Star Trek: Unproduced Stories That Were Never Filmed
With Star Trek celebrating its 47th anniversary this month, now is the perfect time to reflect on what could have been. With 6 television incarnations, 12 movies and a seemingly never ending series of novels it could be argued that at somewhere or at sometime every story has been told in the Trek universe. Au contraire gentle reader! Today we take a look at stories that were envisioned, but never got past the conceptual stage... Kongo
In Gene Rodenberrys first draft proposal, Star Trek is. He proposed an episode called Kongo, where Uhura and Dr. McCoy encounter a planet where roles have been reversed and black people have enslaved whites. Star Trek writer David Gerrold said, "As a matter of fact, the idea was one that very definitely had been considered. A script version had even been written. And rewritten. And rewritten. The story involved a planet where blacks were the masters and whites were the slaves, but either the premise was too touchy for television or nobody could quite make it work.."
He Walked Among Us
Apparently comedian Milton Berle was a huge Star Trek fan and the producers of TOS wanted to get Uncle Milty on the show. Norman Spinrad (The Doomsday Machine) and Gene L. Coon (writer of fan favorite episodes Space Seed and The Devil in the Dark) penned a comedy that cast Milton Berle as a Federation Sociologist and health nut who takes over a primitive planet. Spinrad was so displeased with the finished product he told Star Trek creator Gene Rodenberry, dont embarrass the show by shooting this piece of s**t. (ST Monthly Issue 26) Miss Gulliver
An episode centered on a woman who, after a medical experiment becomes a giant. The script ends with her boyfriend being turned into a giant and joining her to settle a planet. There, they would have presumably grown a civilization of behemoths who would have replaced Khan and his augments as the villains of Star Trek II.
Star Trek: The Academy Years/The First Adventure
Conceived as a means to not only reinvigorate the franchise, but also to save money by recasting TOS characters, Harve Bennett (ST II and III) and David Lougherys look at the early years of the Enterprise crew was originally intended as Star Trek 6. Kirk, a brash cocky Iowa farm boy, Spock an alien outsider and a 30 year old McCoy seeking answers after euthanizing his father, all meet at Star Fleet Academy. The script called for the trio and their fellow TOS characters to end up on The Enterprise and assume leadership roles after the Captain and senior officers are killed. Harve Bennet was said to have been considering casting Ethan Hawke as Kirk and John Cusack as Spock. Gene Rodenberry and the original series cast were said to have vigorously campaigned against the project and following a change in management at the studio, the film was scrapped.
DS9: The Musical
Ronald D. Moores idea involved a virus that would infect the crew and force them to communicate only in song. Can we do a laugh for just one episode? they fought against it and fought against it and fought against it. STVOY: Janeway on Trial
Ronald D. Moore makes his second appearance on this list with a story that would have seen the Voyager crew mutiny and put Captain Janeway on trial. With a blended Federation/Marquis crew, Voyager had a golden opportunity to ask the question, do Starfleets ideals and values still apply when times are desperate? Janeway requiring her crew to stick by Star Fleet rules even at great personal cost, could have led to a mutiny and a great story. Moore wanted to challenge the concept of Voyager and provide Janeway actress Kate Mulgrew with the opportunity to do more with the character, but it was not to be. Moores Battlestar Galactica ran with the concept of a mutiny aboard the Galactica in Season 4 (A Disquiet Follows My Soul, The Oath, Blood on The Scales) which saw key characters take sides over the direction of the rag tag, fugitive fleet, in a great story arc and showed how much of an opportunity was missed on STVOY.
Star Trek: Enterprise Season 5
Enterprise joins Star Trek the Original Series as the only Star Trek shows to ever be cancelled. Despite being in such prestigious company, TOS kicked off 47 years of the franchise while Enterprise nearly killed it. While the program had ironically enough, seemed to be tapping into its potential as a prequel to TOS, it could not generate sufficient ratings to justify its existence. Show Runner Manny Cottos vision of Season 5 however offered an intriguing and even deeper look into the early years of the United Federation of Planets. Among the stories that never made it to the screen: The Return of Captain Kirk William Shatner had pitched a story that involved Enterprise stumbling upon a time and dimensionally displaced Mirror Universe Tiberius Kirk. During the course of the episode it would be revealed that there was no Mirror Universe for him to return to as it had not been created yet. This would lead to Archer working with Kirk to determine where and when the Mirror Universe was formed and making sure it comes into existence. Another proposed idea saw William Shatner playing Enterprises chef, a Kirk look-alike dragged into the Temporal Cold War and needed to fill in for Kirk at a pivotal point in history. Unable to reach an agreement with Shatner, both stories ended up on the rubbish heap. The Borg BeginsGoing to the well one more time with the overused and watered down Borg was on the cards. This story would have seen the secret origin of the Borg Queen with Alice Krige returning to Star Trek as a Starfleet Medical Officer assimilated by the Borg from Season 2s Regeneration Crossover with Doctor Who While later depicted in comic form, two of science fictions greatest and longest lived franchises had never teamed up before. Russell T. Davis former showrunner for Doctor Who has confirmed that had Enterprise not been cancelled, he would have been looking to bring the Tardis into Federation Space. The First Live Action Appearance Of The Kzinti Donated by author Larry Niven to the universe of Star Trek via the Animated Series, the feline enemies of the Federation had never made it to the live action big or little screens. A script entitled Kilkenny Cats, writer Jimmy Diggs said ... Captain Archer encounters the Kzinti after an 80 year period of no contact with the Federation. Larry Niven loved it, D.C. Fontana and Andre Bormanis both story edited the script and signed on the final draft. This story may be resurrected however as part of the fan produced Star Trek Phase II project.
Star Trek: Reboot The Universe
Over the decades, Star Trek has become so insular, so strictly dened, and placed so many layers upon itself that some of the essence of what made us love it in the rst place has been lost. The all-too-reasonable desire to protect the franchise may now be the cause of its stagnation. (Star Trek Re-Boot the Universe. A Proposal for Re-Imagining the First Five Year Mission) J. Michael Straczynski (Babylon 5) and Bryce Zabel (Dark Skies) conceived of a separate universe where Star Trek could start from scratch and be re-imagined while keeping the original universe intact and untouched. Envisioned as taking the characters, settings and storylines from TOS and updating them with modern television storytelling techniques, the pilot would have told how Kirk, Spock and McCoy met and of Kirks ascension to the Captains chair. Intended as a 5 year series, each season would have captured a year in the life of the Enterprises crew with a definitive ending and a return to Earth at the end of the series. Like TOS this re-imagined series would have tapped into prominent sci-fi and horror writers such as Stephen King, Neil Gaiman, Ann Rice and Michael Crichton.
Star Trek: The Beginning
Featuring characters new to the Star Trek Universe and set during the Earth-Romulan War, this movie would have been the 11th Star Trek film, the first of a planned trilogy and bridged the gap between Star Trek: Enterprise and TOS. The story would have focused on Tiberius Chase who may have been revealed as an ancestor of Captain Kirk. The Chase Familys affiliation with anti-alien groups would have to be overcome as he looked to be accepted into Star Fleet on the eve of a massive Romulan attack on Earth. Erik Jendresen, writer of HBOs Band of Brothers penned the script which also featured appearances by Spocks grandfather and Jeffrey Combs Andorian character Shran from Star Trek: Enterprise. This film was killed following regime change, at Paramount.
Star Trek: Federation
In this pitch for a series that would have been produced by Bryan Singer (X Men, Superman Returns), the fall and rise of the United Federation of Planets would have been the setting for a new Kirk, a new Enterprise and crew. In an era where the Federation is in decline, the Ferengi are the dominant Superpower and Vulcan has left the Federation to reunify with the Romulans, The Enterprise would be tasked with recapturing the spirit of the Federations glory days. Writer Christopher McQuarrie and producer Robert Meyer Burnetts 25 page proposal was scrapped without being submitted to Paramount after the announcement of JJ Abrams reboot film. Conclusion After 47 years, Star Trek continues to entertain, excite and inspire fans around the world. For every story that made the cut, there are those that ended up for whatever reason, trapped on the page or in the imagination of the writers. In some cases, the fans have been cheated of great stories, innovative concepts and performances by beloved actors. Others, luckily never saw the light of day! Heres to another 47 years of Star Trek!