Sherlock: 10 Most Hated Episodes

For a show with so little episodes, it's disappointing how many of them are so bad.

Sherlock The Final Problem
BBC

The TV series Sherlock was once considered to be one of the greatest TV shows of its time, but the more it went on, the more ridiculous, tedious and uninteresting it became. The first half of Sherlock contains highly acclaimed episodes filled with wit, sharpness, suspense, and even occasional humour, but the second half seems to go completely overboard with its complexity and comedic scenes, turning the series into an overindulgent, incoherent, and overdone disaster.

While Sherlock has had more duds than successes as a whole, its first half is filled with so many great moments, it's a bit hard to believe the bad episodes and the good episodes even come from the same show. That being said, Sherlock currently only has 13 episodes, and with Season 5 still unsure, it looks like the series will remain to have 13 episodes for a while. Some great one are included in this list simply because they didn't make the cut for the top three of the series.

Still, it's easy to see why Sherlock had such a strong fanbase, considering how smart, well-acted and all-around fun the series used to be. It's a shame many of the episodes of this list come from the same show and the decline in quality is certainly disappointing, to say the least.

10. A Study In Pink

Sherlock And John
BBC

Alas, poor A Study in Pink. This really does not belong on a "Most Hated Sherlock Episodes" list, but because Sherlock only has 13 episodes, only three can be absent from this list. A Study in Pink almost makes the cut for those three, but since it's the pilot offering, it only makes sense that Sherlock fans would prefer the show's other great outings rather than this one.

For a pilot, though, it's a seriously great one. It does a great job at introducing the show's characters and even interjects fun humor during occasional bits. One of the biggest problems the later episodes of Sherlock would have is just how much forced comedy they have, often feeling like the writers set aside the plot at times in order to spotlight a comedic scene.

This episode, however, does comedy without it ever feeling like getting in the way of the plot. Sherlock is a detective show, after all, and like all detective shows should be, A Study in Pink starts the iconic reimagining off as tense, exciting, suspenseful, and most of all, plenty of fun.


9. The Hounds Of Baskerville

Sherlock The Hounds Of Baskerville
BBC

The Hounds of Baskerville is by no means terrible, but unfortunately, it doesn't make the cut for the top three most loved episodes. The thing about this outing is how different it feels from all the other Sherlock small screen offerings, especially when it comes to Season Two. The Hounds of Baskerville feels darker and even leaning more towards fantasy, in a sense.

Certainly, that makes it a unique Sherlock mystery and one that many fans love, but it's also understandable why some Sherlock fans just aren't wild about this one. It feels very much like a standalone and doesn't contribute much to the overall plot or character arcs of the series, and while that isn't a bad thing in it itself, it doesn't help when being compared to other Sherlock episodes.

All that said, The Hounds of Baskerville really is a great time. It's smart and thrilling, the kind of hour and a half that puts you at the edge of your seat, wondering how it'll end. It's plain fun and an episode that many Sherlock fans appreciate, even if not many would call it their favorite.


8. The Sign Of Three

Sherlock Wedding
BBC

Do you remember the actual mystery of this one? You couldn't be blamed if you didn't. The Sign of Three didn't feel like part of a detective show outing at all — instead, it felt more like a sitcom or soap opera outing with a mystery awkwardly shoved in. What this episode really focuses on is John's wedding with Sherlock being his best man anxious about delivering his best man speech, and the mystery feels so out of place, it's almost as if the writers suddenly remembered they were writing for a detective show and forced a mystery at the last minute.

This episode really wants to make you laugh, so much so that the comedic scenes feel so unnecessary and drawn out. Sherlock has always been a funny series, but the first half always remembered that it was a detective show first — the mystery and suspense come first, the jokes and silly antics come second. In the second half, the comedy takes centre-stage, feeling forced and overdone.

If you wanted to see the show Sherlock becoming less of an intense detective mystery and more of a happy-go-lucky buddy comedy, The Sign of Three is for you. For anyone else, however, The Sign of Three remains one of the worst episodes from a once-great series.


7. His Last Vow

Sherlock His Last Vow
BBC

Did you find the "I don't shave for Sherlock Holmes." "You should put that on a t-shirt." joke hilarious in the Season Three premiere? Well, they repeat that joke again for the season finale, only this time it's a different slogan and it's Charles Augustus Magnussen saying the t-shirt line instead of John's wife. How Magnussen would even know that conversation between John and Mary is beyond us, but the show seems to expect us to believe Mary and Magnussen somehow both thought of the same joke in response to a line said by John.

Forced comedy? Incredibly. The number of times that phrase gets repeated throughout this list should tell you just how big of a problem it is when it comes to the latter half of Sherlock. While this episode is notable for being the only one in Season Three with an actual proper focused-on mystery, it isn't helped by Charles Augustus Magnussen just being a boring, generic, and unimpressive villain, certainly no match with Moriarty who was a worthy foe for Sherlock.

This outing also features a pretty dumb twist with John's wife Mary being exposed as a secret agent, which doesn't even contribute anything of importance to the plot considering how she's immediately forgiven a few scenes later — it just feels like twists for twists' sake. His Last Vow is a messy, nonsensical, and ultimately anti-climatic episode, resulting in a disappointing finale for a disappointing season.


6. The Abominable Bride

sherlock abominable bride
BBC

The Abominable Bride's biggest problem is how it tries to do too much, ultimately resulting in it being needlessly complicated and, quite frankly, hard to follow. It would've been fine if the entire thing had just taken place in 1895, but for some reason, the writers felt it necessary to include present-day Sherlock as well, making the final result incredibly messy and chaotic with its time-hopping.

It really does make for an overstuffed episode and it certainly isn't helped by the fact that neither stories are particularly interesting. Sure, the production of the episode parts set in 1895 is certainly impressive, but the plot is poorly written and the way the 1895 storyline intertwines with the present-day storyline is nonsensical and convoluted. The Abominable Bride comes across as a smug and indulgent special that feels far too pleased with itself.

It doesn't work as a standalone and it doesn't work as a continuous part of the show, seeing as how the present-day parts barely contribute anything to the overall story or characters arcs of the series. Given the entire thing just takes place in Sherlock's mind, it's almost unnecessary to watch. It's just an enormous waste of time.


5. The Blind Banker

Sherlock Benedict Cumberbatch Blind Banker
BBC

Season One of Sherlock started off strongly with the absolutely fantastic pilot A Study in Pink — and immediately saw a serious decline with the second offering The Blind Banker. Luckily, the show would then go on to give us great episodes such as The Reichenbach Fall and A Scandal in Belgravia, but The Blind Banker was such a first season dud that some fans even admit the outing almost made them want to quit the series.

This hour and a half is not only filled with clichés and deus ex machinas but cheap Chinese stereotypes as well. Even that aside, the entire thing is just slow, boring, and even a bit all over the place. A Study in Pink was certainly a hard act to follow, but this one would've been bad no matter what preceded it due to its dull storyline and lack of suspense.

Really, The Blind Banker feels like nothing more than filler, and when you're watching a series with only three outings per season, a filler episode is the last thing you want to watch. That's what we got anyway, making The Blind Banker easily the worst of the first season.


4. The Empty Hearse

Sherlock The Empty Hearse
BBC

The Reichenbach Fall is considered by many to be the best Sherlock episode, so of course, the one following it was highly anticipated, with many fans eager to know how Sherlock was able to survive the fall. Expectations were high and unfortunately, they weren't met. The explanation for how Sherlock survived the fall requires some serious suspension of disbelief in order to make it work — plenty of things could have gone wrong with his plan, and the idea of Sherlock never being in any real danger robs The Reichenbach Fall of the thrill and suspense of its ending.

Even that aside, The Empty Hearse is a slog, with much of its runtime seemingly being devoted to making forced jokes instead of actually having a plot. It's hard to even remember what the mystery was because the entire thing seems ridiculously focused on Sherlock's return and keeping how he survived the fall a secret until the very end. Too focused, actually — we really didn't need an entire 90 minutes about the previous episode's cliffhanger.

The worst part of The Empty Hearse is how it would start a serious decline in quality for Sherlock. No episode after this would reach the highs of the ones that came before this, with all of them sharing the same problems as The Empty Hearse — convoluted, overstuffed, too pleased with itself, and filled with forced comedy.


3. The Final Problem

Sherlock The Final Problem
BBC

With the fifth season still up in the air and unconfirmed, The Final Problem will have to serve as the final episode of the series and my, my, is it a final problem indeed. The Sherlock show has become a victim of its own smartness, with every Season Four offering feeling the need to be crazy complex to the point where it's too much. The show has become so ridiculously over-the-top, resulting in mysteries that feel too convoluted to be enjoyable.

Because Moriarty is no longer the show's villain and Magnussen only lasted for one season, The Final Problem's villain is so ludicrous that it comes across as a desperate attempt to outdo the two previous villains. The writers continuously paint themselves into corners because they have clearly lost it and don't give themselves limits to how wild their outings can be.

The entire thing is just a mess — an indulgent, frantic, overwrought, excessive, chaotic, and overdone mess. Unless the writers can prove to return the show to its intelligent-yet-grounded state, The Final Problem is probably better off as the final problem of the series, lest it continues on to go off the rails and release even more absurd and over-the-top episodes.


2. The Lying Detective

sherlock toby jones
BBC

The Lying Detective is nothing more than an hour-and-a-half of actors chewing the scenery and writers being overly smug and far too satisfied with themselves. At this point, Sherlock just became this tiresome tedious slog. There is no substance here, no suspense, no intrigue — it's just 90 minutes of busy work with no real consequence. In simpler terms, it's a gigantic waste of time.

Toby Jones is certainly a great actor but his character is so uninteresting and unimaginative. Killing off Moriarty was probably the worst thing to happen to this show because every new villain that came after him has just been so poorly defined. It's as if the writers killed Moriarty for the shock factor and now have no idea what they're doing with any of their new villains.

Mary, John's wife who died in the previous episode, is still here as a constantly appearing ghost. She is as pointless as ever but the writers refuse to let her go. As always, the second half of Sherlock continues to be extremely messy, this offering giving us way too many flashbacks and a lot of pointless moments clearly only there to help the episode reach its standard runtime. The Lying Detective left a lot of Sherlock fans scratching their heads, wondering what the hell happened to a series once so clever and sharp.


1. The Six Thatchers

Sherlock Holmes The Six Thatchers
BBC

It's only fitting that the worst episode of the series is also the beginning of its worst season. Many fans thought Season 3 was a decline in quality, but even then none of us were prepared for Season 4, the ultimate jumping the shark moment for the series. The Six Thatchers is an absolute disaster — especially since it revolves around Mary, a pointless character who continues to be pointless, and yet the writers seem to think is absolutely necessary to devote an entire episode to.

The Six Thatchers is pretty much everything that made Sherlock go from great to terrible, starting from its beginning. It feels like forever for this episode's plot to get moving, with many unnecessary and irrelevant scenes that, big surprise, are really only there to add more padding and forced comedy. The entire thing is a mess, which seems to be the best word to describe pretty much every Sherlock episode that came after The Reichenbach Fall. The narrative is chaotic and jarringly jumps around from scene to scene and the characters act strangely out of character, especially John Watson.

It really is just an uninteresting and unengaging season premiere, one that's so convoluted and overly complex it often feels plain silly. This doesn't even feel like Sherlock, this feels like a generic thriller you'd watch if you had two hours to kill and there was nothing else to watch. Really, given how awful the second half of Sherlock is, the biggest mystery now is if a fifth season could possibly bring it back to its former glory or if Sherlock is better left done instead of continuing it and letting it get worse.


In this post: 
Sherlock
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Writer, visual designer, and The Simpsons fan. Still hasn't finished Super Mario Bros. 3 and probably never will. Rocks at board games, though.