Netflix's YOU: Every Main Character Ranked From Worst To Best

The best, and worst, characters to be caught in Joe Goldberg's crosshair.

Netflix You Peach
Netflix

Developed by Greg Berlanti and Sera Gamble, YOU is the psychological thriller story of Joe Goldberg and his obsessive tendencies towards those around him. The first season was premiered in 2018 and was based off of the 2014 novel of the same name. written by Caroline Kepnes.

With twenty episodes and two seasons (with a third season confirmed for 2021) available at the time of writing, YOU has become one of Netflix's most watched and infamous shows. The show has such a unique tone thanks to its main character, played so amazingly by Penn Badgley, and his constant internal commentary stacked full of wit and quips.

Being told mainly from the perspective of Joe, with all of his heinous acts being constantly commentated on and justified by his running commentary, the show has a completely unique way of distorting perspectives and turning what would normally be an outright evil antagonist into somebody to root for.

And this distorted way of viewing characters and actions isn't just limited to Joe, with almost every character in the show being given plenty of shady layers and secrets that make them all a compelling watch. Here is every major character in YOU ranked from worst to best.

10. Ellie Alves

Ellie Alves YOU
Netflix

For someone who is meant to be only fifteen when they meet her in the show, audiences will be hard-pressed to find a character more self-confident and quip-heavy as Ellie Alves.

After their father died and their relationship with their mother had soured, Ellie and her sister Delilah moved to Los Angeles and began living in the same apartment complex that Joe would eventually move to in season two. A passionate filmmaker, she draws in Joe's 'care' once he realises she's involving herself with Henderson and later Forty, two of the more unstable individuals the show has thrown up outside of Joe.

As much as she is a victim, and she definitely is, there's no denying the fact that Ellie certainly landed on her feet better than most. Despite the fact that she spent the whole of season 2 mixing with sketchy individuals, ignoring the warnings people around her were dishing out and solo investigating situations she knew were dangerous, she's managed to bag herself a new fresh start out in the world with Joe supplying a steady stream of cash to keep her going.


9. Joshua "Henderson" Bunter

Henderson Netflix YOU
Netflix

Each season of YOU is nothing without a shady figure for Joe to obssess over and end up tangling with. Season one had Ron, Joe's neighbour and the the violent abuser of Paco and his mother, but this role would be expanded on big time and fall onto the introduction of Chris D'Elia's character, Henderson.

A hotshot comedian living in LA, Henderson is an absolute magnet when Joe first meets him, commanding the adoration of everyone from Forty to Ellie. It's Joe's mistrust of Henderson that really kickstarts his spiralling in the season and what really boots everything into unravelling across the season.

Henderson is written just a little bit too inconsistently to really stand out as either a genuine dodgy dude or another unfortunate victim of Joe's unhinged ways however. With Ron, Joe could overhear all of the abuse and torment he was subjecting his family to, which was why the eventual snap made so much sense, whereas Henderson is let down by essentially just being this celebrity that everyone wants to meet and then being someone who Joe starts creeping on because he doesn't trust him.

There are plenty of similar storylines across the two seasons, but this might just be the most shamelessly unoriginal.


8. Ethan Russell

Ethan Russell Netflix YOU
Netflix

A trusty right hand man who probably should have been a bit more aware of what was going on in the shop he was working in every single day, Ethan is a rare good character in the show that audiences can root for. And, unlike most other characters in the show, there aren't any sinister skeletons in the closet with him either.

Blessed with a big heart, Ethan begins as just a little sprinkling of comic relief in the show, constantly trying to talk to Joe at the worst times and constantly being dismissed by the bookstore manager, who is usually in the process of trying to clean up a crime scene or stalk someone on social media. Despite this, he's fiercely loyal to Joe and even refuses to disclose any information to Guinevere Beck about his mysterious relationship with Candace when asked.

There is more charm than meets the eye with Ethan however, and he does end up having a conquest of his own for audiences to root for when he meets Blythe, one of Beck's fellow students and a visitor at the bookstore.

As far as audiences know, Ethan Russell is still working at the bookstore having moved in Blythe at the end of season one.


7. Candace Stone

Candace Stone Netflix YOU
Netflix

The mysterious 'first girl' who dominates the entire atmosphere of the first season of the show with her unknown fate, Candace was Joe's ex-girlfriend who never learned to leave a murderous stalker alone.

The woman who helped truly unleash Joe's obsessive and toxic tendencies by cheating on and refusing to get back with him, Candace's shock arrival at Mooney's Bookstore in the first season's final scene was meant to be the ultimate moment of karma, however the show's decision to have her pop up halfway through the second season ruins almost everything the character had built up.

She tracks Joe down to LA, but then it feels like the writers were really caught in limbo over how they wanted her to be portrayed. She pops up sporadically, engages in this deadly cat-and-mouse game with Joe where she's constantly goading and threatening him, without really ever doing anything.

Her attitude isn't particularly relatable and the way she interacts with Forty and his family makes her pretty unlikeable on the whole. It feels like she was shoehorned in to tie up some loose ends ahead of season three, as well as supplying that shocking moment courtesy of Love Quinn.


6. Forty Quinn

Forty Quinn Netflix YOU
Netflix

The troubled brother of Love in season two, Forty Quinn is introduced as the embodiment of everything that Joe hates about Los Angeles and the people living its lifestyle. It's hard to pinpoint why exactly Forty takes such a liking to Joe in the series, besides the fact that they're two of the main characters and the show needs them together, especially when throughout the season Joe essentially treats him with complete indifference.

But there's more to Forty than what meets the eye, and his development throughout the season is perhaps the most volatile and tragic the show has ever produced. He goes from egocentric, cocky and selfish in the first few episodes, to a figure constantly on the wrong end of things and unable to see he's being played by pretty much everyone, to one of the few genuinely good forces left in the show and someone who can actually see Joe for who he is by the end.

Some of these developments work better than others, and the character come across as pretty unlikeable and unbelievable at times, but there's a certain rawness to Forty that is exposed over the course of the season which really makes for a gripping viewing once he hits his stride.


5. Peach Salinger

Peach Salinger 2 YOU
Netflix

Peach is another complex character to try and unwrap from season one of the show. She's introduced as being affluent and all too aware of it, enjoying a ridiculously lavish lifestyle and basically steering Beck and their friendship group along with her.

From the second she meets Joe she has a distrust of him that only grows as the series goes on. She is constantly badmouthing him to Beck and constantly trying to keep them apart by keeping her friend to herself.

Ultimately she's proven right about Joe, just not necessarily for the right reasons.

Joe remarks that he can see a cruelty in Peach that makes her apparently dangerous to Beck, and he's not particularly wrong either with 'Peaches' constantly belittling and showing a real lack of empathy to the people around her.

It turns out that Peach also has the hots for Beck, which is probably the reason for her instant disliking of Joe, and she attempts to seduce her friend a good few times despite her being in a relationship. Ultimately the deadly cat-and-mouse game Peach and Joe play against each other is a compelling watch, there's just no good 'guy' so to speak of in it.


4. Delilah Alves

Delilah Netflix YOU
Netflix

Steadfast, brave, smart and loyal to the one person close to her, Delilah is a character who has a lot to go up against in the show but comes out on top almost every time. Her one mistake in mistrusting Joe does end up being a deadly one, however almost every single other thing she thinks and acts upon is proven right by the time things are done.

Her initial distrust of Joe, which eventually grows into a friendship as they spend more time together, is one of the most believable arcs the show has ever thrown up, and she deserves a lot of recognition for being one of the few people to investigate Joe well enough to uncover his sinister other world when her suspicions sneak in.

Similarly to Candace, she isn't even taken out by Joe in the end, it's Love that gets that honour. He locks her in his cage, but she once again is able to use her judgement, logic and survivor skills to make it to the point where he is genuinely all ready to let her go free once he's all set to leave LA, something audiences hadn't ever seen a girl manage to achieve with Joe before.


3. Guinevere Beck

Guinevere Beck
Netflix

Portrayed by Elizabeth Lail in the first series and one appearance in the second, Guinevere Beck is portrayed as being a kind, clever and caring individual that absolutely has Joe pulled in hook, line and sinker. From their first chance encounter in Joe's bookstore, Beck is at the centre of everything for Joe.

A wannabe writer who ends up riding the most unbelievably meteoric rise over the course of next to no time, what makes Beck such an interesting character to watch is how the show is able to spill her secrets as Joe discovers them, meaning the audience learns about her as he does. This makes Joe's eventual delusion and distrust towards Beck become that little bit more believable for audiences.

So whilst Guinevere Beck is undeniably a complex character with plenty of layers and secrets, and the fact that her skills and traits for uncovering the truth are eventually the things that lead to her meeting her grizzly demise, the show never really dares to divert her character away from being just inherently good. The darker side to characters like Love just feel more at home in a show like YOU and help produce a slightly more interesting relationship with Joe.


2. Love Quinn

Victoria Pedretti
Netflix

Maybe just the best portrayal in the entire show thanks to Victoria Pedretti's performance, Love Quinn is the next girl to fall into Joe's radar and is, at the time of writing at least, still living to tell the tale.

Produce manager at Anavrin and an aspiring chef, Love stands out and kills every single scene she is in. Fiercely independent but also powerfully loyal to those she builds bonds with, her apathy to the world of social media and image conscious societies absolutely sticks out in show like YOU and is the big pull Joe feels towards her.

Her kindness and empathy for those around her, her brother Forty especially, is admirable in its own right, however when Love is pushed that's when the real beauty of this character comes through. She becomes almost more unstable than Joe is, and is actually the first person audiences see successfully turn the tables on him by locking him in his very own cage.

Love will stop at nothing to protect what she loves the most, which is just the perfect blend of admirable and unnerving in the show, and her kind and caring exterior is really what sells the shock of her shocking revelations late in the second season.


1. Joe Goldberg

Joe Goldberg YOU
Netflix

Everyone's favourite handsome bookstore manager turned stalker, kidnapper and serial killer, Joe Goldberg sort of blends together the roles of protagonist and antagonist in a way never seen before in the world of the television.

Almost everything in the show is shown through the eyes of Joe which, coupled with his internal thoughts being said out loud for the audience, makes all of his terrible actions appear almost justified and this obviously dangerous individual becomes a hero that audiences want to see make it through his trials.

In a way, Joe's charm and witty quips end up snaring in the audience as much as it does the unfortunate people who end up in his crosshairs. Individuals like Candace and Forty, who end up seeing Joe for who he really is, end up being presented as the baddies to the audience thanks to all the rationalising and genuinely funny running commentary he serves the audience.

Penn Badgley explained how Joe was: "the hero of his own story...every serial killer is" and it's important to remember that, however rational Joe sounds to himself, he's not the good guy in the story. Ultimately however his ability to make an audience empathise and even root for him is what really sells YOU as the compelling story it is.


In this post: 
You
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Horror fan, gamer, all round subpar content creator. Strongly believes that Toad is the real hero of the Mario universe, and that we've probably had enough Batman origin stories.