Ranking The Marvel Netflix Shows From Worst To Best
Before there was Disney+, we looked to Netflix for our longform Marvel storytelling.
Before WandaVision took over Disney+ and became the most talked about show of 2021 so far, the MCU had a very different approach to putting their beloved characters onto the small screen. In a deal with Netflix, the streaming giant got a chance to put out six marvel shows which debuted to varying critical responses.
The interpretations of The Defenders and their supporting characters were a mixed bag with some being landmark television of exceptional quality and others being boring misguided shows that were better off not existing.
The varied quality of each show certainly makes for an awkwardly unique collection. After Disney reacquired the rights to each of these characters, the shows ended abruptly.
Whether we'll end up seeing Charlie Cox's Matt Murdock or Mike Colter's Luke Cage popping up in a future MCU project remains to be seen but they deserve to be acknowledged for the first major critical successes that Marvel got on TV (sorry Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.).
The Marvel Netflix shows were often more mature and darker than their family friendly cinematic counterparts but that allowed them to have an edge that the MCU hasn't seen since.
6. Iron Fist
Iron Fist is not devoid of positives, those positives just fail to gel in a way that makes it a likable show. Finn Jones in particular tended to get a bad wrap, but he does the best he can with the material given. Danny Rand is written to be irritating and annoying which makes for a poor central character but none of that is on Jones.
The other performances are pretty underwhelming, at best there's Jessica Henwick who is great as Colleen Wing and at worst is whatever on earth David Wenham is doing in that first season. Either way, the performances aren't this show's biggest problem.
Iron Fist is sadly, just a boring show. The characters aren't interesting and the narrative is weak. Worst of all, after terrific fight scenes from Daredevil, there was significant anticipation that a show about a martial artist would have fight scenes that would at least match Daredevil's, maybe even rival them. Unfortunately, they're just as bland as the rest of the show.
5. The Defenders
What should have been television's Avengers turned out to be a mediocre team up of the Netflix Marvel heroes that underwhelmed and disappointed in almost every sense. In a short season of only eight episodes, the Defenders don't even team up until three episodes in. The show should have capitalised on the already existing relationships and worked at a quicker pace to get the four of them together.
Chemistry wise, there's nothing bad here, the four of them gel well and it is at least somewhat satisfying to see the group unite. That being said, The Hand were starting to feel incredibly overused and tired by this point and the poor pacing meant the whole season fell apart.
More so than any other show on this list, The Defenders suffered due to its overhyped anticipation. But, even with the high expectations, the show just doesn't work on several fundamental levels and ends up being the most forgettable show in the collection.
Feeling slow and uninspired with little payoff or enjoyment to be had, The Defenders severely disappointed.
4. Luke Cage
Luke Cage tackled mature and necessary issues in a way that the MCU previously hadn't attempted. The concept of a bulletproof black man was not lost on the showrunners and they leant heavily into the social issues surrounding the show as they should have. The result is that Luke Cage feels relevant but also celebratory as the cast is almost exclusively black.
Despite the great use of representation and smartly tackled themes, the show itself suffers from pacing issues throughout and ends up feeling very bland in comparison to the other shows on this list. Its most egregious offence is the squandered use of a now two time Oscar winning Mahershala Ali who was implied to be the main villain of Season One before being killed off half way through.
Ali's Cottonmouth was a compelling villain with added dimension that other antagonists of the show sorely lacked and no one else could compare to Ali's versatility. Mike Coulter was a strong Luke Cage but he wasn't enough to stop the show feeling lesser after Ali's departure.
3. Jessica Jones
A difficult show to rank due to how much the show varied in quality over its three seasons. Season One stands as some of the very best material in the Marvel Netflix catalogue but quickly dives off a cliff into mediocrity for the subsequent seasons.
The main reason for this is the absence of Kilgrave, a deliciously evil portrayal from David Tennant who is clearly having a great time in the role. Tennant had exceptional chemistry with series lead Krysten Ritter who in her own right makes for a great Jessica Jones. Before Captain Marvel became the 'first' Marvel heroine to headline a cinematic property on her own, Jessica Jones was trailblazing on Netflix.
The show's first season deals with incredibly sensitive subject matter such as trauma and sexual assault and does so incredibly well. The dynamic between Ritter and Tennant only helps to strengthen those plotlines, so after Tennant departs at the end of Season One, the next few seasons struggle to reach those same highs.
Even with the added addition of the extremely talented Janet McTeer, Jessica Jones failed to live up to its maiden season that had been so exceptional.
2. The Punisher
Carried almost entirely on the back of Jon Bernthal's committed and unrelenting performance, The Punisher ran for two seasons and is easily the most violent of the six shows.
As Frank Castle, Bernthal nails the tortured persona of a dangerous man haunted by his past. Bernthal was a definite highlight of Daredevil's second season and here he shows that he can lead his own show with all the intensity and emotional connection required. Despite his murderous nature, you feel for Frank and sympathise with his tragic past.
The action is bloody and visceral and you definitely get the sense that Frank Castle is a killing machine. Bernthal's physicality lends a believability to each fight and keeps the action fresh and exciting. The supporting cast isn't exceptional which is a shame with most other characters being quite forgettable but if anything, it's just a testament to Bernthal's skills that he is so much better than everyone else.
The Punisher is one of the more consistently good shows on the list, with two strong seasons, which helps it place so highly.
1. Daredevil
The first show also happens to be the best show. Netflix's interpretation of Daredevil was hard hitting and adult oriented and immediately stood apart from the MCU's family friendly fare. Managing three whole seasons, Daredevil was not only a good superhero show but a great drama with fantastic action and brilliant performances.
Chief among them was Charlie Cox's reserved and intense take on Matt Murdock as he proved himself a fantastic lead character. Murdock doesn't have any super strength or accelerated healing to fall back on making his fights and struggles feel all the more impactful. Every blow is felt and the stakes feel particularly high and Cox is great at selling that sense of danger.
Just as good is Vincent D'Onofrio's take on Wilson Fisk who he imbues with layers making him one of the very best antagonists Marvel has ever put on screen. D'Onofrio's screen presence is commanding and dominant and he steals any scene he's in.
The aforementioned fight scenes are brutal and on more than one occasion are filmed entirely in one take. As a result the violence feels visceral and realistic and provides the best action across all the Marvel Netflix shows.
Daredevil raises the bar for superhero shows from its storytelling to its production and the MCU would be foolish not to integrate the cast with the rest of the cinematic characters if given the chance.