Ranking All Main Characters From Boardwalk Empire
11. Gyp Rossetti
From his first scene, all the way through to his last, Gyp held viewers' attention. It was a performance so gripping that Bobby Cannavale received a well-deserved Emmy Award for his portrayal as the hypersensitive, psychopathic mob boss.
An argument could be made that Gyp Rossetti was a little too homicidal, and maybe even a little stereotypical of the unhinged mafioso (think Joe Pesci in Goodfellas); but Gyp's outbursts of rage and homicide aren't an exaggerated play on the character - but a very well-written defence mechanism for a character deeply entrenched in insecurities.
His conflict with Nucky Thompson (and everyone else throughout the third season) comes from one person overreacting very poorly to something small. I'll let you figure out below which one it was. Gyp may have been a caricature, but he was a terrifying and violent figure within the show too. His unpredictability clashed so much with the likes of Nucky and Rothstein, he could make Al Capone look like a pussycat.
As the central antagonist of the third season, all that can be said about the character is that when he made his move on Nucky Thompson, he certainly wouldn't stop until he had consumed (or insulted) all of Atlantic City.
WARNING! VERY EXPLICIT AND OFFENSIVE LANGUAGE IN THE VIDEO BELOW
10. Margaret Schroeder
Every show about gangsters needs an honest bastion of goodness; a character just looking to keep their head down, stay safe and protect those around them. In the case of Margaret Schroeder (later Thompson), all she ever wanted was to get her truly horrible husband some work - and the rest wrote itself with tragedies and triumphs.
Not content with becoming the wife of a mobster, throughout the show Margaret moves with the same virtues she started the series with. As part of the Women's Temperance Movement, it was engaging in the third season to watch her character be one of the driving forces for programs in hospitals offering proper care for women's health and hygiene - something that was lambasted by many others at the time.
In the fourth and fifth seasons, her absence in Atlantic City is sorely missed - but the character was swept away to New York, and the show allowed her to carry out more of her own adventures.
Margaret was one of the few characters the show actively cheered for, and despite entering the series a victim and someone to take pity on, her promotion to an independent and powerful figure was truly the only fictional character in the series to get a happy ending.
9. Jimmy Darmody
Spoiler Alert! Jimmy Darmody gets popped at the end of season two.
While he was only on screen for two seasons, the time Jimmy spent was integral to the show and one could argue that Michael Pitt was as much the lead as Steve Buscemi.
As a returning soldier looking to make a name for himself, his actions in the first episode set about the many chains of events that carried over way past his death. Viewers took an immediate liking to the young father and war hero, and his backstory as a child of privilege looking to find something more authentic in life would certainly resonate with millennial audiences today.
While Jimmy did at times present himself as not the most likeable, or even sympathetic of figures, and despite going against Nucky for a bulk of his time on screen, you couldn't help but root for him. Jimmy's conflict with Nucky was a relationship we just wished the two could resolve, as they were the father-son duo that should have been within the series.
Sadly is wasn't meant to be, and Nucky was the one to put Jimmy in the ground. And while it shocked viewers that a major character had died on screen, it was nothing compared to the obvious trauma and guilt that plagued Nucky for future seasons of the show.
8. Nelson Van Alden/George Mueller
In a show that followed mobsters and swindlers, there had to be a lawman skulking round nipping at the heels of the crooks. But Boardwalk Empire couldn't just give us Elliot Ness (though it does later toward the end), the show needed someone who should have their own TV show all together. With that, viewers were treated to the virtuous, god-fearing, intensely rage-filled and unexpectedly comical Nelson Van Alden, played by Michael Shannon.
For the first two seasons of the show, viewers are presented with a man on a mission from both god and the law. And his stone-faced resilience toward alcohol is only made the more complex when we realise how corruptible he actually is. Convincing himself he is the epitome of righteous beliefs, viewers are never sure if he is enacting the wrath of god or slowly losing his mind.
After going on the run and becoming a mob enforcer under the name George Mueller, Shannon almost becomes a new character as he takes on the persona of a bumbling, comedic individual that still harbours the violent tendencies of Nelson Van Alden.
His rage-filled outbursts throughout the series have included drowning a man during a baptism and scarring a co-workers face with an electric iron - something that summarises the character in so many ways.
7. Eli Thompson
No one has the best relationship with their sibling, but between Nucky and his little brother Eli, things were more tense than normal brotherly feuds.
Throughout the series, Eli and Nucky's strained relationship went back and forth between allies and enemies - going so far as to sanction imprisonment or deaths on one another. And as the Sheriff of Atlantic City, Eli's position within authority for two seasons of the show put him in the thick of some of the key arcs throughout.
Dirty cops on TV aren't the most sympathetic., but Shea Whigham and the writers of the show find some redeeming qualities within the character. His love and devotion to his family made him at times appear more human than his charming older brother, and a lot of his moves against Nucky's wishes were in the best interests of his wife and kids. His ascension after the third season into a full-on mob enforcer did make for compelling television, albeit a strange narrative move for the show.
In the end, while the show wasn't primarily about Eli and Nucky's relationship, their tumultuous relationship did serve as one of the most cathartic endings - as despite betrayal and assassination attempts, Nucky still forgave and wanted the best for Eli.
6. Chalky White
If you were a fan of HBO's other groundbreaking hit The Wire, and you knew nothing about Boardwalk Empire before going in, seeing Omar Little ever so briefly in the first episode of the series was quite a surprise. It was even more of a delight as the character grew and become one of the biggest names within the show.
The character of Albert "Chalky" White is an amazingly nuanced figure to dissect - as the racketeering kingpin of Atlantic City's African-American communities. Chalky was very much equal to Nucky in both reach and influence, with his communal arm extending over the black citizens of Atlantic City, nothing happened without him knowing about it.
Despite the period in which the series is set, Chalky held quite a few cards over Atlantic City. Race was certainly a factor within the character's story arcs; with the second season and most prominently the fourth containing huge racial factors the series touched on. And it was Chalky was who central in both.
It's very easy to forget that Chalky was Nucky's equal, and not his counterpart. In many ways the two worked in tandem as a partnership, and the arcs that saw Atlantic City under threat from outsiders certainly called on the support from both.
5. Arnold Rothstein
Amidst all the drinking, debauchery, gun-shooting and swearing, it was always comforting to see Arnold Rothstein on screen. It let us know there was at least one civilised adult in the room. Civilised might be a stretch, given that he openly admits to allowing a man to choke to death on a snooker ball, but at least Rothstein would be well-mannered about his business.
Throughout the series, Nucky encountered a variety of characters who were his equal within the regions and demographics they represented. And his respectful-but-uneasy relationship with Rothstein might have been one of the more interesting.
What starts off as a full-on war between New York and Atlantic City (thanks to the events of the first episode), later becomes a mutual and respectful business arrangement. In a perfect world, at a different time in history, who's to say Nucky and Rothstein wouldn't be the best minds on the East Coast?
Rothstein commands as much respect with his goons as he does with Nucky. As mentor and business partner to Luciano and Lansky, viewers got to see how Rothstein groomed and nurtured the legendary duo, and his absence in the fifth season is definitely noticed as his proteges are let off their leashes to hit at Nucky with everything they had.
4. Gillian Darmody
If Nucky Thompson were to ever have a female counterpart, it would have to be Gillian Darmody. Ambitious, conniving and headstrong, the mother of Jimmy Darmody was always a thorn in Nucky's side, even when she wasn't intending to be.
Where to begin with such a complicated and interesting character that isn't seen on TV much these days? For starters, she was a dynamite Femme Fatale - getting what she wanted, and when she wanted from some of the most powerful men in Atlantic City. A Lady Macbeth to her own son, it was her whispering in his ear that ultimately led to her own son's death, something she would absolutely deny doing.
Her story arcs after the third season only grazed the main plots of the series, but that didn't make them any less entertaining. From the former madam of a brothel, to a desperate grandmother looking to reacquire the affection she once had - perhaps the best thing about the character of Gillian Darmody was that she had her own agency throughout the series.
Her tragic end in the series is both heartbreaking and befitting, and with metaphors and symbolism laid out to examine, could make her one of the most fascinating characters the show ever created.
3. Richard Harrow
If there was one character on the show universally adored by fans, it would have to be this guy.
A sympathetic battle-scarred war hero; Richard Harrow's debut midway through the first season doesn't elevate much of the story to begin with, but viewers are informed right way that he is as proficient a killer, and quite useful when disposing of unwanted nuisances.
Perhaps the most tragic of the main characters too, all Richard ever wanted was a family to love, and throughout his run on the series that opportunity was forever just out of reach.
Whether it was his brotherly relationship with Jimmy Darmody, or his romantic courtship with Julia Sagorsky, Richard was a character to root for throughout. No matter how many bullets and bodies flew across the screen, none of it mattered unless Harrow walked away the victor.
It makes his fall from grace ever more tragic, as he takes one last job on behalf of Nucky Thompson and is fatally wounded in the process. His last moments mark the end of the fourth season, and in a way mark the end of the show. Viewers thought the show wouldn't be the same after Jimmy Darmody died, turns out they were really thinking about this guy.
2. Al Capone
What's so great about Boardwalk Empire was how it made historically awful people out to be incredibly sympathetic (and even likeable). And for one of the most prolific names in organised crime history, the series did an amazing job fleshing out the life of Al Capone.
In the first two seasons of the show, viewers are treated to the sweet, polite and charming foot-soldier of Johnny Torrio's Chicago outfit. The show doesn't stray too much from Capone's bullish side early on - but the show made Capone three-dimensional, and at times relatable.
Things take a terrible turn for the better during the third season, and the Al Capone we know culturally comes to life as he shoots, beats and whores his way through the Chicago underworld. The polite and smiling chap we remember sharing cigarettes with Jimmy Darmody by the cars evolved before the viewers' very eyes into a maniacal, unhinged, hot-tempered psychopath.
Stephen Graham absolutely killed it as Al Capone, and it goes without saying that the character's elevation from a smaller role at the beginning of the series to one of the biggest hitters by the end was one of the smartest choices the show made.