Ranking All Main Characters From Boardwalk Empire
Boardwalk Empire Characters Ranked Worst To Best
With a new year comes not just new TV shows to get our claws stuck into, but it's also an opportunity to revisit older series' or finally get round to watching a few critically acclaimed that previously passed us by.
As we push forward with the roaring 2020's, there's a strange nostalgia for a critically acclaimed series set almost a hundred years ago. I'm talking of course about HBO's incredible prohibition era gangster series, Boardwalk Empire.
For five seasons, we watched the rise and fall of an Atlantic City bootlegger whose navigation through the era of bathtub gin, cigarette girls and pin-striped suits also brought him into regular contact with some of histories most prolific criminal figures. And in doing so, gave audiences amazing and honourable performances that have to be seen to be believed.
Even though you were watching a show about immoral, criminal outlaws, it was hard not to root for most of the faces on screen. And while they weren't some of the nicest chaps in history, there were little cheers when they came victorious over the law.
In this list, I'll be ranking from worst to best, every person across the five seasons of Boardwalk Empire who was credited at some point as a main character.
21. Commodore Louis Kaestner
In a show filled with real-life murderers and gangsters, none were as deplorable or hateful as the menace of all evil - Commodore Kaestner.
As Nucky's mentor, and Jimmy's biological father, The Commodore's control over the two leads is palpable for the first season, and his devious power-hungry manipulations in the second set off the more violent chain of events. There was something almost generational about the relationship of the three characters, with Nucky serving more as a father to Jimmy than the Commodore himself.
His evil acts across history varied from small such as the influence and manipulation of Jimmy, through his racist and sexist belittling of his housemaid, and all the way to the rape of Gillian Darmody when she was a child, there was not redeeming quality about The Commodore.
His position as so low on the ranking is purely down to his position as a hateful, detestable figure. The Commodore was a man who threw his political (and once physical) strength around too casually during his time on the show.
Had it not been for his sickening vices, a lot of the horrific events in the show might have never happened.
20. Lucy Danziger
Someone had to be close to the bottom of the list, and if you've watched even the first episode of the show, you'll understand why Lucy Danziger is so low.
There's nothing boring about the character in the slightest, quite the opposite! Her role as Nucky's former mistress/girlfriend prior to Margaret Schroeder made for an interesting watch, but Paz De La Huerta's delivery of lines was slurring and irritating from the first episode, to her last appearance.
As the series progressed, Lucy's narrative deflated more and more, and even when the character became embroiled with Nelson Van Alden and bore his child, it still wasn't enough to grip viewers.
The end of the character's run on the show wasn't the best dismount either. After taking some money from Nucky, Lucy leaves her newborn baby with Van Alden and scatters to the wind, never to be seen again. While I'm not one for characters dramatically returning, I was expecting her to come back to the show at some point to shake up the playing field or maybe give her character a proper send-off.
Instead, she's barely remembered after the second season and is mentioned only two more times in passing by ancillary characters. You can see why she's at the bottom of the list.
19. Eddie Kessler
Treat your employees with respect, and you shall get devotion in return. The same cannot be said of Nucky and Eddie's relationship, as throughout the four season run, Eddie appears to be nothing more than a nuisance. Yet he is a proud character who treats Nucky Thompson with the utmost respect at every turn.
Immediately there is a great comedic duo between Nucky and his butler-chauffeur-bodyguard. Eddie's earnest devotion, sincerity and servitude to Nucky is repeatedly a cause of laughs, and catching Steve Buscemi react with an annoyed expression each time endears their relationship further.
Of all the gunslingers and bootleggers Nucky employed, none were as devoted to him as Eddie and it came as a great concern when in the third season he caught a bullet for his boss. It was the first time viewers got to see Nucky show genuine concern for his chauffeur, and while he made it through to the fourth season their dynamic was changed from then on. Nucky's respect for a man who would take a bullet for him grew over time.
Sadly though, Eddie took his own life midway through the fourth season; ashamed at his betrayal when Bureau agents obtained and tortured him for some time on the details of Nucky's operation. It was a real sad moment to see Kessler go, and further drove the point that those committed to Nucky were slowly moving away from him.
18. Mickey Doyle
You'd be forgiven for forgetting a character like Mickey Doyle. He was never really in the thick of any of the show's major plots; always circling the drain of the narrative and serving as almost a prop for locations and plot devices.
Alright! That's not entirely true. The first season did see Mickey hover somewhere between ally and enemy to Nucky Thompson, as his uneasy partnering up with the D'Allesio Brothers should have been a final nail in the coffin. As the series progressed, Mickey became less relevant to the story, but a familiar presence in the Bootlegging warehouses and speakeasy's. Despite being something of an irritating comedic character, he was at times the more logical thinker and offered sound logic to Nucky's business ventures.
"How are you still alive?" is a question asked to Mickey midway through the series' run, and throughout viewers had to ask themselves that same question. The fifth season marked the end of the show, and the end of Mickey Doyle as he was callously murdered by Luciano during a standoff.
Doyle's death in the series was shocking for two reasons - the first being a sheer unexpected surprise on the screen, and the second that Mickey was irritating, but he didn't deserve what he got.
17. Meyer Lansky
You can really tell (at least from the show) that Meyer Lansky went to the Rothstein School of Mannerisms and Decorum;
Alongside his childhood friend and business partner Lucky Luciano, Lansky served as the more level-headed of the two - less foul-mouthed and more prone to civil discussions than the former. Wherever one went, the other wasn't that far behind. And to see the rise of two prolific gangsters, from young pups to overarching crime bosses was a fascinating watch.
In the case of Meyer Lansky, it always felt like the series was barely scraping the surface of the character. With Michael Stuhlbarg dominating focus as Rothstein, and many of the criminal endeavours leaning more toward Luciano, Lansky unfortunately was often cast aside. But that's not to say he wasn't memorable. As the brains of the operation, and Luciano serve as the face and mouth, many of their criminal and logistical pursuits in the series were all thanks to Lanksy.
I'd be remiss if I said that Lansky played second-fiddle to Luciano; and from the third season onwards Lansky did start to grow into his own and show darker, and more wicked sides to himself. Perhaps if he'd had more of his own plot, he would have been further up in this list?
16. Angela Darmody
If there was one legitimate criticism to make with Boardwalk Empire - the show did struggle to find many compelling or diverse female characters to work with. As the put-upon wife of Jimmy Darmody, Angela's role as the bewildered housewife fit the story of the show well, albeit threw away a character with potential.
As Jimmy's bohemian, artistic wife, the series presented the character as someone audiences could relate to at times when crime was discussed so casually. In the company of characters like Gillian, it was Angela who questioned and opposed the obscure behaviours of her husband. Angela as a character could have had stories that went in further and more exciting directions, especially when the first season offered a plot narrative around female independence.
Angela was always a hairsbreadth away from being an interesting character - her bisexual infidelity, her pseudo-sibling relationship with Richard Harrow, or her rising rivalry with Gillian were all foundations for a decent story arc, but in the end only these devices only ever served the male characters around her.
In the end, Angela was "fridged" as her murder at the hands of Manny Horvitz was a tragedy barely taken in by the other characters. Even when Harrow blows Manny's head away, viewers are convinced it was to avenge Jimmy. But thankfully the show did have some courtesy and reveal Harrow was avenging Angela. There was some justice there at least.
15. Owen Slater
Before he was throwing fists around Netflix as Matt Murdock, Charlie Cox was breaking skulls as the right-hand enforcer for Nucky Thompson.
Owen Slater's arrival in the second season seemed almost throwaway at first - the quick-witted, Irish sleuth wooed both Margaret Schroeder and her servants, and could have been regarded as nothing more than a smiling scamp here to shake things up for Nucky. But quickly he proved himself as both competent and visceral as he beat and killed Nucky's opponents.
If there were some grievances to be had with the character, it would the inconsistency of his allegiances; with one breath he is prepared to abandon Nucky and flee with Margaret Schroeder at a moment's notice, and the next he is dutifully watching over, protecting and planning executions on Nucky's behalf.
Owen's time on the show was short-lived, and while it would have been great if he stuck around more (and maybe lived), a season as violent as the third needed a gut-wrenching death to shake up the audience. And what better way to do it, than to return Owen to his sender in a big wooden box.
14. Sally Wheet
The women that revolved around Nucky Thompson came in all kinds of charismatic shapes and sizes. And while most of the women prior to the fourth season seemed enamoured with his wealth and status, down in the sweaty swamps of Florida, Sally Wheet was having none of his shtick.
There was something delightful and refreshing about Sally Wheet, and what Patricia Arquette did to make the character retain gumption is something to be admired. So why is she so low on the list? Maybe because even though she exploded on screen in the fourth season, her role seemed awkwardly diminished almost immediately in the fifth. A character as vibrant as hers made a very brief splash on screen, but then rippled away shortly after her debut.
It's a shame because there was something endearing about a character not impressed by Nucky's money, but enthralled by his character as a person. And Nucky was impressed by her too - a character that matched his "no bulls**t" pursuits made them both a dynamite power-couple. And once Sally established herself in Nucky's operation, she proved herself more than competent amidst his long-serving cronies.
But Sally just didn't land the way Gillian or Margaret did. And even when she meets her (very) unfortunate end in the fifth season, it doesn't hit as big as some of the other deaths in the final outing.
13. Dr. Valentin Narcisse
Every season of Boardwalk Empire saw Nucky Thompson confront and deal with a new breed of villainy appropriately; be it a bootlegging turf war, a political coup or an all-out war. However, in the fourth season Nucky took a step back as this time it wasn't his fight to finish. With the arrival of Dr. Valentin Narcisse, racial tensions escalate within the black community of Atlantic City, and it's Chalky White who must step forward to resolve.
The fourth season is most certainly Chalky's season, and his own brand of villain comes in the form of the well-spoken, well-educated Narcisse. As the season's antagonist, he shows his hand very quickly as a ruthless individual that should not be trifled with.
His undermining of Chalky escalates as he takes over the Onyx Club, roots Chalky out of Atlantic City, and exploits the god-fearing naivete of Atlantic City's black citizens - disavowing heroin with one breath, while pushing it on people with another.
Jeffrey Wright's sombre voice and timid mannerisms as the character are what set him alight. He wasn't threatening in the slightest until he started speaking, and when he did, his thinly veiled threats to anyone in the room made even the viewers hairs stand to attention.
12. Lucky Luciano
If you were a history buff, or at least had some basic knowledge of 20th Century American gangsters, Charles "Lucky" Luciano was certainly a name you'd have heard a few times. With Boardwalk Empire taking place before (and subsequently ending around) the conception of The Commission; what viewers were treated to was the engaging rise of one of America's most prolific gangsters.
At the start of the series, Lucky was confident if a little temperamental, and sitting next to the more reserved Arnold Rothstein made him appear to be nothing more than a hot-headed and bullish brat.
As the series progressed, his aspirations and unities with the likes of Jimmy Darmody, Al Capone and of course his partnership with Meyer Lanksy, offered a well drawn-out narrative for a guy looking to step out the shadows of Joe Masseria and Rothstein.
Throughout the series, his allegiances between the Italian and Jewish mobs made for some of the more interesting dynamics. And while those already aware of history would know where all the roads eventually led, it was still engaging to watch Lucky struggle between his Italian heritage and his partnerships with the likes of Lanksy and Bugsy Siegel.