Modern Family: 10 Examples Supporting Phil Dunphy's Candidacy Of TV's Best Dad
I haven't met one person who doesn't like ABC's hit show Modern Family. It has won 18 Primetime Emmy Awards in total and has only been on the air for four seasons. That is pretty impressive. The reason this show is so successful, I think, is because it is extremely well written and the character developments mirror real life. We have watched the Dunphey children grow up before our eyes and it reminds us of when we were young and how we felt about our parents, however coddling or distant they might have been. I think we all secretly wish our parents were more like Phil and Claire Dunphy. Controlling, but not too overbearing. Funny, but not too embarrassing. Motivational, but not forceful. As great of a character as Claire is, I'd like to focus, if I could, on Phil. There is no denying that Phil is a family man. He's a fabulous husband, the sole breadwinner (until recently), and loves his children to the fullest extent. The Dunphy children are lucky as all hell to have as involved a father as they do, though they often misinterpret his awesomeness as lame and an attempt to appear relatable as the "cool parent". Is it true? Yes, at times. Phil often tries to seem like the more appealing parent, but not because he is intimidated by the natural bond between mother and child, but because of his relationship with his own father. Watching Phil and his father is like watching everything about a perfect upbringing in one minute. Phil is an excellent father because his father was excellent. Yes, he may be a little much at times, but he really steps it up when it comes to helping and supporting his children. I've compiled a list of ten examples that support my opinion that Phil Dunphy is the best father on television. For you Modern Family fans out there, you will agree, I have no doubt. For those of you who have never seen an episode of the beloved show, I'm sure this list will strike a chord and perhaps you'll give it a try.
10. "Go Bullfrogs!" - Season 3, Episode 6
... in which he lets Haley have fun, but checks up on her in an embarrassing way Nothing in the world would have made Phil Dunphy more proud in his first born followed in his collegiate footsteps and attended his Alma Mater. During those precious months of visiting campuses, Phil takes daughter, Haley, to visit his old stomping grounds without Claire. He spends the day showing her all of the fun things he used to do as a Bullfrog, to her utter embarrassment, though she starts to find some humor in it, allowing her to enjoy the time spent away from home with her father. Towards the end of the night, Phil and Haley find themselves at one his favorite bar/restaurants from his school days, eating the best wings the area had to offer. While there, the campus tour guide invites Haley to a party. Initially, she declines the invitation because she is finally having a good time with Phil. Phil, though, tells her its okay for her to go. She leaps at the chance and leaves, but not before thanking him. It only takes a matter of minutes for Phil to get a whiff of the kind of party he's just allowed his teenager to attend when hearing it was taking place at an infamous fraternity house. Cut to Phil marching into the frat house hosting the party to drag his daughter out of a possibly threatening situation. This results in one of the more mortifying experiences in Haley's life, as Phil is not aware the frat house is merely hosting a party for potential students, where faculty and parents were welcome to come. The episode ends with an endearing heart to heart that is enough to make anyone want to give their father a big hug. Even most though teens are able to judge a situation for themselves, it is always a nice reminder that your parents actually care about you when they show up to check on said situation. So what if she was embarrassed? She ended the night knowing that her father is always going to be looking out for her, whether or not she approves. That is a nice thing to know.
9. "Manny Get Your Gun" - Season 2, Episode 8
... in which he expresses his love for family camp and his daughters Phil loves hanging out with his family and especially loves to do so at family camp, a several week long excursion during the summer that the Dunphy girls (including Claire) are not huge fans of. Phil enjoys showcasing his family and how well he believes they get along and love each other. On top of which, the Dunphy's left family camp victors of the Capture the Flag competition as members of the infamous "white team", prompting Phil to walk around spewing a racist victory cry (without his knowledge), further pushing his family away from the idea of returning to family camp. In this episode, after a spat with Claire about getting to a restaurant the quickest way, Phil and the girls get into his car while Claire and son, Luke, get into hers, attempting to race each other on different routes to finally put an end to the eternal "whose way is faster?" argument. During the ride, middle child, Alex, admits that she doesn't want to go back to family camp, which leaves Phil completely defeated. He loves family camp so much that he didn't realize how hated it was by the rest of his family. The girls' telling him that they think what he looks forward to every summer is stupid translates to Phil that they think hanging out with him in ridiculous, which prompts him to give a speech about knowing the day would come when "his daughters would outgrow him". Phil begins crying, which makes the girls cry, and a very emotional conclusion is formed; even though they love him indefinitely, the girls are not interested in the same family building techniques as Phil. I am always amazed at how free Phil is with his emotions. Having a father that didn't really share his emotions was a little, I don't know, drab. I think it's important for both parents to actively encourage their children to be emotional, no matter how ugly or poorly timed that emotion might be. It is okay to be emotional with your family. If it's not, then who will you ever be able to get emotional around?
8. "Good Cop, Bad Dog" - Season 2, Episode 22
... in which he cracks the whip on Haley and Alex in hopes they will stop taking advantage of him In another daughters based lesson, Phil is assigned to be the bad cop while the designated slave driver Claire takes Luke and step-brother, Manny, out to celebrate a good report card. The boys express they are unhappy Phil will not be included in the fun as much as Phil does, however it is agreed that it's his turn to take the reigns. Initially, Phil takes the nice route, asking the girls to clean their bathroom before going out and carrying on with their plans for the day. Within minutes, they yell to Phil that they're finished and run to the car in order to leave. Phil, checking on the bathroom, sees it is still disgusting and runs out after them, yelling for them to stop. Haley still attempts to drive away, stopping only when Phil jumps on the hood of the car, claiming that they have "poked the bear", meaning big trouble. We watch as Phil, pale and stern, starts cracking the whip on the girls, forcing them to scrub, organize and unclog the bathtub - all average chores that don't seem unfair to me at all. To the girls' dismay, Phil begins taping their laptops shut and ordering them to continue on with their housework passed the point of Claire's instructions. His drastic change from easy going parent to wicked boss is a direct result of the girls taking advantage of him. When Claire gets home, after failing at being the fun parent herself, Phil is reduced to a stuttering mess, begging her to never make him be mean again. Though he is known to be a push over, Phil provides the girls with a very valuable lesson here. Don't ever underestimate a nice guy, especially when he has to power to take everything away from you.
7. "Run For Your Wife" - Season 1, Episode 6
... in which he proudly wears his number one dad shirt while missing his kids It is apparent from the beginning on this episode that Phil has had a wonderful time having his kids home for summer break. It is now, on the first day of school, that he realizes his life is going to change as much as his children's. Claire, however, basks in the first day of school glow, knowing she finally has time for herself again. In an attempt to keep his mind off of his children, Phil challenges Claire to a race around the block. Claire doesn't want to, at first, because she knows that she is going to beat him, which may upset him further. Halfway through the race, Claire is the obvious victor, however Phil is still trying with all his might. Hot, Phil removes his sweatshirt to reveal a T-shirt with his family's faces printed on it with the phrase "World's Greatest Dad" written as well. It is then that Claire realizes Phil is really hurting now that the kids are out of the house. She even says, "I realized that the first day of school is tough on all my kids, especially the one I married." Phil is not afraid to show how much he loves and cares for his family. I have never seen a more proud father in my life, especially with kids who, from the outside, don't appear to be particularly fantastic. The sporting of his beloved t-shirt is an everpresent reminder that, even though we may not be with our families, our families are always with us. Awww...
6. "The Butler's Escape" - Season 4, Episode 4
... in which he shares a story from his childhood with Luke and accepts his decision to give up magic Phil Dunphy is a magic enthusiast. There is even an episode dedicated to his high school rivalry with another magician he would often compete with in his youth. He was, presumably, elated when Luke took up the craft and encouraged him to pursue it. In this episode, Luke tells Phil that he is quitting magic and taking up other activities. Left without reason, Phil spends the rest of the episode revisiting his own magical talents, talking about how Luke is dismissing his natural abilities. While trapped in an act called "The Butler's Escape", Phil asks Luke to explain why he is quitting magic. Turns out Luke was being bullied at school for the talent, which is a subject that Phil can relate to. He shares a story with his son about his days of cheerleading (a portion of his past that he will forever be proud of) and how he would get made fun of for being on the team. He ended up having a wonderful time, though, meeting other male cheerleaders and getting to hang out with all the pretty girls. Whether or not the heart to heart had enough of an effect on young Luke to encourage him to take up magic again, I'm not sure. We don't see any further magic tricks coming from Luke throughout the remainder of the season. We can, though, confidently say that Phil made his son feel proud, if only for a moment, to be who he was and do what he loved. A very "magical" moment indeed.
5. "Party Crasher" - Season 4, Episode 16
... in which he explains perfectly how he feels regarding Haley dating a much older dude In one of the most watched episodes in Modern Family history, Phil has another breakout father moment. This episode focuses around Claire's father, Jay, and his wife, Gloria, during Manny's birthday, while the unexpected birth of their child rocks the evening. In a side plot, though, Haley, having been expelled from college and now working in retail, brings home a much older jean designer. Throughout the episode, he learns more and more things about the guy Haley is spending her time with, like how he's been married and divorced several times, though Claire convinces Phil that Haley isn't seriously attracted to the man and is doing it solely to piss them off. Once at the hospital after Gloria goes into labor, Haley and her beau state that they are going out to dinner, then to a party, and then going to get a hotel room because they'll be out really late. Claire, plastering a smile on her face, gives Haley a credit card and sends her on her way. As the elevator doors close, Phil loses his mind, dismantling Claire's course of action and calls a second elevator to run after her. As he travels down, Haley returns alone in the original elevator, demanding to know what Claire was thinking letting her leave with this older man. Claire remains silent and smiling. Phil returns, not realizing Haley has come back, and again starts yelling at Claire about her reverse psychology and how his daughter is only a young girl and he cares too much about her to let her go off with a scum bag. Haley then gets off her elevator and hugs him. Phil revels in his daughter's good judgement, Claire revels in being right, and Haley revels in knowing that her parents do care about her, even though she begs for adulthood. Phil was worried enough about his daughter to chase after her despite his wife's plans. Sometimes not listening to the other parent is the right thing to do. Had Haley not returned, Phil would have won father of the year for bringing her back down to Earth. You can see, though, that seeing Haley make the right choice greatly effects him and from this point on in the series, Phil trusts her even more. Not only that, but he takes Claire's methods of attack more seriously.
4. "Fears" - Season 1, Episode 16
... in which he faces his own fear to save his son and his son's truck One of my favorite episodes, "Fears" delves into several family members facing their fears (duh). Haley is up for her driver's test, which she has already failed twice, which sends the Dunphy ladies out of the house for the day. Phil and Luke, curious after a comment made by an exterminator who had recently been in their crawl space, prepare to look under the house for treasure. While Phil knows there isn't real gold or jewels underneath the house, he still believes there could be something fantastic that he and his son could share an adventure in rescuing. However, Phil is afraid of actually going into the crawl space. I think it's the creepy crawlers, though it isn't ever specified. Rather than go in themselves, Phil attaches a video camera to one of Luke's toy trucks and sends it in for reconnaissance, which Luke doesn't think is a good idea because it is his favorite truck. They go ahead and the truck, inevitably, gets stuck so Luke goes in after it. Luke then, inevitably, gets stuck himself and Phil must go in after him. And he does, proving once and for all that parents will do whatever it takes to keep their children safe.
3. "Moon Landing" - Season 1, Episode 14
... in which he takes on the role of mom after Claire leaves, embarrassed by her family This is an episode where I really feel for Claire. She meets an old friend of hers for coffee who describes what her life is like. While listening to the story, Claire realizes that if she hadn't married Phil and had children, it could be her life. In an attempt to one-up her friend, Claire talks about how wonderful her life is and insists they go back to the Dunphy house so that she can introduce her old colleague to her family. As if it were written (duh), the house is in complete disarray, two of the children reek of alcohol chasing a rat, Haley and her boyfriend are fighting publicly in the front yard, and Phil is locked in a port-o-potty sporting a ridiculous mustache. Much to Claire's dismay, her friend leaves as quickly as she can, and Claire is left to put the house back together. However, she promptly has a meltdown spawning from her personal disgrace for her life, and leaves the house and her family members as they are. We follow Claire to a fast food restaurant where she indulges in a greasy burger, listening to her interior monologue explain that, although she loves her family and that it should be enough, she wanted someone outside of her family to see how wonderful they are. She goes home and finds the house back in order, the children calmed and smiling, and Phil sitting at the head of the table with a pizza. He had single handedly put life back together for her. Without questioning her, without talking about the ordeal that had occurred hours earlier, Claire joins her family and the episode ends, no apologies necessary. Phil is an excellent father in this episode because of his ability to step up and take over when Claire cannot. He doesn't punish the children or make them feel bad for having embarrassed Claire (that we can see), but helps them clean up the mess and shows them that sometimes there are bad days, but it's nothing a pizza at the dinner table can't fix.
2. "Arrested" - Season 4, Episode 7
... in which he reprimands Haley for her bad judgement This is the first, and so far only, episode that we see Phil angry. Not just angry, but scary angry. Dad angry. Haley, who is away at school, gets arrested after a drunken altercation with a police officer. Initially worried for her well-being, Claire and Phil go to the campus, rescue their daughter from jail and then escort her back to her dorm room to prepare for a meeting with the school's dean and student liaison. Once back at her disgusting dorm, Haley expresses a very laid back attitude about the ordeal which sends Phil into a frenzy. He shockingly reprimands Haley for not being a serious student, for breaking the law, and for disappointing him to no end. After making a short speech about how she can't be treated as an adult and the difference between real life and movies, he storms out of the room, Claire proudly following. At the meeting, Haley is made aware that she is going to be kicked out of school, but not before delivering a very heartfelt speech about how she now understands the pain she's caused to her family and the embarrassment she's caused for the school. They clean out her dorm room and take her home, ultimately telling her that they forgive her for what she's done and promising that life at home would be vastly different from what it was like when she was in high school. Phil demonstrates, quite expertly, that constant yelling and promises of eternal disappointment mean less and less, no matter what the situation. When used sparingly, reprimanding will yield drastically positive results.
1. "Virgin Territory" - Season 3, Episode 16
... in which he admits that he trusts Haley and will not let her decisions change the way he sees her In "Virgin Territory", the truth about the status of Haley's virginity is revealed to Phil by Alex. On a trip to the mall to fix cousin, Lily's, doll, Alex accidently lets on to the fact that Haley is no longer a virgin, though it isn't said directly - presumably to keep young Lily in the dark. Their trip to the mall becomes evermore awkward when the doll repair diagnosis strangely mirrors how Phil feels about Haley knowing Haley is no longer a virgin. While Haley hints that she is still the same person, Phil breaks down slightly. He hugs Haley and metaphorically expresses to her that he trusts her and knows that she is a responsible person who makes her own decisions. At the end of the episode, Phil asks Claire how long she had kept Haley's secret from him. When she admits it had been months, instead of getting angry, he hugs his wife and thanks her for keeping it from him for as long as she could. It's clear Phil is very afraid of his children growing up and growing away from him, but as the series goes on and milestones are met, we see that it is getting easier and easier to accept the change around him. He is one hell of a husband, that is undeniable, but he is an even better father that America's audiences will not soon forget.