Star Trek Picard: Everything You Need To Know About The Borg
What do you know of Seven of Nine's adoptive family?
The Borg Collective has existed in several forms in the Star Trek universe throughout the years, often taking on the role of antagonist while sometimes fulfilling the role of tentative ally. While the end goal of the Collective may be perfection and unity for all, its methods leave a lot to be desired.
Trace the steps of the Borg's development, from its inception in Star Trek The Next Generation to its most recent iteration in Star Trek Picard. Who are they? What do they want? How will they do it? Are they the race that sent V'Ger back to Earth to find its creator?
And, most importantly, is resistance really futile?
11. Who Are The Borg?
In season one of Star Trek The Next Generation, producer Maurice Hurley came up with an idea. There would be a race of aliens with immense power that would become the deadliest threat that the Federation had ever faced. They would be able to take over peoples' minds. They would wipe out entire colonies and civilisations. They would destroy the Federation's oldest enemy, the Romulans, as a demonstration of power. They would become the definitive Big Bad of the Star Trek universe.
Things did not begin smoothly.
The season one episode Coming of Age introduced the idea that Starfleet was facing infiltration. Admiral Gregory Quinn beamed aboard the Enterprise with his aid, Lieutenant Commander Remmick to conduct an inspection that was truly a screening process for them to see had the Enterprise been overcome. Satisfied that it hadn't been, they confessed their fears to Picard, who found it hard to take them seriously.
Several episodes later however Conspiracy showed us just how correct they had been when Quinn and several other Starfleet Admirals found themselves the victims of parasites controlling their every thought and move. Remmick fared worst as his body had become host to the alien queen. The queen was killed by Picard and Riker, thus causing all drones to die - but not before a homing beacon was sent from Earth out into the stars.
And that was the last time they were heard from.
The idea, while sound, suffered in execution from poor effects and a degree of silliness. The threat needed to be reworked into something grander. The Romulan re-introduction continued as planned, dropping the plot point that several colonies along the Neutral Zone had been destroyed - seemingly scooped directly off the surface of those planets. But while the show took the Romulans in a different direction, this seed of an idea for the new villain remained.
The idea would rest until late in the second season. Q Who? introduces the Borg to the franchise in the form that they would come to be known. Hurled across the galaxy by the omnipotent being Q, the Enterprise D first encounters the Borg in system J-27.
There, a solitary Borg Cube approaches them and informs them simply that resistance is useless and they will be assimilated. What follows is a truly unsettling sequence where the Enterprise is shown to be in no way ready to counter this threat. Losing crew members, losing power and on the brink of losing the battle, Picard admits he desperately needs Q's help and they are returned to the Alpha Quadrant.
But now, the Borg knew of their existence.
10. Who Speaks For The Borg?
It would take another year before the Borg would return. The original plan for the end of The Next Generation's third season was to ignite the Klingon civil war. However, this plan was put on hold and the Borg story line was pulled forward. Maurice Hurley, the creator of the Borg, had since left production on TNG and it was down to writer Michael Pillar and director Cliff Bole to give the Borg life.
The Best of Both Worlds is frequently and deservedly credited as solidifying TNG as one of the stand-out examples of science-fiction television, stepping outside of the shadow of The Original Series. The cliffhanger at the end of part 1 was and arguably remains the greatest cliffhanger of the franchise - an assimilated Jean Luc Picard speaks, as Locutus of Borg, to Riker, echoing the familiar catchphrase 'resistance is futile' before the music swells, the camera closes in and Riker gives the order to fire a kill shot directly at the cube containing his Captain.
For this story, the writers addressed what would become a common issue with the Borg - speaking to the collective only had power for so long before it slipped. This episode sees the Borg search for a liaison to assist in the assimilation of humanity and for that they choose Picard. In writing this storyline, Star Trek would be forever changed.
This story came in the days before serialized television as it is known today and the idea that Picard would carry scars from this wasn't even considered. The second part of the episode shows a clearly traumatized Picard looking out of his ready room window, haunted by his experience. In a Star Trek first, the following episode Family showed his clear pain and fear over what had happened.
The two-parter itself is thrilling, giving true power to the Borg. The infamous Battle of Wolf 359 occurs off-screen early into part 2 and the Federation suffers its worst ever defeat when 39 vessels and 11,000 lives are lost. The shot of the Enterprise arriving to the graveyard of ships is chilling, not least when the camera lingers on the broken engineering section of a TOS Movie-Era Constitution Class ship, dropping the subtle hint that even Captain Kirk would not have stood a chance against these foes.
9. I, Borg
A true villain cannot be one-dimensional. Evil for evil's sake can offer a threat but it holds very little opportunity for story. TNG's fifth season added a new element to the collective. It challenged the idea of the individuals who were trapped inside the many. Johnathan Del Arco, who has recently returned for Star Trek Picard, steps into the role of Hugh, a Borg survivor from a crash site. He is saved from death by Dr. Crusher, beamed aboard the Enterprise and locked in the brig.
The episode is key for several elements but chiefly for showing without any uncertainty that the Borg Drones do not question their purpose while connected to the collective. When they are part of the One, they are tools to a function. However, separated from the rest of the Borg, Hugh's individuality begins to assert itself. He grows, learning to speak in the singular rather than the plural, taking on his name and expressing genuinely curiosity at the crew's hesitance to be assimilated. It is only in his friendship with Geordi that he comes to understand that individuality is more desirable that the collective.
I, Borg is a key factor of Picard's growth as well. Since his assimilation and liberation, he has carried the anger and pain toward the Borg with him, though unexpressed. Here, he is able to display it. He happily agrees to a plan that would see Hugh become a carrier for a pathogen that could wipe out the collective, seeing no moral or ethical issues.
It takes Guinan, a survivor of a race destoyed by the Borg, to convince him to meet with Hugh. Hugh recognises him as Locutus and Picard works this angle, testing the sensibilities of the drone. Once he sees that Hugh is no longer part of the collective but rather a frightened young man, he cancels the plan.
Though Hugh would return to the collective for the safety of the crew, he takes with him the lessons taught by the Enterprise crew and they in turn learn from him. The Borg may pose the greatest threat in the galaxy when they come in force but when viewed alone, they are a race of slaves, condemned to help enslave others.
8. The Borg Find A New Messiah
Cybernetic creatures have a varied history in Star Trek. All synthetic life has been banned by the start of Star Trek Picard and it is stories like Descent that pave the road as to why. Dr. Noonian Soong was the greatest mind that the franchise has yet known in the field of positronics and cybernetics, inspiring such scientists as Bruce Maddox and Agnes Jurati.
He first created the android B-4, a prototype to develop his positronic brain. From this jumping off point, he moved to create a being that would be more human, feeling as humans do and expressing those feelings at will. After B-4, Soong created Lore.
Identical to Data in appearance, Lore was as different as it was possible for two of the same type of android to be. Lore was consumed by his feelings and fed the anger and hatred in his heart. He orchestrated the destruction of his home colony. He attempted to destroy the Enterprise when he was reactivated. He murdered his father on his return home. From there, he vanished for several years until resurfacing in an entirely new role.
When Hugh returned to the collective, the assimilation process began to work in reverse and he in effect assimilated those drones nearest him with individuality. They passed it on to others and this infection of individuality spread. They would separate from the collective and drift, fearful and lost until they were discovered by Lore. He fed them with his passionate hate of organics, building them from a rabble of lost souls to a devastating army.
The familiar fear of destroyed colonies returned as the unknown assailants attacked. Discovered once again by the Enterprise crew, Lore manages to briefly control Data and together they stand as the Gods of this new Borg religion.
This would be the last time that TNG would use the Borg as it moved into its final season. Lore was overcome and dismantled. Hugh regained leadership of the small family he had liberated. These Borg at the very least seemed to be in a position of newfound strength, free of the collective and free from false Gods.
7. What If The Borg Had A TARDIS?
Star Trek: First Contact is a direct sequel to The Best of Both Worlds and it doesn't touch upon the story threads introduced by Hugh. Written by Brannon Braga, Ronald D. Moore and Rick Berman, it does what all good sequels do and it takes the story in a far darker direction than Star Trek had ventured before.
The Borg return to Federation space and begin an onslaught that brings them to the very orbit of Earth, while Starfleet have sidelined the new Enterprise E and her crew, for fear of what Captain Picard will do when facing the collective again. After a brief but explosive fight, the Enterprise (having disobeyed their orders and joined the fight) aids in the destruction of the Cube, but not before a smaller Sphere escapes and disappears back in time.
For those who were discovering the Star Trek franchise through the new Next Generation movies, this is the film that probably hooked them. At the same time, Deep Space Nine and Voyager were on the air, so much like today there was plenty of Trek to choose from. But this was big budget cinema. This was 1996 and this was a horror film disguised as a sci-fi adventure. The Borg, treading water by the end of The Next Generation, returned in full, terrifying force. They are vampires, destructive and immensely powerful. However, First Contact will always be remembered best for the introduction of one of the all-time great Trek villains.
'I am the beginning, the end, the one who is many. I am the Borg.'
Alice Krige's Borg Queen is a seductive and sinister foe for Data in this film. While she is interested only in achieving perfection for the collective and is willing to wipe out humanity to do that, she frames herself as a new mentor for him. She shows seeming fondness and care, guiding him through gruesome skin grafts so that he can better feel emotion and sensation. All the while, she is commanding the drones under her command to spread out on the ship and take the rest of the crew.
Picard leads the fight against them, advising the crew not to hesitate when it comes to shooting at assimilated comrades. His attempts to fight back build on the resentment he already feels and in one of Patrick Stewart's most visceral deliveries, he hisses with seething hatred that he will stop the Borg. He will make them pay.
The Borg transformed from cold, unstoppable automatons to creatures of utter dread in First Contact. The simple plot point (send them back in time) worked beautifully. Gone was the support that the Enterprise could hope from Starfleet. The birth of the Federation itself was under direct threat. The Borg had come to destroy them all. It was a height that they would never again reach as the stories that followed began to veer toward the smaller and less fearsome aspects.
6. Breaking The Borg
Star Trek Voyager's setting of the Delta Quadrant ensured that a face off with the Borg was all but inevitable and the end of its third season finally delivered. Scorpion parts 1 and 2 are among Voyager's best episodes. The Borg are shown, in one of the franchise's shortest teaser segments, to be completely obliterated in moments by an enemy even greater than them.
Species 8472, Star Trek's first entirely CGI aliens, were another formidable force. Coming from another reality, they cut through the Collective like it was made of butter. However they show no intention of stopping with the Collective along, leaving Captain Janeway with only one solution, to broker a treaty with the Borg. To see the Borg fleeing from 8472 as they do flips the positions between Starfleet and the Borg, as only the Voyager crew are able to create an effective weapon.
In Part 2, the audience is introduced to Seven of Nine. Much like Jean Luc Picard's Locutus, her role is to act as intermediary between the Starfleet crew and the collective. She is quickly transferred to Voyager and finds herself the sole survivor of her Cube. She takes Voyager into 8472's realm and they conduct a devastating attack, resulting in the withdrawal from Borg space.
In showing an enemy that the Borg was truly unable to fight, this story offered a glimpse at the stagnation of the Collective. It is commented that it is because of learning and experimentation that Voyager's Emergency Medical Hologram is able to replicate a way to fight Species 8472. The Borg have no such methods and rely on brute strength the entire time.
This shows that even though they have been shown to be unstoppable in the past, they are certainly not invincible and are not above cutting deals to survive.
5. A Mother/Borg Relationship
Seven of Nine is the most important and fully realized Borg character on any of the franchise's series so far. With Locutus, there had been Picard both before and after. But with Seven, there had only been the drone to begin with and all of the slow defrosting led from there. Through her many clashes with the individuals on Voyager, she develops greater freedoms, respect for humanity and crucially, a will to be herself.
Her many relationships combined to make her the character that is now working with Picard and the crew of the La Sirena, but arguably it is her mentoring role to both the Borg children and Naomi Wildman while still serving in the Delta Quadrant that showed the maternal nature within. Much like Hugh, Seven's move toward individuality came in degrees.
While Hugh's journey has been shrouded in more mystery to date, Seven's first few years were on full display. How does an ex-drone adapt? What characteristics survive assimilation? She is shown to be self-conscious at times, hardly unique to an ex-drone, but her quest for perfection remains. This aspect of the Collective never leaves Seven in all of the stories that followed. Naturally, the Borg need to be perfect would extend to parenthood.
The creation of the 29th century Drone may have been accidental but Seven quickly assumes responsibility for him and his development. It is here, contrasted with the stiff and slow newborn, that Seven's journey from Borg to Human is shown. She is a member of the crew. Her search for perfection has become tempered with interactions with others.
She teaches the Drone about individuality and warns him of the dangers of the Collective. Her fears are proven correct when it is the Collective who orchestrate the events that lead to the death of the Drone. Seven is alone again, struggling without the small family she was so briefly a part of. The Collective destroys Seven's family. Twice.
4. Do Borg Dream Of Assimilating Sheep?
Deep within the Collective, there was a place where the Drones could escape during the hours of regeneration. It wasn't every drone who had access to it but it was enough that secret communities began to build, existing only in the dream state. It was called Unimatrix Zero and Seven of Nine was a community member. When she went back into her regeneration state, she would visit with the other people she had come to know. It was like shore leave for the drones. It was a place to escape.
The Borg Queen, as played here by Susanna Thompson, was a very different creature from the one seen attempting to seduce Data. This Queen had no interest in seduction. She was a scientist at heart, though one not interested in the scientific method. She would sacrifice countless drones if it meant destroying the linked freedoms between them and their dream states. She managed to invade and effectively reassimilate dozens of drones with methodical ease, fighting again with the crew of Voyager.
Unimatrix Zero was an interesting idea, again playing on the notion of individuality within the Collective. Here, the Borg could have their cake and eat it - they were drones by day, individuals by night. More than that, even Seven, who was an individual in her own right, was more relaxed and more at ease there. It seemed to be not dissimilar to a respite club or spa. It was antithetical to the Collective and to the Queen.
Seven and the crew of Voyager were able to liberate hundreds of drones from the Collective and dealt a heavy blow to the Queen's plans for domination. This did, however, expose a weakness at the heart of these interactions. With the continued exposure that Star Trek Voyager was giving the Borg, they lost their mystery and position of fear in the franchise. Certainly they were still an evil and deadly foe, but each time that Voyager survived an attack, it lessened the Collective.
Gone were the days of the creatures who invaded the Federation. Gone were the frightening vampires of First Contact. Excellent and cold as Thompson's Borg Queen was, she had the power to send a fleet of vessels to capture Voyager and instead opted not to. The Borg needed a refresh.
3. The Borg Queen Vs. The Queen B
Star Trek Voyager's finale Endgame is a divisive episode. It undoubtedly ends abruptly and relies on Janeway Ex Machina to get the ship home, yet, it is an episode full of heart and feeling. I
t does feel like an episode that came at the end of a season that was never aired and perhaps would have benefitted from being stretched out over several more episodes - not to mention a longer coda - but there is an element of the story that is both critical and maddening and that is the crippling of the Borg.
For this episode, Alice Krige returns as the Borg Queen for the first time since Star Trek First Contact. She brings a very different dynamic to the show. She is more maternal and sensual once again, offering Seven the embrace of family rather than the return to the many. She shows anger and hate toward Admiral Janeway. She is full of emotion and this sets her aside from Thompson's Queen. There are plenty of arguments as to which actress played the role better but this story is somewhat hampered by this Queen who is full of emotion.
Compare these two Queens for a moment to Jack Torrance from The Shining. The novel's version sees Jack as a good man descending into hell. The movie's Jack is a clearly dangerous and disturbed man from the beginning. Both have their strengths and weaknesses.
Krige's Queen is full of feeling from the beginning and so her fear and final laugh at Admiral Janeway lacks what could have been a chilling arc for Thompson's colder Queen. Consider the impact had a cold, emotionless Queen suddenly began to melt before Admiral Janeway, looking in horror and her disassembling body, before turning with an insane smile to taunt Janeway about the death of her crew.
In another universe, perhaps.
Endgame allows the Borg to be overcome by the pathogen that Janeway introduces by allowing herself to be assimilated. It is never quite explained how this manages to do so much damage to the Borg but if the events of Star Trek Picard are any indication, the Borg are not gone. They are still out there.
2. Wait, The Borg Had A TARDIS?
No, this was not the long desired crossover between Star Trek and Doctor Who. Star Trek Enterprise does not have the same fanbase that is enjoyed by the other series. It was marred by issues from the beginning, stumbling through much of its first and second seasons, despite some solid talent both in front of and behind the camera.
One of the issues that faced it was the fact that it was a prequel series and so the audience knew that there was only so much in the way of threat that the galaxy could offer. Those slaves to canon knew that the Romulans couldn't appear. They knew that the Cardassians and the Breen, the Dominion and yes, the Borg would not be making appearances.
Loopholes. Thank God for Loopholes.
Enterprise's second season delivered the episode Regeneration and it succeeded where Star Trek Voyager had not: it made the Borg frightening again. Using the time travel as shown in Star Trek: First Contact, the story shows that wreckage of the Sphere had crashed into the Artic.
This wreckage is found by a team of scientists, who proceed to discover, defrost and revive several Borg drones. What follows is a genuinely tense hunt. Enterprise is recalled to find the ship that the unnamed aliens have escaped on to rescue the research crew. The entire audience knows there is no point in attempting a rescue but the crew don't know that. The chase begins,
Aided by a fantastic score by composer Brian Tyler, the Borg are back and are as close to the dread-inspiring creatures of Star Trek: First Contact that the audience has seen since. It is fitting that the franchise needed to travel into the past to make them frightening again. But the drones that face off against Captain Archer's crew are as menacing as any that had been seen in the Star Trek universe.
The Easter egg at the end of the episode is a little forced but ties the story into the wider narrative nicely.
1. The Borg of the Future
What remains to be seen is where Star Trek Picard is going to take the Borg into the 25th century. The Borg are clearly still operating as the characters on board the Artifact show real apprehension at the idea of the Collective regaining contact with the former drones on board.
What is the purpose of the experiments that the Romulans are conducting? What is Hugh's role in all of this? How will Seven's journey connect her back to the goings-on of the Romulan scientists.
One thing is certain - at this point in Star Trek's narrative, the Borg are still out there. They may have been severely weakened by Janeway's attack and the destruction of another Queen but they are not gone. Their space is vast and their technology is immense. If the Borg ever do decide to come in force, the Federation may not be able to put up much of a fight.
So what is Maddox's plan by introducing Soji to the Artifact and is it a way to finally defeat the Collective once and for all? Only time will tell. What is very exciting is the notion of Seven of Nine and Jean Luc Picard sitting down together, the two foremost experts on Borg behaviour and thinking.
If that doesn't reinvigorate the Borg in Star Trek, nothing can!