Sherlock: 10 Best Minor Characters

Because it wasn't just Sherlock who hogged all the limelight!

Sherlock Irene Adler
BBC

(Note to editor: Hi there, just wanted to ask if you could replace the thumbnail for me as I've chosen not to include Molly Hooper because I don't think she fits the bill of minor character. Hope you like the list, and I can change some of the entries if you feel they aren't quite right. Michael)

A show is only ever as good as its supporting cast, but a supporting cast is only as good as the minor cast. When creating a show, it's crucial to guarantee that every part of it works down to the bone. One of the best ways to ensure this is to establish a solid set of characters, all the way down to the smallest bit parts.

A minor role is a character who doesn't appear very often - if even more than one episode - but can play a significant part in either the development of a lead, the plot of the episode or even an overarching moment in the series. Sherlock was fantastic at creating memorable versions of such characters, primarily because Sherlock and Dr Watson often found themselves dealing with new one-off clients on a regular basis.

The following ten entries are the minor characters who made the biggest impact on the show. Whether that's because the audience was instantly attached to them, they presented a substantial challenge or were just entertaining is interchangeable, but what isn't is the fond memories they left behind.

--

This list will contain spoilers.

10. Sarah Sawyer

Sarah Sawyer Sherlock
BBC

Before Mary came along, John Watson did not have much luck with women, and it's easy to see why. Taking care of Sherlock Holmes was a full-time job, and while John always tried to make space for someone special, he'd often get side-tracked due to his business partners shenanigans. The first significant instance of this was Sarah Sawyer.

The beginning of this relationship was filled with promise, as they met during a job interview in "The Blind Banker" when John wanted to join her GP practice. After getting the job, the two began to hit it off, and despite some rough patches - like John falling asleep at work - they went out on a date and eventually became a thing.

Of course, as far as first dates go, being kidnapped and threatened with death isn't a great start, but it seemed to work as they were still together in the next episode.

Although her time was brief, it was easy to fall for Sarah's charms, as her quick wit and sharp tongue were enjoyable, and her flirtations with Watson helped them to have great chemistry. She wouldn't be his romantic endgame, but she was great as the show's first touch with romance.


9. Bill Wiggins

Sherlock BBC
BBC

One of the best things that Sherlock did was integrating some of the classic characters from Arthur Conan Doyle's world and making them contemporary. That's something that could be found tenfold with this adaptation of Wiggins from the Baker Street Irregulars - and that's not in reference to the recent Netflix series.

Bill Wiggins was introduced in season three's "The Last Vow" and instantly made an impression, as while guarding the drug den that Sherlock was frequenting, he managed to prove his powers of deduction by examining John Watson, and figuring out how he'd ridden there. It was always fun to see the show play with the idea of other people rivalling Sherlock's deductive talents, so this was a nice surprise.

Additionally, his skills as a chemist - which played a major part in his drug usage - was handy to Sherlock, if a little for the wrong reasons. It was fascinating to see a character of such small stature make such a big impression, as, under different circumstances, you could even see how Bill Wiggins could have been the next Sherlock Holmes.


8. James Sholto

James Sholto Alistair Petrie Sherlock
BBC

As can be expected from the legendary detective, mysteries always seem to follow him, and he can't even take a day off to enjoy his best friends wedding. The episode "The Sign of Three" was a lot of fun, not only because viewers got to see Watson tie the knot, but because of the introduction of his old commander and friends James Sholto.

This character was described as elusive and introverted, which was clear from his delicate and quiet demeanour. Sholto had been a commander in Afghanistan and accidentally led a group of fresh recruits into an ambush, resulting in their deaths and his disfigurement.

The horror of this event not only damaged his body but his psyche too, as the families of the deceased brought shame upon him, and one even tried to kill him in the events of the episode.

This character played into some fascinating ideas about being a disgraced military hero who has to survive the guilt of their mistakes and the hateful eyes of those affected by their tragic past. It made the whole case incredibly believable, as you could see why someone would seek to harm him and understand why he'd consider giving up.


7. Henry Knight

Russell Tovey Sherlock
BBC

"The Hounds of Baskerville" was an excellent delve into Sherlock's version of a horror story. It took the absurd concept of a man being haunted by a giant dog and turned it into a compelling story about genetic modification, paranoia and conspiracy, and it was all spearheaded by Henry Knight.

This episode followed Sherlock and Watson as they were employed by Henry to help him prove that the titular creature had murdered his father. However, as the episode went along, it became clear that Henry's sanity was in question and that there may be something far more sinister than a giant canine in the land of Dartmoor.

The human mind is capable of a great many things, but it often manifests itself in strange ways to cover traumatic memories. Henry's incredibly fragile mental state and constant paranoia was a great example of this, as the poor man was so damaged, and you genuinely wanted to see him get help.

Of all the clients that Sherlock ever had, this was undoubtedly one you wanted to see get his money's worth if only to bring him some much-needed peace.


6. Jeff Hope (The Taxi Driver)

Jeff Hope Taxi Driver Sherlock
BBC

As the first major antagonist of the series, you would have thought that Jeff Hope wouldn't be considered a minor character. However, he does quite easily fall into the category as he only appears in one episode and seems to just be a pawn in the hands of Moriarty. Still, that doesn't mean he didn't make a great first impression.

Seeing a terminally ill killer gambling with his own life was a fascinating direction for the show, as it came as a big surprise and was a very satisfying pay off for the mystery. Part of what made Jeff so exciting as a villain was his anonymity. This was a significant part of the case as no one ever suspects the taxi driver, making him an interesting secretive antagonist.

The final encounter between this man and the titular hero was incredibly entertaining, and that came from the fact that Jeff seemed like such an ordinary bloke. Seeing him delve into the world of crime thanks to the fact that he was on death's door was a frightening examination of how we're all capable of going off the deep end when we have nothing left to lose.


5. Phillip Anderson

Sherlock Philip Anderson
BBC

The trajectory of this character was fascinating as he went from being an irritating thorn in the side of our lead to an obsessive fanatic who seemed to encapsulate a fourth-wall-breaking manifestation of the viewer. He essentially played two roles in the show, both of which were just as fun as the other.

At first, Anderson was a typical cynic detective working underneath Lestrade, like Sally Donovan. He was constantly at odds with Sherlock and, while he was good at his job, was always overshadowed by the brilliant detective. It seemed that this would be his character forever, but it all changed in season three.

After Sherlock's supposed demise during season two's climax, Phillip Anderson was unconvinced, as he became obsessed with proving that Sherlock was still alive. He went from a clean-shaven detective to a ragged and scruffy conspiracy theorist, and it was incredibly entertaining.

Every viewer could relate to his paranoia and enthusiasm. They were just as desperate as him to find out how Sherlock managed to evade the reaper's scythe, which took him from a seemingly unimportant distraction to a very likeable and memorable character.


4. Janine

Janine Sherlock
BBC

Janine crossing paths with Sherlock might have felt like a whirlwind romance at first, but it became clear eventually that it was anything but. This tragic character was incredibly likeable, and from the moment she stepped onto the screen, you knew she'd have a key role to play, even if it ended in disaster.

She was introduced in the episode "The Sign of Three" as Mary's maid of honour and instantly hit it off with Sherlock, flirting and even receiving a dance lesson from him. Eventually, it was revealed in the episode "His Last Vow" that the two had formed a relationship.

While seeing Sherlock "date" might have been a little bit of fan service, it didn't take away from the fact that she brought out a side of Sherlock that viewers had never seen before. It's a shame it was all a ruse from the detective, as he wanted to use her position as the PA of Charles Magnussen for his investigation.

Afterwards - rightfully so - their relationship ended, as Sherlock's fake proposal unveiled that their relationship had been a lie. Still, she got a fair bit of cash for selling their story and bought herself a lovely cottage, so at least it worked out for her in the end.


3. Culverton Smith

Sherlock Toby Jones Culverton Smith
BBC

There's nothing scarier than someone who wants to kill you and can get away with it whilst still being beloved by the public. That terrifying notion was the basis for this character and the plot for the episode "The Lying Detective", which saw Sherlock come face to face with one of his scariest antagonists to date. He left a massive impression, despite only appearing in one episode.

Culverton Smith was a wealthy philanthropist and charity worker who managed to fool Britain into treating him like a celebrity whilst being an active serial killer. It was the perfect way for Sherlock to explore the idea of corruption in power and even look at similar figures from the BBC's real-life history.

Another aspect of this characters greatness has to be the casting of Toby Jones. Not only did he bring a certain amount of star power to the role, but his incredibly creepy performance was bone-chilling, and it was easy to see how he was able to charm the world into letting him get away with his crimes.

The fact that this villain was such a memorable part of the series, despite his lack of screen time, is impressive.


2. Kitty Riley

Kitty Riley Sherlock Katherine Parkinson
BBC

If you want the definition of the phrase "there's no such thing as a small role", then look no further than Kitty Riley.

This character had less screen time than all the other characters on this list, yet made a considerable impression thanks to her strong dialogue, wonderful performance - given by Katherine Parkinson - and placement as a pawn in Moriarty's game with Sherlock.

She first came along by pretending to be a Sherlock superfan and confronting him in the bathroom, only to have it revealed that she was an investigative journalist looking for her first big scoop. She had decided that Sherlock was her ticket to stardom but was promptly sent away after he uttered the words "You repel me".

This drove her right into the arms of Jim Moriarty, who instantly tricked her into believing he was just an actor and got her involved in his ploy to ruin Sherlock's reputation.

While she didn't do much outside of this, she acted as a great example of how Sherlock's abrasive personality - however justified - could cause him significant issues. Although those words meant nothing to him at the time, they drove a valuable ally right into the hands of his arch-nemesis.


1. Irene Adler

Sherlock Irene Adler
BBC

Well, if you thought John's time with romance was bad, then get a load of this.

Calling Irene Adler a minor character feels like a bit of a stretch seeing as she was so significant to Sherlock's development. Still, she only appeared in one episode - excluding a cameo in the mind palace - meaning that she falls into the category. Her time spent in "A Scandal In Belgravia" was instantly memorable, as she posed a massive challenge to Sherlock and charmed audiences with her effortless confidence.

Adler was a dominatrix who used sexuality to gather information and images from high-ranking officials - including royal family members - to act as insurance and pave her lifestyle. This came to a head when she ran amuck with Sherlock, constantly flirting with him and attempting to use him to further her agenda, which ended up backfiring for her in the end.

Although she wasn't entirely a villain, she acted as a primary antagonist yet managed to come across as likeable thanks to her quick wit, intellect and bravado. It was hard not to root for her as she almost brought the entire country to its knees.


In this post: 
Sherlock
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!