Love, Victor Season 2 Review: 8 Ups & 3 Downs

Love, Victor grows up with a mature and engaging sophomore outing.

Love Victor Season 2
Hulu

Love, Victor was one of 2020's most refreshing TV dramas.

A spin-off of the equally groundbreaking movie Love, Simon, the Hulu series told the story of high school student Victor Salazar as he struggled with his sexuality, fearing that his religious family wouldn't accept him if they knew the truth. Though a little safe for some, the show was praised for offering up an uplifting yet authentic coming out story while also tackling issues that Love, Simon did not. Moreover, it was instant success for Hulu so it was only a matter of time until a second season followed.

That second season has arrived and things at Creekwood are quite different: Victor and Benji are in a happy relationship (as are Lake and Felix), Mia has left town for the summer and Victor's parents are attempting to accept their son for who he is. Naturally, drama soon follows... but does it pack as much of a punch as its predecessor?

Love, Victor dares to defy a little more in its second season and with that comes some familiar TV tropes that threaten to undercut its story. However, it also produces a compelling look at the lesser-seen second chapter of the coming out story and it ultimately succeeds because it maintains that one thing that made its first season such a joy: Heart.

First, the negatives...

Please be aware, this post contains SPOILERS for Love, Victor Season 2.


Downs...

3. Too Many Love Triangles!

Love Victor Felix Lake
Hulu

One of the main reasons that Love, Victor's second season succeeds in so many areas is its subversive nature. It doesn't always rely on traditional story beats to move things along and even surprises you in places (which we'll get to shortly). However, as the season moves on, it gets bogged down in love triangle after love triangle and it all begins to feel so, for lack of a better term, familiar.

The partially-forced conflict between Victor and Benji leads to the former finding more than just a friend in the lovable Rahim (in spite of the fact that they had about three interactions), Lake and Felix keep pleasantly surprising us until they are cruelly ripped apart just to be paired with other people and Victor's father wants to start seeing another woman after indicating that he wanted to rekindle what he had with his wife.

Some of it pans out nicely but a lot of it relies on the aforementioned forced conflict while some of the other developments just feel completely unearned. It's not enough to upend a good season but it does leave you feeling like you know these characters a little less when we should, in fact, know them more.

One love triangle would have been pushing it... but three?


2. Benji's Character Regression

Love Victor Benji
Hulu

One of the reasons that it was so easy to fall in love with Benji in the first season was the fact that we saw him through Victor's eyes. We fell for him as Victor did.

However, the character feels drastically different in the second season and it's hard to feel the same way about him. An intentional device to once again make us feel what Victor's feeling? Perhaps but it only succeeds in making Benji inexplicably unlikeable - something we all thought would be impossible in the first season.

Once that glorious first episode is out of the way, Benji exists solely as a plot device, sulking and eye-rolling his way through every moment he isn't getting his own way. Now, the later reactions over Victor's betrayal are both authentic and earned, but at that point, the forced conflict between the pair early on has dried up any desire to see real conflict. And that's a shame because it's hard to believe the Benji from season 1 would treat Victor's fears over coming out publicly and being intimate with such an apparent lack of consideration.

Michael Cimino and George Sear are an absolute joy to watch together, and there is no doubt that 'Venji' is endgame material. It's just a shame that season 2 spent more time forcing them apart than actually letting them deal with the problems they faced together.


1. The Time Jump

Love, Victor Michael Cimino
Hulu

While not exactly the cause of the season's aforementioned issues, the time jump at the beginning certainly didn't help them. Initially picking up where season 1 left off in the teaser, we then skip 10 weeks forward in time to showcase the new dynamics just as the summer is coming to an end.

Now, don't get this writer wrong, time jumps can be pretty effective when used right and Love, Victor does go a long way to justify the decision to pick up where it does, but I can't help but feel that this robbed us of some of the truly great dynamics that the characters spend the rest of the season talking about.

Considering how major the idea of coming out was to Victor, shouldn't we have seen how doing so instantly changed his life? Moreover, shouldn't we have seen the highs of his first relationship with a boy (instead of getting repeatedly stuck on all the lows)? And shouldn't we have seen how his mother and father reached the places they were at in their attempts to process Victor's revelation instead of just getting told how they behaved?

A lot of the drama we got ended up justifying the time jump but that doesn't mean the show would have benefited any less from showing us how important that summer was to Victor (instead of telling us about it).

Now, for the positives...


Ups...

8. Love, Simon's Presence Remains Without Overshadowing

Love, Victor Michael Cimino
Hulu

Love, Victor was so committed to setting itself up as a standalone property in its first season that, Instagram messaging with Simon aside, it was easy to forget it was related to Love, Simon at all.

Of course, that all changed in the eighth episode when Nick Robinson and Keiynan Lonsdale reprised their roles as Simon and Bram, so when Love, Victor season 2 featured its own cameos and references to the founding father of the 'Simonverse', it was nice to see. And, like Simon's reduced role as narrator this season, those references added a great deal to the actual story.

Love, Victor can - and does - stand on its own, but a reference to the movie that started it all every once in a while is always welcome.


7. Another Huge Step Forward For LGBTQ+ Representation

Love, Victor Michael Cimino George Sear
Hulu

Before going any further, it just should be said how important it is to have a TV series like Love, Victor on the air (or in the streaming world). No, it isn't the first time a TV show has told (or even prioritised) a teen gay romance but to see one headline a show that looks and feels like every other teen romcom (not-to-mention the fact that it's a spin-off of the first major Hollywood movie to ever do so) is a major step in the right direction in terms of representation.

Love, Victor tells a queer love story in the same way that American TV has told so many heterosexual love stories, tackling conversations about love, sex and once again going a long way in highlighting that love is love.

The second season goes about it in different and arguably more striking ways than its predecessor. As for how it accomplishes that, well let's find out...


6. Life After Coming Out

Love Victor Benji
Hulu

Love, Victor set out to show that Love, Simon wasn't the most universal coming out story ever told. It accomplished that but its decision to tell another coming out story - and subsequently end the first season at said coming out - divided people. Yes, it was different but, in a way, it was also the same.

What sets Season 2 apart, however, is the fact that it tells a completely different story. Focusing on Victor's relationship with Benji and his parents' attempts to accept him now that they know he's gay, the second season is all about life after coming out - something that Love, Simon barely got the chance to show.

There's an exciting 'second chapter' feeling that sticks with the season throughout all ten episodes. It feels like uncharted territory and it doesn't shy away from delving into the highs and the lows that come with that new chapter.

Though not a perfect one, this is the kind of original story that many wanted to see from the first season - and what a refreshing story it is.


5. Love, Victor Grows Up

Love Victor Benji
Hulu

One of the more conflicting elements about the first season of the show was its inability to figure out what kind of audience it was geared towards. Originally intended for Disney+, it was bright, colorful and looked exactly like it would belong on that platform. However, it walked the line of mature content without ever fully going for it, so when it was moved to Hulu for that reason, viewers were a little confused as to how just far it was willing to go - one of the things that earned it the 'safe' label.

The second season is much braver than the first. Written for a Hulu audience this time around, it adopts a more upfront approach. The stories are more powerful, yes, but the subject matter is more mature, allowing for a deeper exploration of themes such as sex and alcoholism that you never would have seen in the first season.

Love, Victor very much grows up in its second season and its unapologetic bravery in 'taking things to the next level' will hopefully start a trend for other YA queer love stories to do the same in the future.


4. Felix Shines In A Subplot Standout

Love Victor Felix
Hulu

There is a strong case to be made for Felix having the season's most engaging story. That's not a slight on the rest of the season but an indicator of how strong his arc is.

We caught glimpses of his internal conflict in the first season when he took Lake to his house but that very much comes to the forefront here. Attempting to keep his family together, he takes on multiple new jobs so that he can pay rent and protect his mother from the real world. But the cracks begin to show as he must face a difficult choice over protecting his mother like he has been doing or getting her the help that she needs.

Felix has always been one of Love, Victor's most engaging characters. On the surface, he's a source of constant comic relief, often lightening up a heavy moment with his quirky one-liners and self-deprecating humour. But what made him truly endearing was the fact that there was something beneath all that humour. And that conflict comes to life in a really striking manner.


3. Subverting Expectations

Love Victor Isabel
Hulu

Another one of the season's most interesting storylines revolves around Victor's parents as Isabel and Armando attempt to find out what separated life looks like. However, their separation is used incredibly well to highlight their differing views of Victor's coming out as Armando copes with his son's sexuality much better than Isabel does.

A unique spin on the 'unaccepting father' trope, it presents the brilliant Ana Ortiz with a really powerful story as Victor's mother must find a way to overcome everything she had been taught about the idea of being gay and accept her son for who he is.

A refreshing subversion of the norm, Ortiz is phenomenal and this story is one of Love, Victor's most powerful, highlighting what might just be the show's most important relationship in the process.


2. It Leaves You Wanting More

Love Victor Michael Cimino
Hulu

As frustrating as the first season's pacing was for many, it was an expert method of highlighting that there were a lot of places to go in Victor's story of self-discovery. While Love, Simon had to fast-track a lot of that, the Hulu series took its time with it and, in spite of the predictable cliffhanger ending, it undeniably left viewers wanting more.

That 'more' came in the form of the lesser-discussed second chapter of the coming out experience, chronicling Victor's first relationship with a boy while delving into how each of his family members accepted him in their own time. Like any TV teenage love story, it had its own issues but it did find its way back to a place that once again left you wanting more.

The ending doesn't quite recreate the authentic edge-of-seat feeling that Victor's coming out did but it does ensure that you'll be back for season 3 - and that, in itself, is a huge win for a show that could have been one-and-done.


1. The Performances

Love Victor Benji Lake Felix
Hulu

One of Love, Victor's strongest assets is undoubtedly the performers that bring it to life.

Michael Cimino delivered a career-defining performance in the first season and he follows up on that beautifully here, telling the next chapter of Victor's story with a leading performance that is both subtle and captivating.

He's once again joined by that remarkable ensemble that made us instantly fall in love with their characters the first time around. Rachel Hilson is wonderful as Mia, sensitively showcasing her struggles as she attempts to find her place once again. Bebe Wood is even more stunning than she was before, highlighting her versatility as a performer as she nails all of the typically-comedic Lake's more emotional moments. And Anthony Turpel delivers arguably the most endearing performance of the season as Felix once again steals the show.

George Sear also delivers with Benji's meatier role this season and his on-screen chemistry with Cimino is incredible. Mason Gooding succeeds in portraying Andrew as the more-nuanced character we only saw glimpses of in the previous season. And, as we discussed earlier, perhaps the season's best performance goes to Ortiz - who goes above and beyond in highlighting Isabel's conflicts in an authentic way.

Love, Victor continues to be a groundbreaking show that is brought to life by an absolutely exquisite cast.


In this post: 
Love, Victor
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.