MCU Theory: How The Original Black Captain America Changes Everything
Falcon & The Winter Soldier could turn Sam and Bucky against the government.
What if the new Captain America is the real villain of Falcon & The Winter Soldier? What if Steve Rogers' legacy is going to be taken apart just as Iron Man's was in Spider-Man: Far From Home?
And are you ready for Falcon and The Winter Soldier to be at war with their own government (again)?
The key to all of this is a secret buried in the past of Captain America and the super soldier serum programme.
A new news report from Deadline has confirmed that Carl Lumbly has joined the cast of Disney+'s first MCU show and the exciting suggestion is that he will be playing Isaiah Bradley. If the name doesn't mean anything to you, it should - he was the first black character to take on the mantle of Captain America.
He was introduced in 2003 in the Marvel Comics limited series Truth: Red, White & Black and quickly became a tragic fan favourite thanks to the strength of that story. Along with a huge number of black soldiers from World War II, Bradley became a test subject in a government scheme to recreate the super soldier serum that transformed Steve Rogers into Captain America.
His possible inclusion is a huge deal and not merely because he's an important character in Marvel lore, but because of what his involvement will mean for Sam Wilson and his own transformation into Captain America.
4. Project Rebirth
In Steve Rogers' story, becoming Captain America was a noble choice of the subject - he entered it knowing the stakes and the possibility of death. He effectively put himself forward as a sacrifice to help win the war and while he came out of it with some obvious positives, that potential sacrifice matters. He chose to take on the great power that comes with great responsibility and in the MCU, his attitude it precisely what makes him the perfect candidate.
For Isaiah Bradley and the hundreds of other test subjects, it wasn't a matter of such simple choice. They became part of Project Rebirth, a collaboration between US, British and German who came together to replicate the super soldier serum.
In a narrative choice designed to mirror the real life Tuskegee Syphilis Study - in which African American men were told they were getting free healthcare but were in reality infected with syphilis to observe the effects of the disease untreated - the serum's early forms were tested on African American soldiers. That's incredibly dark material, but it's something the MCU will apparently use as an important reference point, and it's important.
It gets darker too. In the comic, only five of the test subjects survive - including Bradley - and then in the name of secrecy the government executed the commanders of the camp they were taken to as well as hundreds of black soldiers at the camp. Their families are told they died in battle.
If Bradley's story is being used in Falcon And The Winter Soldier, it is an incredible, important decision and one that completely reframes Sam's story. It's a brilliant way to bring in a real world issue - well, several, given the focus on eugenics at the moment - that deserves amplification.
[CONTINUED - Page 1 of 4]
3. Isaiah Bradley: Captain America
Despite the strength of the story that brought him to the comics, Bradley is something of a lost figure in Marvel lore. His name is nowhere near as well-known as Sam Wilson, who inherited the famous shield and it's about time he became as important as he deserves.
In the comics, he ends up being the sole survivor of his test group and in a move that mirrors Zemo's story in Civil War, takes on the mantle of Captain America when he steals a costume and shield and embarks on a suicide mission to destroy the Nazis Super Soldier efforts. He's captured after taking out their top scientist and experimented on as the Nazis seek to reverse-engineer him, but escapes. Stunningly, on his return to America, he's court-martialed for his actions and imprisoned from 1943 to 1960 when he's pardoned and released.
So why is he so important to Falcon And The Winter Soldier? Well, the answer is two fold. First, it comes down to what he and his history mean to Sam.
[CONTINUED - Page 2 of 4]
2. Sam Wilson's Burden
Despite the fact that Sam was handed the shield at the end of Endgame by Steve Rogers, we know that he doesn't start the Disney+ show as the new Captain America. For a start, the hint is in the title.
The big rumour is that Sam rejects the Captain America mantle, which leads to the government taking their own approach and hiring John Walker - otherwise known as US Agent in the comics - who will become the government endorsed new Captain America while Sam and Bucky presumably continue to operate underground.
Given the events of Civil War and Bucky's story, it should come as no surprise that Sam would reject the government using him as a symbol. It's disrespectful to Steve's memory and it's worth remembering that during Infinity War, Steve is still operating underground. In Endgame, he's retired. There is no Captain America because Steve hasn't healed his rift with the government. Why would Sam agree to be their puppet?
But the suggestion put forward by SlashFilm's sources is that after initially rejecting the mantle, Sam is convinced when he discovers the story of Isaiah Bradley, who was the original Captain America.
Presumably, the show will slightly redevelop Bradley's history if that "original" label is to be believed: so instead of Project Rebirth, we find out that the quest to develop Steve's serum involved the clandestine experiments on other test subjects. In essence, Sam and Bucky will discover that the US government were no better than HYDRA and the Soviet Union, who used guinea pig test subjects to create their own super soldiers and assassins.
And who better to blow that secret apart than Zemo...?
[CONTINUED - Page 3 of 4]
1. Zemo, The Government & The Super Soldiers
The reason for Zemo's reappearance makes a lot of sense in this context: he discovered the secret of The Winter Soldier programme and its undiscovered super soldiers (who he killed) and his disdain for Captain America and the idea of government sponsored superheroes with no accountability could make the value of a secret like Project Rebirth even higher. In his hands, it would be a weapon to bring down the entire government.
If you think about it, Zemo's hatred of Captain America as a symbol sets him up perfectly as the right person to destroy his legacy. And that is something we've already seen in the MCU in Spider-Man: Far From Home, in which Mysterio's real plan was to discredit Tony Stark and destroy HIS legacy. For them to revive that idea would fit their usual approach to using similar themes across multiple stories.
And making Captain America a product of an evil scheme with secret victims would absolutely fit.
With the story focused on the secret of the first Captain America and his fellow test subjects, we could see Sam and Bucky tracking Zemo after his escape, discovering the secrets of Project Rebirth and realising that the US government are the real villains.
That would set them on a path of clashing with John Walker's new Captain America and his government sponsors as they attempt to reclaim what that mantle means and change the perception of Steve Rogers' legacy. That would also make Walker the villain of the piece, which we all suspected when it was announced that US Agent was going to be involved at all.
Having the rebranded US Agent take the mantle of the new Cap is important here too, because it will fit with Sam's personal crisis over the meaning of being Captain America. Walker is no more than a jingoistic symbol doing the government's bidding - he's The Winter Soldier with an acceptable face - and his militaristic attitude and inevitable over-enthusiasm will make him the opposite of what Steve Rogers stood for.
Sam and Bucky fighting him to reclaim the Captain America name is a hugely significant symbol and calling back to the man (or men) who almost lost everything so that Captain America could even exist is a big deal too. Giving him his name as Sam seeks not only to clear Steve's but also find his own is perfect. Having him reclaiming that history and putting respect on Bradley's name would be perfect too.
In short, Isaiah Bradley is going to be the key figure in convincing Sam Wilson to become Captain America and by the time the show finishes, we will legitimately have a new Captain America.