South Park: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best
With season 24 on the horizon, it's time to review the best and the worst South Park.
No matter how solid a comedy is, it can't stay on top forever. The Simpsons was the hottest thing on television during the 1990s but that show peaked over twenty years ago. At first, this may seem like an unfair criticism. I mean, a comedy can't stay funny for that long, can it?
And yet South Park has been on-point with its hilarious satire for over two decades. The creators, Trey Parker and Matt Stone, are clearly not afraid to mix up the formula or stir the pot on the most controversial issues.
Every time it feels like the show is getting stale, it will pull out a blinder like Scott Tenorman Must Die, Trapped in the Closet, or Imaginationland. With recent episodes maintaining the same standard, it looks like the comedy juggernaut isn't slowing down any time soon.
Now, just because South Park is solid doesn't mean it's perfect. Some narratives fall flat and there are a few seasons where the creators clearly miss the mark. With season twenty-four looming forward, now feels like the best time to break down the iconic show's best and worst seasons.
23. Season 21 (2017)
There are no awful episodes of South Park. Having said that, Season 21 is the worst of a great bunch. The show has made a reputation for holding no punches. But in 2017, it feels like the creators were afraid to fully commit to riffing on Alexa, Mark Zuckerberg, and Netflix. The storylines ridiculing Hollywood's obsession with expanded universes or cancelling Columbus Day are explored well, but it feels like the writers were wearing kids gloves.
It's not a terrible season; it's just too safe, which is a word that should never be used to describe one of the most controversial animated satires of all time.
22. Season 3 (1999)
Trey Parker and Matt Stone were so certain their show was on the verge of cancellation, they thought it sensible to rap everything up with the movie, South Park: Bigger, Badder, and Uncut. It's clear the creators' focus was on the film because season 3, which came out the same year, is all over the place.
It was the first season that had episodes that centred on the separate adventures of the four boys. This is a great idea in theory but these storylines don't hold water.
But it's not all bad. Season 3 introduced iconic characters such as Butters, Tweek, and God. The Chinpokomon episode, which parodied Nintendo's most lucrative franchise perfectly deconstructed the absurdity of fads. The story resonates with modern viewers more now than ever due to the video game franchise's resurgence in popularity.
21. Season 16 (2012)
There wasn't a lot of material to work with in 2012 which is why Season 16 makes fun of Bane, memes, and eh... zip-lining. I Never Should Have Gone Ziplining stands out though, because of the segments where the four boys appear in live-action.
However, the entry doesn't do anything creative with these parts and so, comes across as pointlessly gimmicky. Season 16 also has an storyline mocking Avatar director, James Cameron, which feels a few years too late.
A Nightmare on FaceTime seems like a cliched jab at Blockbuster, but it's actually the year's best episode. It emphasises the cluelessness of Randy when he purchases a Blockbuster store after the company goes bust, causing him to fall into a Jack Torrance-styled psychosis.
20. Season 22 (2018)
To leave an unforgettable first impression, each season of South Park usually starts by tackling a heavily controversial issue. With season 22 kicking off with a plot about school shootings, it looked like the creators were pulling no punches.
But after that, it felt like the South Park team got cold feet since a lot of the season falls flat due to tame storylines and relying on recycling jokes.
The ManBearPig saga stands out since it serves as an apology to Al Gore after Matt Stone and Trey Parker admitted they unfairly belittled the politician in previous storylines. However, it felt like this two-parter was made out of obligation rather than because the writers had a compelling story to tell.
19. Season 20 (2016)
South Park has recently shied away from self-contained episodes and focused on season-long narratives. When the creators decided to do a ten-episode story arc about the 2016 presidential election while it was unfolding, it sounded like a stroke of genius.
But because Trey Parker and Matt Stone were so certain Hillary Clinton would win, they were blindsided when Donald Trump was sworn in. This caused sub-plots to be abandoned and scripts to be rewritten in hours. This sadly led to a very clumsy and uneven season.
The cheap digs at obvious targets like the Ghostbusters remake and Elon Musk feel so insipid, this season felt safer than when the show premiered.
18. Season 18 (2014)
Season 18 was pretty ambitious since it was the first time South Park tossed aside the self-contained plots and instead, focused on serialisation. Since this was the cartoon's first attempt at this sort of story-telling, it was a little clumsy, but it worked over all.
Although aeason 18 is mainly known for Randy Marsh coming out as the New Zealand singer, Lorde, it's not as funny as you may remember. Randy shouting "Lorde! Lorde! I am Lorde!" in a tight dress and wig is funny... until you realise it goes on for eight episodes!
Sadly, the season fails to neatly tie all the plot threads. If the creators have difficulty connecting all the narratives in a nice little bow, maybe they should consider bringing back single-episode plots in the future.
17. Season 13 (2009)
Because of Kanye West's larger-than-life personality, lampooning the rapper on South Park was inevitable. In the Fishsticks episode, West's misinterpretation of a joke convinces him he is a homosexual fish. This sounds like the dumbest possible way to ridicule the Grammy-winning singer and yet, it works perfectly.
Season 13 wasn't afraid of letting loose on touchy topics like the recession and the the incompetence of the Obama administration. This sort of hard-hitting critique has been sorely missed and it was nice to see the guys behind South Park still having some backbone.
Of course, it's not all perfect. Eat, Pray, Queef tries to highlight the double-standards that women must go through on a daily basis, but the premise is mishandled. The episode where an alien gangster causes humanity to blow up Finland is insane. As entertaining as these stories are, there is no commentary, just generic wackiness.
16. Season 23 (2019)
The first episode of season 23 is the weakest of the lot, having Kyle forced into a detention camp after being reported by Cartman. The two 4th graders have been at odds since the beginning so starting season 23 with ANOTHER conflict between Cartman and Kyle feels like the show is retreading the same formula.
Although Randy Marsh crazy escapades works best in small doses, the season focuses on his latest get-rich-quick scheme; setting up a weed farm called Tegridy Farms.
Now, putting a scene-stealer like Randy Marsh in the forefront isn't always a good idea, and it hasn't worked in previous seasons. However, having Randy's story take place in a separate location is a nice change, and it allows the supporting cast a chance to shine.
15. Season 15 (2011)
With 14 seasons under their belt, Matt Stone and Trey Parker worried they were out of touch and strongly considered throwing in the Towelie. When they eventually agreed to move on with season 15, the pair implemented their self-doubt into an episode called You're Getting Old. In this story, Stan turns ten and suddenly hates everything he originally loved. Matrix mentor, Morpheus, informs Stan that he can now see the world for what it really is now he has been "awakened".
At first, you'd assume riffing on The Matrix in 2011 would be the most dated gag possible. But because the creators put their soul in this episode, it is one of the most touching storylines in the series.
The reason why this season isn't higher on this list is because the episodes, Funnybot and Royal Pudding, are among the series' worst.
14. Season 17 (2013)
Although South Park has a habit of dragging out certain jokes, spoofing Game of Thrones for three episodes straight felt mandatory, because there's just too many GoT jokes to condense into 22 minutes.
But it isn't just an hour of poking fun at one show. This trilogy uses GoT as a backdrop for a console war which concludes in a Red Wedding-styled get-together with Bill Gates beating the hell out of Sony's CEO. Never had South Park been so ambitious at juggling so many plotlines and yet, managed it so perfectly.
Sadly, no other episodes stand out (save for World War Zimmerman), and the Goth Kids 3 episode is so shoddy, even the creators condemned it.