How I Met Your Mother Finale: 10 Questions We All Need Answered
It's still hard to believe that How I Met Your Mother is finishing, let alone still airing. The miracle of its shelf life is well appreciated by us fans, and the final season looks like it's poised to wrap everything up quite nicely. Even though we're already 8 episodes into the final season of How I Met Your Mother, there are still plenty of reveals and events that the writers need to satiate us with before we riot. After all, we still have burning questions that date back all the way to 2005. So I put together a wishlist (more like a checklist) of situations we definitely need to see before the mother of all shows comes to an end. They range from events that have been set up in recent seasons to things we've been waiting to have explained since the first season. Including... 10. Where The Pineapple Came From
Okay, this is a longshot, but Craig and Carter have said that they will answer all of our unanswered questions. If you don't recall, the pineapple was shown all the way back in 2005 during Season 1. After a night of heavy drinking, Ted forgot everything that had happened to him while hanging out with Barney. As a result, his friends had to explain the events of the previous night to him when he woke up with a pineapple on his nightstand a woman sleeping right next to him. In other words, Hangover ripped off How I Met Your Mother, which is pretty amazing. We found out what Ted did that night and who the woman was, but we were never told where the pineapple came from. And we've been waiting...patiently. How could the writers reveal this in Season 9? Hopefully, it will tie in with the mother. We already know that she pops up several times throughout the series, though Ted obviously never meets her. It's possible that the pineapple came from her or is connected to her somehow, and Ted could learn this when he first meets her or even in a flashforward. She could have been working at a midnight farmer's market, or more convincingly, she could be connected to Trudy (the woman Ted slept with) in some way.
9. Why Ted's Hand Is Bandaged When He Meets The Mother
When Season 8 premiered, we saw Ted sitting at the bus station with his hand wrapped up and bloody. This has apparently happened after the wedding, and it's the moment when Ted meets the woman he eventually marries. So...why is his hand messed up? Earlier in the show, Ted tells his kids he's only ever been in one fight, and that was his fight with Doug at MacLaren's back in Season 4. My first guess was that Ted got into some kind of disagreement with Barney over Robin, and they've been building that conflict up as being the climax of this season-long wedding. But if Ted's only been in one fight, then something else must be about to happen. What could that be? So far in Season 9, we've seen Ted romancing Cassie, a girl at the wedding who has been emotionally unstable. It's possible that Ted meets the mother before the incident at the bus station and Cassie gets between them somehow. Another possibility is that Ted tries to sever ties with Cassie, which is met with violence somehow. We'll just have to wait and see!
8. The Final Slap
The slap bet isn't over. Marshall still has two final slaps to dole out to Barney before the series ends. Kids, you remember the slap bet. Back in Season 2, Marshall and Barney made a bet over Robin and whether or not she was in porn. Believing he won, Barney slapped Marshall, but it turned out that Robin was actually a Canadian pop star. As slap bet commissioner, Lily ruled that Marshall could slap Barney 10 times in a row or 5 times spread out over eternity. Barney foolishly chose the latter, and Marshall has been tormenting him ever since. When we got to the last slap in Season 7, however, Barney made a new deal with Marshall. Marshall let Barney get rid of the ducky tie (another inside joke) if Marshall could slap him three more times. With two left, we know that at least one slap is coming January 14 thanks to www.theslapbetcountdown.com. My guess is that this episode will have a flashforward to Thanksgiving, or Slapsgiving if you want to be cool about it.
7. What Barney's Job Actually Is
Barney has worked for some shady corporate businesses during the series' run, including the indomitable GNB. But we still have no idea what Barney actually does besides fire people, make deals with Koreans and make tons of money in the process. Whenever asked, Barney goes to his typical answer, "Ha! Please." But how great would it be if we finally knew what it was that Barney does? Of course, the mystery adds to the enigma of Barney Stinson, but the writers could certainly reveal this in a way that tugs at our heartstrings (they've pulled this off in the past). How great would it be if Barney came to the realization that his heartless career and obsession with suits was the reason he couldn't make it work with Robin? That would be a serious issue to address as these two get married and have to balance their love lives with their careers, and I think that's definitely worth watching.
6. Whether Or Not Barney And Robin Will Go Through With The Wedding
Things between Barney and Robin have been shaky at best since they first became love interests in Season 4, and there's been a lot of doubt as to whether or not they'll actually stay together if they do end up saying, "I do." We know that Ted will be making some kind of move to get Robin back with the locket, and we know that Robin is pretty flustered with Barney at the end of Season 8. In the flash-forwards so far, we've seen clues that point to both possibilities. We've seen Barney and Robin dancing at the reception, and we know at least Barney goes on the honeymoon. But we've also seen Barney without a wedding ring. Strangely, they've kept Robin's hand away from the camera in all of the flash forwards, so we really don't know for sure what's going to happen. Will they get divorced? Will they stay together? Only time will tell.
5. How Everyone Else Will Meet The Mother
The writers have told us that everyone else will meet Ted's future wife before he does, starting with Lily. In the Season 9 premiere, we got to see Lily become the first person to experience the woman we've been waiting 9 years to see, and their "how we met" story was quite flawless. She and Lily were fast friends, but how will everyone else receive her? Since we know that the mother and her band will be playing at the reception, it's clear that Barney and/or Robin will meet her to plan the wedding. I can see Barney drooling all over her, but Robin is notoriously bad at making friends with women. How will that go? I'm not worried about Marshall, though. If Lily likes her, there's no way Marshall won't have a quirky interaction with the legendary mother, possibly during the reception. The best scenario would be for them to bond over Marshall's terrible jokes about fish. After all, we already know the mother has some Zooey Deschanel-like peculiarities.
4. Meeting Robin's Mom
Speaking of meeting mothers, when will we get to meet the ever-elusive Madame Sherbatsky (or whatever her last name is)? In a recent episode, we almost got to meet her before she cancelled on attending the wedding altogether, but I'm not so sure the writers will just leave it at that. This would be a major character development for Robin, who clearly has some lasting mommy/daddy issues that we still haven't fully discovered. And what about Robin's sister? We already know that some of Robin's family is already there and ready to shoot the doves after the ceremony (that's another event we're waiting to see), but why is Robin's immediate family more difficult to track down than the secondary characters of Saved By The Bell? If they do introduce Madame Canada (I've decided), this will be a big moment for the season that many of us would love to see. Having her surprise Robin by showing up at the ceremony could play into the cold feet it looks she's going to get. Maybe all she needs is some motherly advice she's been sorely lacking, though it's great that Barney's mom, Loretta, stepped up and filled that role in a recent episode.
3. Will Ted Get To Name His Kids Luke And Leia?
We'll most likely see a few flashforwards of Ted and his future wife having their kids, but we still don't know their names (or even the mother's name at that). Ted has always vehemently declared that the love of his life will let him name his two kids Luke and Leia, so it will be extremely fun to see how the mother reacts to this request. It could go either way. The mother has been portrayed as a quirky spirit so far. The kind that reminds me of the wacky parents you see pranking their kids on iFunny. Since it's clear that she's going to fall in love with Ted, and his own idiosyncracies, I have little doubt that she's going to at least meet him halfway. So, maybe they'll name their dogs Luke and Leia.
2. How Ted Meets (And Falls In Love With) The Mother Of His Kids
I know this is kind of a given, so I added the part about falling in love to keep you from rolling your eyes. Okay, we've all been waiting for this, some of us for 9 years. How are the writers going to meet our expectations? They clearly took the safe route by pacing themselves with little reveals here and there, staying away from having us meet the mother at the same time as Ted and even showing us how he's going to propose to her. Still, there's a ton we have yet to see. After all, there's a pretty good chance that the mother is still dating Louis, the guy that Ted talks about in The Time Travelers episode from season 8. How is Ted going to win her heart when it looks like it's already taken? For me, that's going to be way more interesting than an exchange of "Haaaaave you met me?" My prediction is that the writers will keep showing us flashforwards of their future relationship before Ted and the mother actually meet. I wouldn't even be surprised if we got to see their wedding before they lock eyes for the first time.
1. Ted's Kids...9 Years Later
Once Ted finishes the mother of all stories, how we are going to view the kids? Are they going to be Ted's age by the time we see them onscreen again? Rumor has it that all of the scenes with Ted's kids, including this one, were filmed years ago. If that's true, then the continuity will be salvaged. Otherwise, this is going to be a somewhat awkward conversation akin to this promo. Part of me hopes that they do have the aged kids displaying their reactions to Ted's ridiculously long tail because that would mean we get to see the mother join them on the couch and prove that she's not dead. It just wouldn't feel right if we didn't get to see the whole family together. Additionally, how great would it be to see some flashforwards with Barney, Robin, Lily and Marshall hanging out with the kids? I have a feeling that the surreality of these moments would break my television. What other HIMYM questions do you want answered before the show ends? Share your thoughts below in the comments.