Star Trek: 10 Worst Things Captain Janeway Has Ever Done

Star Trek's first captain in the Delta Quadrant made a few questionable calls.

Puppy Janeway Q Star Trek Voyager
CBS Television Distribution

Captain Kathryn Janeway has been quite rightly decorated many, many times as a highly capable commanding officer. She led the crew of USS Voyager through the heart of the Delta Quadrant, getting most of them back home. Starfleet may even count the ones who didn't make as acceptable losses in the long-run.

BUT.

Does that mean that Janeway was the greatest captain in Starfleet history? Considering she, or at least a facsimile of her, will be leading the ragtag crew of the USS Protostar on a new mission in the upcoming Star Trek: Prodigy, it bears exploring as to whether or not this person is the right person for the job.

What exactly is the reason for the many deaths of the members of the crew? What did she do for morale, when some of the crew were attacking other members? Who else in the history of Starfleet used the transporter as their own personal execution toy? While Captain, and later Admiral, Janeway made some amazing moves and saves in her career, she made some fairly dodgy calls in her time as well. It's time to shine a light on this highly questionable officer.

10. Instigating A Civil War (Death Wish)

Captain Janeway Death Wish
CBS Media Ventures / Paramount Pictures

Quite frankly, this one is going to seem a bit unfair. Captain Janeway is compelled, when Quinn asks her for asylum aboard Voyager, to hear him out - even if it means standing in the path of the Q Continuum. Thankfully, they are at least willing to engage in the trial, for if nothing else, it's something to do.

Janeway rules in favour of Quinn, who then immediately takes his own life. While everyone had been prepared for this, few were prepared for the idea of a Q civil war, which breaks out quickly after Quinn's death. A civil war is bad at the best of times, but this particular one sees multiple stars going supernova in the Delta quadrant.

Whoops.

A race of omnipotent beings going to war is something that no mortal wants to get dropped in the middle of and, though her responsibilty as a Starfleet captain effectively forced her into the position, Janeway's decision to rule in favour of Quinn led to the destruction of several star systems, the deaths of untold members of the Continuum...though it also led to the creation of Q-Junior, which is a silver lining, depending on who you ask!


9. Stranding Voyager In The Delta Quadrant (Caretaker)

Star Trek Voyager Caretaker
CBS

Here is the big one, second only to the execution of a being, in the list of Janeway's most questionable acts. On arriving, unwillingly, in the Delta Quadrant, Voyager finds that the Ocampa are threatened by the Kazon. The actions of the Caretaker, a being of immense power, have drained much of the Ocampa's individuality and resilience from them, leading to their inability to fight the Kazon.

More than that, with the Caretaker now dead, his array contained enough technology to make the Kazon a major threat to the Delta Quadrant. However, it also contained the technology to send Voyager back to the Alpha Quadrant. Janeway makes her choice and fires two tri-cobalt devices at the array, destroying it before the Kazon can get their hands on it.

There are deeply mixed feelings about Janeway's call. While nearly everyone can understand why it was necessary, it does strang the crew 75 years (or so they thought) from home. It's enough for former Maquis like Seska and Jonas to seek their own alliances, away from the ship. It leads to quite a number of crew deaths, and this is a call that would sit on Janeway's shoulders for years to come.


8. Shutting Herself Away (Night)

Captain Janeway Night
CBS Media Ventures

The season five premiere episode Night sees Voyager plunged into an area of space that is quite literally made of nothing. There are no stars, no gaseous anomalies, no planets. It is simple a void between the great distances of the Delta Quadrant, and it gives the crew plenty of time to think.

This is bad. This is very, very bad. Once Captain Janeway is given what is effectively a forced shore leave, she retreats into herself entirely. Cut off from the rest of Starfleet, she begins to allow old doubts and fears to surface, going so far as to begin shutting herself away from the crew entirely. Even Chakotay, who is not only her first officer but her closest friend next to Tuvok on the ship, can't convince her to lift her chin.

It takes this friendship to shake her from her doldrums, as she plans what is essentially a suicide mission to stop a Malon scow from polluting the area any further. Tuvok, having seen this behaviour before, warns Chakotay. Though the scene in question is a warm one of friendship, it is unfortunately an example of the captain letting her insecurities take over which, though altruistic, led to her decision to leave Voyager altogether.


7. Picking Torres Over Lt. Carey (Parallax)

Star Trek Carey
CBS

In the second episode of Star Trek: Voyager, Janeway discusses the allocation of officer roles and the potential candidates for them. Lt. Joe Carey is the obvious choice for Chief Engineer, as he is next in line in terms of both rank and experience, following the death of the previous chief.

Chakotay wants Torres for the role, which is complicated slightly by the fact that she had recently broken Carey's nose. From Carey's point of view, what follows is both a complete disregard for his injury, but also his position on the ship.

In a similar move to making deals on the golf course, Janeway and Torres get to know each other during a shuttle mission. This results in the captain picking Torres, over Carey, as Chief Engineer. Carey is then relegated to serving under the person who broke his nose and passed him over for a promotion. To add insult to injury, he effectively vanishes for several seasons, only reappearing to serve as Red Shirt during the fateful mission to retrieve Friendship One.


6. Making A Deal With The Devil (Scorpion)

Captain Janeway Scorpion
CBS

This was the decision that could easily have cost Janeway, not only the loyalty of her crew, but their lives as well. When Voyager finally encounters Borg space, they find themselves thrust into the conflict between the Collective and Species 8472 who, at the time, are presented as a malign presence.

Janeway decides to work with the Borg to defeat them, trusting that they will allow them safe passage through their territory once completed. Despite the strong objections from Chakotay and the rest of the crew, she proceeds with the plan. It is, in reality, a bad call.

Not only does it result in the Borg regaining their strength in the Delta Quadrant, but the Collective immediately reneges on its word once the threat is dealt with. It takes a near-mutiny from Chakotay to help Janeway accept even his contingency plan, so convinced as she is that by teaming up against one enemy, she may be able to change the nature of the Borg.

Though the decision, like others on this list, was made with the best of intentions, there is little doubt it is one of the most dangerous calls that the captain ever made.


5. Checking On Her Lower Decks So Infrequently She Needs Directions (Good Shepherd)

Voyager Good Shepherd
CBS

If the recent Star Trek: Lower Decks has taught us anything, it's that the junior members of the crew could do with a little more noticing by the senior staff. Mariner and Boimler have both flown under the radar so long they can get up to all kinds of chaos on the USS Cerritos, which is so outlandish that it seems like this might be the exception.

However, by the close of the sixth season of Star Trek: Voyager, Janeway displays that she has visited the lower decks of the ship so infrequently, and dealt with those members of the crew so little, that she is both unaware of their activities and even needs directions (from Tom Morello no less) to actually find them.

Compare this to a certain Captain Picard, who was able to identify the section of Jefferies Tube that he was in with Neela Darren simply from glancing at the walls. That, too, came in his sixth year onboard the far larger Galaxy-class USS Enterprise-D. Unfortunately, this is a fairly poor show from Kathryn Janeway.


4. Hunting The Equinox (Equinox)

Star Trek Voyager Equinox
CBS

This was summarised perfectly as the only time that Voyager's dedication plaque came down off the wall. In this two-parter, Janeway's rage and feelings of betrayal lead her into one of, if not the, most merciless hunts in the history of the ship.

The USS Equinox is saved by Voyager, having arrived in the Delta Quadrant through almost identical circumstances. However, their journey through the Quadrant has been met with far more strife. An early encounter with the Krotonan Gaurd cost the ship half of its crew, and it only got worse from there. When they discovered that they could harvest the bodies of nucleogenic lifeforms as fuel, they seized the opportunity. Captain Janeway was not pleased.

She hunted the ship into submission, with only four members of the crew surviving the chase. While the aliens themselves were responsible for most of the deaths, Janeway's pursuit of the ship cost it a nacelle, effectively ending any chance for it to continue on its journey. Only when Captain Ransom elects to sacrifice himself to safeguard the survivors, does Janeway call off the chase and allow the remaining crew to stay on Voyager.


3. Tuvix (Tuvix)

Star Trek Tuvix
CBS Media Ventures

Tuvix is, in many ways, Captain Janeway's Kobayashi Maru test. There was simply no way to win here. So while this absolutely ranks on any list of the worst things that she has ever done, it is of course also done in the act of saving lives as well.

In this writer's mind, there is little doubt that Janeway made the right call. That doesn't mean it was a good call though. Tuvix, though short-lived, bore all of the memories of both Tuvok and Neelix, creating this new form of life. To erase him was to execute him, awful as the decision may be. Even the Doctor, programmed though he was to follow order, could not assist in the procedure.

Janeway took the full responsibilty here and it does truly rank as one of the worst things she has ever done. Was it a negative action though? This falls squarely into the realm of necessary evil. Tuvok and Neelix needed to be saved, which had to come at the cost of Tuvix's life.

As revealed in her autobiography, ghost written by Dr. Una McCormack, this was a choice that Janeway never, ever forgot.


2. Never Promoting Harry Kim (The Entire Series)

Harry Kim
CBS

This poor man. The forever Ensign, as he's come to be known in the fandom, suffered the most under Janeway's tyranny on board the USS Voyager. Fresh out of the academy during the events of Caretaker, Harry Kim had zero experience before taking his post at ops on the bridge. However, he would go on to see more in the course of his duties than many other higher-ranking officers in the fleet.

Also, he dies. Several times.

Janeway displayed not only the ability to grant field commissions, such as those she bestowed on the Maquis, but that she could also reduce, and raise, members of the crew in rank. She demoted Tom Paris from Lt. to Ensign, only to reinstate the higher rank again. All of this, in front of Harry Kim and his single, solitary pip.

On top of all of this, the events of Endgame show a vengeful Admiral Janeway changing history to ensure that Captain Kim of the USS Rhode Island is erased from history, meaning the final rank this poor man has yet to achieve is still ensign!

Even Wesley Crusher made Lt. by the events of Star Trek: Nemesis!


1. Altering History Because She Doesn't Really Like It (Endgame)

Star Trek Voyager Endgame
NBC

Exactly what right did Admiral Janeway have to alter history, thus changing the lives of everyone in existence, during the events of Endgame? That is a question that the Admiral doesn't seem to consider as she steals the temporal device from Korath and takes her shuttle into the past.

Her actions may be coming from a place of love - she is concerned with getting her crew home safely after all - yet she is potentially condemning trillions of lives to a different fate in doing so. Consider the argument that Captain LaForge made to Chakotay in the episode Timeless - he can understand the former commander's actions, but he has to act to save history.

Who is to say that history didn't play out exactly as it was meant to? Who is to say that Seven of Nine was supposed to survive at all? Her actions may have saved lives and dealt a crippling blow to the Borg, but Admiral Janeway proved that her own motivations meant more to her than the entirety of reality.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"