South Park: 10 Times Butters Was TOO Innocent
Oh, hamburgers!
The rocky mountain town of South Park, Colorado is famously inhabited by a whole host of colourful characters, each with their own distinct personalities that really bring the town to life.
Stan, Kyle, Cartman, and Kenny have faced off against aliens, waged war in Imaginationland, and even helped send a whale to space. Why they ever did that in the first place though, who knows. It's clear that these four steal most of the spotlight in their class and their crude, unapologetic sense of humour has kept audiences laughing for 25 seasons and counting.
It's not only Cartman's diabolical schemes and Kenny's countless deaths that have kept us coming back for more, and there is one character who has never seemed to fit in.
Leopold 'Butters' Stotch tends to be the butt of many jokes and finds himself getting caught in the crossfire when things inevitably go haywire in town. Unlike many others in town, Butters is a genuinely good-hearted individual who never lets cynicism or selfishness get the better of him.
His pure heart often means he gets taken advantage of, but he doesn't let that stop him from being the most innocent person in the quaint little town of South Park.
10. Butters' Fifteen Minutes Of Fame
In the penultimate episode of season five, the show decides to stick to its guns and kill off Kenny for good. Well, at least until the end of season six but still, it's a much longer turnaround than his usual next episode resurrections.
With Kenny gone, Stan, Kyle, and Cartman look for a replacement to fill the void that he left behind. They even go as far as hosting tryouts to find the most suitable candidate, but before that, they decide to give Butters a shot.
It becomes clear that the extent of Butters involvement in the group is just to be the scapegoat for any undesirable tasks. Butters is so willing to do whatever it takes to be part of the gang, even if it puts him in a precarious position.
One such task is having prosthetic testicles superglued to his chin so that he can make an appearance on The Maury Povich Show, in order to be gifted some sort of prize. A poorly devised plan if ever there was one.
Things take a turn for the worse when Butters meets people backstage with genuine disfigurements who make a living from talk show appearances, and don't take kindly to imposters. He somehow manages to juggle a grounding from his father, protesting with the self-proclaimed 'freaks,' and keeping those balls glued to his chin.
In the end, Butters actually seems to come out on top. After Cartman exposes him by ripping the prosthetics from his face, the freaks turn on Cartman, rather than realising Butters was an imposter. Butters fans, rejoice for the small victory.
9. VR Mayhem
Video games offer a sense of escapism and wish fulfilment that can be difficult to find anywhere else. With the rapid technological advancements in the realm of virtual reality, the possibilities continue to grow.
Cartman offers Butters this feeling of escapism in spades, by strapping him in to a state of the art VR headset that mimics the real world. At least, that's what Butters thinks is happening. The truth is that it is just the real world, and Butters is wearing soundproof headphones and a clear piece of tupperware.
Butters innocence is shown in his ability to trust Cartman completely and fully believe that he is experiencing a next gen gaming setup. He even comments on the graphics around him and remarks that the snow looks "kinda fake." His innocence is then immediately called in to question though when he decides to test out the limits of what he can do in VR.
First things first, he gets payback on his father for all the times he's been grounded with a swift punch to the groin. He then channels his inner Trevor Philips and steals a car. Things take a turn for the worse for poor Butters though when he pushes a bit too far and attempts to beat up and rob a prostitute in true Grand Theft Auto fashion, resulting in him getting stabbed.
8. Butters Falls In Love
South Park's bread and butter is parodying real world events, people, and everything in between. This is no different in the season 7 episode, Raisins.
After Wendy breaks up with Stan, his classmates decide to take him to a Raisins restaurant - South Park's take on Hooters - in an attempt to take his mind off his troubles.
Instead, Butters is the one who becomes smitten with one of the waitresses and is convinced her flirty nature is a show of romantic interest in him. He promises her that he'll return soon and gives her an even bigger tip before leaving, using up all his allowance in the process.
Lexus continues to lead Butters on and tells him to come back to Raisins so he can see her again, and of course Butters being the naive soul that he is, construes this as an indication of them being in a relationship.
He calls Lexus after school, keeps a picture of her in his room, and even tells his parents he has a girlfriend. When Butters takes his parents to Raisins to meet her, they immediately realise what is happening and try to warn Butters but he doesn't listen. It's only when Lexus tells him plainly that they aren't together that reality sinks in for him.
Through his heartbreak, Butters still manages to remain optimistic and even has a wonderful pearl of wisdom that shows he always looks for the good in the world. He says, "I'm sad, but at the same time, I'm really happy that something can make me feel that sad."
Butters, you are far too good for this world.
7. Leopold 'Mantequilla' Stotch
With all of the chaos that the kids of South Park cause, it can be easy to forget at times that they are all just a bunch of 10 year olds, who sometimes just do kid stuff.
For example, in the episode, The Last of the Meheecans, they are all engaging in a classic game of Texans Versus Mexicans. Standard fourth grader stuff, of course. The rules are simple enough, with one team trying to prevent the other from hopping over Cartman's backyard fence and crossing the border.
Butters, ever trying to fit in, takes his role as a Mexican very seriously and dons the persona of 'Mantequilla.' Long after everyone else has made it over the fence and stopped playing, Butters is still trying to get himself across the border.
He ends up getting lost, taken in by a couple who believe him to be a lost Mexican child and put to work by them. He commits so well to the role in fact, that he makes it to the actual border between the U.S and Mexico, and becomes a national symbol of revolution for the Mexican people.
The episode ends with Butters using everything he has learned on his immense journey to finally hop over Cartman's fence, and claim victory for team Mexico. All in a day's work for Mantequilla.
6. Super Fun Time
For as much as Cartman rips on Butters, the pair tend to find themselves together more often than Cartman would probably like to admit.
When visiting a pioneer village, Butters is tasked with being Cartman's partner for the duration of the school trip. He is given strict instructions not to let go of his partner's hand until they are back on the bus. His devotion to following the rules is tested when Cartman sneaks out of the village in order to visit a neighbouring amusement arcade, Super Phun Thyme.
The pair play air hockey, game on arcade cabinets, and partake in a roller disco, all without ever releasing their grip on each other. The two are completely oblivious to the fact that there is a hostage situation unfolding next door, and are convinced that the numerous police surrounding the pioneer village are in fact looking for them.
Butters is determined to make it back in to the village with Cartman, jumping from a moving truck to get back in to the village without arousing suspicion.
Even when one of the hostage takers holds the pair at gunpoint and tells them to put their hands behind their head, Butters is defiant in the face of danger, citing his teacher's instructions that he mustn't let go of his partner's hand. He even swings Cartman around like a giant club to knock the assailant down.
Only when he drags Cartman back on to the bus, does he finally let go of his, presumably very sweaty hand.
5. His First Kiss
As mentioned previously, sometimes it's good to see the kids of South Park engaging in normal activities for their age, rather than facing giant mechs in the form of Barbara Streisand, or having all adults banished from the town.
Take Butters psyching himself up for his first kiss, it's innocent and heartwarming to see him finally become a man in the eyes of his friends. Until it leads to him becoming a pimp and running a very successful prostitution ring, that is.
When he realises that he can bring other customers to the girl who kissed him and take a cut of the profits, everything begins to snowball until Butters is the CEO of his very own "Kissing Company". He becomes a pimp without even realising and even attends a pimp convention to gain some insight from other like-minded entrepreneurs in the industry.
Butters is so successful that the South Park Police Department gets wind of the operation and Detective Yates, goes deep undercover to bring down what he believes to be South Park's most prolific prostitution ring.
Someone ought to tell him that Butters Kissing Co Ltd. is strictly kisses and hugs only. Well, at least until actual prostitutes sign on then things become a bit more problematic. At least what Butters doesn't know won't hurt him.
4. The Ghost Whisperer
Eric Cartman's place in his group of friends is a strange one. They don't seem to like him, and he definitely doesn't like them.
Cartman pushes the other three too far one day when he eats all of the skin from a bucket of KFC chicken. This is the last straw for Stan, Kyle, and Kenny, who decide to ignore Cartman completely.
The rest of their class decide to do the same as pretty much everyone in school has had enough of Cartman's selfish, arrogant attitude. This leads Cartman to the only logical explanation for the situation that he finds himself in, being that he has in fact died and become a ghost, trapped on Earth with unfinished business. Naturally.
The only one who doesn't get the memo about ignoring Cartman? Butters, of course. When Butters greets Cartman, it prompts Cartman in to thinking Butters is a ghost whisperer tasked with helping him carry out his unfinished business so that he can go to Heaven. Butters, absolutely terrified of being haunted, reluctantly agrees to help the spirit of Cartman.
The pair go about making amends for all of Cartman's previous misdeeds in a hilarious montage filled with callbacks to previous episodes where Cartman has terrorised the citizens of South Park.
It culminates with the pair once again finding themselves in a tricky situation and managing to foil yet another hostage situation. Two hostage situations in the same year seems like it would inflict a lot of trauma on a 10 year old, but Butters being his usual happy-go-lucky self, never lets it get him down for long.
3. My Robot Friend
Say what you will about Butters, but one thing about him is that he knows how to write a catchy song. From the theme song to his very own episode, to his signature I've Got Some Apples, try to not find yourself humming along in the days after watching. it's impossible.
The same is definitely true for his little ditty about his new robot friend, A.K.A Cartman dressed up in a cardboard box. There's that famous secret bromance again.
Of course, as he did with the VR incident, Butters is totally convinced that Awesom-o is a sentient robot companion specifically for him, and all of the adults are astounded by Cartman's commitment to his role as a robot. His commitment is all part of his plan however, to retrieve a rather incriminating tape of himself dressed as Britney Spears dancing with a cutout of Justin Timberlake.
As is always the case when this dynamic duo get together, chaos ensues on a family vacation to Hollywood when Butters brings his robot pal along with him. Cartman gets kidnapped by the military who must be as naive as Butters, and plan to turn the robot in to a weapon.
Butters eventually gets the last laugh when Cartman is found out, and Butters exposes the tape to the rest of the class. Maybe he does have a bit of a mean streak after all. Who could blame him after all he's been through?
2. Paris Hilton's Plaything
It's surprising how positive Butters's outlook on life is considering he doesn't seem to come from the most loving environment. His own mother did try to kill him after all, and his father will ground him at even the most minor of infractions.
Their lack of love for their only son is more than apparent when Paris Hilton visits the town and takes a liking to Butters. She views him as a cute plaything, and wants to keep him as a pet. This is obviously absurd and no one can purchase a child to keep as a pet. Unless you have a spare $250 million lying around, of course.
Butters's parents jump at the chance and don't seem too upset at the thought of their son leaving them.
Butters himself however, is not too keen on being Paris Hilton's latest pet, after he sees how terribly treated her previous ones have been, resulting in their untimely deaths. He pleads with his parents to stay with them but the price of Butters's freedom is set at a quarter of a million dollars.
So what does Butters do? Immediately gets to work mining coal so he can buy his freedom.
1. Bad Times With Weapons
The adults of South Park can often times be just as irresponsible as the children, and this is evident when someone willingly sells them genuine ninja weapons at the Park County Fair.
Stan, Kyle, Cartman, and Kenny are living out their ninja fantasies in this ultra stylistic episode that switches between the standard construction paper based animation, to anime-style action pieces that depict the children's imaginations.
One such scene is when they are battling the evil, Professor Chaos, Butters's alter ego that was created when the gang shuns him. Butters, sweet as he is, doesn't have any weapons at all and his costume is just simple aluminium foil. Bless him.
He's way in over his head facing off against his pals though as its becomes clear fourth graders should never be trusted with dangerous weapons. Kenny lodges a throwing star right in Butters's eye, and it only gets worse for him from there. They glue fur to him so they can pass him off as a dog, he gets taken to the pound where he's locked up to be euthanised.
It's clear that his foil armour isn't quite up to the task of deflecting ninja stars, so maybe Butters is better off steering clear of any role-playing for a while.