8 Most Pointless Deaths In Game Of Thrones

The Red God could have probably done without these.

Ygritte Shireen Game Of Thrones
HBO

The Many Faced God is cruel and indiscriminate but there are times when he's just greedy.

With shock deaths, off camera deaths, mass deaths and many more, Game Of Thrones is utterly saturated with corpses. And simply by the law of averages a story this wide and sprawling will kill a few errant characters that maybe could have gone without being killed.

Obviously, needless death sometimes has its own purpose - this is after all a cruel world where death is dealt with almost casually. It's a fact of life. But even then from time to time after we've stopped hiding our eyes at the horror we're left scratching our heads. 

We can be a little precious when it comes to our favourite characters but when drama is added solely for shock value, it can just seem odd at best and an utter betrayal at worst. Sometimes characters are offed just to get them out of the way, which might serve a purpose, but to fans will never feel anything but needless.

These are the worst examples of pointless deaths that either shocked for shock's sake, veered away from conventions of the show or feel like they were a little too blatantly assassinated by Martin or the show runners. 

8. Oberyn Martell

Game of Thrones HBO Oberyn Martell death
HBO

Season four kicked off with promises of revenge and reprisals and the most intriguing new character was Prince Oberyn. Finally that tragic tale of Elya Martell and her children was threatening to come full circle on the Lannisters. Finally we would receive some small portion of justice for some of the brutality in Westeros. 

What we got instead was a long, elaborate fake out by Martin and the show runners.

This doorway into Dorne was an interesting prospect on the small council and a huge threat for not only House Lannister but for enemies of Westeros. And given that he belonged to the only house that successfully resisted the Targaryens and their dragons, Oberyn made Daenerys' impending occupation all the more intriguing.

Volunteering to be Tyrion's champion was also exciting, like everything the Red Viper did. When we were treated to that fighting clinic he put on against the Mountain we were happy about Tyrion's direction and Oberyn's future arc. And then, out of nowhere he was abruptly and gruesomely popped like an over-ripe tomato.

This was shock for the sake of shock, and rather cruelly it felt like it was being set up as a book swerve. No such luck.

And to top it off, in the wake of his death, the connection would still be as volatile with Dorne and Tyrion would be free to sail away, after interrupting his father on the toilet. Pointless.


7. Barristan Selmy

Barristan Selmy Game of Thrones
HBO

As with all the great slain fighters on this list, the effort dedicated to selling Selmy as a great warrior was entirely wasted with a death that served no great purpose. This perhaps isn't the worst death for a warrior given that it actually took place in a battle of sorts but this was a man who carved out his legend in the White Book of the Kingsguard.

The Sons Of The Harpy were a clunky and abrupt addition to the  Meereen story and would have benefited from a much slower build to culminate in the death of a legend like Barristan The Bold. 

While the back alley labyrinth he ultimately died in evened the odds somewhat, there's not really enough in that sequence to convincingly sell the death of the best swordsman Jamie Lannister and Rickard Stark have ever seen. 

Perhaps it might have worked better if Barristan were saving Grey Worm from accomplished fighters as opposed to masked former slave owners. And it's not like it marked the culmination of a story.


6. Khal Drogo

Game Of Thrones Khal Drogo death Daenerys
HBO

This isn't only a pointless death, but the absolute worst way for the character to go out. 

If Khal Drogo was torn apart by wolves or died cutting himself out of the belly of a sea dragon nobody would have batted an eye. Instead he basically perished thanks to the combination of an infected boo-boo and some bad voodoo.

At one point the biggest threat to the crown was mobilising to cross the narrow sea and take the "Iron chair". That he was undone by a scratch is unfathomable.

Martin loves to cite historical accuracy when he inserts certain elements but that argument in support of this death comes across as pretty insufficient. Even ignoring the White Walkers and dragons, the widely accepted fallacies of fiction itself would eliminate this death as a viable option. 

Ultimately Dany learns and gains very little from the experience with Drogo: she eventually loses the majority of his men, replaces him with a lover and then ends up in season 6 back where she started. So what narrative purpose did his death even serve?!


5. Ygritte

Ygritte Jon Snow Game of Thrones
HBO

The whole fated lovers thing is actually a decent arc to have in a fantasy but the way this couple part ways is less tragic and more just tacked on. 

The shock factor was surprisingly low, in part due to the circumstances leading up to the death but also the death scene itself. The two share one last embrace after the shot to the heart and while it is a touching moment it doesn't fit in with the usual realistic coverage of death in Thrones.

The separation of these two was inevitable but it may have made more sense to have her death at Hardhome. It would have been better than introducing the red shirt female Wildling only to kill her.

If that were Ygritte sitting up with cold, dead eyes that scene would have been the perfect crown to a stunning episode.


4. Ros

Ros Game of Thrones
HBO

Originally just "The red haired !*$%," Ros' character was given more scenes and a name due to her impressive showing in her first scene. George Martin then said she should probably have a name if she would keep appearing.

If we've learned anything by watching Game Of Thrones it's that being an interesting and charismatic side character is tantamount to asking a Clegane to take a little off the top. Ros was no exception. 

While her death served to remind everyone about Littlefinger's low character and evil intent it still felt largely pointless to the story. She had leaked information to Varys and while this is relevant it felt more like Ros' continued presence was becoming problematic for the writers more than it was for the story. 

In closer proximity to Joffrey's death, this would have had a lot more impact, but as it was the writers missed a massive opportunity and Ros died incidentally.


3. Stannis

Stannis Baratheon Game Of Thrones
HBO

Described in Ice And Fire as the unbending iron to his brother Robert's true steel, Stannis really exhibits this in his death, which is made unceremonious by the man's own preference. Stannis the mannis would certainly not cower from death, but by the same token he probably wouldn't launch an attack on the largest stronghold in the North without keeping all of his men in line. 

Once again, this is where the books ring a little more true. He not only has his sell-sword army plus local reinforcements, but a plan on top of these superior numbers. 

Freeing the North up for what will no doubt be a bloody battle between good and evil in the form of Jon Snow and Roose Bolton respectively, Stannis' death serves a narrative purpose. It's just that the almost funny comedy of errors that brings it about is ludicrous.

The scene also involves a pointlessly distracted Brienne, who does not need to be distracted to miss Sansa or change the course of her story at all. It just felt like an excuse for Sansa and the North in general to be in a state of false peril going into the end of the season.


2. Jojen Reed

Game Of Thrones Jojen Reed
HBO

This poor Crannogman's death is the very definition of the term 'overkill'.

Arriving at their destination, Jojen is near death from exhaustion and exposure, stabbed holey by a Wight, finished off by his loving sister and exploded by some magic incendiary grenade, courtesy of the Children.

The scene may be the most gloriously fantasy filled scene in Game Of Thrones up to that point and it is reward at the end of a slow arc. Still, it felt like a needless waste of all that CG, particularly as the show then just left Bran's story alone for an entire season.

We don't know what they're doing with Bran in Season 6 yet but we do know that they are going back to him. There will be considerable need for more dynamism than visions and fever dreams as he hangs about in a tree and Jojen could have been part of that.


1. Shireen Baratheon

Game of Thrones Shireen Death
HBO

Oh come on!

In a world where we're hinging some pretty sketchy things on historical accuracy I'd like to posit one historical trend; Fathers, even devoutly religious ones, when in feudal medieval struggles for the crown, tend not to burn their daughters alive to get rid of some snow. A tactical mind like Stannis would surely deem that action tactically reckless given the state of his army at the time. 

 The death itself was horrifying on many levels and may have trumped the outrage over Sansa's rape scene. Maybe it would have been less jarring to the Princess' death if more men were sacrificed? It would certainly make it seem less like a completely out of character suggestion.

The premeditated nature of the infanticide illustrated by Davos' excursion back to the Wall was at least a good way to set up proceedings but it is one of those moments where you think Game Of Thrones may just be well written as villain porn.


Which of these deaths do you think was the most pointless? Share your picks below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

Eddie is a writer, cinephile, TV fan and wrestling abuse victim from Newcastle. After receiving his film degree in London he returned home to lift boxes in the vein of an 80s montage... It's not as fun as it looks in the films.