Star Trek: 10 Reasons Enterprise Totally Sucked
Full Disclosure: for reasons I cannot explain, I genuinely like Star Trek Enterprise. Maybe it's nostalgia for the early '00s form of edgy slickness; maybe it was the possibility of a truly 'cool' Trek, but most of all I think it was the fact that Enterprise was a genuinely frustrating show. The plotting was always a little left of ideal, the characterization too muddy, and the design a little too conservative. It was simultaneously generic and truly weird, and ended Star Trek on the small screen in the worst way possible. It was never as "Ed Wood bad" as Voyager occasionally was, and a lot of the characters were genuinely likeable, but in many ways, that made it worse; it hurts to be let down by something you like. It was redeemable in a way that Voyager never was - it could break our hearts week after week. Maybe it was good that we haven't had Star Trek on television for almost 7 years. It had its highs, it had its lows, but here are the 10 reasons why Enterprise did, ultimately, totally suck... 10. The Weirdly Rampant Sexism
Star Trek doesn't have the best track record when it comes to dealing with women's issues. Race relations? sure, but women have been woefully under-utilized and at worst relegated to window dressing (even the series with the strongest women characters, Deep Space Nine, regularly failed the Bechdel Test) so when our brave Captain Archer threatens to knock a female character "on her ass" in the first ten minutes of the pilot episode, I was more than taken aback. The rest of the episode doesn't fare much better. T'Pol, our token Vulcan and, in this series, the first to serve on a Human ship, is consistently noted by her gender as well as her species, which seems a little unfair. and don't get me started on how much leering the male characters on the show do about the female characters; I mean, I live here and I consider it worth noting. The worst part is that the female characters are regularly underwritten or weakened by the sort of quivering-chin romance and flippant sexualizing we should all be past by now, and while the cast got better about all this by the end of the series, it never got to a point where it was bearable. However, some characters suffered more than others.
9. Hoshi Sato
If your answer to the question, "How can we demonstrate a character coming into their own on an action/adventure series?" is, "Send them into panic attacks and fits of hysterics any time they face the tiniest bit of adversity," then congratulations, you are now in charge of every Hoshi Sato arc on Enterprise. If there is a particularly complex task for the crew to do, you could count on Hoshi to object to it; if there's an away team being assembled, she would be the last to volunteer. Especially in the first season, the writers would go out of their way to represent her as more than a little incompetent. Considering that she must have received the same training as everyone else, you would think she would be able to at least handle the odd challenge or two, if a bit grudgingly. but no, she demurs from even the most essential tasks In terms of characterization, there hasn't been a more obnoxious character other than Wesley; but, to Linda Park's credit, her delivery was never as shrill as Will Wheton's. In fact, despite her character's problems, the actress made Hoshi endearing in a sort of younger sister capacity. Unfortunately, this is more of a problem than a benefit, and one endemic to the series itself.
8. The Infantile Storytelling
It would be far from true to say Star Trek never moralized. Very far. But, for the most part, the way such stories are handled works them into the overall plot. The story arc speaks for itself, in short. Unfortunately, that's not how it works on Enterprise. Most episodes have a message, and that message is hammered at with the hammiest fists Berman and Braga could find. It wouldn't be so terribly problematic if the issues they were tackling weren't so complex. But Enterprise isn't all that complex a show, so there still has to be good guys and bad guys. More often than not, the bad guys are the less fortunate of the two. The only time moral ambiguity gets involved is for plot twisting purposes. The only trace of ambition with their approach is Archer's Sorkin-esque speech at the end, which attempts to touch on both sides of the issue and offer some resolution to those lacking social justice. But what's most insufferable is the lazy, shocked questioning that the crew of the Enterprise employs when confronted with these issues. It's a cheap way to broach the problem, and one that is used so often that one has to wonder about the character's naivete. There are some things that should have been abandoned with The Original Series.
7. Poorly-Handled Serialization
For its third season, Enterprise did something unusually bold: they gave the whole season over to a single storyline. The show had not demonstrated that they could support serialization even close to this before, you see, for it's first three seasons, Enterprise was largely governed by a "Temporal Cold War." Apart from being confusing and poorly applied, this plot line dragged the show down merely because the show refused to abandoned it. Lots of televisions shows made this mistake when first experimenting with serialization. Heroes died on this principle, while Fringe decided to move on from it's early stories. Enterprise was first among them though, and there for, it was their series to lose. And boy did they lose it. After three seasons of hacking away at a plot that was arguably only there to help excuse any problems with the rest of the Star Trek canon, they had to end it with alien Nazis. However, season three, in the long run, held together. At least the stories that were connected. What sabotaged it was its stand-alone episodes.
6. Bad Planet-Of-The-Week Episodes
One of the advantages of television is it's ability to tell stand-alone stories with existing characters, continuously. In fact, it's the defining characteristic of the medium. So when a show fails in this department, it's just about over. Enterprise started out not strong, per se, but manageable. Then the Xindi storyline came along and from then to the end of the series, it seems like anything that wasn't related to the main story or part of a two or three-parter was throwaway material. I'm not even sure why at this point. I can't tell you what went wrong, whether it was the writers, producers, or performers, or just dumb luck. I will go back and watch the third and fourth seasons and find swaths of them unwatchable. Maybe I'm a judgmental bastard. who am I kidding, I am a judgmental bastard. But I am endeared by Enterprise, and I want it to be good. But it makes it so hard sometimes. Next section.
5. Forced "Youth Market"Alignment
The early 2000s were a time of a huge youth market explosion. There was Napster, there was the proliferation of iPods and cellphones, and there was the beginning of programming targeted at the 18-23 crowd. One of these successful youth-oriented shows was Buffy the Vampire Slayer. The characters were always pairing off and developing interpersonal dramas that would carry the show in its later years. The result was that a lot of niche shows wanted to model themselves after Buffy and shows like it. Including Enterprise. Full Disclosure Pt. II: I am a huge Buffy fan. Any charge you can level against the average Buffy fan can be leveled against me: 'shipping, character self-identification, even overlooking some of Joss Whedon's greater sins and faults. that being said, Enterprise neither had the robustness nor the talented writing staff that could sustain the sort of twisting interpersonal relationships that Buffy had. In fact, a lot of the simplification of the writing and the inclusion of so... many... goddamn... love... triangles... were probably the choice of the studio to give Enterprise an edge with which to compete on the 18-23 level. Enterprise was a show that wanted to be sophisticated, but was hampered by its studio wanting to get a healthy cut of that precious youth market. Sadly, plotting was only the first stop for them.
4. That Goddamn Theme Song
The bane of my existence. Here's the deal (Full Disclosure pt. III): being a mere 10 years old when this series premiered, britpop and post grunge were hugely influential on me, and I used to be a huge fan of this theme song. Hell, to this day, the Verve's Urban Hymns is one of my favorite albums and I can still listen to the Calling unironically. But I grew in taste. I understood where musical tastes and moods came from. I am a Music Director of one of the larger college radio stations. I can tell when something is merely a facsimile of another. This is one such occasion. I can't remember a single series with lyrics that had an enjoyable theme song. The single best sci-fi series to air this last decade, Firefly, had awful lyrics. I can't see the 2000's genre prototype being any different, but there's something extrordinarily gimmicky about it too. Like I said earlier, Enterprise wanted that precious youth market, so they came in with an overproduced, cynical cash-in song. If there's an upside to this, the song represented a pale attempt by Berman and Braga to drag Star Trek into the 21st century. However, Paramount wanted to drag the series back to the 1960s while trying to impress with flashy new effects. The results are, as expected, insipid.
3. Futzing With The Design
That folks, is a phase pistol, and it represents everything wrong with the production design of this show. Star Trek has always had a number of devices that are more plot fixes than technology, and that's probably the way it should be. Tricorders can just about do anything, until they can't for convenient reasons. Same with phasers. A phaser was essentially a way to end a conflict with force, or occasionally blow something up or cut through a door. What they are doesn't really matter. What they represent is an escalation of conflict without any real risk of death or injury, unless it's needed. Enterprise originally had a different type of weapon, essentially a plasma gun. This weapon had no stun settings, no high tech multi-use interface. This was a gun, and it was completely suited to the dangerous, wild-west galaxy that they were exploring. This was a series that wanted to embrace the consequences of the moment, and there you go. But instead the studio pressed upon them the phase pistol. The phase pistol is a plot fixer that limits itself by tying itself to a more familiar technology. Ostensibly the studio wanted something that Star Trek fans could connect with, something that wasn't completely alien to this universe. what they got was a prop that completely negated what they were trying to do and say about the violence in this show's universe. It didn't help matters that the producers and prop people liked the original gun better.
2. Straying From Roddenberry's Vision
Gene Roddenberry had very specific ideas for how the universe would be two-hundred years in the future, and therefore had very specific rules for how his show would be run. They are legion, covering everything from production design to public health. But the ones affecting the rendering of stories and characters are the most precient. They are as follows: There will be no interpersonal conflict between the main cast. They are Starfleet officers and are the best of the best. Starfleet can do no wrong. Humanity surmounted it's moral quandaries in the interest of bettering itself Racism, sexism, poverty, strife, disease, war, and greed have all been eliminated. They will not appear on the show. Now, just to be clear, I don't believe that Roddenberry's rules make good storytelling, or even good television. There are in turns both hopelessly optimistic and aggressively naive, in the same way George Lucas believed that bra's don't exist in space. But they present an interesting challenge to those writing the show, as it forces them to come up with new conflicts and solutions. How can you broach the social ills of this century 200 years in the future? How can mankind fail, and how can they persevere at such and advanced level? I even think it's refreshing to see a cast come together instead of bickering about an issue for half an episode. Yet again, not so with Enterprise. As the first show completely free of Roddenberry's tradition, the narrative freedom afforded was often abused. More often than not, conflict was generated almost completely from within the cast. What's more, the characters seem almost obstinately fallible. For at least the first two seasons, every episode's central action was motivated by Captain Archer pointedly doing something that the only reasonable person on the ship, T'Pol, told him not to do. It's tiring to say the least, and maybe makes a case against so much narrative freedom. but only maybe. Because Enterprise's greatest fault is probably it's biggest boon.
1. It Dared To Be Great
Great television is a very subjective point of view. There are so many different ideas and perceptions that it is inevitably a losing battle to argue for an objective perspective. But I would like to believe, somewhere out in the ether, there exists at least a general definition of what great television is, and Enterprise often meets that definition. No other Star Trek series dare touch racism on Earth's soil, no other series dealt with interpersonal relationships in such a mature way. Enterprise broke ground in terms of serialization and prequels on network television, things that were difficult to parse even for Hollywood. Even the camerawork was fresh and exciting (in my opinion, having a greater influence on handicam use in television than 24). But what led Enterprise to greatness most often was its heart and ambition. Enterprise seemed practically doomed from the start, with the winding down of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, the failure of Firefly and the loss of other action adventure shows, American audiences seemed less interested in science fiction television. But Enterprise continued on and kept trying to tell the stories it wanted to tell, despite mismanagement, studio pressure and meddling, and budget constraints. And what stories. This show wanted to break down humanity and look at how we could be as great as these characters, and how these characters could become part of the greater Star Trek legacy. The fact that it failed as many times as it succeeded hurts, but it's the fact that they tried that counts. Enterprise did suck, but only in that it never quite reached the heights it was aiming for, and could have reached had it had time, because if there is anything worse than ambition, it is ambition tempered by failure. As it stands, we have this incredibly flawed, yet incredibly moving set of 98 episodes. And I'm happy with that, even though I'm still sore about a whole host of problems with the series itself. I can live with it. Except the Vulcans. What the hell was their problem? Agree? Disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.