Star Trek: 11 Greatest Unfinished Story Ideas
To boldly go back to the stories that they just sort of forgot to expand...

10. Decker And Ilia (Star Trek: The Motion Picture) TMP is a beautifully photographed film and contains what are arguably the best special effects of the entire series. Its themes of exploring one's sense of being and what does it mean to question one's existence are some of the strongest elements ever tackled. The crew has to think their way out of this one instead of "phasers on full, fire!" At the film's climax, Decker seemingly sacrifices his life by physically joining with the machine-entity V'Ger and in the process is reunited with his long-lost love, Ilia. What exactly happens to Decker and Ilia is intentionally left vague, but one can wonder whether they really die, especially as Kirk lists them as "missing in action." Spock states their joining with V'Ger may be an ascension of sorts towards the next step in human development. These heady concepts of evolution and consciousness would have perfectly lent themselves to an intelligent exploration of the universe within ourselves; "The Human Adventure is Just Beginning." Sadly, fans were never able to take the next step on that particular journey.
9. Who Built The Dyson Sphere? (TNG: Relics) Relics is more famously known as the episode that brought Montgomery Scott into the world of the 24th century and it certainly is a blast seeing Scotty interact with the crew of the EnterpriseD. Yet it also contains one of the most compelling scientific discoveries ever made by the crew of the Enterprise. The Dyson sphere was an immense hollow construction that had a habitable interior surface equal to that of hundreds of millions of planets. Freeman Dyson first proposed this bold concept back in the 1960s and a sphere such as he described could solve problems as far ranging as energy consumption and over-population. This is an idea that seems all but impossible to realize, but leave it to Star Trek to turn the seemingly impossible into the possible. Yet the question remains: "who exactly built this thing and how?" The Enterprise's mission is one of exploration and the Dyson sphere would have provided the chance for that central mission to be placed front and centre. However, little time is devoted to ponder this fantastic discovery and it is never brought up again, which was a missed opportunity to put the "science" first in science fiction.
8. The Unification Of Vulcan And Romulus (TNG: Unification) In 1991 Star Trek was celebrating its 25th anniversary, for which TNG planned to celebrate with the crossover event that fans had wanted since its premier in 1987: the two-part episode Unification. In it Spock believes that after centuries apart the Vulcan and Romulan people's future lies together as one united nation. After his plan is thwarted, Spock decides to continue to work with the underground unification movement in the hope that one day his vision of a peaceful coexistence can be realized. And then . . . Regrettably there never was an "And then . . ." A storyline rife with such game-changing ramifications certainly warranted some sort of additional chapter. An episode dealing with the political fallout between the Federation and the Romulan Empire would have gone a long way toward combating the feeling that this was in effect a "reset button" episode. In this instance, having no follow-up feels like a missed chance at something great. " 'There are always possibilities,' Spock said." It's just a shame that a continuation to Unification wasn't one of them.
7. Close Encounters Of The Star Trek Kind (TNG: Schisms) Throughout Star Trek there have been numerous instances of comedy, political intrigue, romance, and war stories, but there have only been a couple of times where Star Trek has drifted into the realm of horror (the Enterprise second-season episode Dead Stop is one such example). The episode Schism is a perfect example of such. In essence, Schisms is an alien abduction story that perfectly creates a growing sense of fear. Riker discovers that an alien race from another space-time continuum is abducting the crew and performing various physical experiments on them. Just as the crew devises a way to seal the rift between the two dimensions, a energy pulse similar to a probe slips through and escapes out into the depths of space. Maybe the crew isn't as safe at the end of this episode as they hoped they were. Seeing how the brave crew of the Enterprise is just as vulnerable to the things that go bump in the night would have been a great starting point for exploring the darker corners of the galaxy. As Q once warned Picard, there are terrors in the galaxy equal to the wonders to behold, but Schisms was the last time this particular nightmare gripped the audience's hearts and minds. (On a more lighthearted note, this episode contains what is one of the funniest moments of the TNG series: a recitation of a poem written by Data about his cat, Ode to Spot. "Felis Catus, is your taxonomic nomenclature/An endothermic quadruped, carnivorous by nature?" Beautiful!)
6. The Probe That Could Talk To Whales (Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home) All Star Trek fans know this one by heart: alien probe of unknown design and origin; ships and starbases rendered powerless; a signal transmitted. Then vaporized oceans; devastating storms across the Earth; time Travel; humpback whales. Naturally, Kirk and company save the day, the probe goes back from where it came, and then the inevitable question: "where exactly did it come from?" While the probe's actions end up basically being a case of miscommunication, it did still nearly destroy the entire planet. And what would happen if this energy disrupting device fell into the hands of one of the nefarious races of the galaxy? It would have been a well placed coda at the end of the film if the characters made some mention of wanting to learn more about the probe, who created it, and why it was intent on contacting a highly intelligent aquatic species. Admittedly it would have been very unlikely for there to have been a direct film sequel to The Voyage Home. Nevertheless the probe's origin remains a rather large, yet fascinating, unanswered question in the Star Trek franchise.
5. The Parasite Infiltration Of Starfleet (TNG: Conspiracy) Conspiracy stands as one of the stronger episodes from the inaugural season of TNG. In its original conception, the infiltration in question was conducted not by parasitic aliens but by a type of nanotechnological species that would have served on a certain level as a precursor to the Borg. This storyline was eventually abandoned and what fans are left with is far more disturbing than nanites and frankly much more gruesome. In their adolescent stage, these alien parasites enter the host body through the mouth and reside in the chest cavity, where they grow at an alarming rate, allowing them to control the host both physically and mentally. In one of the more graphic scenes of the series, Picard and Riker kill the alien queen by blowing the head of the unwilling human host to bits. The queen bursts through the host's chest, only to succumb to a barrage of phaser fire by the Enterprise's captain and first officer. While there is an allusion to the investigation of the parasites in the fourth-season episode The Drumhead, nothing else is ever said concerning the events of Conspiracy. With presumably dozens of high ranking Starfleet officers having been infected, this was another storyline that could have been brought back to terrific effect. It comes across as a somewhat glaring omission that something that had nearly brought the Federation to its knees was never explored again. Instead of being simply an odd exclusion, never returning to the parasite infiltration feels more like a huge missed opportunity.
4. The Planet Killer (TOS: The Doomsday Machine) The Doomsday Machine is one of the most tense, action-filled episodes of the franchise, featuring a great premise coupled with award-winning writing and brilliant pacing. The Enterprise discovers the Constellation adrift and nearly destroyed by the planet killer. Its sole survivor, Commodore Matt Decker, is barely clinging to the last shreds of his sanity. With Kirk stranded on the derelict Constellation and the planet killer rapidly approaching the most densely populated parts of the galaxy, it is only by detonating the Constellation inside the planet killer that disaster is averted, and the weapon destroyed. Interestingly, a number of the questions that would naturally have arisen in the wake of The Doomsday Machine are addressed in the episode itself: it is determined that the planet killer originated from somewhere outside of the Milky Way. Its superior construction and advanced weaponry makes it a safe bet that it was built by a civilization more advanced than the Federation. It is theorized that it was intended as a deterrent in an ancient war, but at some point was set loose, possibly destroying both sides in said conflict. The possibilities for future storylines involving the origin and purpose of the planet killer could have been nearly limitless. What two ancient powers were at war with each other when it was built? Was the planet killer actually intended to travel indefinitely across the cosmos? Did it have an overriding mission that it failed to complete? Was it more than a machine and in fact a life-form of some kind, possessing consciousness and an awareness of what it was doing? Regrettably, we are left to wonder. (One quick note: though never revealed in Star Trek: The Motion Picture, it was suggested by the studio, and generally believed by fans, that Commodore Decker was in fact the father of Will Decker .)
3. Sela (TNG: The Mind's Eye, Redemption, Unification) The season-four finale Redemption Part 1 blew the minds of fans across the globe with a revelation yet to be surpassed in all of Star Trek: security chief Tasha Yar, struck dead towards the end of the first season, was alive and well and evidently a Romulan! It marked the start to a summer full of speculation as to what exactly was going on here. It did not take long, however, for observant fans to make the connection between Sela's appearance in Redemption and the plot of the third-season episode Yesterday's Enterprise. The ramifications of time travel have been a part of Star Trek as long as it has been in existence, of course. Yesterday's Enterprise centers around the fate of the Enterprise-C, the immediate predecessor of Picard's Enterprise-D. A temporal rift plucks the Enterprise-C from a battle with the Romulans and displaces it decades into the future. In this timeline, the Federation is locked in a bitter and grueling war against the Klingons and Tasha Yar is still alive. It is determined that in order to set things right, the Enterprise-C must be sent back through the temporal rift, a mission that will most assuredly lead to its destruction. With Tasha onboard, the ship is sent through, the timeline is restored, and the Enterprise-D continues on, unaware of what exactly has just taken place. In Redemption, Sela tells Picard that Tahsa had survived the battle and was in fact her mother. Sela was born as the result of a relationship between Tasha and a Romulan general. While Picard professes disbelief to all this, the audience can see that the specter of doubt has been raised within him. The stage has then been set for the Enterprise crew to determine once and for all what really happened to the previous ship named Enterprise. Yet, when Sela does reappear in the episode Unification, no mention is made of her questionable (though the audience knows genuine) heritage. The door had been opened for a deep and thorough exploration of whether or not it is ethical to alter the timeline, even with the best of intentions. These types of cause and effect, time travel-loop stories are one of the things that Star Trek has accomplished magnificently throughout its fifty years. Why the audience was never treated to this potential epic storyline is a loss that is still felt by fans to this day.
2. Whatever Happened To Lieutenant Saavik? (Star Trek II, III, and IV) There are those who could make a very convincing argument that this entry should be listed at #1. When first introduced, Saavik (played by Kirstie Alley) quickly became a favorite character amongst fans. Strong willed and opinionated, but tempered by a cool intellect, she was focused on trying to understand the seemingly odd and random behavior of the Humans around her. Actress Robin Curtis would go on to portray Saavik in both Star Trek III and IV, but after her brief appearance in the latter, Saavik was never seen or heard from again. Fans have never been willing to accept that this important new addition to the crew had simply vanished. To this day her true fate remains a mystery. The most difficult thing to bear is that there was a plan in place to provide a fitting end to this admired character. During the early planning stages for Star Trek VI the character Valeris was in fact intended to be Saavik. And just as Valeris was involved with the film's conspiracy storyline, so too would have Saavik. It would then have been revealed that Saavik was half Romulan and that her mixed heritage was a factor in her choice to side with the conspirators. With Saavik in the film, not only would her actions have reason (as Valeris' do not), but her betrayal would have provided an emotional punch to Spock. So what happened? When he heard what was being planned for Saavik, Gene Roddenberry immediately protested, saying that the writers couldn't turn such a well-liked character into one of the bad guys. He was certain fans would never accept it, even though it would have been a surprising, but believable dramatic turn for her. And so Saavik was changed to Valeris and fans were denied a true and proper ending to a character that deserved so much more than she was given.
1. The Guardian Of Forever (TOS: The City On The Edge Of Forever) Superlatives abound when discussing The City on the Edge of Forever, yet an agonizingly small amount is known about the Guardian itself. Here's what little is known: the Guardian is a time portal that was created by an ancient civilization billions of years ago. It is a sentient device that has its "own beginning and own end," a tantalizing, if vague pronouncement. And it has for ages longed to be asked a question. If an advanced race could build something as powerful as the Guardian, then what else were they capable of accomplishing? Perhaps after crafting this nearly omnipotent device, the Guardian's architects felt threatened by it. Could the Guardian have in turn felt threatened itself and, out of a sense of self-preservation, found a way to trick them into traveling into the past, wiping themselves out from all of history in the process? Spock discovers that the Guardian is the center of the temporal disturbances the Enterprise had been monitoring in that region of space. Could it be possible that the Guardian was in actuality malfunctioning, "leaking" these temporal waves, as it were? Imagine a TNG episode showing how the Guardian has been studied for years since its discovery with no progress being gained toward understanding it. Suddenly it reawakens and demands to speak with "those from the starship Enterprise." Would that not have made for an exciting hour of television? Perhaps an episode of DS9 in which it is learned that the Dominion is seeking to locate the Guardian and Sisko and company must race to stop them. Then again, perhaps in this particular example, knowing less is what makes the mystery so engaging. It is this air of the unknown that makes the Guardian legendary and provides a constant source of debate and discussion amongst fans. It is likely that nothing could every adequately explain just what or who the Guardian is or why it was built in the first place. Chances are fans will never know, but it sure is fun to guess. Are there any other Star Trek stories that need to be further developed? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.