Star Trek: 10 Worst Things Data Has Ever Done
The android who wants to be more human and somehow keeps on making the same mistakes.
Lt Cmdr Data. Found by the crew of the USS Tripoli after the Crystalline Entity had ravaged Omicron Theta; seemingly the last of the Soong type androids.
Less "perfect" than his brother, Lore, Data chose to spend his life understanding humanity and attempting to become more like his friends and shipmates on the USS Enterprise. Ultimately he would meet his (first) demise selflessly swapping places with Jean-Luc Picard to save the galaxy one final time.
But behind all that evolution, the Shakespeare performances, scanning for lifeforms and Chinese finger puzzles lay something of an internal darkness. Whether naivety, stupidity or the simple workings of a positronic mind, Data has made some highly questionable decisions over the years. What better way to deal with them than dragging them out into the sunlight for a good discussion.
Fans have a deep appreciation for the one of a kind android although it does come to light that he's been given a free hall pass on several occasions. Occasions when others may well have faced brig time or even court martial and dismissal from Starfleet.
Truly amazing what "I was controlled by my brother/dead mother/malfunctioning emotion chip" (delete as applicable) can help out with.
10. Attempted Comedy
This might have been one of those early attempts to flesh out Data and push the character forward but genuinely his foray into stage comedy has the potential to be the worst thing ever.
While the ship deals with the arrival of Thaduin Okona (recently reprised in Lower Decks), Data decides it's a wise move to expand his repertoire on the comedy circuit.
In fairness to Data it's Okona that suggests he's missing out on the element of humour and starts him along a dark and frankly misinformed path.
This, at least, doesn't put anyone into physical danger unlike several others in this list. Yet even if you take the attempt at scripted comedy out of the equation, Data mauls joke after joke after joke. It's Quip Murder One from the jiggly armed routine in Ten Forward complete with oversize cigar down to the terrible stage show with The Comic on the holodeck.
As part of the programme on the holodeck the fake audience are there to laugh at anything. What is significant about this Worst Thing is that, rarely, Data realises that this is a terrible choice because he has no emotional connection to the humour.
9. Forced The Enterprise On A Detour
Writing interstellar letters to a child - what could possibly go wrong?
Data spends eight weeks communicating with a young girl called Sarjenka on Drema Four before he decides that it's time to tell Picard.
That's two whole months before he goes to ask the captain if he can violate the Prime Directive and intervene with the natural progression of a planet. Data's actions force the captain's hand when the communications turn into a plea for help that even he cannot ignore.
This leads to Picard having to enact some distinctly off-the-books activities to complete the mission and rescue Data's pen pal. It gets substantially worse as the android goes on to make promises to Sarjenka about staying on the Enterprise without any concerns for her future and the fact that he's probably broken about a dozen Federation laws.
This all started because he picked up a signal and started a chat, but the question remains as to why Data didn't take this to the captain immediately considering the seriousness of the situation. Yes, it's a planet-sized disaster but Data has pulled the Federation into something where they should not be playing God.
8. Lal
There's a bit of a recurring theme here. Once again Data chooses to go about doing something that has serious, life-changing consequences without consulting a soul.
The Offspring is a superlative episode of The Next Generation. Yet, when you put it into the context of Data's decision-making and personal mental development, his thinking is untethered.
The creation of Lal is both brilliant and horrific at the same time. Mapped from Data's own positronic net, Lal soon begins to outgrow the original programming. Not just in the formation of contractions within her language but, later, the emergence of real emotion.
But the evolution beyond her original parameters goes beyond the capability of Lal's own build, leading to a cascade failure and deactivation.
The tragedy here is that the crew become emotionally attached to Lal as her journey of life progresses. When it comes to her death they are all utterly shell-shocked but yet, because of his inherent emotionless nature Data just carries on. Bizarrely he seems to have been affected more by the death of Tasha Yar less than a full season into TNG and this is almost a backward step in his adventure of life.
7. Kivas Fajo
The one that might be a good thing, might be a bad thing.
The story of The Most Toys is well known among fans especially thanks to its epically eye-opening conclusion.
Through the episode Data is acquired by Collector, Kivas Fajo who is obsessed with unique items. The Soong type android very obviously falls into that category and through faking Data's death, Fajo sits him in pride of place. Literally.
Fajo turns out to be a spoiled, selfish, emotionally detached humanoid with no care for anything other than his collection, ultimately killing the person closest to him.
But it's what happens as Data returns that really piques the interest of fan because, as is noted in the episode, there appears to be weapons fire coming from the transporter beam as he is beaming out. It raises the question as to whether Data fired the Varon-T Disruptor or it genuinely had an overload in transport.
We may never know but there are a few things to think about here. One is that Data may have intentionally tried to take a life and if he did it also means he has openly lied to Riker. Could this be an emotional response perhaps?
6. Placed A Sick Child At Serious Risk (Brothers)
In Brothers, Data (yet again) is controlled to take the Enterprise to a backwater planet to meet up with his creator Dr Noonien Soong.
At the same time, the Federation flagship should be taking a sick child for emergency treatment after eating some deadly berries. The episode makes it very, very clear that this child will die if he doesn't receive the vital treatment.
Now, consider that Data knows this because he is only called by Soong while the ship is enroute. Much chaos ensues as Data shut down the ship, creates the mother of all security passwords (not his mum's surname or first school) and then escapes the ship.
At no point during the next part of the story, while he is engaged with Soong and party-crasher Lore, does he even make reference to the emergency situation aboard the Enterprise. Ok, he can't get back and no-one else can beam down but there is no sense of urgency from someone who is as dedicated to duty as Lt Cmdr Data. The Enterprise is also pretty much disabled until found by Riker's away team. Once more, nothing said!
5. Had A Relationship Just For The Experience
For someone without the ability to understand or display emotions, Data sure does like to put other people through the spin dryer.
In the case of Ensign Jenna D'Sora he decides the best way to deal with romantic relationships is to be in one. By "be in one" I mean to provide zero emotional support and stamp on her heart. How Ensign D'Sora comes out of this unscarred emotionally I'm lost.
Through the course of the episode we see Data attempt to mimic a relationship with the ensign who is only just getting over her last boyfriend. It might well be a rebound but from the get go it looks doomed to failure.
Jenna puts her all into the relationship, snuggling up to Data, the occasional kiss and even a row to round it all out. However for Data it's still all mathematical and when Jenna asks him just what he was thinking about when they kissed he's focused equally on multiple ship operations.
Fortunately Jenna realises that it's not right to continue this dalliance and stops the relationship short. While Data might appear caring, it's all part of a designed programme and not at all natural.
4. Stabbed Troi (Phantasms)
Unusually Data is in control of all his faculties during the bizarre nightmares of season seven's Phantasms.
Straws in heads, Victorian engineers and Sigmund Freud aside, there's one part of this which is both utterly bonkers. and in turn, the catalyst for the second part of the episode. In one of Star Trek's eeriest and most chilling sequences, Troi senses (how, Data's an android?) that she's being followed. Entering the turbolift she seems to be fine until Data forces the door open. Menacing and with a focused stare in place he proceeds, almost Psycho-like, to stab Deanna in her shoulder.
It is revealed that the crew have been infected by parasites that are extracting their cellular peptides. These were were living in the new warp core and awoke when it was activated. Data is on the verge of a cybernetic neurosis throughout this episode with the attack on Troi being the culmination of his subconscious experiences.
If you saw this in the UK on it's first BBC2 airing then the episode clipped to the following scene just as Data raised the knife and skipped Troi's screams. Yes, sometimes a cake is just a cake but he gets off lightly once more.
3. The Emotion Chip
Does this guy ever learn?
That's a genuinely good question considering that his journey on The Next Generation is all about his development towards becoming more human. He makes a ton of mistakes but one thing he keeps on avoiding is taking advice from Geordi or informing senior officers of his decisions.
Take the emotion chip for instance. While it's change in shape, size and functionality (it was broke!) might be contentious issues among Star Trek fans, the bigger one is that Data chooses to stick it in his head. Admittedly he's not to know they're heading into battle and the Enterprise-D's demise but it's a pretty flippant decision.
As you would expect there are side effects. Surely Geordi would have been a little more skeptical considering the last time Data played around with emotions he got tortured. Luckily this time he only gets captured and tortured thanks to his best friend. Why wouldn't you stay away from this guy???
Picard forces Data to keep the chip in and deal with it although by the time we get to First Contact he has the option to turn it off and on miraculously.
2. Zero Point Six Eight Seconds
How could this one not be included?
Captured by the Borg aboard the Enterprise-E, Data has his emotion chip forcibly reactivated and is placed at the mercy of the Borg Queen.
Utterly powerless and in the belly of the beast, Data is tempted with human flesh and to ultimately sit at the side of the Queen herself as an equal to rule the Collective. She had failed to complete this with Locutus. however, Data presented an opportune second chance.
HIs allegiance at the movie's finale is, it would seem, all an act. Picard genuinely seems terrified at the thought that Data has switched sides but fortunately it's just a bluff and the pair save the day as only a Star Trek movie duo could. Or was it?
Data admits that he was tempted for a tiny fraction of a second by the Queen's offer. Now given his track record of reckless behaviour on this list, Picard would have been justified in being more than a little skeptical on precisely how long that sway to the dark side might have been. Remember too how we have evidence that Data may have lied before in regards to Kicas Fajo.
1. Tortured Geordi
When you think things can't get any worse than your best friend allying himself with his evil twin and the Borg, it does.
Side note as we go; Data isn't totally under his own control here however it's not what you would pop round to tea for.
Captured by the Borg, Lore realises that Geordi can see the carrier wave which is controlling Data and has his brother perform further experiments on the engineer. Neutralising La Forge's pain receptors, Data inserts nano-cordical fibres into his head with the intention of destroying his existing brain cells. While it may well look like Data is setting up a game of Ker Plunk in Geordi's head he's actually planning on using the engineer's cranium to see if he can build an artificial neural net to take over his cognitive functions. Chances of survival; 40%.
Of course it's all forgotten about and washed over in a matter of seconds at the end of the episode but viewers must have wondered what the after effects of being tortured by your bezzie mate would have been. Also it's apparent Geordi didn't learn his lesson as we'll see next.