Sherlock: Each Main Character Ranked From Worst To Best

From Baker Street to Scotland Yard, which characters rank the highest?

Benedict Cumberbatch Sherlock
BBC

The residents - and friends - of 221b Baker Street are an incredibly diverse and well-written set of characters, and they were a significant part of what made the 2010-17 run of Sherlock utterly engaging. This modernised adaptation of the classic Arthur Conan Doyle novels surprised many as it grew to extreme heights of popularity, becoming a British TV staple.

The reimagining of this Victorian-era consulting detective presented the character in such a unique light and brought a tonne of new directions for the iconic role. However, it wasn't just the eponymous hero who got a massive revamp, as the majority of the novel's recurring characters also featured similar attention.

Each member of the primary cast had an enormous part to play in the narrative and the show's tone. Although some certainly weren't given as much attention as others, they were all at least treated with the right amount of dignity and given plenty to do.

By ranking these leading roles form worst to best, there is a chance to look back on this great show and examine how Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat reinvented some of literatures most iconic heroes, villains and landladies.

7. DI Lestrade

Sherlock Lestrade
BBC

Rupert Graves is a massively underrated performer, with a vast career under his belt, and a few notable roles in impressive projects, but his position in Sherlock is one of the most prominent. DI Lestrade - full name Greg Lestrade - acts as a great buffer between Sherlock and Scotland Yard, but sadly that's mostly where his character remains.

The talented actor does a really good job of bringing personality to a role that might otherwise have felt dull. His serious mannerisms display plenty of professionalism, but it is undercut with a sarcasm that keeps him feeling unique and endearing. The character works as he needs to act as a professional handler of Sherlock, yet is so entwined into the detectives personal life that he comes across far more personal.

With that being said, the role doesn't have as much agency as might be expected from the metropolitan police force. He is often presented to be lacking in intelligence - at least compared to Holmes - and this makes it difficult to trust his detective skills.

Lestrade is mostly well done, but holds an easy place at the lower end of the list.


6. Molly Hooper

Molly Hooper Sherlock
BBC

Seeing the loveable and utterly charming Molly Hooper at the lower end of this article is a disappointing sight. However, it isn't a reflection of poor quality in acting or character building, but rather a display of how intense the competition between these roles is.

Hooper is brought to life by the very talented Louise Brealey, who takes this morgue specialist from St. Bartholomew's Hospital and turns her into one of the most likeable characters in the show. Molly stands apart from the other roles as she seems to be the most honest and innocent, with her awkward shyness combined with an evident crush on Sherlock making her utterly endearing.

The character is given some decent agency in the narrative - particularly in The Abominable Bride - but in a similar vein to Lestrade, she often feels like an assistant to Sherlock's whims and not a fully autonomous part of the series.

Although she is entirely adorable and a fantastic worker, she doesn't fit into the mystery-solving as well as others.


5. Mrs. Hudson

Mrs Hudson
BBC

You can call Mrs. Hudson whatever you like: loveable, a motherly figure, a landlady, just don't call her your housekeeper. While Mrs. Hudson also falls into the trap of feeling irrelevant to the plot at times, she gains a higher position on the list since her role is vital to the humanisation of the two leads, and the governing of 221b.

The character is played to perfection by Una Stubbs, who perfectly balances the matriarchal caring figure with a harsh and sarcastic personality. The Baker Street landlady isn't just a character there for the sake of comedy, as she acts as a vital piece of the detective puzzle. Mrs. Hudson shows the human side to the agency, as she often takes pity on it's clients and lovingly watches over the boys as they run their business.

There aren't too many drawbacks in regards to her performance or writing, as Stubbs makes the role easily loveable, which makes any thought of danger towards her thoroughly upsetting. The only limitations of the character come from her lack of impact on the mainline plot.


4. Mycroft Holmes

mycroft holmes
BBC

Mark Gatiss often appears in the work that he writes, and Mycroft is one such role that he excels in, as the arrogant and powerful older Holmes brother is an enjoyable part of the series.

He certainly has the best introduction, as the first episode deliberately bates the audience into believing he is Sherlock's arch nemesis, Moriarty. However, once it is revealed that the character isn't the malicious and calculating antagonist, he instantly becomes a humorous and petty side to the story.

Seeing the sibling rivalry between the two Holmes boys is not only amusing, but gives the audience a notion that Sherlock isn't the perfect genius you may think he is. This leads to a far more engaging series, as the audience are aware that he can be faulted.

Mycroft is incredibly patronising, not only to Sherlock but to every character, and this helps him to exude an aura of superiority. Additionally, his place in the show is incredibly vital, as he often finds himself completely entwined with the main storyline of the episodes, and this helps him to rise a little higher.


3. Jim Moriarty

Jim Moriarty
BBC

Sherlock's version of Moriarty is easily the character who differs the most from his literary counterpart. Professor Jim Moriarty was not in the novels as much as you might expect, only appearing majorly in the story The Adventure of the Final Problem. However, the character would subsequently be referenced consistently and brought back in many derivative works, and has become a staple of the property.

Moriarty's presence in the novels saw him as criminally insane and ruthless, but very calm and focussed, leading to most versions of the character being performed as reserved and stoic. However, Andrew Scott's performance deeply contrasts this as he chews the scenery and overplays almost every action. This could very easily have come across as cheap, but it works very well in the show's context, as he feels like the complete antithesis to our protagonist.

This performance became one of the most popular aspects of the show, and it's easy to see why, since Scott's supervillain is wholly indulgent and doesn't care what anyone thinks, making him fun to watch no matter the context.


2. Sherlock Holmes

Sherlock BBC
BBC

The role that brought Benedict Cumberbatch into the spotlight. This version of Sherlock is incredibly interesting, as he plays with a lot more insecurity and relatability than his literary counterpart, but still feels accurate to Conan Doyle's creation.

From the characters first appearance on the show, you completely understand his nature. The unempathetic and incredibly rude genius has a tonne of trouble dealing with people and the conventions of life, making him frequently in conflict with those around him. This traditionally comes across as arrogance, and while that still rings true for the show, here it feels a little more grounded.

This version of Sherlock is constantly plagued by his own mind. Whether that's an inability to shut it off, a lack of vocal filter, or merely a tonne of self-consciousness, it makes him feel like he is continuously working and struggling to stay afloat. This makes his arrogance and abrasive behaviour feel far more believable, as he cannot control his mind.

His character has flaws, as the series began to pander a little too far towards his quirky characteristics as the show progressed. However, he is still one of the best versions of the brilliant detective audiences have ever seen.


1. Dr. John Watson

Sherlock Martin Freeman John Watson
BBC

Many readers may be surprised to see that the titular character isn't at the number one spot on this list, but there are many reasons why John Watson ranks as the best role in the show. The first - and most important - is that he is the audiences' eye into the series. John is the first character that the audiences meet, and he guides them through the show delicately, whilst still giving them plenty of conflict and entertainment.

In many adaptations - and even the novels themselves - Watson is treated as a secondary figure to the leading detective. Traditionally he isn't the most well-developed character and is a simple contrast to Sherlock. However, this version utterly delves into him, bringing with it the concept of PTSD, marital frustration, loyalty and a tonne of agency.

Martin Freeman has given many fantastic performances in his career, but this one stands out as he genuinely delves into the dark psyche of a war veteran, turned assistant detective, whilst still capturing the sarcastic sense of humour that he is known for.


In this post: 
Sherlock
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!