South Park: 10 Most Disturbing Episodes
Poor taste is the name of the game in South Park, but did these episodes go too far?
Warning: Sensitive Content Ahead!
You'd think that after almost thirty years on the air that the beautifully twisted minds behind South Park would have lost their spark for making us laugh at the most appalling things, and yet somehow the show is still firing on all cylinders.
Starting out its life as a subversive, surreal and overtly disgusting comedy, the show has slowly evolved over time into a pillar of American satire that takes no prisoners and sinks its fangs into any subject - no matter how taboo or upsetting said subject may be.
The show's ongoing vicious social satire and unwillingness to compromise its integrity for the sake of good taste have ensured that its dedicated following has stood by it through thick and thin, even when controversy has come a-knockin'. And, for a show like South Park, controversy is forever waiting in the wings.
Which brings us to this list.
The episodes featured here are undoubtedly the show's most disturbing outings, which touch upon taboo subjects such as paedophilia, sexual assault and school shootings. Although if you're a fan of South Park, you're likely used to such nastiness and those featured here today will likely come as no surprise to you.
10. Proper Condom Use - Season 5, Episode 7
Perhaps the most outright disgusting episode on this list, Proper Condom Use is chock-full of nauseating moments that will permanently scar you.
When Cartman is taught how to 'milk a dog' he enthusiastically tells all of his friends, which leads to Stan masturbating the family dog in front of his parents' book club. The outraged townsfolk then decide to lower the age in which sex education is taught in school, and as a result, the highly deranged sexual dysfunctions of both Mr Mackey and Miss Choksondik are shown to us in the most graphic manner possible.
And trust us when we say it's not pretty.
That rather gruesome sex scene aside, we're also treated to Mr Garrison's unconventional way of putting on a condom, numerous up-close photographs of real sexually transmitted diseases, and Cartman discovering that you don't need to go to the bathroom when you're wearing a condom all day.
The episode does wind its neck in a little towards the end when it settles into becoming a Mad Max parody, but the creators just couldn't help themselves and it ends on the townsfolk gleefully watching as Stan once again w*nks off his dog Sparky.
9. Scott Tenorman Must Die - Season 5, Episode 4
An obvious, yet very necessary inclusion to this list, Scott Tenorman Must Die is one of the show's most beloved and infamously depraved half hours.
After being scammed into buying the pubes of eighth-grader Scott Tenorman, Cartman begins a crusade for revenge. Most of his attempts to either ridicule or maim Scott backfire, including a particularly inspired plan to train a donkey to bite off Scott's genitals, which ultimately doesn't come to fruition.
But in typical Cartman fashion, he saved the best plan for last.
He invites Scott to attend the Chilli-Con-Carnival, an event organised by Cartman himself which consists of rides, stalls and a chilli making contest.
Through an elaborate series of events, Cartman was able to get Scott's parents killed for trespassing and then steal their bodies from the scene of the crime. After spending a night with the hacksaw, he then cooked Mr and Mrs Tenorman's remains into a chilli, which Scott eagerly wolfs down.
It's a particularly horrific series of events, all of which are perfectly capped off by Cartman lapping up Scott's tears in the most disgusting display of victory we've ever seen.
8. Stanley's Cup - Season 10, Episode 14
On the surface, Stanley's Cup appears to be an affectionate parody of underdog sports movies. The kind of which South Park's creators likely grew up with, and have strong memories attached to.
But of course, leave it to Matt and Trey to take a wholesome set of sporting films, and pervert them into one of the show's most upsetting and deeply unpleasant half hours. After having his bike towed, Stan is forced into coaching a pee-wee hockey team in order to get it back, and upon learning that one of its players Nelson is suffering from an aggressive form of cancer, Stan vows to lead the team to victory.
It all sounds very wholesome, but soon turns sour when Stan's team ends up playing against a professional hockey team who brutally beat the children into submission before securing victory. The failure of the team then leads to Nelson giving up hope and he succumbs to his illness. All the while the opposing team celebrate on the blood-soaked ice as 'We are the Champions' rings out all around them.
It's an incredibly shocking ending and one that will forever live in infamy amongst fans of the show.
7. Cartman Joins NAMBLA - Season 4, Episode 5
Considering himself too mature for his peers, Cartman takes to the internet to find more like-minded people, but upon advertising himself online as a young boy looking for mature friends, he very quickly attracts the attention of some older men who have more than simple friendship on their minds.
Cartman's enthusiasm for having older friends quickly sees him becoming the poster child for NAMBLA - the unfortunately very real North American Man/Boy Love Association - and willingly brings his classmates into their evil clutches.
The episode does undercut the sickening storyline by utilising very old-fashioned slapstick humour, but it will still likely make your skin crawl throughout. And whilst it's usually the case for South Park to use its secondary plot to provide some levity, this one has an equally distressing b-story to keep things grim throughout.
After discovering that his parents are expecting another baby, Kenny sets about trying to murder his unborn sibling. Starting off with simple pills, and eventually going so far as to attack his mother with a toilet plunger. Everything in this episode is presented in a highly silly way, but the actual content will never be anything less than truly disturbing.
6. World War Zimmerman - Season 17, Episode 3
The satire in South Park has never really aired on the right side of subtle, but World War Zimmerman's approach to its source material was akin to taking a sledgehammer to a newborn baby.
In a parody of World War Z, Cartman begins suffering from a series of nightmares that show the downfall of civilization as a result of the verdict on the George Zimmerman trial - with the zombies being replaced with outraged African Americans who are rioting in protest.
A fairly dicey premise to begin with, the episode wildly swings from shocking to genuinely impactful at a moments notice, and rarely gives the viewer a chance to breathe. The final one-two punch of Zimmerman's highly comical execution, followed by Cartman 'standing his ground' and point-blank shooting Token is some of the most biting and downright nasty content the show has ever produced.
World War Zimmerman is arguably one of the show's finest hours due to its uncompromised brutality and meaningful social commentary, and proof that despite all the puerile humour, South Park is a show that always has a message and isn't afraid to go to dark places to get its point across.
5. Cartman Sucks - Season 11, Episode 2
Never ones to shy away from the most harrowing of subject matter, this season eleven episode saw Matt Stone and Trey Parker take aim at gay conversion camps and pulled no punches in showing just how abhorrent these places actually are.
After being tricked into a compromising position by Cartman, Butters is shipped away to Camp New Grace, a facility designed to help its prisoners to 'pray the gay away'. We're immediately shown the damaging effects of such a place, with its highly traumatised inmates being prone to suicide and self-harm in order to repress their true selves.
Butters typical naivety means that he's seemingly unaffected by much of the camp's nastiness, remaining upbeat and positive in spite of the overwhelmingly grim conditions. His overall confusion as to what's going on plays perfectly into the episode's subject matter and leads to many great gags that produce plenty of belly laughs.
Thankfully, the episode does have something of an upbeat ending, in which Butters manages to save one of his fellow campers from succumbing to pressures of Camp New Grace, but the inherent darkness of its subject matter still lingers long after the closing credits.
4. The China Problem - Season 12, Episode 8
Most certainly one of the most controversial episodes of the show, The China Problem immediately caught people's attention with its reliance on Chinese stereotypes in the main plot, but it's the B-plot's content that really got a rise out of the public.
As Cartman goes on a perilous journey to try and thwart an invasion by China, which has plenty of unsavoury content on its own, the rest of the boys are shown to be plagued by a traumatic event in which a dear friend of theirs was sexually assaulted.
It's then soon revealed that said friend was in fact Indiana Jones, and said assault and traumatic experience was seeing Kingdom of the Crystal Skull. And whilst nobody would care about the writers slinging mud at a notoriously bad movie, its execution here is certainly in poor taste.
Parodying the likes of The Accused and Deliverance, the boys' flashbacks show Steven Spielberg and George Lucas brutally raping Indiana Jones, completely throwing any sense of subtlety out of the window.
Even by Trey Parker's own admission, this episode's content does air on the side of being dark as opposed to funny, and we're certainly not going to disagree with him here.
3. Miss Teacher Bangs A Boy - Season 10, Episode 10
With a name like Miss Teacher Bangs a Boy, you just know this episode is going to be all kinds of wrong.
And just as you'd imagine, it absolutely is.
Focusing on Ike's blossoming romance with his kindergarten teacher Miss Stevenson, the episode takes aim at the idea that society is weirdly less outraged by female teachers taking advantage of their students, and is clearly having a lot of fun poking at this wide-spread hypocrisy.
Miss Stevenson's enflamed passion for Ike is contrasted to a beautifully warped level by Ike's lack of affection for her, with the toddler quickly tiring of the honeymoon phase and preferring to watch TV instead of talking to his beau. Thankfully the episode is tasteful - or as tasteful as one can possibly be with a plot such as this - and the underlying ickiness of the whole scenario is played for laughs as much as it possibly can be.
The main plot aside though, there are several other highlights, with Cartman's spoof of Dog the Bounty Hunter acting as the perfect juxtaposition of tones to help alleviate what is a particularly grim morsel to swallow.
2. Dead Kids - Season 22, Episode 1
Even the most mean-spirited of horror films tend to tread carefully when it comes to the subject of school shootings, but South Park has never been known for its subtlety, and their take on the highly distressing issue is every bit as brilliant as you'd expect.
If the horrible name wasn't enough to clue you in on this episode's inherent darkness, we're almost immediately shown the kids answering math problems whilst the harrowing sounds of an active shooter ring out from the corridors, although nobody reacts to the chaos. These ideas are utilised further and more abundantly throughout the episode, and they never fail to be intentionally provocative and darkly funny.
The B-plot in which Sharon slowly loses her mind due to everyone's compliant attitude is a perfect reminder as to the baffling acceptance of such acts being a facet of American culture but in typical South Park fashion, it's perfectly complemented by Randy constantly asking her if Aunt Flo has come to visit.
A somewhat obvious and incredibly puerile joke, but one that the writers get a surprising amount of mileage out of. Which is a further testament to their comedy chops.
1. Britney's New Look - Season 12, Episode 2
On paper, the idea of South Park lampooning the media storm that surrounded a troubled Britney Spears back in 2008 does sound like it'd be good for a few mean-spirited laughs. Little did audiences of time know, however, that what Matt and Trey had in store with us was much, much darker.
After learning that the press is offering good money for any pictures of the mentally-fragile pop singer, the boys set about staging a picture with Miss Spears. Only for their plan to backfire and she blows her brains out.
Somehow Britney survives this suicide attempt and spends the rest of the episode as a bloody stump with its tongue lolloping around as she tries to sing and speak. Britney's exploitation continues, despite her serious need to be put out of her misery.
Given everything that the public has come to learn about Britney in the last few years, this episode's underlying nastiness has only become more disturbing with time, and its final sequence just goes to show that despite South Park being a comedy, it's capable of crafting some highly disturbing horror moments.