Star Trek: 10 Great Stories You Never Got To See

Some things are just too genius to exist.

Ds9 For nearly half a century, the Star Trek franchise has left an indelible mark on the popular culture and public consciousness of the western world. It has championed our noblest aspirations by its optimistic portrayal of a future in which the human race has largely overcome some of its more crippling character flaws. At other times, it has forced us to look at ourselves in the mirror by ruminating on how we might one day be viewed by more enlightened generations of our descendants. Star Trek has also inspired a number of technological advances we now take for granted, most notably flip phones and tablet computing, and multiple generations of scientists, engineers, astronauts, and visionaries have identified Star Trek as the spark that motivated them to pursue those careers. It is no exaggeration to say that had Star Trek not existed in the second half of the 20th century, the second decade of the 21st century might look vastly different. For reasons both artistic and bureaucratic, Star Trek history is replete with scripts, stories, characters and concepts that have, for one reason or another, fallen by the wayside over the years, some failing to achieve liftoff and some being abandoned during production. To celebrate those stories that we almost got to see, we've compiled a list of the more noteworthy, interesting, and/or absurd ones.

10. Kirk Bangs McCoy's Daughter

As any red-blooded fan of the original Star Trek can tell you, the Enterprise's weekly excursions were never complete without Captain Kirk, shall we say, satisfying his Tiberius. It didn't matter much if it was with a comely young crew member (Shaternization, if you will) or a voluptuous green-skinned alien - Kirk was always going to get some action, of some sort, even if the very safety of his crew and the known universe was still in the balance. And according to the original draft of the script that ultimately became the second-season episode "The Way to Eden," it didn't even matter if it was his best friend's college-aged daughter. In writer Dorothy Fontana's first draft of the teleplay, Dr. McCoy's daughter Joanna is introduced, has a bit of perfunctory conflict with her dad, and promptly jumps in bed with the twice-her-age captain as an emotional coping mechanism. You know, just the way such things always happen in real life. Kirk then lectures McCoy about how it was all his own damn fault for being such a crappy dad, seemingly without accepting any part of his own involvement in the shenanigans. The show's producers, perhaps realizing this scenario was a bit offensive even in the late 1960s, handed Fontana's script to Arthur Heinemann for a series of rewrites, wherein the Joanna character was eliminated entirely and Kirk was given a disposable sex kitten-of-the-week to rub up against instead. Score one for social progress.

9. The TNG Olympics

An episode that had the potential to be as polarizing (or as ridiculous) as DS9's baseball episode later became, "IQ Test" would have seen Captain Picard and the Enterprise-D crew pitted against representatives of an alien race in an Olympic-style series of athletic contests held at the behest of Q and one of his fellow Continuum dwellers. Originally a spec script submitted by a freelance writer, the teleplay was polished by staff writer Herbert J. Wright and was apparently in serious danger of actually being produced before being (wisely) deep-sixed by producer Michael Piller. While very few specific details from the script have ever been publicly divulged by the writers and producers involved, one can only imagine the dizzying array of possibilities that existed: Data and Dr. Crusher in an inter-gender synchronized swimming death match with the fate of the universe hanging in the balance? Captain Picard showing off his fencing chops? Worf being made to appear in awful sports-themed episodes of two different Star Trek series? The mind boggles at the potential competitive scenarios, and one is left to wonder, given Star Trek's track record for topical social commentary, whether the story would've featured a doping scandal and/or a host venue without flushing toilets and hot water.

8. Uncle Milty Meets Captain Kirk

Speaking of Olympic events (or at least things that should be Olympic events), who wouldn't want to see William Shatner versus Milton Berle in a scenery-chewing contest? Well, it almost happened. Writer Norman Spinrad, author of the second-season TOS episode "The Doomsday Machine," was invited by the producers to write an episode featuring Berle, who was a big Star Trek and wanted to appear on the show. But here's the kicker: Berle, at the time America's most beloved comedian, didn't want a comedic role. According to Spinrad, Berle wanted to establish himself as a serious actor, and had chosen Star Trek as the means by which to do so. As the story went, Berle would portray a sociologist named Bayne, who studies a planet's primitive society, gets a bit too full of himself, and starts masquerading as a god. It falls to Kirk and the Enterprise crew to intervene and uphold the Prime Directive (presumably, Kirk would also find time for carnal relations with a fetching native girl, which totally isn't against the Prime Directive). The episode nearly made it to the production schedule before the producers decided against casting Berle in a straight dramatic role. Attempts were made to rewrite it into a comedy piece, but the episode was ultimately abandoned.

7. Now Drumming For Def Leppard... Lieutenant Tom Paris

When he wasn't busy turning into a giant slug, Voyager's navigator and resident rebel-without-a-cause was always getting himself into trouble. Maybe Captain Janeway will think twice the next time she decides find hired help at a penal colony. Veteran Voyager writer Dr. Harry Kloor envisioned an episode in which Paris, on the run from alien baddies in his Delta Flyer, crash lands on a planet and gets his arm ripped off, or mostly ripped off, or just partially ripped off. Sources are unclear as to the extent of the intended amputation, but it's safe to surmise that Paris wasn't going to be starting many slow-claps for quite a while. The story then had an alien physician/benefactor coming to Paris' aid and restoring the use of his arm with the help of Borg nanoprobe technology. The idea was ultimately dropped when the producers decided 1) an injury of that extent would be difficult to portray convincingly, and 2) if it could be portrayed convincingly, it would be too gory for the audience. Thus, the question of how a man learns to wipe his backside with a Borg hand remains, for the time being, unanswered.

6. DS9 The Musical

It's true: Deep Space Nine (or, more accurately, one member of its writing staff) wanted to go all Cop Rock on us, and amazingly, the architect of the idea was none other than Ronald D. Moore (who, quite regrettably, chose not to carry the idea of a singing cabaret episode over to Battlestar Galactica). Even more remarkably, it seems Moore was very much emotionally invested in the idea and repeatedly tried to get the episode made. "There's just some tech virus that infects the crew and they can only communicate in song, you know? And just do it! And have a ball," went Moore's pitch, which was received just as unenthusiastically each time he tried to revisit it. "They fought against it and fought against it and fought against it," lamented Moore, seemingly unable to grasp why anyone would think this was a horrible idea. Unsurprisingly, Moore never managed to make any headway with his DS9-does-Chicago brainchild, and the world was spared two decades of internet arguments about whether Odo and Quark wearing straw boaters and singing "Hello My Ragtime Gal" constituted great science fiction or a desperate collective cry for psychiatric help on the part of the show's creative staff.

5. Voyager Mocks Its Own Audience

Let's face it, Star Trek fans have never been renowned for the ability to poke fun at themselves, or to have fun poked at them. Why? Because walking around in public wearing pointy rubber ears and speaking in nonexistent languages is serious business, dammit. It is thus unsurprising that Jack Trevino and Toni Marberry's Voyager story pitch, in which the show would subtly satirize the phenomenon of Trek fandom, never really got off the ground. The concept went like this: in the several years since Voyager's stranding in the Delta Quadrant, the residents of an alien planet have been monitoring the ship's log entries and onboard communications. So impressed are the aliens by what they overhear that, naturally, they model their entire society on Voyager's example and take to dressing in Starfleet uniforms and emulating individual members of the crew. Voyager then arrives at the planet and is greeted by, for all intents and purposes, an exoplanetary Star Trek fanboy convention. It's not difficult to see why the story never had a chance of being produced, tantalizing though it may be to imagine Captain Janeway standing atop a podium screaming "Would you people GET A LIFE?"

4. Dr. Phloxenstein

Another Jack Trevino story pitch, intended as a prequel of sorts to the TOS second-season episode "The Changeling," this one likely would have gone into production had Enterprise been picked up for a fifth season. Entitled "Tan Ru," it would have chronicled the original Enterprise's encounter with the eponymous alien probe a century before it was encountered (having by that time merged with the 21st century Earth space probe Nomad) by Kirk's Enterprise. But here's where it gets weird. The Tan Ru probe, for reasons that remain unclear, would have compelled Doctor Phlox to construct a hybrid life form from bits and pieces of assorted dead aliens, in an obvious homage to the Frankenstein films. It would no doubt have been interesting to see how the story was executed, given the Star Trek franchise's previous track record of paying tribute to bygone filmic eras (most famously with Tom Paris and Harry Kim's Captain Proton holodeck program on Voyager). It certainly would have been great fun to see Phlox interacting with a hunchbacked assistant and shrieking "It's alive! IT'S ALIVE!" Unfortunately, Enterprise didn't remain alive long enough to see it to fruition.

3. Archer Meets Shatner

The fourth and last season of Enterprise was chock full of homages to the original Star Trek, including a visit to the Mirror Universe (previously seen in both TOS and DS9) in the two-part episode "In a Mirror, Darkly." But that story was not the first choice of the Enterprise creative staff. In fact, the whole Mirror Universe idea was conceived with William Shatner in mind. Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens penned the script, wherein Archer's Enterprise happens upon a sort of temporal/inter-dimensional penal colony, one of whose residents is Captain Tiberius, Kirk's alter ego from the TOS episode "Mirror, Mirror." Tiberius wants to use Enterprise's transporter to get back to his own time and place and resume smacking around incompetent underlings and bedding assorted female crew members (Kirk and Mirror-Kirk are not without similarities, after all). Tiberius convinces a reluctant Archer to help him return home, with the episode's payoff being that the two men wind up being responsible for creating the Mirror Universe in the first place. Despite the intrinsic awesomeness of a story in which William Shatner is revealed to be William Shatner's creator (because who else could possibly be up to the job?), Shatner and Paramount were unable to come to terms and the deal fell through.

2. Star Trek: Men In Tights

When work began on the project that became Star Trek: First Contact, writers Ron Moore and Brannon Braga were certain only of two story elements: time travel and the Borg. Picard and the Enterprise-D would pursue their biomechanical adversaries into Earth's past and there do battle with them, but Moore and Braga wrestled with selecting a time period in which to set the story. Ancient Rome was discussed (until it was realized this would entail putting our heroes in togas) as was the American Civil War (undoubtedly because actor/director Jonathan Frakes already had a convincing enough beard for a Confederate general). The historical locale upon which they finally settled, at least temporarily, was the Italian Renaissance (indeed, Star Trek: Renaissance was even the film's working title for a time). According to Moore, the story featured the Enterprise crew visiting an Italian village, tracking the Borg to a medieval castle, and fighting them with swords and phasers. Naturally, the question of why one would bring a sword to a phaser fight remains an open one. Mercifully, Moore and Braga eventually opted to change the time travel destination from the distant past to the near future, and First Contact became the most well-received of the TNG-era feature films.

1. James T. Kirk €“ Shot in the Back by Tolian Sorin Over a Matter of 80 Dollars

While this one doesn't really qualify as something you never got to see (since the footage is widely available online, it was released on DVD, and if you've read the entirety of this article, there's a strong likelihood you've seen it already), but it makes the top of this list by virtue of being the most ill-conceived, poorly-executed, utterly wrongheaded thing that ever almost made it into the final cut of a Star Trek production. The original script of Star Trek Generations had Captain Kirk meeting his demise by being shot in the back and....well, dying. As one might expect, director David Carson and actor William Shatner both had strong misgivings about the iconic Kirk character suffering such an ignominious fate, but Paramount executives insisted the scene be shot as scripted, and so it was. It was not until test-screening audiences howled in outraged disapproval that the studio execs were persuaded to authorize a rewrite of the scene, which then had to be reshot at an expense of $5 million in a two-week pickup shoot that wrought havoc on an already cramped post-production schedule. The end result? Kirk avoids an ignoble coward's death by... getting a bridge dropped on him. Oh my. Which other unmade Star Trek stories do you wish had been made? Share your own picks in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

Recovering print journalist, writing professionally since 1991, polluting the internet and wasting the world's bandwidth since 1995. Board-certified Doctor of Memetics and Trollology, offering free consultations to qualified patients.