Riverdale: Ranking All The Main Characters From Worst To Best
Before season five, let's remember the best and worst characters Riverdale has to offer...
Having most recently finished up its fourth season, Riverdale has been entertaining, confusing and moving audiences since 2017. Having aired nearly 80 episodes as of this writing, the show has been everything from murder mystery, teen melodrama, romance, horror and crime-drama, with just a splash of mad comedy and musical episodes for good measure.
Along the way, fans have been introduced to numerous characters, all taken from the Archie Comics on which the show is based and all offering something to the overall wackiness of the show's biggest misadventures.
Led by the core four of Archie Andrews, Jughead Jones, Betty Cooper and Veronica Lodge, there are alongside them an odd assortment of high school friends and enemies, gang leaders, mobsters and shady parents, all of whom work together to keep the insanity of the show running full-speed with every passing season.
Not all of the characters are as great as others, but all are memorable creations...for better or worse.
With that in mind, here are all of Riverdale's major characters ranked worst to best. This list will focus only on the main characters, so recurring players such as Mary Andrews and Ethel Muggs will not be included here.
14. Hiram Lodge
Back in season one, Hiram Lodge worked wonders, but that's only because he hadn't turned up on screen yet. Before his season two debut, Hiram was a shady, frequently mentioned bad guy, the shady father of Veronica who would, inevitably, become one of the show's main villains down the line.
As a mysterious presence everyone seemed scared of back in the show's debut, he worked. Come season two, when he actually turned up, he was nothing but a flat and unengaging villain who hasn't been given any time to grow as a character.
Though Mark Consuelos is okay in the role, trying his damnedest to chew through the lackluster material his character is given, Hiram is still exactly as he was when he arrived on the show: the villain. Only, his whole shady bad guy act has now become stale and painfully repetitive, and the threat he once posed is well and truly gone.
There could be something deeper there, but we've yet to see it.
13. Hermione Lodge
Back in the show's first season, Hermione seemed poised to be one of Riverdale's most intriguing leading ladies, but as time has worn on she has become a one-dimensional shell of her former self.
The problem, simply put, is not Hermione herself, but her husband Hiram. Before Hiram came to town, Hermione was a vibrant, interesting character, with a personality, likability and flaws. But with her mobster hubby back in the picture, all of her characterisation seemed to fall out the window, making way for a boring, unfortunately pointless presence on the show.
Again, actress Marisol Nichols seems somewhat interested in what's taking place, but the writers don't give her any room to breathe, making her switch between mother and criminal with little to no motivation or necessity. She has her moments, particularly when it comes to her relationship with Veronica, where she seems ready to be something bigger and better, but these moments are far too inconsistent and short-lived to mean anything.
12. Josie McCoy
Josie McCoy was, for the show's first three seasons, one of Riverdale's leads. Which, looking back, is rather surprising given the fact that she did literally nothing to move the plot or develop beyond singer and tough-as-nails high schooler.
Acting as the lead singer of Josie and the Pussycats, Josie's role on the show was relegated to that of background player, popping up on screen when the narrative needed her to but not giving her anything to do worth remembering.
She was, however uninvolved her antics were to the show's main plot, actually quite likable, proving to be a complex young woman who was bursting with potential. The writers just never took the time to let her go and be a part of the bigger story, and all of her possibilities were left squandered by the time her stay as a series regular was up. What a waste.
11. Kevin Keller
In a show close to overflowing with unlikable characters, Kevin Keller remains a breath of fresh air to the dark tone of the series. Played by the incredibly endearing Casey Cott, Kevin's friendship with Betty was great to watch in the first season, and his honest, unfiltered nature often makes him one of the show's funniest characters.
But, like the majority of characters sitting on the bottom half of this list, Kevin suffers simply because he's never really given anything to do. His role since season two has been nothing more than side character who gets cool lines and disappears.
Worse than that, though, when he does turn up, it's often to act as an obstacle to those around him, meaning his development is constantly overshadowed by the rest of the core gang. He's sweet, complex, strange and loyal, but he's also underused and slips down the rankings because of it.
10. Reggie Mantle
A recurring character in the show's first season, played by the superb Ross Butler, Reggie has been portrayed by the equally awesome Charles Melton since the second season, after Butler left the show to film 13 Reasons Why.
Initially the high school's recent a-hole jock, he has since had interesting roles to play in the show's bigger storylines, briefly dating Veronica, leading the Dark Circle, and being a constantly engaging character thanks to Melton's smarmy, confident performance. When the writing is working for him, that is.
Again, the Riverdale curse strikes. For all his perks and compelling attributes, Reggie is yet another character who feels underused and underdeveloped, often going long periods before doing anything of note. Like Kevin before him, he is a great character when allowed to shine, but only seems to turn up when the narrative conveniently needs him to mix things up.
Because of this, Reggie is both inconsistent and even forgettable in places, and looking at his potential, that just really, really sucks.
9. Alice Cooper
The mother of Betty, Alice Cooper is not a famous rockstar, but Riverdale's most committed and complex journalist. Alice is a character made up of many different parts, moving between being a loving mother, elusive lurker and moral reporter with each passing episode - depending on what the narrative needs her to do in that moment.
She is, more often than not, a very interesting character, shown over the course of the show to be intelligent, independent, and brave. But with this mesh of personality traits and a constantly remixing of her role in the stories, she is also quite inconsistent, switching between roles with literally no warning or adequate build-up.
Honestly, at this point she's more of a plot device than an actual character, rarely developing or given anything resembling a consistent storyline. When she gets her moment, Alice has proven to be one of the show's best characters, but this never lasts as long as it should.
8. Toni Topaz
Riverdale loves a rebel, and with Toni Topaz's season two introduction, the show got one of its best. At first, it looked as though she was nothing more than a new supporting character, destined to be lost amongst the show's bigger personalities, but after a brief will-they-won't-they with Jughead Jones, the writers threw out a curveball by having her get together with the fiery Cheryl Blossom.
No one was quite expecting the pairing, but honestly they might be the best couple on the show, sassing their way through town, sticking by each other's side and being a force to be reckoned with.
The problem with Toni, though, is the union itself. A great couple they may be, but once they got together Toni's characterisation waned, with the relationship actually stunting her development away from Cheryl.
She's tough and smart, and her loyalty makes her an endearing player, but she still feels kind of underdeveloped - and like many of Riverdale's underused gems, she too is bursting with potential not yet utilised.
7. Archie Andrews
Archie Andrews, the show's protagonist, is massively overshadowed by the bigger personalities around him, but he is by no means a bad character. KJ Apa has done an admirable job of making the high schooler an endearing, even relatable guy, and Archie's loyalty, genuine kindness and selfless nature make him easy to root for as a whole.
But, boy, do the writers struggle to balance his virtues with his failings. Though he is, in many respects, the nicest guy on the show (bar his own father), Archie's constant mistakes, nonsensical decisions and weird actions constantly threaten to alienate him from the audience.
Archie should have grown a lot more than he has, but as it stands he is a character unable to learn from his biggest mistakes and weaknesses. He's constantly saved by his friends, and has gone from normal teen with an aptitude for singing to one-dimensional boxing champ seemingly overnight.
Archie is funny, he's sweet and his naivety does sometimes make him a great character, but all told his inconsistencies and poor overall development really let him down.
6. Veronica Lodge
Veronica Lodge came into Riverdale a force to be reckoned with. Confident, feisty and unfiltered, she was introduced as the stereotypical mean girl, rich, arrogant but entertaining to watch. And that could have been it, really, but the writers (as well as actress Camilla Mendes) weren't interested in making her so one-dimensional.
Befriending Betty Cooper, dating Archie Andrews and locking horns with rival it-girl Cheryl Blossom, she proved rather quickly to be more than a pretty face with an overflowing well of confidence.
She is easily one of the show's most intriguing characters, someone who no matter what they go through is able to come out on the other side stronger and more determined than ever.
Though her mean girl demeanor sometimes gets in her way, making her more annoying than anything else, her sass, cool factor and toughness always keeps her on the right side of the audience. We could do with less of her and her parents' drama, though...
5. Betty Cooper
The resident detective of Riverdale, Betty Cooper is the show's ultimate problem solver. Always down for a good mystery, she has throughout the show's first four seasons been the light radiating through the darkness of the town. She saved Cheryl, figured out the mystery of the Black Hood, saved Jughead's dad from jail and always, always, always tries to do what is right.
In that sense, she kind of mirrors Archie, in that she's constantly hoping to do the right thing and stick up for what she believes in, even when the writing decides to make her go "dark" and, quite frankly, painfully cringe-worthy.
Yes, Betty has moments where she can be a lot to take, and her angst (especially in earlier seasons) was more awkward than it was compelling, but in the end Betty is exactly the character the show needs, willing to jump head first into trouble and do all she can to save the day.
4. F.P Jones
F.P Jones is far from a good person, but the joy of his character is that he'd happily be the first to admit it. Plus, all those terrible things he's done were done to protect those closest to him, and though it's fair to say his approach to certain situations wasn't ideal, his motivations helped make him a genuinely likable character.
Like (almost) all the parents on the show, F.P is far from great, but as the show has gone on it has become clear that he really is doing his best, and wants to keep everyone he and his son care about out of harm's way.
On top of this, there's his sobriety sub-plot, which works wonders to make him endearing to audiences, and his surprisingly good leadership of the Serpents also makes him seem less like a deadbeat dad and a criminal, and more like a good guy trying to atone for his past mistakes. Plus, Skeet Ulrich rocks in the role.
3. Jughead Jones
Arguably the break-out character of the show thanks to Cole Sprouse's committed performance and his signature hat, Jughead Jones is not just Archie's best friend, keeping things in order when they seem destined to go out of control, but he's also the show's narrator, summing up the confusing events surrounding the town and giving the series a voice of reason behind the madness.
Every show needs a sarcastic sidekick, and Jughead fills that role without fault thanks to his whip-smart remarks. But as the show has gone on, it has become clear that he is not merely a sidekick, in place to liven up proceedings with a splash of humour, but a fully-formed and deeply complex protagonist in his own right.
There are some moments we could have done without ("I'm a weirdo" comes to mind), and his sudden commitment to the Serpents felt far too rushed in places, but overall Jughead really is one of the best Riverdale's got, and Archie would be long gone without him.
2. Fred Andrews
Every character on this list are very strange, very flawed people. But not Fred, the loving and morally sound father of Archie.
Fred was a breath of fresh air to the insanity of Riverdale's most insane moments. He was not crazy, manipulative or vindictive. He didn't hold grudges, he stayed out of trouble, and he remains the only truly good parent to ever grace the show. He may not have been part of the main plotlines of the show's first three seasons, but he was the true heart of the series.
Riverdale is a show bursting with larger-than-life personalities, but Fred is not up there with them. He's the most grounded and realistic of them all.
Luke Perry tragically passed away before season four, and so Fred was written out of the show with perhaps its best-ever episode. Even in his absence, he was still making the show a better place. Perry brought his real-life likability to the role, and it's safe to say the show will never be quite the same without him.
1. Cheryl Blossom
In the end, there is no character better than Cheryl Blossom. No character better sums up the off-the-wall madness of the show than Riverdale's resident it-girl. Madelaine Petsch's intense and purposefully over-the-top performance fits perfectly with the tone of the show, and she honestly seems to be the only cast member there to realise how ridiculous the show can be.
Initially starting out as nothing more than the high school mean girl, Cheryl quickly blossomed (sorry) into a strong, confident leader and loyal friend. Under her tough-as-nails persona, she has shown more than once to be much more complex than her appearance who lead people to believe.
Her relationship with Toni has been a particular stand-out, a left-field development that is arguably the best thing to happen on the show. But even with this development, Cheryl has continued to grow and mature. She may often be portrayed as something of a villain, but Cheryl is much more than your standard, run-of-the-mill antagonist - she's the most entertaining, complex character on the show.
Besides, no one can pull-off sassy one-liners quite like her.