Making A Murderer: Where Are They Now?
Much has changed since Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey were first convicted back in 2007.
It has been almost five years since the acclaimed true-crime docuseries Making a Murderer premiered on Netflix. Since then, the world has continued to turn and plenty has changed. It could not have been predicted that the next few years would bring the election of Donald Trump, or the beginnings of Brexit, or a major global pandemic. Yet, for Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey, one thing remains static: they are incarcerated for their alleged involvement in the murder of Teresa Halbach, without an end in sight.
That is not to say that there haven’t been any recent developments regarding their convictions. Making a Murderer’s second season explored how their fight for freedom resumed post-conviction, and it remains an ongoing fight today. Although the last few years have been difficult for the two men and their families, glimmers of hope in the shape of new evidence, appeals and petitions continue to emerge, altering the nature of their challenges over and over again.
So, since directors Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos last updated us in 2018, what exactly has been happening with these cases? From the convicted to their legal teams, the documentary's main players have headed in many differing, and often fascinating, directions. Let's take a look at where those at the centre of the Making a Murderer story are today...
5. Dean Strang And Jerry Buting Are International Celebrities
If anybody came out of Making a Murderer looking good, it was Steven Avery’s former lawyers Dean Strang and Jerry Buting. Upon the documentary’s release, the two men were propelled from the position of middle-aged legal professionals to international heartthrobs overnight. Although they were replaced after their client’s conviction, they remain supportive of Avery’s continued fight for freedom.
Buting has been keeping particularly busy since Avery’s trial. In 2017, he published a book entitled Illusion of Justice: Inside Making a Murderer and America's Broken System. Soon after, it was picked up by ABC, who are planning to turn it into a television series. After both men completed their joint world tour, Buting decided to hit the public speaking circuit again, this time teaming up with David Rudolf, who is best known as the defence lawyer from The Staircase. These endeavours have not, however, distracted Buting from his legal career. Among others, he currently represents Todd Kendhammer, who is serving a life sentence for murdering his wife and covering it up by staging a car accident. Buting maintains that Kendhammer is innocent, and he is working tirelessly to prove it.
Like Buting, Strang has ingratiated himself into the literary scene. Most recently, he released the snappily titled Keep the Wretches in Order: America’s Biggest Mass Trial, the Rise of the Justice Department, and the Fall of the IWW. For the most part, he spends his time lecturing while continuing to work as a lawyer.
4. Kathleen Zellner Continues To Fight For Justice
Those who watched Making a Murderer’s second season will know that Kathleen Zellner is a force to be reckoned with. If anybody can prove Avery’s innocence, it is she, and that is exactly what she aims to do. Zellner continues to be integral in strengthening his case, regularly bringing forward new evidence and tenaciously arguing for her client’s rights to be upheld.
Avery is not Zellner’s only high-profile client. The attorney is currently handling many other cases, with her focus as always on wrongful convictions. Over the years, she has represented a myriad of people from all walks of life, including one of the victims of infamous former United States national gymnastics team doctor Larry Nasser, and the now-exonerated Kevin Fox and Mario Casciaro, both of whom were falsely accused of murder.
Recently, she has been making great strides while working on the intriguing case of Shan Fieldman. Fieldman was convicted of hiring a hitman to murder his ex-wife. Considering that this so-called hitman was actually an undercover cop, it seems like a cut and dried issue on the surface. However, a vast amount of vital contextual information was not permitted to be used during his trial, meaning that the soundness of the jury’s decision to convict him is questionable. Thanks to Zellner, Fieldman won the habeas corpus before the 7th Circuit Court in August of this year, enabling him to legally dispute the validity of his detention.
3. Ken Kratz Is Subject To Karmic Law
If those involved in Making a Murderer were comic-book characters, Strang, Buting and Zellner would be the superheroes while Avery and Dassey would be the unsuspecting victims. That leaves only the villain - a role which Ken Kratz inhabits perfectly. Although justice has not been served for Avery or Dassey, it has, in a way, for the perpetually smirking, pompous lump that is Kratz. For that, let us all be thankful.
Anybody who finished the documentary’s first season will know that the prosecutor abused his position of power and sexually harassed a number of women. Since this information came out, his career has unsurprisingly bombed. Overall, he has been keeping a low profile, even voluntarily resigning his Wisconsin law license.
His treatment of Avery and Dassey during their trials was widely criticised, causing Kratz to receive a slew of negative comments and death threats online. His Yelp page is, in particular, is a sight to behold. For example, Yelp user Mary G writes that she has “taken sh*ts with more integrity” than the prosecutor, while Eric W brands him a “Pathetic toxic stain on the universe”. These are two of the kindest observations pertaining to Kratz that can be found on the internet.
2. Brendan Dassey Is Repeatedly Failed By The Legal System
To claim that Brendan Dassey was in any way involved in Teresa Halbach’s murder involves a major stretch of the imagination. Nonetheless, just like his uncle, he remains in prison. At the moment, he is incarcerated in Oshkosh Correctional Institution, and he will not be eligible for parole until 2048, when he will be 59 years old.
In June 2018, Dassey’s legal team sought certiorari, or in layman’s terms, a judicial review of the lower court's decision about his case. Justices scheduled a conference, and Dassey's request was placed on the agenda. It was at this meeting that they were due to decide whether his case would be heard, but for undisclosed reasons, it was removed from the topics of discussion and never rescheduled. By the end of the month, certiorari had been denied, which was an enormous blow for the 31-year-old and his legal team.
Taking a different approach, Dassey's lawyers and supporters also tried to convince Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers to commute his sentence. In December 2019, Evers publicly refused to consider his case. They remain hopeful that he will change his mind though, and continue to put pressure on him. After all, a commutation could provide Dassey with his long-awaited key to freedom.
1. Steven Avery Makes Another Bid For Freedom
Steven Avery still resides in Waupun Correctional Institution, stripped of his freedoms and convicted of a serious crime that he may not have committed for the second time in his life. No matter how you feel about the father-of-four, it is undeniable that the system has repeatedly failed him throughout his life, and continues to do so today.
Last year, Avery received news that he had won the right to appeal his case after potential new evidence was discovered. Possible human bones were found in a gravel pit, which, despite never being tested for DNA, were then passed over to Teresa Halbach’s family. If the bones did in fact belong to the murdered photographer, then the prosecution’s theory that she was killed on Avery’s property would be undermined, casting doubt upon their entire argument. Likewise, a forensic fire expert had concluded that no human body was ever in his burn pit, exposing further holes in their claims. Unfortunately, despite this critical information coming to light, Avery’s request for a new trial was rejected in August 2019.
2020 has not been going particularly well for Avery either. In prison, he contracted the COVID-19 virus, although he appears to have since fully recovered. There have been no significant new developments in his case over the past few months, but no matter what adversities he faces, it is clear that he and his supporters will not stop campaigning until he has been exonerated.
The Ultimate How To Get Away With Murder Quiz