The Simpsons: 20 Annoying Mistakes You Didn't Notice

The devil is in the details, and Fox don't always seem to care...

As with any show that runs into extreme longevity, The Simpsons will forever be shackled by a need for fidelity to the past that in no way stands in the way of unique, original storylines to keep fans happy. But with very nearly 550 episodes under their belts, that attention to detail in writing can inevitably suffer, and continuity errors that conflict established facts and storylines in the canon can and do appear, leading to unquantifiable rage from fans, and accusations of sloppiness. To combat the inevitably disproportionate response to the appearance of plot-holes and missed continuity threads, later episodes have simply ignored canonical details for a laugh, but if you look hard enough, there are plenty of examples that suggest that someone in the bowels of Simpsons HQ wasn't really paying enough attention, and let some glaring issues get in. These aren't always ruinous, by any means - after all, this is a cartoon played for laughs - but the devil is in the detail, and as with anything that encourages such familiarity with characters, and depends on the audience knowing and loving them, it is annoying to see something clumsily missed. Behold, the most affectionate list of mistakes you're ever likely to find on the internet...

20. Homer Got His Job Several Different Ways

Despite being horribly under-qualified, massively uncommitted, and basically a walking disaster area, Homer has shown unfeasible durability in terms of his job at the Nuclear Power Planet, despite multiple sackings and apparently just turning up when he wants to, to do very little at all. You have to wonder how he ever got the job in the first place, and luckily the show has the answer. Or, several answers in fact. In "Homer's Enemy", when Frank Grimes asks Carl and Lenny how Homer got the job, they say he simply turned up on the opening of the plant and got hired, which contradicts two other episodes. In "The Blunder Years", we learn about the tragic fate of Smithers' father, which establishes that the Nuclear power plant was clearly open when Homer was young, and also when it is revealed that he failed his initial interview and had to threaten Mr Burns in order to get hired at the second time of asking when Bart is conceived.

19. Lisa Has A Wandering IQ

We might definitely know that Lisa is a genius, as has been established almost relentlessly since her earliest appearances, but quite how much of a genius seems to be a matter for debate. In "Homer's Enemy", her IQ is revealed by Homer to be 156, despite the fact that Lisa herself has come up with two alternatives: 167 in "They Saved Lisa's Brain" and 159 in "Smart and Smarter".

18. The Simpsons Break Their Multi-State Ban All The Time

Thanks to various cross-country shenanigans, The Simpsons are banned from every state in America other than Arizona and North Carolina, as revealed in "Kill the Alligator and Run", when the family is accused of killing Florida state mascot Captain Jack the alligator (who doesn't actually die anyway) but then in subsequent episodes and seasons, episodes, the Simpsons have been to many other states such as Delaware, Missouri, Washington DC, New Jersey, California, New York, Nevada, Oregon, Vermont, Illinois, Utah, and Florida again twice.

17. Homer's Inspiration Disappears

In "And Maggie Makes Three," it is established that Homer only works at the Nuclear Power Plant to afford having three kids, and that Maggie is his inspiration to work. But that doesn't exactly fit with other episodes of the show, which shows that the wall he faces changes between a window showing piping, a map of nuclear sites around the country, a solid wall, and his plaque. And he's probably not working for hi spay-check either, given the wild discrepancies that can occur in it from month to month. In "Much Apu About Nothing", Homer's wage is revealed as $24,395.80 a year before deductions (or $18,833.88 after,) which is a pittance for a Nuclear Safety Inspector (though perhaps not exactly surprising under Mr Burns' regime). But in "American History X-cellent," Carl tells Homer that he's drinking a $60,000 bottle of wine to which Homer replies "Woohoo! I'm drinking my salary!"

16. Mr Burns - Nasty Or Nice?

Mr Burns' origin story is all over the place, especially concerning who he was before he became the megalomaniac Nuclear Power Plant owner. We've seen two different takes on his childhood - first in "Burns' Heir", he's a rich, evil child, and "Monty Can't Buy Me Love" establishes that his father took him to a picnic at age 6 (where he had his first "gay" experience), but in "Rosebud", it is shown that he grew up in a poor family as child, until a twisted, loveless billionaire took him as his heir. And then there's the issue of niceness: in "Them, Robot", Marge says that Mr. Burns was originally a nice man when he first came to Springfield, but in "Burns' Heir" again, he is shown firing his nanny as a baby, suggesting he was pretty much born evil. You can probably discount anything Grandpa Simpson says about Mr Burns' past, given that not even his family believe his stories - so that accounts for the issues created by Burns' time in the army (not to mention the major plot hole relating to Armin Tamzarian).

15. Carl Carlson's Heritage

Another backstory/origin tale issue, no doubt created by the sheer number of episiodes, and writers' commitment to adding new joke elements to established characters. Carl Carlson has both a black family and a white family according to the show. In "The Seemingly Never-Ending Story" and "The Blue and the Gray", we meet his dad and sister, who are both black and resemble Carl closely, but in "The Saga of Carl", Carl reveals that he was adopted by a white family (possibly in Iceland, since he reveals he spent some of his boyhood in Iceland in "'Scuse Me While I Miss the Sky," so quite who those two suspiciously familiar looking charlatans remains to be seen.

14. Left-Handedness Is Apparently Temporary

The whole foundation for Ned Flanders' Leftorium is that there are many prominent lefties throughout Springfield, including billionaire Mr Burns, quite helpfully, which is ultimately what saves the store from closing when Ned is threatened with bankruptcy in "When Flanders Failed." That reprieve must have only been temporary however, since Ned himself has been seen doing right-handed things himself (which perhaps explains why he gives a right-handed salute outside his own left-handed shop) and most of the lefties who save his shop - including Bart Simpson, Principal Skinner, Moe and Mr. Burns - have all seemingly forgotten they were ever left-handed and limited by the unavailability of left-handed items.

13. How Old Is Wiggum?

Thanks to some more wayward writing, it has been established that Chief Clancy Wiggum is at least three different ages - or that he should be, anyway. In the timeline established by "Mother Simpson," Wiggum appears as a teenager - probably 16 - in a flashback to 1969, which would have made him 42 in the present (it was aired in 1995, but it doesn't seem that anyone else ages, so he could well still be 42). But then in "Weekend at Burnsie's" he appears to be a similar age, though he is markedly slimmer, and in the ironically named "The Way We Weren't" he appears in a flashback set when Homer was 10, confusing his age further, especially in line with his appearance playing cops and robbers with Homer when the pair are both children.

12. Homer Is Firing Blanks... Sometimes

As part of the side-effects of his working at the Nuclear Power Plant, Homer is revealed to be sterile, as established in season 3 in "Brother, Can You Spare Two Dimes," and has been for some time - at least since Bart was born. But in "O Brother, Where Bart Thou?" a full 18 seasons later, it is revealed that Marge is taking birth control pills, which Bart swaps with Tic Tacs in an attempt to get a little brother. So why exactly is Marge still taking birth control pills if her husband is firing blanks? Is she really that forgetful?

11. The Spucklers

What began as an opportunity for throw-away red-neck jokes has seen Cletus Spuckler and his family given more prominence as the show has gone on, but there are some serious inconsistencies. The Spucklers weren't even called the Spucklers to begin with, as Cletus' name was initially given as Cletus Del Roy, but it's the lineage of the family that is the most confused. When Homer was ordained as an Internet minister, he was about to marry Cletus and Brandine, and remarked "Wait a minute... are you two brother and sister?" to which Brandine replied, "We's all kindsa thangs, which is something of an understatement. In "The Italian Bob," Brandine remarked to Cletus "Yer tha best husband, brother and son I ever did have," despite early episodes establishing a Spuckler family member called Maw. And then in "Little Big Girl," one of the Spuckler sons draws a family tree that suggests that Brandine is the child of Cletus and an alien. Additionally, in one episode it is revealed that the Spucklers have 51 children, but other episodes throughout the show's history have suggested numbers as diverse as 19, 44, 31 and 39, including a sheep and a walking hot dog. The short answer, it seems, is that nobody really knows.

10. Ned Flanders Is One Of The Oldest Men In Springfield, Except When He's Not

How old is Ned Flanders? In "Hurricane Neddy", Ned was sent for treatment with Dr. Foster 30 years ago for anger aversion that lead to his speech eccentricities (despite the fact that all of his male relatives apparently share a genetic predisposition to the same quirk), when Ned was a child, making him 34 or so, assuming that he was 4 when he was treated. But in "Viva Ned Flanders", he reveals that he is 60 years old, and when Mr Burns is awarded the Oldest Living Springfieldian award, Ned remains standing with all other residents who are older than 60.

9. Milhouse Is A Dirty Liar

In Season 15 episode "The Way We Weren't," when Milhouse kisses Homer, he says that that was the first kiss in his whole life, but a whole 12 seasons before that in "Bart's Friend Falls in Love," he has a girlfriend who he relentlessly kisses, so either Milhouse decided that his first experiences didn't count, or he completely wiped Samantha Stanky out of his memory entirely.

8. Smithers' Origin Story Changes At The Drop Of A Hat

Like Ned Flanders, and Clancy Wiggum, the show has also suggested that Waylon Smithers is three entirely different ages. In "The Simpsons 138th Episode Spectacular", Troy McClure mentions that the executive personal assistant is in his early 40's, and in "Bye Bye Nerdie", Homer remembers beating him up in middle school, putting them at similar ages (though presumably Flanders would have had to be older). But then in "The Blunder Years," when Homer is overcome with screaming terrors, it is eventually discovered that the cause was his discovery of the dead body of Smithers' father, who sacrificed himself to save Springfield from a nuclear meltdown 25 years earlier. That would make Smithers younger than Homer, and only in his late 20s, rather than his early 40s.

7. Where Were Marge And Homer Married Exactly?

Did Homer and Marge have an understated paupers' wedding, or a traditional, more lavish affair? The show can't seem to decide, as in "The War of the Simpsons", Homer mentions "that big bash we had with all the champagne and musicians and holy men and everything", which Marge points out was their wedding, but in flash-back episode"I Married Marge", Homer was only able to afford a cheap wedding at Shotgun Pete's.

6. Bart's Allergies

Bart has a number of allergies, from cauliflower and shrimp - as established in the episode "Please Homer, Don't Hammer 'Em" to butterscotch, imitation butterscotch and glow in the dark monster makeup - as stated in "Blood Feud." So you'd think he was a little less cavalier about eating any of them, which is disproven at the end of "The Frying Game" when he says that "I ate so much free shrimp," or that his mother would be particularly careful about exposing him to anything that might kill him, which she does in "A Milhouse Divided", when Marge reveals plans to cook her speciality of Butterscotch Chicken for Bart.

5. What's The Deal With Smithers?

No, not his sexuality: that's not up for debate. Instead, the issue here is his confession of love for Mr Burns, which happens at least twice, despite the fact that Burns reacts to each time as if it is a brand new revelation.

4. Desperate Moe Forgets Employing A Woman

In season 8 episode "The Homer They Fall" Moe says that no women have been to his bar since 1979, but back in the third season episode "Flaming Moe's," he hires a female waitress to help deal with the added custom that comes from his stealing Homer's cocktail recipe. And it's not the only women he seemingly forgets, as in "New Kid on the Block" and "Homer the Vigilante," Ruth Powers, the next-door neighbour of the Simpsons appears in the bar, even ordering a beer, while Marge goes to the bar in "Bart Gets Hit by A Car." Moe can perhaps be forgiven for forgetting Ruth, since the show has never really been clear on when she left the show: she apparently sold her house to Sideshow Bob in disguise and moved to Detroit (even though she appears at the party he hosts to celebrate moving in), and she has appeared as a Springfield resident since apparently leaving a couple of times.

3. Homer's Baldness

Homer's baldness has been put down to a number of causes over the course of the show's history, from the suggestion in "Homer Scissorhands," that the hair loss began in high school, thanks to over-loving it, to the revelation that he pulled more of his hair out each time one of his children was conceived, with Maggie leaving him as bald as he is now. But then in "Marge on the Lam," it was revealed that Homer once volunteered for an army experiment just to get out of dinner with his sisters-in-law, which involved being injected with a serum whose side effects were hair loss, loss of balance and giddiness, explaining not only his baldness, but apparently also his stupidity. Another hair issue relates to Grandpa Simpson, who had a thick head of hair in his younger years, but then went bald, revealing, somehow, three pointed growths on the top of his head, much like his grandchildren's hair. Clearly, this is not his hair, since that was brown, so what the hell is up with his head?!

2. Maggie's First Word Is Any Number Of Things

Non-Canon episodes and shorts have had the Simpsons' quietest member speak a number of times, but those don't legitimately count as her first word, so you have to turn to real episodes for the answer to what her first word was. Canon says that Maggie's first word was "Daddy" in "Lisa's First Word," though only viewers witnessed that, so her family believe her first word to have been "Ja" (Norwegian for "Yes") in "Coming to Homerica." But in "Gump Roast" everyone watched a clip of Maggie saying her first word, which contradicts that, and the Simpsons movie suggests in a gag that her first word is "Sequel." And the single most annoying recurring mistake/continuity error in the entire Simpsons' history...?

1. Mr Burns' Age

The oldest man in Springfield title would presumably indicate that the Simpsons writers have a grasp of how long Mr Burns has been around the place, but his biography changes so wildly, that it's almost impossible to pinpoint how old he actually is. At times he has been presented as being both 81 and 104 in different episodes, but it has also been implied that he is anywhere from 118 to 123, with one joke suggesting that his age is the same as his pin-number, implying that he is at least 1000 years old. Which other Simpsons continuity errors do you think deserve to be on this list? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.

Watch Next


In this post: 
The Simpsons
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.