MCU: Ranking Every Netflix Marvel Season Worst To Best

How does The Punisher Season 2 compare to Netflix's other Marvel Cinematic Universe TV shows?

Marvel Netflix Shows
Netflix

Although it only launched back in 2015, the Netflix corner of the Marvel Cinematic Universe already has enough content to outstrip its big screen counterpart, with six different shows, 12 different seasons, and well over 100 hours of action.

It all started with one hell of a bang, as Daredevil banished all memories of the Godforsaken Ben Affleck movie from 2003 and entirely changed perceptions of what the MCU could be, with the pop colours, witty banter, and CGI sequences replaced with a dark aesthetic, adult themes, and a grounded approach that felt a world away from Iron Man and Captain America (who received passing mentions, but of course would never appear).

Four years on, and after a number of highs and lows, it might all be coming to an end: Iron Fist, Luke Cage, and Daredevil have all been cancelled, and the long-term futures of the remaining series are up in the air. The Punisher Season 2 is the latest to be added to the mix (and likely the next to be cancelled), but how does it compare to the rest of the Netflix MCU?


12. Iron Fist Season 1

Iron Fist Finn Jones
Netflix

Prior to Iron Fist's arrival, it seemed like Netflix and Marvel's partnership could do no wrong. Luke Cage may have struggled in the second half of its first season, and likewise Daredevil Season 2, but still all of the shows up to that point were largely acclaimed by fans and critics alike, and generated huge amounts of hype.

Iron Fist, the last hero to arrive before The Defenders, changed that. With Game of Thrones' Finn Jones in the title role, the show sadly had very little to do or say; the plot, such as there was one, was stretched thin even by Netflix standards, Jones' charisma-less performance was more Danny Bland than Danny Rand, the villains - and there were a lot of them - unfocused, undeveloped, and uninteresting, and worst of all the fight scenes, which should've been the saving grace, were horribly choreographed.

It's not all bad: Jessica Henwick's Colleen Wing is a legitimately excellent addition to the universe, and the Drunken Master-esque fight scene with Lewis Tan's Zhou Cheng is gloriously entertaining, but between the Hand and the Immortal Iron Fist, this is punching well below its weight.


11. The Defenders Season 1

Defenders Netflix EW
Netflix/EW

The Defenders was the master plan; the equivalent of Phase One's build-up to The Avengers, this brought together four heroes after each had a solo series (and Daredevil had two seasons) under their belt.

The idea, as conceived back in 2013, was a solid one, but the execution, coming in 2017, was not. Although only eight episodes long, the show still suffers from the pacing problems that plague so many of these shows, with the biggest crime being that, despite already spending dozens of episodes with these characters before a team-up we knew was coming, it still took until the end of the third episode before bringing them together.

It was also another victim of the Hand, who remained vague, out-of-place, and, well, incredibly dull. The direction was particularly poor too, with the universe's darkness taken so literally it was difficult to make out what was going on at times, and while each of the central characters - even Danny Rand - is well served, it can never justify its existence beyond being a corporately mandated event.


10. Iron Fist Season 2

Iron Fist Season 2
Netflix

Iron Fist's second season doesn't magically solve all of the problems from the first; it can't make Finn Jones a proper lead actor, nor Danny Rand a hero you really want to root for, but dammit at least it tries. It's a series well aware of the issues with Season 1, and it does its best to offer an apology - including its biggest and most welcome change, which is cutting the season down to just 10 episodes.

It means the pacing feels much better, even if there's still a lot of going round in circles with the plot, and it does make some genuinely interesting decisions late in the season.

Alice Eve's villain is a huge step up from the ones we saw in Season 2 as well, but unfortunately there's still a lot of plodding to get through before the good stuff happens. It's not the mess that Season 1 was, but it's the kind of poor-to-middling fare Netflix and Marvel should be much, much better than.


9. Jessica Jones Season 2

Jessica Jones Season 2
Netflix

While it's far from the worst season of these shows made, Jessica Jones Season 2 is, by some distance, the most disappointing. After a stunning debut run, which established Krysten Ritter's hero as one unlike any other, we had to wait two-and-a-half years for the follow-up, and we got this.

The single biggest problem with Season 2 is that it's been ordered by Netflix, and yet doesn't actually have any story to tell. Season 1 had an incredible focus, and was driven by the personal, character drama and trauma of Jessica and the villainous Kilgrave. Season 2, on the other hand, doesn't really know what it wants to be.

There's no real antagonist, and the plot meanders around in a number of different directions, never fully-committing to any of them until it's much too late, and making a few strange decisions in the process, especially regarding Trish. That it works at all largely comes from another phenomenal performance from Ritter, while its messaging and themes are also great, and there's some really excellent direction, it's just a shame it's all wrapped up in a 13-hour slog of a story.


8. Luke Cage Season 2

Luke Cage Season 2
Netflix

With Luke Cage now a viral sensation, Mariah Dillard taking over the Stokes empire, and new villain emerging in the form of John McIver, there's a lot to like about Season 2 of the show.

It doubles down on a lot of what worked in the first, with more excellent music, fantastic performances from the likes of Simone Missick and Alfre Woodard, and a story that tackles themes of black culture and history, identity and community, immigration and politics, and most of all family. It should be engrossing stuff, and at times it really is, but the biggest problem here is Netflix bloat. There's simply not enough plot to sustain 13 episodes - even 10 would be a stretch here - and it turns what should be a rich saga into a bit of a chore, even if the individual pieces are worth watching.

Like with Iron Fist's sophomore year, Luke Cage Season 2 saves its biggest, most interesting moment for the end, but the journey there never fully justifies it, and since it's been cancelled, nor will the future.


7. The Punisher Season 2

Punisher Season 2 Close up
Netflix

The general trend, Iron Fist excluded, is for the Netflix Marvel shows to suffer a sophomore slump, and The Punisher is no exception. Thankfully it doesn't suffer quite as great a drop-off as, say, Jessica Jones, but its second season didn't quite come together as well as the first.

The biggest problem is its attempt at telling two distinct storylines - one involving Billy Russo who, after the events of Season 1, is out to regain his memories and gain revenge, and another involving the mysterious Amy and the even more mysterious John Pilgrim. Both have their moments, but the structure means deviating away from them in turn for long spells at a time, and they're never able to coalesce.

Holding it all together, though, is Jon Bernthal. He proved with Season 1 that he's the definitive Frank Castle. He proves in Season 2 that he's the definitive Punisher; a raging, animalistic killing machine who comes to embrace exactly what he is, without trading on attempts at being a good person, having a dark humour, and showing some vulnerability too. Add in some stunningly brutal action sequences, and Season 2 is still largely a success, just not quite as big a one as the first year.


6. Luke Cage Season 1

Marvel Luke Cage
Netflix

Choosing between Season 1 & 2 of Luke Cage, and indeed The Punisher Season 2, is a little bit of a coin flip - overall, there isn't much difference between them. However, Luke Cage Season 1 edges it because, for the first seven episodes, it's right up there with the best of this universe.

The conflict between Cage and Cottonmouth is riveting drama driven by both character and theme, with Mike Colter's bulletproof hero a steady, sturdy presence and Mahershala Ali shining brightest than his megawatt smile with a mix of cunning and charisma, and it's all backed up the MCU's most distinct soundtrack.

It's not just that it's thematically rich, but that it uses those themes to craft a fascinating power struggle in Harlem, which itself becomes a character, and complex characters, including one hell of a supporting cast. Sadly, the final six episodes suffer after a shocking twist at the midway point: the story begins to stall, and new villain Diamondback cannot come close to matching Cottonmouth - indeed, he's downright laughable at times. Had Luke Cage stuck the landing it'd be much higher here, but that it's not even lower is simply a testament to how good the first half was.


5. Daredevil Season 2

Daredevil Punisher
Netflix

Coming just a year after the first season in order to capitalise on its success, the second season of Daredevil starts off with a Bang, the first episode introducing us to Jon Bernthal's instantly defining take on Frank Castle.

The first four episodes serve as a Daredevil v Punisher mini-arc, and if it was to be judged purely on those four episodes, it'd be among the best things the MCU has done: a gripping, explosive, and tight story with great action and performances. Unfortunately, it's also the downfall of Season 2, because what comes after cannot hope to live up to it.

The rest of the story introduces us to the Hand, who are boring from the off and can't match the intensity of the brawls involving Matt or Frank in other episodes, and Elektra, who is more of a mixed bag, but results in some poor decisions from Matt. The season never feels like one complete whole, with its multiple sections never really coalescing into a singular form, which leaves it a bit messy, but still very entertaining.


4. The Punisher Season 1

the punisher
Netflix

Following on from his incredible introduction in Daredevil, a solo series for Frank Castle was quickly commissioned, and for the most part it didn't disappoint.

Frank Castle, not The Punisher, is the key there, because Season 1 is much more about the man behind the moniker, taking a deep dive into his psyche, and what motivates him to be the seemingly ruthless killer he is. Some of it is stuff we've seen played out before - Daredevil touched on the character's backstory too - but Bernthal's bristling intensity makes it work, as does his chemistry with Ebon Moss-Bachrach's Micro.

Some of the conspiracy plot doesn't work though, while some of its messaging is very muddled, and you could really cut this down to a mini-series of around 6-8 episodes and have something really special, because once it gets going - with the villains properly established, and Castle let loose - it is nothing short of incredible; a blistering, violent, gunshot of a show.


3. Daredevil Season 1

Daredevil poster
Netflix

The one that started it all also remains one of the benchmarks for the Netflix Marvel Universe. It's difficult to overstate just how much of a game-changer this was back in 2015, being so different to every other MCU product out there - the two TV shows at that point, Agents of SHIELD and Agent Carter, were more in line with what you'd expect - but even without that context, it more than holds up.

Charlie Cox gives a haunted take on Matt Murdock that'll make you forget Ben Affleck ever suited up as The Man Without Fear, and even better is Vincent D'Onofrio's Wilson Fisk, who manages to give a performance of such ferocity, such menace, and yet such nuance that no MCU villain had then managed to come close to, and few have since either.

With a jet black darkness at its core, and a fierce rivalry between Daredevil and Fisk for Hell's Kitchen's soul, it merges superhero action with epic crime drama to wonderful effect. Like most shows, it could do with a little editing down, but most of it is so gripping it's never too much of an issue, and if the performances and storyline don't do it, the jaw-dropping action certainly will.


2. Jessica Jones Season 1

jessica jones netflix
Netflix

Daredevil showed what a serious, adult drama set in the Marvel Cinematic Universe could do, but Jessica Jones perfected the model. Taking a character unknown to mainstream audiences, it was a superhero show that aimed for something bigger, and pulled it off.

This isn't just about crimefighting, but rather a deeply personal story of abuse and addiction, with the series touching on topics including depression, abortion, rape, and PTSD with the kind of approach such subjects need, but without ever coming off as too heavy-handed or clumsy. Key to that is Krysten Ritter, whose Jessica possesses the same kind of inner darkness and demons as Matt Murdock, but mixes them with a genuine sense-of-humour too.

There's a great balance hero, with the series managing to be funny and sexy without undercutting its violent and dramatic elements, and the battle between Jessica and Kilgrave (David Tennant giving one of his best, and most frightening, performances as another complicated villain) is cackling with intensity.


1. Daredevil Season 3

Daredevil Season 3
Netflix

One of Netflix's most recent Marvel offering also manages to be the best, bucking the recent downward trend of the universe to deliver its most complete season yet.

Picking up several months after The Defenders brought Midland Circle down on top of Matt and left most people believing him dead, he returns to the streets of Hell's Kitchen, ready to give up being Murdock and instead live as the Devil in order to stop Wilson Fisk - who has negotiated his release from prison to a high-security penthouse - for good.

The first season looks like a warm-up match compared to what follows, even if the season mostly keeps them apart, with Benjamin 'Dex' Pointdexter drafted in to do a lot of the fighting. The clashes are brutal and bloody, but there's also an engrossing crime mystery at play too with regards to Kingpin's control. The supporting players are fleshed out, with Karen Page in particular stepping up big time, and the season plunges Matt to horrifying new lows.

With a gorgeous visual style that blends the gothic with the religious, story elements adapted from Frank Miller's Born Again and yet going off in its own bold directions, some brilliant performances from everyone involved, and action sequences so good they make Season 1 look like Iron Fist (well, not quite, but you get the gist), this wasn't just a return to form, but a whole new benchmark, and - given the cancellations - one unlikely to be topped.

Which Netflix Marvel season do you think is the best? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.