Marvel's Daredevil: 18 Problems With Season 2
As Helen Lovejoy is oft to say, 'Please, won't somebody think of the bathophobiacs!'
When I was asked if I was keen to write an article about the problems in Daredevil Season 2, I immediately said yes. Then I realized that I basically said yes to publicly labeling all the reasons why my supermodel girlfriend who does volunteer work and loves rugby union isn’t perfect.
Season 2 of Daredevil was everything I wanted it to be and then some. This isn’t only because my hetero life-mate Frank Castle was finally given his due as a live action character but because it was simply a stellar show with great acting, writing and fighting all around.
This article will include feasible gripes balanced with some more tongue-in-cheek points because I’ve now become the internet’s equivalent of that lady who comes to your school to check everybody’s hair for nits.
Here are a few of the problems found in everybody’s favourite show about a blind lawyer with super senses, living in an city destroyed by aliens. A multitasker who dishes out justice whilst simultaneously having philosophical debates with a man who’d rather punch a bullet through your head then punch you.
The Devil of Hell's Kitchen was consistently coerced to get his hands dirty in Season 2 and this left a couple of stains.
18. ASAP Slap Of Sanctimony
Foggy Nelson himself isn’t a bad character in the slightest. In fact, when weighed up against the other supporting characters in the Marvel Universe, he’s arguably the most important counterweight to the heroic title character. Without Foggy, there’s no Matt and without Matt, there’s no Foggy.
Despite the fact that I’m kind of embarrassed that, as a young’in, I once wanted to be partnered with Foggy (he was one half of the Bash Brothers in The Mighty Ducks), I can’t slag the guy. He got to shine during this season. He killed it in the People vs Frank Castle case and rightfully put Matt in his place after all the times he s*** on their friendship and business for a piece of that Eleketra pie.
Still, Foggy is in a perilous position because he’s forced to make the consistent, sanctimonious speeches. Which he goes and does immediately in the second scene of the very first episode. For anyone who is unsure of the relationship between the two, the conversation is forced and it looks like they’re going to suck face at the end.
Going from Frank straight out slaughtering a whole bunch of Irish mobsters to an immediate philosophical debate was jarring and made for an awkward opener.
17. 'Oh, This? Eh, It's Just A Scratch. A Massive, Deep, Horrendous Scratch That Will Most Likely Claim My Life'
There was once a thug, name of Grotto
Irish mob, messed with Frank and got shotto
His response to this hit
Was to say, ‘Eh, f**k it’
And just to go to a bar and get blotto
Grotto was the sole survivor of The Punisher’s onslaught on the Irish mafia, barely escaping with nary a scratch on his side… except for the giant, obvious shard of shrapnel that he had protruding from his side. Going to the bar to find Foggy and Matt to represent him, Matt senses Grotto’s elevated heartbeat and warns him from stirring any trouble.
After revealing that he’s actually there to find Nelson and Murdock (how he managed to do that in such a short amount of time is also unrealistic), they have a perfectly normal conversation until Grotto passes out because of the previously mentioned giant shard of shrapnel.
Either Grotto is tougher than Brock Lesnar’s punching bag or his tendency to forget the burden of mortal wounds is a serious affliction that needs immediate attention.
16. 'We Go Together Like Pump Action Shotguns And A Whole Bunch Of Bullet Spread!'
There are going to be very few problems related to Jon Bernthanl’s portrayal of Frank Castle in this article, but there was something about his official, physical introduction to the series that bothered me immensely.
Frank’s leisurely stroll down the hospital halls to finish off Grotto (Castle isn’t a man of half measures) was a scene of cinematic beauty but it was his use of a shotgun, a weapon known for its spread, and unleashing its fury that had me a little stifled.
Now, The Punisher and a shotgun go together like ramma lamma lamma ka dinga da dinga dong but not only were there civilians clearly in the line of fire, Karen was also running beside Grotto the entire time. Yes, Frank is an expert marksman but the spread of a shotgun is not as predictable as that of a semi-automatic weapon; he could have easily clipped and/or killed an innocent.
15. This Show Has An Agenda Against Bathophobiacs
Daredevil is in not a show for those with Bathophobia, which is basically a fear of hallways combined into a phobia towards depths (‘Bathos’ in Greek means depth).
Could you imagine suffering from this obvious, debilitating fear that would probably hinder you on a daily basis and then watching this show? You would have a fear-induced anaureysm in every single fight scene.
I know that hallways make for great framing devices (Frank’s bloody, brutal and intimate gauntlet in prison being my personal highlight) but the showrunners really need to claim responsibility for all the poor bathophobia sufferers out there.
A hallway in Daredevil is like a shrine for suffering, pain and death. How would this world work if every single hallway was clearly out to get you? Hallways are getting a bad rap and somebody needs to speak up for them 'cause they’re really not all that bad, just a little overzealous when they get one too many tequilas in them.
14. Punishment Versus Paraplegia
This is a problem that arises in pretty much every superhero focused media in which the hero absolutely refuses to take a life but DAMN Daredevil!
The core concept of this season was to place ‘funhouse mirror’ versions of Matt up against him and see what sparks will fly. However, after seeing the cruel canvas that Matt uses to paint a picture of pain and potential paraplegia and comparing it to Frank’s ‘one shot, one kill’ mentality, you really have to question that maybe Matt is a sadistic bastard.
More often than not (and this isn’t talking about the ninjas because ninjas don’t count), Matt absolutely eviscerates his enemies and clearly cripples them.
Being so hellbent about not taking a life, it’s kind of jarring to see that he’s more content to cripple a crook so they need to s*** in a nappy henceforth.
‘NO, FRANK! KILLING IS WRONG! KILLING IS SO WRONG, I WON’T STAND IT! WHY CAN’T YOU JUST PILEDRIVE THEM ON CONCRETE, SNAP EVERY EXISTING BONE IN THEIR BODY AND THROW THEM DOWN STAIRS INSTEAD! CLEARLY IT’S MUCH MORE MERCIFUL! YOU HEARTLESS FIEND!’
13. Teasing Us With The Coolest Superhero Concept Ever
After an intense back-and-forth philosophical debate with Frank, Matt (in a scene lifted straight from a Garth Ennis and Steve Dillion’s ‘The Choice’ Punisher story), has a pistol taped to his hand, with Frank testing him to see if he’ll truly take a life to save one.
Eventually, Frank opens fire on the Dogs of Hell (the residential bike club) and Daredevil escapes, forced into a melee with the rest of the charter. He takes them all out in a glorious brawl with the gun taped to his hand the entire time.
Now, DD having the gun taped to his hand is not a gripe I have about the show. What does bother me is now I want to see a hero who has a guns stuck to his hand. Could you imagine that guy trying to make toast?
12. Matt Murdock Sells Black-Market Bananas
This is a problem that has been often overlooked throughout the entirety of the series existence; how in the hell does Matt Murdock afford his apartment? He’s in Manhattan (albeit a decrepit part – still, residency in Hell’s Kitchen, fictional or otherwise, wouldn’t be cheap) and his apartment is admittedly awesome.
It’s been a running theme that Matt and Foggy are broke. They may have a plethora of clients but they’re getting paid in currency such as bananas and pies, which only pay the rent if your landlord is Donkey Kong.
Still, Matt’s always in a tailored suit, looks a million bucks (except for all the cuts/bruises you get from brawling every night) and appears as if he would smell great (or at least have real soft hair). Bananas and pies aren’t paying for that apartment.
Unless he’s selling them? Are black market bananas worthy of punishment?
There you go, I just spoiled Season 3.
11. Second Act Lull
After all the conundrum of battling, bartering and breaking down barriers with The Punisher, the season then introduces the most important woman in Matt Murdock’s life: Elektra.
Her portrayal, design and mixture of confidence and vulnerability all spoke true to the core of the character (I wish Frank Miller would give this show a chance but I wouldn’t hold my breath) but after feeling the force of nature that was Frank Castle, Elektra’s introductory episode in the mid-season was a little too much of a breather.
Obviously, audiences need the chance soak in everything they have just witnessed but going from the heart-wrenching confessions of Castle in the cemetery to Matt and Elektra’s cat-and-mouse relationship seemed to be more of a step back than a step forward in terms of ‘must see’ television.
Or course, the show corrected itself hastily but you cannot deny that Frank’s boots were initially a little too big to fill and word is that ninjas generally have tiny feet
10. Nobody Fondly Remembers Law School
This is a minor nitpick and I won’t spend too much time discussing it but I happen to know a fair few people who went to law school and let me tell you this: none of them remember it fondly.
Yes, Matt literally wears rose coloured glasses but the way he and Foggy discuss law school was like it was the time of their lives. My baby mumma suffered and slogged through law school (she did awesome, thanks for asking) and there is no way that any law student looks back at the days where they had to cry into books thicker than their head for nights on end.
Law school is a horrible time (except for those times you got so blind drunk that you don’t remember that you're a law student). Matt and Foggy make it seem far more fun than it actually is.
9. I Hate To See You Go, But I Love To Watch You Leave
Matt Murdock is a ladies man. This may not be as prevalent a factor in the show as it is in the comics, but he has an undeniable charm that few women can resist. Maybe it’s because he is being one hundred percent sincere in a world where everyone has an agenda. Or maybe it’s cause he’s more ripped than a cactus’ Fleshlight.
It’s because of this ability to bed a bevy of beauties that Matt Murdock may have put his identity truly at risk. Matt was flabbergasted when Elektra stated that she knew he was the Devil of Hell’s Kitchen. You know why? Because, and I quote, ‘You can’t mask that a*s.’
This poses a rather large problem for Matt because it turns out the junk in his trunk may result in him being dumped in a trunk. If he goes the route of the ladies-man he's been portrayed as, this is trouble. A crisis this serious deserved much more attention than it was given and should have received a justifiable story-arc in which Matt tries to valiantly change the appearance of his a** to no avail. I want to see my Daredevil dare jorts.
8. Speaking Of A Big A**hole...
What was up with that big a** hole? My money’s on it’s being used as some form of travel to Kun Lun (where Iron Fist garnered his monicker) but for the depth and scope that it possessed, it was nothing more than a weird afterthought.
This hole was used as an episode-ending cliffhanger, with Daredevil and Elektra waiting patiently to hear how far it actually travels (at least forty stories) but it is never referenced once afterwards. No one stops to say, ‘Yo, you remember that ridiculously giant hole in the ground? That was some weird s***, right?’.
No matter where you are in the Big Apple, if there is a giant hole in the ground, people tend to notice. If Beyonce’s cellulite gets a two-page spread in some shlocky entertainment magazine then a hole that would go through subways, power lines and the like would not be so easily overlooked. It’s visually impressive but served less purpose than, say, a giant hole in the ground.
7. What's Good, My Ninja?
As most normal people often do, I love me some ninja. Part of the appeal of Daredevil is that he can be dealing with the type of thugs you’ve probably crossed paths with at the pub and then be fighting a mountain of ninjas the next minute. The character thrives seamlessly within two immensely different worlds and he’s all the more interesting for it.
As the season progresses, it’s hard to shake the feeling that maybe there is such thing as too many ninjas. The fights are a spectacle but the Hand ninjas are the red shirts of the Daredevil world and it’s only men like Nobu who seem to possess any form of threat.
In fact, for some reason, Matt can hold his own against multiple ninja foes, yet when he has to go one-on-one, it’s the most knock-down, dragged out and intense battle yet. I can’t speak math pretty well but I’m fairly certain that the higher the percentage of ninja, the higher the chance they have at defeating an opponent. Yet, in Daredevil, it seems to be the opposite.
6. Maybe That's Why He's Called 'Stick'?
When Elektra casually strolled back into his life and brought with her a mess of martial arts mysticism with the Hand and Chaste, Matt immediately put his legal life on the backburner and left Karen and Foggy high and dry to represent The Punisher. What was quite possibly the biggest trial they’ll ever come across paled in comparison to Elektra’s needs.
When Karen goes to confront Matt and finds Elektra in his bed, she’s understandably upset. Both because of their romantic link (Matt and Karen’s, not Karen and Elektra’s, unfortunately) and because Matt seemingly ditched them in their greatest time of need for another woman.
But Karen didn’t stop to ask just who the hell Stick was. I mean, if Stick wasn’t standing there, the scene would make a lot of sense. It looked like Matt and Elektra had done the sideways shuffle and were engaging in some pillow talk. But for someone as intuitive and curious as Karen, to not turn around and ask just who the hell the weird, David Carradine-esque, old, blind man was seemed ridiculous.
It’s as if she immediately assumed that Stick was part of a weird, two-thirds handicapped Ménage à trois. Have you heard the one about two blind blokes trying to screw an assassin? Neither have I and that’s the point.
5. Matt Was Willing To Throw It All Away
Nearing the end of the season, Matt Murdock has finally come to the conclusion that he is in way over his head and that both he and Elektra are up against insurmountable odds in the form of an ancient, organised crime syndicate full of ninjas. The war between the Hand and the Chaste is both ancient and everlasting and now they have become deeply entrenched in this battle for supremacy.
In an obvious fake out. Matt tells Elektra that they’ll run away together. Forgot the Hand, the Chaste, Stick, Hell’s Kitchen, all of it… Just go off into the sunset and make awesome looking babies on a beach in the Bahamas.
After a season of witnessing Matt Murdock travel through every circle of hell to protect his unkempt kitchen, hearing these words come out of his mouth just seem a little shoehorned. He later told Stick he basically loved her, but wouldn't admit it, but come on.
I mean, I’m not blind and even I can see why running away with a woman who looks like that seems like the best idea ever. However, I’m also not a hero sworn to protect a city with bloody knuckles each and every night due to my overwhelming sense of duty. I just kick dogs cause it’s easier.
4. No! Boo!
Nobu is an undeniable badass and was proof that the Hand actually had found the secret to resurrecting life. He was a true presence and was basically the only ninja that you knew would be making a difference when he arrived. His fight with Matt in season one was spectacular and he only continued to highlight his abilities throughout season two.
However, in the final showdown, there were a couple of things that Nobu did that made me slap my brother’s head with my palm. Firstly, in the fight pitting the remaining Hand ninja against Daredevil and Elektra, four of the guys stand by while Nobu takes a tag-teaming from the two elite fighters. They literally stand there and watch their superior get his a** kicked and don’t dare move an inch.
Maybe it was due to their respect for him, but Nobu never stated that he wanted them to stand back. In fact, the numbers game seemed to be their direct and distinct approach throughout the entire season, right up until it would have actually worked for once.
3. Nobu Stooped To A Power Rangers Villain Level
Lastly, when Nobu kills Elektra, he allows her and Matt to have a moment before she dies. Yes, I know it’s for the sake of drama and emotion but it took me back to when I was a kid, yelling at the monster-of-the-week in Power Rangers to just attack them when they were forming whatever Mega Tigerzord superweapon they had. It would be a fifteen minute montage and the enemy just stood there. Dragon Ball Z gets a pass for allowing people to power up, though, because shutup.
Nobu’s a monster who uses children as blood donors, zombifying them to create an ancient resurrection chamber and probably parks in handicapped spaces because he’s an a**hole. Allowing Elektra and Matt to whisper sweet nothings so The Punisher can arrive and turn the tide of the battle made absolutely no sense whatsoever.
2. Where Are The Orchids?!
I know that this is all due to the characterization of Elektra and her general aura as an enigmatic, heart-stealing warrior who exits your life as quickly and nonchalantly as she entered (right after she turned it topsy turvy), but if the woman sacrificed herself for you, I’m sure you’d have something to say at her very lonely funeral.
This is what Matt Murdock, oh wise conjurer of philosophical debates revolved around the moral intricacies of justice and vengeance, had to say at his lover's funeral (the woman he was prepared to drop everything for):
‘I wanted to say a few words about her. I don’t have any.’
Are you serious, Matt? That’s all you got? I mean, Stick simply said, in his smary way, ‘God rest her soul’, because Stick IS a smarmy !*$%. But Matt, who can have a heart-to-heart with Frank Castle of all people, chose that zinger for Elektra’s funeral. Then he tries to tell Stick that he was all like, 'Pfft, I didn't love her' and Stick is like, 'Sure, buddy'.
And to make it all worse? He tells Stick that she likes orchids. WHERE ARE THE F***ING ORCHIDS THEN, MATT?!
No wonder Elektra is going to be resurrected for the third season; she has to get revenge for the worst funeral ever.
1. Hell's Kitchen? God's Thermomix
In the finale of the season, Karen Page has taken over Ben Urich’s old job as a journalist and voice of the people. Here’s what she writes after The Punisher and The Hand have shaken Hell’s Kitchen to its core:
Rather poignant, I’ll agree, (let me pretend like my degree in Creatrive Writing gives me at least a modicum of a validity) but there’s one thing that completely bothered me about this powerful, thoughtful, soul-searing monologue.
Karen’s writing about Hell’s Kitchen like it’s Haiti or some s***. Sure, the Chitauri tore that place up but I’d take a home in Hell’s Kitchen over a tent in the Congo any day because in the Congo, my limbs are about as safe a frat party for date-rape enthusiasts. Yeah, there’s ninjas and there’s a guy going around shooting (hardcore criminals) on a consistent basis, but Hell’s Kitchen seems like God’s Thermomix when compared to too many other places to list.
What issues did you have with Daredevil Season 2? Let us know down in the comments.