Malcolm In The Middle: Every Lead Character Ranked From Worst To Best

From top, to bottom, to middle - which characters from this show rank best?

Malcolm In The Middle Lois
Fox

The world of sit-com comedy is filled from top to bottom with dysfunctional families. This is because such a vessel for plotlines has been proven to work countless time in shows like Full House, The Simpsons and many more. However, while there are many famous family units in the TV world, the Wilkerson's from Malcolm in the Middle easily rank as one of the best.

These ridiculous characters were a tonne of fun, and each of them played to specific archetypes of family units. This made the show incredibly funny, but most importantly, one of the most relatable shows on TV.

While the series has been over for some time now, it's still a highly appreciated project that acts as a time capsule for early 2000s TV. It's clear that Malcolm in the Middle still holds a lot of sway, especially with the recent references from Wandavision. When looking back on the series, it's still easy to fall in love all over again.

Ranking the main characters based on their humour, personality and involvement in the plot is an excellent opportunity to explore what keeps it good to this day.

9. Abe

Malcolm In The Middle Abe
Fox

The fact that the charming and loveable Abe Kernaban makes it to the bottom of this list is a testament to the quality of the characters in this sitcom, as this loving father and wonderful friend was easy to fall for. Gary Anthony Williams did a great job in the role, helping Abe feel likeable and chucking in some particularly funny moments.

However, there were a few downsides to the character that bring him down. For example, most of the show's roles had very distinct characteristics, but Abe never felt very unique. His personality and humour was mostly reserved compared to the others, and sadly this made him come across as very forgettable.

While Anthony Williams worked really hard in the role, he wasn't given tonnes to play with, as Abe always felt like a side character with no real importance to the plot. His only involvement came from other characters such as Stevie and close friend Hal, giving him no agency in the show's main story, and leading him to the lowest point on this list.


8. Dewey

Dewey Malcolm in the Middle.png
Fox

Of all the characters in the show, Dewey was the one who changed the most. Sadly, this wasn't down to a sense of development or organic progression. Rather, he grew out of his position, which resulted in the need to alter his character dramatically.

Initially, Dewey acted as the cute youngest brother, gaining humour from how adorable and seemingly innocent he was. Of course, he was secretly a master of mischief, and while watching this was entertaining, it often felt a little hollow. Child characters tend to feel shoehorned in for the cute factor, and while Dewey did that well, he still fell into the potholes of that cliché.

This couldn't last forever, and eventually, Dewey went into a slight crisis of character. He didn't have many characteristics outside of the cute factor, which Erik Per Sullivan's age didn't allow any more. The show worked around this by writing him into a musician angle, giving the Wilkerson family a sense of creativity that was lovely to see.

Sadly, while this was a good direction, it left him feeling far less consistent than the other characters in the series.


7. Stevie

Stevie Malcolm In The Middle
Fox

Stevie - the son of Abe - deserves a lot of credit for his importance in the show. This is due to the fact that he started as a seemingly one-bit character, designed to be mocked by the brothers, but fast became a series regular and good friend to the family, feeling like a true honorary member.

There's a lot that Stevie did right, most notably the connection to geeky archetypes of the time. With thick glasses and a weak disposition, the stereotypical loser character was a common trope during the early 2000s and even persists today. This gave Stevie a great place in the show and helped to show that while Malcolm was smart, he wasn't like his peers.

However, where Stevie fell short was in his lack of nuance. Despite being an amusing character, his poor breath control, slow speaking voice, and relative innocence was incredibly one-note, and he never got the right amount of development to overcome this.

He was a great piece of the puzzle but lacked the depth needed to rank higher.


6. Francis

Malcolm In THe Middle Francis
Fox

One of the show's funniest aspects was the strange rivalry between the kids and Lois, and no one embodied this better than Francis.

Having a child like him must be massively frustrating, as his abhorrent behavioural skills and reluctance to take responsibility for his actions seemed to be a constant source of stress for his parents. But, this made him all the more entertaining, as audiences love someone who doesn't care.

A huge aspect that Francis brought to the show was a unique narrative perspective. His position outside the main story was great and presented a unique cutaway which was often very entertaining. The young man's time in military school (Marlin Academy) and working at the ranch (The Grotto) were great changes of scenery, and gave the show some much needed variety.

Francis' biggest issue came from the fact that his immaturity could be frustrating. While the other boys could get away with their juvenile antics because of their age, Francis couldn't as he was a fully-fledged adult. While he did grow up a lot during the series, his delinquent nature was often rather damning for his character.


5. Craig

Malcolm In The Middle Craig
Fox

Malcolm in the Middle worked because it took typical aspects of everyday life and blew them out of proportion. Craig was a fantastic part of this, as everyone knows someone like him. There are just some people who have good intentions in life but find that nothing ever goes their way. This poor character just needed to catch a break, but it was clear he never would.

While Craig was likeable enough - thanks to his lack of luck and underdog status - he could also be very arrogant and corruptible by power. These flaws only served to make him more interesting and led to some great moments, such as his tyrannical rule over Lucky Aide and intense Softball skills. Additionally, his unrequited love of Lois led to plenty of tension between him and the family.

He ranks slightly lower due to the fact that his side character status made him often feel irrelevant to the leading family unit and the fact that his rather annoying personality and creepy love of Lois made him somewhat unlikeable at times.


4. Reese

Malcolm In The Middle Reese
Fox

Reese was virtually unrecognisable at the beginning and end of the show. He started out as the typical bully older brother, and was a rude, obnoxious and violent character. Yet, it was hard not to feel drawn to him thanks to his amusing naivety, character development and solid performance from Justin Berfield.

Unlike Dewey, Reese's dramatic evolution felt genuinely organic, as viewers were shown a softer side to him, which didn't contradict the aggressive and violent aspects they already knew. Reese's blissful ignorance made him so likeable, which only made his previous seasons as the violent older brother even more compelling.

One of the best additions to the character was his discovery of cooking. There was a time when it seemed Reese would never find something he was truly passionate about, but his love of making good food was a lovely addition to prove that no matter how much you struggle, there is something out there for you.

Everyone who has an older brother could understand Reese's character, and even without such experience, it was easy to relate to him, despite how over-the-top he was.


3. Lois

Malcolm In The Middle Lois
Fox

As stated earlier in the article, one of the show's most significant selling points was its ability to take everyday life and convert it into humour. This is what helped it become incredibly relatable, and for many people, Lois was one of the most ubiquitous characters.

Plenty of viewers could identify with her, either because they had similar perceptions of their mothers or because they knew how hard motherhood was and how you could never win.

The series presented Lois - played sublimely by Jane Kaczmarek - as an over-the-top villain, holding a tyrannical rule over the low-income family. Her anger and punishments became a major part of the show's narrative, as almost every episode revolved around the children trying to misbehave, all while avoiding their mother's wrath.

However, on the other end of the scale came the fact that Lois was totally understandable. Her children were little monsters, and it made sense that she was so demanding and angry all the time. This was the icing on the cake, as her motives were believable, despite how extreme her methods were.


2. Malcolm

Malcolm In The Middle Malcolm Frankie Muniz
Fox

The show's titular character needed to land well on this list, and it's safe to say he does. While his arrogance could be frustrating, Malcolm was believable thanks to his position as the middle child and his agency in the plot. As the eponymous hero, the narratives often revolved around him, and while this did alter as the series progressed and the focus shifted, you never lost that sense of him being the lead.

It felt a little hard to relate to him at times, thanks to the fact that his status as a genius made him overly confident. However, this worked really well, as it made him flawed and, therefore, more enjoyable. Despite his abrasive moments, Malcolm was funny and had a great repour with the other character. Plus, it was impossible not to fall for his youthful cynicism.

Although all of these aspects bring him up, one major component helped him stand out, that being his position as the fourth-wall-breaking narrator. He was the only character to talk directly to the audience, and that made him your eye into the world. For that, he ranks high but isn't quite number one.


1. Hal

Hal Bryan Cranston Malcolm In The Middle Water Park
Fox

It really could be no one else.

When thinking about Malcolm in the Middle's best elements, you come up with plenty of buzzwords like humour, relatability, goofiness and character. Hal is the person who embodies all of these aspects best. He captures everything that made the show unique, thanks to his position as a goofy dad, massive overreactions and phenomenal performance from Bryan Cranston.

The father of the Wilkersons was by far the funniest character, and this came from the fact that he constantly made mountains out of molehills. Whether it was because he panicked too quickly or just got a little too invested in something (dance revolution, rollerblading or speed-walking, for example), you could always rely on him for some ridiculously over-the-top humour.

However, despite how ridiculous this character was, you could still relate to him as he fulfilled the fun dad archetype. He was embarrassing and oblivious but cared about his wife and kids more than anything else in the world. Sure, his ego got out of whack sometimes, but he always fell back to loving his family.

Sometimes it's hard to remember that Walter White hasn't always been a badass.


Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!