New X-Files Series: 10 Things Fans Want

Fox is officially in talks to bring the show back!

The truth is out there - again. Fox has announced that they are in talks to bring back The X-Files, using the term €˜revival€™ €“ and both Gillian Anderson and David Duchovney seem to be interested, with Anderson promoting #xfiles2015 on Twitter. It's huge news for fans of a show still wildly popular over twenty years after it first hit the airwaves. Maybe it was fate. At Comic Con 2013, the show's 20th Anniversary panel was one of the most popular and highly attended, winding up as a standing room only event that outdrew many upcoming film panels. At the time, many felt that Fox needed to cash in on the continued interest in the show by announcing a third movie, but though series creator Chris Carter and both Duchovney and Anderson were willing, the studio didn't take the bait. Carter instead wound up producing a pilot for a new show, The After, for Amazon, which was picked up for a series order based on its popularity with fans of its streaming service. However, just weeks ago the web giant announced the series would not be produced after all, with no explanation given. Now, during the Television Critics Association press tour, Fox TV chiefs Dana Walden and Gary Newman - who were with the network throughout the original run of The X-Files - have stated they're in talks with Carter to bring the show back, to the delight of Anderson, who's already pushing the Twitter campaign. Duchovney also recently stated he would be interested in doing more of the show. Anderson currently has both Hannibal and The Fall on her resume, and Duchovney is attached to the upcoming show Aquarius, but depending on the direction producers take, they could still have time in their schedule to revisit The X-Files. What do fans what in all this? Let's consider ten things fans will be looking for from a new/returning X-Files series!

10. The Original Stars Must Come Back In Some Capacity

Be honest - you don't even remember that Cary Elwes (Saw, Robin Hood: Men In Tights) and Lucy Lawless (Xena: Warrior Princess) had recurring roles on the final season of The X-Files. One of the big hopes of the show's producers in its final years was that it could live on without stars Gillian Anderson and David Duchovney, especially the latter, who had already escaped his contract and had big screen dreams like David Caruso before him. Only it never worked out for either party. While Robert Patrick's John Doggett was a solid addition in a pinch (and earned Patrick a Saturn award), Anabeth Gish's Monica Reyes put fans to sleep, and by the time Elwes and Lawless joined the cast, viewers barely took notice. As for Duchovney - he starred in the alien comedy Evolution, and little else, until returning to television with Californication. Unlike contemporaries Law and Order and E.R., which had revolving door casts, The X-Files relied heavily on the chemistry between its leads, and the will they/won't they romance between them. Producers themselves can be blamed for milking fan interest in the relationship question for so long. Shippers - fans of the opinion that Mulder and Scully should be together - weren't interested in seeing anything but their beloved couple, and the final season saw the show with its lowest numbers since its sophomore year. That means that in order for a revival or new series to work, Anderson and Duchovney must come back. Full time may be a little too much to ask for, especially since Gillian Anderson currently stars in both The Fall on the BBC and in NBC's Hannibal, but both actors have said they're interested. Fox must have both in at least a recurring capacity, and preferably lead roles at least to start.

9. Bring Back The Bulk Of The Writing Staff

One key component to the success of The X-Files was that it had a terrific writing staff, including series creator Chris Carter, Frank Spotnitz, Vince Gilligan (who would go on to create Breaking Bad), Tim Minear (Angel, Firefly, American Horror Story), James Wong and Glen Morgan (the duo behind Final Destination), and Darrin Morgan (also a producer on Fringe). For the show to succeed, even as a new series, this sort of talent needs to come back. They know the characters and the world of The X-Files better than anyone, and just Carter alone won't be enough to make the show a success. The best thing Carter ever did was surround himself with great writers.

8. Shoot It In B.C.

After season five and the first X-Files movie, production of the series moved from Vancouver, British Columbia to Los Angles, at the insistence of star David Duchovney, who wanted to be closer to his family. The show's torching of Fox Mulder's office was the very last televised scene in the Canadian city. Sadly, after the move, the series took major hit in quality. Oh, the production was still top notch but the look and feel had changed. The gloomy, overcast skies of B.C. were a huge part of the atmosphere of The X-Files, and sunny L.A. simply did not look the part. The show got too bright. The brighter look was also accompanied by a (likely unintentional) shift in tone, as episodes themselves got lighter throughout season six and seven before producers righted course in season eight. In any case, The X-Files: I Want To Believe in 2008 went back to B.C,, and as much as that film was just an overly long monster of the week story, it at least had the look and feel of a proper X-Files outing. The show will get massive brownie points with fans if they return to B.C. and avoid the sunny skies of L.A. It's a dark show after all.

7. No More Comedy Episodes

The aforementioned shift in tone that took place in seasons six and seven involved a move to more light-hearted, comedy-filled episodes with whimsical musical cues, supposedly witty banter in the dialogue, and an overall joking atmosphere compounded by the newly brightened look of the show. Fans with the series since the begin became frustrated, and arguably, TV Guide was partially to blame - they had been raving for a while that The X-Files was funnier than most comedies when it did lighter episodes. Perhaps all the rave reviews of early comedy episodes went to the heads of the writing staff, because by season six, there were twice as many as in previous years. In season seven they made up almost a third of the episodes: The Goldberg Variation, The Amazing Maleeni, X-Cops, First Person Shooter, Hollywood A.D., Fight Club, Je Souhaite (to be fair, X-Cops wasn't intentionally a comedy, it just wound up as one). Fans don't want The X-Files comedy hour. They want dark, creepy and disturbing. With American Horror Story really dropping the ball this year, Fringe off the airwaves, and The Walking Dead strictly a zombie show, there's a huge opening for the paranormal drama to come roaring back - just lay off the jokes.

6. No More "Scully As The Madonna"

No, not Madonna the pop legend. The biblical one. One of the most bizarre choices the X-Files writing staff ever made was to portray Dana Scully giving birth as some sort of miracle, as a Christ-like event, complete with a star of Bethlehem hanging in the night sky over the birth site. By this point in the show, the producers seemed to be throwing mud at the wall to see what would stick in terms of how to play out the mythology, and since Scully's inability to conceive was widely covered in earlier seasons, a pregnancy would be unexpected - and rile up the "shippers" cheering on the romance between Mulder and Scully. Fanning the flames of fan passion is easy, writing a convincing immaculate conception that doesn't involve the virgin Mary is not. The Madonna Scully storyline fell flat, so flat that by the time the second X-Files movie rolled around in 2008, son William had been killed off (off-screen, with little more than a few lines of dialogue spared to explain his fate). The show had hinted at Scully's biblical connections before, but rather than just portraying her as a woman questioning her faith, they seemed to suggest she had been chosen as some sort of protector by a higher power. In a show grounded by science, albeit it in the realm of extreme possibility, those episodes always felt out of place. When the show comes back, for the sake of the fans' sanity - no more of this!

5. Scale Back The Romance

With Mulder and Scully now officially together, can we please end the war between "shippers" and "noromos" and move on to more important things? For some fans, the question of "will they or won't they?", or more accurately," should they or shouldn't they?" became the overall question of the series, rather than whether aliens really existed, or if the truth was really out there. It turned the show into a paranormal Moonlighting, and while great as a subplot, it sadly overshadowed the groundbreaking work the show did elsewhere. In short, many fans became fanatical in their love or hate of the MSR (Mulder-Scully Relationship) to the point that websites were set up on either side of the battle line to promote specific points of view. Message boards were overrun by full-on flame wars. Take a side and be attacked by the other. It was a black eye for X-philes (what fans of the show were referred to as). There's no question that fan interest in the relationship benefited the show in its early years, but trying to recreate it would fail, because it was something that was never planned and happened naturally. Further, by the end, even many a shipper had become tired of the romance. Mulder and Scully are together, it's done, and trying to recreate this in new characters would seem too artificial and heavy-handed.

4. Find A New Antagonist

Alex Krycek is dead, shot in the head by A.D. Skinner. The Cigarette Smoking Man, who so often cheated death on The X-Files, and is frankly one of the best television villains of all time, is dead as well, and for once, there's no question: fans watched the fleshed burned from his bones when he was shot in the face - with a missile. While over the top to say the least, it was actually a pretty cool scene, one that removed any uncertainty about the fate of the most evil human being to ever walk the world of The X-Files. Which means that, except in flashbacks or as spirits, William B. Davis (who at age 77 is still a very busy actor in genre works and has a recurring role in Continuum) and Nicholas Lea will not be back, and a new antagonist needs to be found. The surviving X-Files villains, various members of the shadowy Syndicate and alien replicants - well, they're just not enough to fill in as a main bad guy. Which means that a new, compelling antagonist must be found. And whoever it is, he or she will have some large shoes to fill.

3. Wrap Up The Colonization Storyline

They didn't prevent it, but they may have postponed it. The mythology of The X-Files (the ongoing story that it told from episode to episode, season to season) was that an alien race that had once called Earth home was set to return and colonize the planet by way of a virus carried in a substance known as the "black oil" which would infect and enslave a human host. A group of government figures and doctors were aiding in colonization plans, engineering alien-human hybrids to create a slave race which would as a by-product ensure that at least some form of humanity survived. They were also, in secret, working on a vaccine against the black oil - which would later mutate and do more than just enslave a host, instead gestating inside a human being to create a fully-formed alien creature. Colonization was to be underway by 2012, but that date has come and gone, so unless the proposed X-Files revival is set a few years in the past, an explanation will be needed. That's no big deal, but what is a big deal to fans is that this storyline is wrapped up. As a third movie hasn't happened to date (which was expected to deal with this), closure is still something fans desperately want. A new X-Files show needs to get this out of the way right off the bat, not drag it out for five years that may or may not happen. Deal with colonization, then come up with a new mythology storyline.

2. More Monster Of The Week Episodes

Like The X-Files, shows such as Buffy, Angel, and early seasons of Fringe mixed in mythology episodes (told in a serial style) with standalone outings generally referred to (thanks to the Chris Carter created series) as Monster of the Week episodes. These are the episodes that gave fans the Fluke man, Donnie Pfaster, and Eugene Victor Tooms, among others. In any revival, more of these will be necessary. Serial shows are hit and miss these days outside of HBO and AMC; it's always a gamble as to whether viewers have the attention span for an on-going story. Fringe, the heir-apparent to The X-Files during its five year run on Fox, never really caught on despite being a fantastic sci-fi procedural (even without the aliens, it tied in heavily, going so far as to reference the X-Files as part of its world in one episode). A large part of that was a mythology that many found difficult to follow. Any X-Files revival needs to have some brilliant MOTW episodes to really catch on with a new generation of fans.

1. Make It A Continuation or TNG, Not A Reboot

Do not reboot The X-Files. No other actors will ever be accepted as Mulder and Scully, period. It doesn't matter if it's Jennifer Laurence with her hair dyed red acting across from whatever Hollywood pretty boy is the star of the moment: fans will revolt. The only way to make a new X-Files series work is for it to be a continuation of the original series with Mulder and Scully back either full-time or in reduced roles (since Anderson and Duchovney do have other commitments), or to do it as a Next Generation show where new agents build from the work of the original two. And even then, guest starring spots featuring Mulder and Scully will likely be necessary to sell it to fans. Still, there is no other property on television that is begging for a Next Generation style series as much as The X-Files is. Thanks to services like Netflix and its continued popularity online on various blogs (many of whom do "X-Files rewatch" coverage), forums, and social media sites, a younger generation of fans is now turned on to just how good this show was. News of the revival was huge when announced, and covered by news outlets across the globe. Fox is literally sitting on a gold mine - they just need to do it right. Exited about a possible return for The X-Files? Add your thoughts below!

In this post: 
The X-Files
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.