Mindhunter Season 2 Review: 5 Ups & 3 Downs
After almost 2 years, David Fincher's excellent TV show returns in style.
Mindhunter's first season was met with near universal acclaim from critics and audiences alike. Now, almost 2 years later, viewers can finally see the new chapter of Holden and Bill's story. But did David Fincher's creation not buckle under the pressure?
TV shows with great first seasons have the sad tendency to get radically worse the longer they go on. More often than not, the spark that made the show work simply disappears and fans have to stomach unwelcome changes to performance and writing quality.
Thankfully, this curse has seemingly passed Mindhunter by. Season 2's 9 episodes aren't without some minor faults, but overall the shows high quality has not only been retained, but one might even argue that it's gotten even higher.
In the wake of the news that Netflix prefers to cancel its shows after 2 seasons, Mindhunter not only decides not to put a definitive closure on anything, but also subtly teases more great things to come. After the appetite built by the excellence of this new batch of episodes, season 3 is a must. Hopefully we won't have to wait another two years to see it.
SPOILERS incoming.
First, let's look at the positives of the second season...
Ups
5. An Effective Villain
Wayne Williams appeared quite late in the season, but even then, that isn't actually a negative. He was smug, calm, collected and knew how to play the game with the police and the press. In the short run, it was endlessly frustrating but also very interesting to watch, and crucially, because of the way he was introduced, he didn't overstay his welcome.
His calm voice and annoying smirk could easily have got on the audience's nerves after couple more episodes, but keeping his presence short and sweet was a masterstroke. After so many episodes of build-up, the villain had a considerable weight of expectations on his shoulders: in short, if he was disappointing, the whole chase would've felt pointless.
Thankfully, it worked out great, thanks to both excellent writing and the actor's performance. His tics, vocal performance and demeanour all combine to an unnerving effect, especially during the more tense scenes and while his arrest could feel anticlimatic, ultimately that's the way the events played out in real life, so it's hard to argue with.
4. Even More Superb Acting
Mindhunter couldn't possibly work, or at least couldn't be considered such a high quality show, if it weren't for the excellent acting. For the most part, the entire cast once again did not disappoint.
Bill Tench's inner conflict and frustration were easy to sympathize with in most part thanks to Holt McCallany's superb performance and Holden hadn't lost any of his quiet intensity this season and thanks to Jonathan Groff also remained a joy to watch. Somehow, he also managed to become way more likable.
The show also really hit the mark with supporting characters this season. Henley, Charles Manson, Son of Sam or Wayne Williams wouldn't be half as memorable if not for some truly great casting choices. It's worth to note that none of them really had much time to work with, so it's doubly admirable that they managed to leave their mark.
3. More Of The Same, But In A Good Way
While some second seasons always seek to reinvent the wheel, Mindhunter thankfully stuck to what it knows. Season 2 does shake up the formula in some ways, but crucially, in others it was very much more of the same. Season 1 was adored for a reason, so there was no point to changing some of the things that worked.
Previously, Holden and Bill's interviews with the killers were some of the most engaging and interesting scenes of the whole show and it's no different this time around. While it was always going to be difficult to beat Cameron Britton's Ed Kemper, the interviews with Charles Mason and Son of Sam among others once again struck the mark. It's just a shame they were so short, seeing as there was a potential for more.
Once again, the dynamic between core characters remains the focal point of the show. The complicated relations, complete with frequent secret keeping, between Gregg, Wendy, Bill and Holden really glue the show together and feature heavily in some of the show's best scenes.
2. An Engaging Storyline For Bill
Bill was already an interesting character in season 1, but the writers really focused on letting him develop in season 2. His family issues, while perhaps a little on the nose, made him a much more complex and easy to sympathize with character. Having the agent who studies killers' son become one was a little bit of a stretch, but ultimately it worked.
Tench's problems weren't just limited to his home either. They added a wonderful layer to many of his other interactions, especially in the Charles Manson interview. It was clear that he was conflicted about whatever his son could be considered responsible for his actions and what his crimes would say about him as a father.
One could almost psychically feel the restlessness and powerlessness both Nancy and Bill felt in relation to Brian. He was their son, whom they loved and they tried to somehow rationalize his behavior, but they couldn't find a way out and seemingly felt trapped. The whole situation was heartbreaking both for them and the viewer and it felt like there were no good solutions.
Seeing the way we left things at the end of season 2, there are many ways the situation could develop. One way or another, it probably won't end ell.
1. The Atlanta Child Murders Case
The Atlanta Child Murders case was the main storyline of the entire season and there's hardly anything to criticize in the way it was executed. With every new body and still lack of suspects, you could positively feel the tension rising.
The whole storyline was centred around the feelings of hopelessness and powerlessness that the case inspired. On another show - one written and acted less expertly, perhaps - the endless waiting and slow pace of the investigation could be perceived as boring. In Mindhunter though, it only made the viewers more emotionally invested and vying for a conclusion of some sort. A conclusion that both in reality and in the show we may never completely get.
The way the case ended could feel underwhelming to some - after all, Wayne was only convicted of two of the murders, and the cases relating to the children remain open to this day. But historical accuracy was the best way with this one, especially with a show like Mindhunter, it would be naive to hope for a simple and traditionally happy ending. The tragedy of the situation only helped make even more of a impression on the viewer.
And now on to the negatives...
Downs
3. Too Many Killers, Too Little Time
Before getting into the specifics, it's worth noting that all of the downs are rather minor gripes that only marginally spoiled the overall enjoyment of the show. You can probably expect them to be ironed out by the time the show returns.
Having said that, the show seemingly bit more that in could chew in season 2 with the sheer amount of killers on our screens. BTK killer's vignettes, while interesting back in season 1, have managed to lose some of their shine, and the whole plotline started to feel a little underwhelming.
Most of the season was dedicated to the Atlanta Child Murders case, which saw its conclusion at the very end, however, the creators also decided to pepper in an assortment of other famous killers, including Charles Manson and Son of Sam. While both Manson's and Son of Sam's scenes were engaging, well written and kept the viewer on their toes, they went by very quickly.
After spending so much time on Ed Kemper last season, restricting such interesting characters to couple short minutes seems like a waste of potential. Especially Damon Herriman's outstanding performance as Manson warranted more screen time.
2. Wasting Anna Torv's Potential
Apart from Holden, Bill and Ed Kemper, doctor Wendy Carr was one of the most intriguing characters the first season had to offer. With her role not being too extensive, many may have expected to learn more about her in season 2. In some ways, we did, but in others, not at all.
Wendy's storyline this season was mostly centred around her sexuality and making her first steps towards becoming a more hands-on part of the whole operation. Both of those plots seemed fine on the surface, but after completing the season, they retrospectively feel rather underwhelming.
During the course of 9 episodes, we learnt that doctor Carr was recovering from a toxic relationship. With Kay, she constantly kept putting her feet in her mouth and went too deep, too fast. Her throwing out that magazine at the very end marked a lack of actual development and return to square zero. It wouldn't at all be surprising if we never see Kay again, much like Debbie, Holden's season 1 love interest.
With regards to the Bureau, this season Wendy wanted to become more involved with the practical, not scientific side of the work, however, her interviews came out as rather underwhelming and in the end she hadn't achieved much. She was simply no match for Holden.
Anna Torv is an excellent actress, but in season 2 she still hasn't gotten many opportunities to showcase it. Her storyline wasn't a total miss, but it didn't keep up with the rest of the show. Not to mention that she hardly even appeared in the finale. Here's hoping that season 3 will finally give her a chance to shine.
1. Not Following Up On Holden's Panic Attacks
One of the more disappointing aspects of the season was the way the show dealt with Holden's panic attacks. With the way season 1 ended and season 2 started, it seemed like they would be focal point of the season, or at least Holden's main story this season.
And yet, after couple of episodes they seemed almost non-consequential. "He's back", said Bill, and that was it. Holden popped a Valium or two for the rest of the season, but the topic was pretty much never revisited. Seeing the psychological effects of the job was an enticing prospect, but instead we got a dead end.
It would possibly be wrong to say that the creators simply forgot about it, because it would make sense that we will see those panic attacks come back with vengeance next season, but the whole plotline seemed to have zero impact on Holden and the rest of the show.
What did you think of Mindhunter's second season? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.