Recasting The Stargate Atlantis Reboot

This fan favorite series' recasting potentials are as endless as the characters themselves.

Natalie Martinez Stargate Atlantis Teyla Emmagan
Universal Pictures/Syfy

Stargate Atlantis was the first spinoff show set in the highly successful Stargate universe. The main plot of Stargate Atlantis followed a group of volunteer human soldiers and scientists who ventured through the Stargate on Earth into a whole new galaxy to search for the lost ancient city of Atlantis.

Atlantis took the formula of the original Stargate show and elevated it to an entirely new level. With a constantly evolving cast of amazing actors portraying classic characters, the show sadly only ran for five seasons, about half as long as the original Stargate series.

However, even with a shorter lifespan, Atlantis became a fan favorite hit, joining the likes of Star Trek: Voyager as a successful spin off sci-fi show.

Thanks to some rumours brought up during the reunion of the original Stargate cast, fans once again grew excited and hopeful that streaming giant Amazon Prime Video could perhaps bring the old show back in some way. But what about Atlantis?

If Atlantis was ever given a second chance, it would most likely be as a reboot. And while there is no reason why the original actors could not return to the show, it is still good fun to imagine the many possibilities of a total series recast. The following are just a few possible picks for the heroes and villains that fans might like to see in any future Stargate Atlantis reboot.

10. Mads Mikkelsen As Commander Acastus Kolya

Polar Mads Mikkelsen
Netflix

When the crew of the Atlantis began to reach out to other planets in their new galaxy, they learned that most human colonies were in a similar state of development as those under Goa'uld rule, barely reaching early medieval technologies and beliefs.

That is until the crew stumbled upon the Genii, a civilization that learned how to hide their technological advancements from the Wraith and had reached World War II levels of development in technology and political beliefs.

The Genii military was led by Commander Acastus Kolya, played by Robert Davi, a shrewd leader who immediately viewed the technologically advanced crew of the Atlantis as a threat to his people, rather than an ally to help overthrow the Wraith.

Kolya became a constant threat to the crew of the Atlantis, often taking the base over in many attempted coups. Kolya's brutality and tactical genius are perfect for Danish actor Mads Mikklelsen to take up in a reboot.

Mads Mikkleson is no stranger to playing the villain, both on the big and the small screen, and could easily give Kolya more depth behind his actions, portraying the character as a man trying to save his people above all others, even at the expense of other civilizations.


9. Timothée Chalamet As Michael Kenmore

Dune movie
Warner Bros.

Michael, played by Connor Trinneer, was a surprise villain introduced in season two of Atlantis as an amnesiac crew member of Atlantis. Over the span of his first episode, Michael tried to remember who he was and attempt to get back into his old life. However, over the episode's runtime, Michael began to uncover the truth about who he really was.

In fact, Michael was not a member of Atlantis' crew, he wasn't even human. Michael was a experiment conducted on a Wraith solider using a method developed by the Ancients in an attempt to end the war by converting the wraith into their prey

Michael escaped his captivity by the humans and slowly began to revert back into his Wraith form, though not completely. Michael became a hybrid monster, an enemy to both Humans and Wraith, and would continue to be a menace to the galaxy for the rest of Atlantis' five-season run.

While Michael became a monster, his story also had a tinge of tragedy, as he was taken against his will and experimented on by our supposed heroes, turning him into a monster shunned by everyone he ever knew.

That tragedy mixed with ultimate malice could be portrayed excellently by Timothée Chalamet, who has shown off his acting props in sci-fi settings and has shown his diversity in playing a loveable goof and a horrific cannibal. This background could help to give Michael a great dual personality as he struggles to understand himself and his place in the universe.


8. Jonathan Majors As Todd The Wraith

Lovecraft Country Jonathan Majors
HBO

When the Wraith first began their long and grueling war with the human crew of the Atlantis, they were easy to view as soul-sucking monsters intent on ruling over their galactic flock of defenseless humans with malice and glee in the terror they brought with them.

That is until Commander Sheppard encountered a starving Wraith, played by Christopher Heyerdahl, who Sheppard befriended and escaped from Commander Koyla's jail with. A Wraith Sheppard decided to simply call Todd.

Todd the Wraith gave the Wraith the same complex morality as Teal'c and Bra'tac gave to the Goa'uld. Todd gave a deeper insight into the political structure of the Wraith and how their soul-sucking powers actually work, including the fact they can give life as well as take it.

Eventually, Todd became an invaluable ally in assisting the Atlantis crew with sabotaging the Wraith and causing mini rebellions and civil wars in the Wraith hierarchy. Todd was both comedic and imposing in his own ways, and as such is quite the fitting role for actor Jonathan Majors to portray.

Majors has successfully played both villains and heroes on television, and has shown that he can do comedy while also being incredibly imposing physically.

The Lovecraft Country star could give Todd a more fleshed out place in a reboot, participating in more stunts and fight choreography, as well as giving Atlantis a much more diverse roster of actors for the show's new era.


7. Lana Parrilla As Queen Death

1510409574 Lana Parrilla Once Upon A Time
ABC

After prolonged fighting with the crew of the Atlantis, the Wraith command hierarchy was shattered and reorganized under many different leaders. One of the most intimidating was a Wraith Queen known simply as Queen Death, who was played by Andee Frizell.

Queen Death was different from most normal Wraith Queens. She desired control over the entire Wraith armada and brutally chased after that desire. Her forces decimated entire worlds along with any rebellious wraith, even Todd's forces crumbled under her rule.

While there are plenty of actresses who could play Queen Death, one of the most obvious is Lana Parrilla, who is well known as the Evil Queen in ONCE, and as Rita Castillo in Why Women Kill.

Ms. Parilla could do an amazing job as Queen Death, perhaps making the character a more prolonged threat, rather than a one-off villain. Queen Death could even be the leader of the wraith already when the Atlantis crew first arrives in the reboot, adding a more imposing presence and singular threat for the Wraith empire, like Anubis was for the Goa'uld in the later seasons of the original Stargate.

Queen Death being portrayed by Lana Parilla could give the actress a chance to be a more brutal villain, not limited by network censorship, and could give the character a much-needed overhaul and give more personality for our heroes to fight against.


6. David Tennant As Dr. Carson Beckett

David Tennant Around The World In 80 Days
BBC

Dr. Carson Beckett, played by Paul McGillion, was one of Atlantis' most popular side characters. Like most medical officers in a sci-fi setting, he had a lot of charisma, an unshakeable moral compass, a close connection with most of the main characters, and one of the saddest deaths for fans of the show.

Beckett's intelligence mixed with the seemingly limitless power of Ancient technology helped the crew of the Atlantis time and time again escape fates worse than death and also helped to steer the conscience of Atlantis' first commander Dr. Elizabeth Weir, in times of great uncertainty for her.

Beckett was also willing to sacrifice himself to save others, something that led to his tragic death. Yes, he did come back as a clone captured by Michael later in the show, but the reboot could probably avoid doing that.

Of course, there is no better Scottish actor to play a medical officer than beloved actor David Tennant. Tennant could give Beckett his classic charm and sense of humor, but could also portray the doctor as someone struggling with the pressures and decisions that come with such a difficult role.

Tennant could show how being a combat doctor in a sci-fi war could be overwhelming, how morality can easily be lost when fighting something not human, and how that morality is needed no matter what galaxy humans are in. He could show the importance of being a human doctor, and could also get in some great Scottish banter with the rest of the cast.


5. Lena Headey As Dr. Elizabeth Weir

Game of Thrones Cersei
HBO

Played by Torri Higginson, Dr. Elizabeth Weir was the first leader of the crew of the Atlantis. Her steady leadership mixed with deep compassion for her subordinates made her a perfect commander for military actions, scientific research, diplomatic relationships, and eventually public relations with Earth and their allies across the new galaxy.

Dr. Weir may not have had the same level of comedic charm as General Hammond or Jack O'Neil, but she more than earned her spot as a leader forced into an unfamiliar galaxy with a seemingly endless number of threats big and small.

Dr. Weir did her best to keep as many of her people alive while also helping an entire galaxy of strangers overthrow their alien overlords, up until her tragic death from an incurable brain tumor.

The role of Dr. Weir would be perfect for acclaimed actress Lena Headey. Her familiarity with leadership roles could help her give Weir that sense of command, while also allowing for some truly breathtaking personal moments, as the command of humans stranded lightyears from home would no doubt cause mental anguish.

Those external problems, mixed with Weir having to confront her own personal beliefs, motivations, and her brain tumor can create one of the most compelling characters in television if given to an actress that can achieve those levels of compassion and leadership. A less than easy role on paper, but Ms. Headley could easily take that role and elevate it to something special.


4. Bill Hader As Dr. Rodney McKay

Bill Hader Richie Tozier
Warner Bros.

Dr. Rodney McKay, played by David Hewlett, was a selfish, narcissistic, sexist, cowardly man. Someone who you wouldn't believe could also be someone quite selfless and caring, willing to put aside his own feelings and ego for the good of the group, if not the entire galaxy.

McKay is perhaps Atlantis' most complex character, as he has so many different layers to his character. There is the simple ego on the surface that can lead to McKay's more negative traits, but below all that is someone who is a good person.

That's why one of the best actors that could portray McKay is Bill Hader. The SNL actor has gone through many different roles on TV and film and has been able to show his acting skills in many ways that would help flesh out McKay in a modern reboot.

Hader could keep McKay's sense of humor, his scientific mindset, and amazing problem-solving skills, along with his cowardice and greed. Hader could also help to bring out more of McKay's change over time.

Bill Hader as McKay could show how people change under stressful situations, learning to adapt in strange environments for survival, and how the true nature of heroes isn't always seen immediately on the surface, as it can take time to emerge for all to see.


3. Kumail Nanjiani As Ronon Dex

Eternals Kingo Kumail Nanjiani
Marvel Studios

Ronon Dex was one of the last members of Stargate Atlantis' main cast team to join, and originally was an enemy to Sheppard when they first met.

Over time, the team and the viewers learned more about Dex's tragic past; how he was one of the last surviving members of a human warrior colony that used advanced technology to resist the Wraith for several years until their ultimate annihilation.

Dex was portrayed by Jason Momoa in one of his earliest well-known roles besides Baywatch. And while it may be hard to replace Momoa with anyone else for the role of Dex, Kumail Nanjiani could possibly fit that role.

Nanjiani gave fans a brief glimpse into his acting chops with his most recent role in Marvel's Eternals, and his current physical size would be perfect for the warrior role. He could also give his own unique sense of humour, while also proving his ability to delve into truly deep sad roles.

Najiani could explore Dex's struggles with being the last of his people, finding a new family on the Atlantis, and how his hatred for the wraith mixed with his desire to protect the galaxy can all boil together in a unique role.

Playing Dex could also give Nanjiani a chance to pursue a role that tends to be more serious and somber than the comedic relief fans are used to with his previous acting jobs.


2. Natalie Martinez As Teyla Emmagan

Natalie Martinez The Fugitive
Quibi

Teyla Emmagan, played by Rachel Luttrell, was one of the first people the crew of the Stargate encountered when they ventured outside their Ancient city. Teyla led her highly spiritual people through the Wraith raids, and she quickly earned her spot as third in command to the crew of Atlantis.

Teyla also had semi psychic powers from one of her ancestors who had Wraith DNA spliced into them. Teyla was able to use this power to often replace or overpower Wraith soldiers, scientists, and even their queens. Tayla's child even became a major plot device for Michael's plans to take over the galaxy, though that may be scrapped in any potential reboot.

While not as comedic as most of the members of Atlantis, Teyla was incredibly compassionate and cared deeply for her people and her comrades in arms. Her superhuman strength and fighting prowess made her and Dex the frontline in any combat situation the main Atlantis team encountered.

This fighting prowess mixed with noble compassion would be perfect for actress Natalie Martinez. While not the most recognizable name on this list, Martinez has shown through her previous acting roles in The Fugitive TV show, Death Race, Kingdom, and Stephen King's Under the Dome.

Ms. Martinez can do physical stunts, can be compassionate and likable on-screen and off, and could easily earn her spot in an Atlantis reboot.


1. Paul Rudd As Lt. Colonel Sheppard

Ant Man Paul Rudd
Marvel Studios

While Dr. Weir is the brains of the whole Atlantis operation, Lt. Colonel Sheppard, played by Joe Flanigan, is the arm. He led his team through the Stargate every day trying to fight off the wraith, learn about the Ancients, encounter friendly and hostile human colonies, keep his team alive, and help as many innocents as he could.

There is plenty of arguing about how Sheppard was just a rip-off of the original Stargate's Jack O'Neil. However, Sheppard tends to have a deeper outlook on his past actions in the military, and during his leadership on Atlantis. Sheppard also had a tendency to delve into dark places when needed to save someone's life or complete his mission.

This is why one of the best actors to portray Commander Sheppard in a reboot is Paul Rudd. Paul Rudd has plenty of experience with comedy, but playing Colonel Sheppard could give him a chance to delve deeper into a serious role, with Sheppard's willingness to do the hard thing clashing with the morality of many of the rest of Atlantis' crew to create a compelling and complex character.

Paul Rudd may not be the best actor for Sheppard in terms of stuntwork and being one of the most popular actors in the world, but his overall character makes him a perfect fan cast for Atlantis' reboot.

And you never know, television can be greater than movies in terms of storytelling, and that is always attractive to actors looking to play different characters with intriguing moralities and stories.


Contributor

Your friendly neighborhood writer across the pond in the United States' west coast with a deep love for everything nerdy. He is a big fan of Batman and Godzilla and is always excited to see what the future of the entertainment industry will bring.