a dark backstory and plenty of turmoil. Fans fell for him, and they fell hard, so choosing someone to take over for him is a challenge.

But, one actor who could be up to the task is Josh Gad, known best as the voice of Olaf in Frozen, but also the star of movies like Beauty and the Beast, The Internship, Pixels and more. He's a big star in musical theatre and comedy but could have a great run here.

Gad has optimism and energy that suits Hurley well. He's also proven in movies like Murder on the Orient Express that he can go dark when he needs to, so all the bases are covered.


7. Sayid Jarrah - Riz Ahmed

Sayid And Riz Ahmed
ABC/BFI

There were plenty of characters who were essential to the group's survival, but one of the most important was Sayid. Without him, there's no way the victims of Oceanic Flight 815 would have survived, but it was still an incredibly difficult time for him, thanks to his backstory and the prejudice he faced.

Riz Ahmed has been a slowly rising star for at least a decade now and has found himself thrust fully into the spotlight thanks to his roles in big movies like Rogue One, Venom and The Sound Of Metal - which scored him an Academy Award Nomination. He's an actor who can flip between comedy and severity, which is something Sayid would do pretty much every episode.

More than this, Ahmed also has a wonderful ability to make his characters feel storied, which would be necessary to Sayid. His past significantly influenced the way he acted and operated whilst on the island, so an actor who could convey that is vital.


6. Juliet Burke - Emily VanCamp

Lost Recast
ABC

Juliet was a fantastic character who came and injected new life into the show and displayed a deeper, more layered side to the others that moved them away from being simple antagonists. Her evolution from an antihero to a fully-fledged protagonist had many calling her the best female character in the show. So, naturally, this recasting would need to be good.

One ideal candidate would be Emily VanCamp, better known to many as the MCU's Sharon Carter. You need only look at her role in the Marvel Universe to see just how good she is at playing complicated characters who keep plenty of secrets, slowly unveiling their past and themselves. She's clearly qualified for this part.

VanCamp is believably likeable yet tough at the same time. There's a rough exterior to her that seems guarded and defensive, but when she opens her characters up and lets people in, viewers often get something special. If she were to take on this role, then the character's reputation would remain intact.


5. John Locke - Anthony Carrigan

John Locke And Anthony Carrigan
ABC/Warner Bros.

One of the island's first mysteries wasn't the identity of the others or the state of the landscape itself, but rather the intentions of the elusive and peculiar John Locke. The more you learned about John, the more you saw things from his perspective, but it has to be said that he felt out of the ordinary right from the get-go, so his new actor would need to reflect that too.

In that case, Anthony Carrigan is perfect for the job. The first thing that strikes you about this actor is his bald head and slightly unsettling face. He has a look that's both intriguing and slightly off-putting, which aligns perfectly with how the show represents Locke at first. Plus, he's got plenty of experience playing quirky/creepy characters, Gotham being the best example.

He's also made it clear that he's excellent at funnier characters, like NoHo Hank in Barry and Dennis Caleb McCoy in Bill and Ted Face The Music. Thus, it's clear that the man's got versatility for days, which would help him out here.


4. Charlie Pace - Rupert Grint

Charlie Pace And Rupert Grint
ABC/Apple TV

Casting a popular actor from a fantasy movie franchise worked well for Lost when they cast Merry Brandybuck (Dominic Monaghan) as Charlie, so why not do it again?

The struggles of drug addiction, fame and violent conflict were all things Charlie Pace suffered in his life. His time on the island was riddled with problems but also thrills. Although he went through a lot of pain, he also found love, friendship, and bravery. Sound familiar? Well, Ronald Weasley experienced something similar during his time at Hogwarts (if you ignore the drug addiction).

Rupert Grint would be an excellent choice for Charlie, as he's effortlessly charming and fun but also able to deliver a sense of pain and suffering. His post-Harry Potter career hasn't taken off as much as it could have, and a role like this would be a great chance to show off his skills.

The man's a talented actor, which is evident in the HP series and his roles in the shows Snatch and Servant. So, he'd fit right in here.


3. Kate Austen - Emma Mackey

Kate Austen And Emma Mackey
ABC/Netflix

Like Sayid, Kate's biggest problem (apart from being stranded in the middle of nowhere) was the fact that she harboured a dark past. As a criminal on the run, she had to work hard to build trust with her fellow survivors, which led to a very compelling journey.

It would make sense to cast someone here who has credibility but is also waiting for a big break to take them to the next stage of their career. With that in mind, it seems that Emma Mackey - better known as Maeve from Sex Education - would be a perfect choice.

Mackey bridges the gap between sweet/caring and aggressive/intimidating incredibly well, and that's something that would work for Kate. She needs to have a sense of fire to her, but also a desire to do good by everyone else, and that's something Mackey can bring by the bucket-load.

Casting her would make Kate complex, likeable and rough around the edges, in just the right way.


2. James 'Sawyer' Ford - John David Washington

James Sawyer Ford And John David Washington
ABC/Netflix

If Jin had a good redemption arc, then Sawyer had a great one. This character started as a thorn in the heroes sides but eventually became one of the most popular characters in the show. His change from being a sly and manipulative conman to a thoughtful and brave hero was a highlight for the series. As such, he needs someone with mountains worth of charisma.

John David Washington hasn't been a star for long - only starting to make a name for himself around 2018 - but he's taken Hollywood by storm. Washington has proved he's a competent leading man in movies like BlaKkKlansmen and Tenet, and that's something he could sink into here.

One crucial factor for Sawyer was his charm. Even at his worst, fans still fell for him, and that's something Washington could achieve. He's effortlessly suave and smooth, which would make his version of Sawyer a great anti-hero.

Of course, he'd have to work on his southern drawl, but he'd surely nail that.


1. Jack Shephard - Charlie Cox

Jack Shephard And Charlie Cox
ABC/Wikimedia Commons

As far as leading men go, Jack is a mixed bag. He's an incredibly compelling character, with plenty of flaws and a sorrow-filled backstory. But, at the same time, he's somewhat vanilla, meaning his centric episodes were dull at times. However, it was all carried through by the outstanding performance from Matthew Fox, so whoever gets the role needs to step up.

Charlie Cox is easily the man who can, as he's got all the qualities of a fantastic leading man, whilst chucking in the kind of unconventionality that kept Fox's performance engaging.

Cox skirts the line between a Hollywood actor and an average Joe finely, which would make his version of Dr Jack Shephard believable and relatable. Plus, Cox's look and acting style could quickly emit the feeling of authority and intelligence that made Jack a strong leader.

He has made it clear with his leading role in Daredevil that he's more than capable of carrying the weight of a series on his back, and this central figure is something that would fit right into his wheelhouse.


In this post: 
Lost
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!