Riverdale Season 3: 4 Ups & 2 Downs From 'Big Fun'

The cast of Riverdale shine in the absurdly-brilliant musical episode.

Riverdale S3 Ups Downs 16
The CW

Contains spoilers from Riverdale Season 3, Episode 16.

Riverdale has spent the better part of its third season convincing us that the supernatural is running wild in the small town, making for more of a bizarre offering than ever before. The focus on the satanic game known as Gryphons & Gargoyles, that has swept across town like an epidemic, has taken the show into uncharted territory, but it has also presented the young protagonists with a rare opportunity to relate to their parents - who also found themselves embroiled in the same madness at high school.

That played a major role in the show's second-annual musical episode, during which the students of Riverdale High put on their own production of Heathers: The Musical. A rather on-the-nose choice perhaps, but it allowed the writers to dig deep in 'Big Fun' and fully explore the psyches of two of the show's richest characters in Cheryl and Jughead.

The result was a surprisingly poignant turn, as the notoriously campy show used the phenomenal musical performances to allow these characters to express themselves in a way that they never have before. If we learned anything from this episode, it's this: Only when Riverdale is at its most ridiculous does it begin to make sense.

First, the positives.


Ups...

4. Cole Sprouse's Singing

Riverdale Jughead Cole Sprouse singing
The CW

Oh Cole Sprouse, where have you been hiding that voice?

The sight of Jughead Jones belting out the lyrics of "Seventeen" with Betty Cooper is one that we all never knew we needed, but once it happened, we just couldn't look away.

Though the musical talent of the cast has been well-documented over Riverdale's three seasons, Cole Sprouse had never really flexed his vocal chords. It was never a problem because, while Archie Andrews was a sweetheart on stage and Josie McCoy was a sultry queen, Jughead's inherent broodiness made it believable that he would never get in front of a microphone. As a result, nobody really batted an eye when he had a reduced role in last year's musical episode.

However, that all changed in 'Big Fun'. The writers knew that fans would be waiting to see what Sprouse had to offer in the vocal department and teased us the whole way throughout, giving Jughead quirky lines of dialogue within songs as they built up to the big moment. Then, when that moment came, he absolutely nailed it.

Powerfully belting out the song, he held his own against some of the show's most revered singers, (including Lili Reinhart and Madelaine Petsch) and put us all on notice: Jughead Jones can sing!


3. Edgar Evernever Has Arrived

Riverdale Edgar Evernever Chad Michael Murray
The CW

All season long, Riverdale has focused on the sheer absurdity of this mysterious Farm through Alice Cooper's bizarre obsession with it. Despite Betty's best attempts to get through to her mother, she hasn't been able to convince her (or now Kevin) of its cult-like tendencies, as Alice seems to listen to only one person: Edgar Evernever. Well, 16 episodes in, we finally met the illusive leader of The Farm.

Portrayed by Chad Michael Murray, Edgar debuted in the episode's final scene as the only person to applaud following the conclusion of Riverdale High's musical. With a slow, calculating clap, he led the charge as a significant number of audience members soon followed - all dressed in white, all applauding slowly and, most importantly, all members of The Farm.

The writers have done a masterful job of building up Edgar as the Big Bad of this season without actually having him appear on screen. Now that he has shown up in the final stretch, we'll finally get to observe him in action and, in doing so, see if he really does live up to his reputation.

So far, so good.


2. Kevin And Fangs

Riverdale Kevin Kellar Fangs Fogarty
The CW

Fangs Fogarty's sexuality has been the subject of extensive debate among the Riverdale fandom. When the Serpent first showed up, he was rather flirtatious towards Kevin, something that the latter eventually addressed when he went to see Love, Simon, stating that he couldn't date someone named "Fangs".

It was then completely dropped altogether when Fangs ended up in a secret relationship with Mitch Klump - the star of the last musical that Kevin directed and the girlfriend of Kevin's secret on-again/off-again boyfriend Moose. Though a complicated love quadrangle that sounds like YA gold, Kevin and Fangs remained outsiders and never really interacted, at all. However, it appears that the impact of Mitch's death is still resonating with both of them.

After they were the only two to speak up in the Farm-like meeting before rehearsals, they discussed how they still can't get Mitch's death out of their head. Flash forward twenty minutes and they're both seen passionately singing to one another in the midst of a creepy Farm ceremony, dressed in white, holding hands and, yes, they actually kissed. While this was quite fast-tracked (even for Riverdale), it was undeniably fulfilling to see them finally get together, and it gave viewers hope that we may see something real grow out of it.

Kevin and Fangs being forced together by an unusual cult-like ritual? Absolutely not. But Kevin and Fangs bonding over their shared grief? Now that sounds like one of the most sensible things to ever come out of the completely senseless world that is Riverdale.


1. It Finally Addressed The Ridiculousness Of It All

Riverdale Jughead Betty
The CW

"Can't we be seventeen?" Betty Cooper mused as she cradled Jughead's face.

In that moment, Betty wasn't just reciting the lines of one of Heathers' most iconic numbers, she was asking a question that many of us have been asking those characters for the past year.

When Riverdale first hit our screens, it was a show about lost teenagers that just so happened to find themselves caught up in a murder investigation. Sure, the town was Lynchian and the characters a little too promiscuous, but it still felt relatively grounded. However, throughout the show's run, it stopped being about real people and instead, we got Gargoyle Kings and drug lord mothers. It didn't happen overnight per say, but it sure felt like it.

However, the writers used the music of Heathers to finally address the sheer ridiculousness of the lives that these characters are living. As Jughead struggled with the realization that his mother was literally using his childhood home as a drug lab and Cheryl finally opened us about her, quite frankly, bizarre behaviour through the lyrics of "Seventeen", we finally got to see that these characters aren't as used to their crazy lives as they are portrayed to be.

Turns out that it wasn't just us getting frustrated by the absurdity of it all, the characters felt it too and, in doing so, suddenly became a lot more three-dimensional than they had been in a very long time. Yes, they realised that they are growing up, but they also realised that they wanted to do so in as "normal" a way as possible.

'Big Fun' was a surprisingly touching tale about the journey into adolescence, using the music of Heathers (and the show's exaggerated past) to highlight each character's thoughts and feelings about growing up.

Now, for the negatives...


Downs...

2. Kevin, You Savage

Riverdale Kevin Keller
The CW

It doesn't take a genius to figure out that the best musical TV episodes are those that use the music to express what is going on in each character's mind. The songs become tools to get the protagonists to where they need to be, aiding in their journey of self-discovery and letting the viewers know what they're dealing with.

With that in mind, it's easy to see why Veronica, who had just discovered that her parents were separating, was the perfect candidate to sing "Lifeboat" - a subtle ballad about devastation and loneliness. Even if it wasn't, the performance was preceded by a scene between her and Hiram, who denounced his own family because there was no longer any trust between them. So, it's safe to say that we knew what she was going through. We all knew what she was going through.

However, that didn't stop Kevin from breaking down how she was feeling by brutally reminding Veronica that her world was falling apart. "I was going to talk about the devastating loneliness that your character feels at this particular moment," he said with an absurdly straight face, "but it seems like you're already there so... take it away."

Of course, this was supposed to be a subtle way for the writers to remind us that Veronica was the perfect candidate for the song (you know in case we couldn't infer that from the really obvious devastation she experienced in the episode), but having it come from Kevin was all sorts of wrong. If they absolutely felt the need to include this expository conversation, couldn't they have just had Kevin start describing the scene before Veronica interrupted him with something like "already there, Kev"?

This wasn't subtle at all and ended up portraying Kevin as heartless - something we know that he really isn't.


1. Lady In Red

Riverdale Toni Topaz
The CW

While plenty of the episode's stories seamlessly went hand-in-hand with Heathers' music, one did not.

Cheryl and Toni's falling out played a major role in the episode and, for the most part, it fitted in perfectly ("Seventeen" anyone?). However, there was one scene that, although it was performed well, ended up coming off as rather forced.

Outraged by the fact that Toni wore red (which, in case you didn't know, Cheryl "invented"), the leader of the River Vixens suddenly launched into a tirade about how her ex-girlfriend needed to leave the school before Monday at first bell (or else!!!). Sorry, what?

Again, this was all simply done to create an argument "major" enough so that Toni could belt out the first few lines of "Dead Girl Walking" and make them seem relevant to the plot. But it was problematic, at best.

While the ultimatum was totally in line with Cheryl's character, Toni's decision to randomly wear red felt incredibly contrived. Since showing up, Toni has dressed in all-black and, quite frankly, rocked her own look. Why would she now suddenly go for one of the brightest colours possible, especially if it was Cheryl's colour? Sure, she's been confrontational in the past, but she hasn't gone out of her way to hurt somebody she cared about and, as a result, this felt like an out-of-character move that took place for no reason other than the fact that the song required it to.

-

Did you enjoy Riverdale's musical episode? Tell us in the comment section below.


Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know Riverdale?

Riverdale Gang Pop's
The CW

1. Pop's Chock'lit Shoppe Was Owned By Which Family For Over 80 Years?

In this post: 
Riverdale
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.