Star Trek: Worst 11 Crossover Episodes

One of the best events of a Star Trek series is the fan-serving crossover episodes, where characters from one series appear in another. These have occurred in all the modern series and whole-heartedly deserve their status as prestigious TV events, given how they unify fanbases, and their inevitable effect on ratings. And while some appearances were brief (such as Commander Riker in the Voyager episode Death Wish), others had the entire episode built around them - like Sarek - and the results have often been a mixed bag, despite how well the idea of cross-overs is invariably received. Inevitably, not all of the crossovers were such a good idea - like THAT Enterprise episode. And in other cases we've had very brief nods to the fans with thirty second appearances in episodes such as Quark turning up in Star Trek: The Next Generation - although he was also meant to appear in Star Trek: Insurrection but the scene was cut. Other episodes were just unsatisfying, like Sons of Mogh in Deep Space Nine. The best episodes are certainly an easier prospect to run through, and we will offer that rundown after this article, but to commemorate the fact that not every episode can be as great as perhaps was intended, we've compiled a list of the worst crossover episodes in Star Trek history. But of course, by virtue of the quality of the top 10 there are some good episodes in here - and remember to keep a key eye out in the future for when our run-down of the ten best Star Trek cross-over episodes is posted.

11. Emissary (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)

Emissary was the pilot of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine; it turned the crossover cameo in a Star Trek pilot into an expectation. A lot of set up occurs in this episode but some of the more interesting scenes are those with Commander Sisko and Captain Picard. You see, at the start there is quite a bit of animosity between Sisko and Picard, as while Picard was assimilated by the Borg during The Best Of Both Worlds, the Borg destroyed the USS Saratoga resulting in the death of Sisko's wife. The Picard appearances bookend Emissary in order to show the character growth of Sisko during the events that occur in the episode. It was initially planned for there to be a major crossover episode with Deep Space Nine and the Enterprise-D for the end of the first series of DS9. This didn't happen (unfortunately for us crossover fans), and instead the first series was closed with In The Hands Of The Prophets instead. Emissary is the best Star Trek pilot when considered in hindsight, but because some crossover episodes are of such high quality that it pushes this one down to the worst list. A shame really, because I'm sure this would appear in many people's top 20 lists for DS9.

10. Caretaker (Star Trek: Voyager)

Caretaker took the approach of having Deep Space Nine appear as a location at the start of the episode with Quark and Morn both making very brief appearances. Of course, one little crossover point which is missed sometimes is the character of Gul Evek €“ who appeared in Voyager, Deep Space Nine and The Next Generation. Caretaker simply wasn't as good as Emissary from Deep Space Nine, and much like The Walking Dead €“ it spent an odd volume of time with the cast on a farm. The two-part episode really dragged in the middle until Harry Kim and B'lanna Torres finally get back on-board Voyager. And frankly, destroying the Maquis vessel just made no sense in that manner at all. The entire episode felt like a missed opportunity. The crossover element of Caretaker was just to get the ball rolling for Voyager. Of course towards the later series you would have two TNG characters appearing on a semi-regular basis to the extent that Reginald Barclay ended up appearing in more episodes of Voyager than he did in TNG. Whilst those could be considered crossovers at the start, by the time Troi appeared for the fourth time it was less a crossover and more a recurring character.

9. Encounter At Farpoint (Star Trek: The Next Generation)

Encounter At Farpoint was the pilot episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation and launched a continuous period of some eighteen years of Star Trek on television until the final episode of Star Trek: Enterprise. It isn't a traditional crossover story at all, but does feature a cameo from the late DeForest Kelley as Admiral McCoy. Kelley refused to take anything more than the scale rate of pay for appearing in the episode. He felt that this was a way to say thank you for Star Trek and hoped that his appearance would boost ratings and publicity for the new series. Apart from this and a mention of Captain Kirk's Enterprise in The Naked Now, this would be the only inclusion of any elements seen in The Original Series for some time to come. Farpoint is looked upon fondly, due to it being the pilot of TNG. But really, it isn't a particular fabulous episode much like the other episodes in the first season. This was partly in how it was written €“ the Q storyline was shoehorned into the story in order to expand it to a two-part episode and so it just didn't fit with the other story.

8. Q-Less (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)

Q-Less was a direct sequel to The Next Generation episode Qpid and featured the return of Q and Vash, in their only appearance in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. It was the last of three appearances in the franchise for Vash, but Q would make a couple more appearances in The Next Generation as well as a bunch in Voyager. Much like Q's interactions with Picard has the stand out scene of the court room; the entity's sole appearance alongside Sisko does too. But this involved Sisko punching him in the face. Probably one of the most memorable and funny moments from the first season of DS9. Q was a bit untapped for DS9 mostly because we just didn't get a sense of a similar relationship with Sisko that he had with Picard and would later have with Janeway. We never really got to find out what the Prophets or Q thought of each other or if there was any relationship between the two. The only problem is that how do you explain Q coming back again and again to DS9 €“ and the character wouldn't have fitted in at all during the Dominion Wars seasons.

7. Broken Bow (Star Trek: Enterprise)

Broken Bow didn't actually have a crossover from another series as such €“ the actor who appeared was from the film Star Trek: First Contact. James Cromwell's appearance as Zefram Cochrane was purely a cameo more than anything else and the character didn't do anything or really affect anything in this episode. There is simply so much going on in this episode that the cameo gets lost in the mix. Broken Bow did hold up a lot of promise for Enterprise €“ but it wasn't at all what the producers wanted to make as the original premise for the entire first season was effectively covered in this episode. Season one would have seen the construction of the Enterprise and returning their Klingon to the homeworld. Arguably it would have made for a much better season one. Admittedly the producers by this point were stuck with tradition. It was expected for there to be some sort of crossover as Broken Bow was a pilot of a new Star Trek series. The only characters who appeared in an earlier setting than Enterprise (other than the various 20th and 21st century time travel episodes) were those in Star Trek: First Contact and Cochrane was the obvious route.

6. False Profits (Star Trek: Voyager)

This is probably one of the least noticed crossover episodes as it didn't feature any well-known stars from a different Star Trek series. False Profits was a Voyager episode which acted as a sequel to The Next Generation episode The Price. Both of those episodes featured the Ferengi characters of Arridor and Kol. While Dan Shor came back to play the part of Arridor, Kol was a non-speaking role in the first episode and so was re-cast for Voyager. After being stranded at the other end of a wormhole in the TNG episode, the Ferengi arrive at a planet and immediately pose as gods leaving Voyager with a conundrum about how to remove them. False Profits was an interesting follow-up to The Price, but didn't deliver the crossover spectacle that we've come to expect. The problem with False Profits is just that there is nothing to stand out, and it ends up being a fairly average Voyager episode. You know what I mean, it involves some funny make-up for Neelix (who appears as a Ferengi) and some scenes that I can only describe as shenanigans. There were some good Ferengi episodes in Deep Space Nine, and this isn't even in their league.

5. Birthright (Star Trek: The Next Generation)

One of the two stories in Birthright has Data working alongside Julian Bashir when the Enterprise visits Deep Space Nine. The android is caught by an energy discharge and begins to dream €“ well that's our crossover. It wasn't originally intended to have Bashir appear in the episode, instead it was meant to be Jadzia Dax €“ but Terry Farrell was busy filming the Deep Space Nine episode Move Along Home. It is a blessing that Birthright isn't as bad as Move Along Home, but neither of the two stories are that engaging. On the one hand, you have Worf investigating a colony of Klingon/Romulan hybrids and in the other story you have Data dreaming about his father being a blacksmith. While both stories seem like they could have had ongoing effects to the characters, neither are ever mentioned again. Another actor who is better known for a different role in the franchise also appears in this episode - James Cromwell. He appears as Zefram Cochrane in Star Trek: First Contact and appears in Birthright as Jaglom Shrek, but is barely recognisable under the makeup. His part was to have been bigger in this two-part episode, but he broke his leg between the first and second parts and he had to be written out.

4. Sons Of Mogh (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)

Sons Of Mogh featured the return of Kurn, the brother of Worf, in his only appearance in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Kurn had a bit of a character arc alongside Worf in his Star Trek: The Next Generation appearances, and frankly it is always good to see Tony Todd on screen. Just take a look at his other appearance in DS9 as an older Jake Sisko in The Visitor if you want a look at what Todd can do. This episode was a proper crossover, but wasn't much of a surprise as since Worf joined the crew of DS9 it was just a matter of time before his brother showed up. Although Kurn appearing was initially pleasing, it just seems very out of character to find that he wanted to die because of the dishonor to his house €“ something he had dealt with before. Kurn ends the episode with his mind wiped and his face changed, and with no idea left that he is Worf's brother. It still would have been fairly easy to revisit the character in later episodes despite the memory loss, but it was a plot point that was left open which the writers never returned to.

3. Past Prologue (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)

The first of two mentions of the Duras sisters in this list; three episodes into Deep Space Nine and they made their only DS9 appearance in Past Prologue. This is an appearance that sometimes gets overlooked because the episode is remembered for a different reason €“ it features the first appearance of Garek. The Klingons are selling bomb making chemicals to a Bajoran terrorist who is seeking to permanently close the wormhole so that Bajor will be left alone by both the Federation and the Cardassians. The episode has some highlights, but it is a mostly Kira driven episode rather than a proper crossover. Including the Duras sisters was a nice touch, but really it is another nod to the fans rather than anything interesting. They could have been simply replaced by new characters and there would have been no difference to the plot. While it was an interesting episode to give an indication that not all Bajorans were fond of the Federation, it just didn't gel. While it was meant to introduce Garek, it actually ended up being the character's only appearance during season one. It was simply one of those "dodgy aliens turn up on the station and meddle" episodes.

2. Firstborn (Star Trek: The Next Generation)

Firstborn is that Worf/Alexander episode of The Next Generation that featured an Alexander from the future coming back in time to make his younger self become a warrior in order to prevent the murder of Worf. All in all, it's actually an interesting episode which is something akin to Deep Space Nine's The Visitor €“ although not nearly held up to such high esteem. It is an Alexander heavy episode, which isn't necessarily a good thing. While this isn't as bad as a Fistful of Datas or Cost of Living, it isn't great in hindsight. What makes it even less interesting or relevant is that Alexander later appeared in DS9 having not taken the path that the future Alexander here was concerned about. It features a very brief cameo from Quark, as the Enterprise crew are investigating the actions of the Duras sisters and call on him to find out some information. He appears for a single conversation on the view screen of the Enterprise. But the guess the point of this episode wasn't to have it be a crossover. It's an interesting take on the idea proposed by The Visitor but misses out because it didn't have Tony Todd.

1. These Are The Voyages... (Star Trek: Enterprise)

These Are The Voyages... had so many issues that it's difficult to list them all. The premise itself was OK €“ the final adventure of the Enterprise NX-01 is watched on the holodeck of the Enterprise-D. But it was riddled with problems. The romance between T'Pol and Trip which had been built up for two years was totally brushed aside. Despite the course of several years having passed since the previous episode, the entire Enterprise crew (and the ship for that matter) looked exactly the same. Plus both Jonathan Frakes and Marina Sirtis are simply a great deal older than during The Pegasus €“ the episode that the holodeck scenes were meant to be during. It isn't their fault, and in fact Brent Spiner didn't appear in person as Data as he thought he was too old for the part at the time. Plus you have the matter of Trip's death €“ which was just plain stupid, to the extent that they've tried to rectify it in the novelizations following the end of the series. All in all, the episode is just a silly way to force some TNG into Enterprise, and Rick Berman and Brannon Braga should be ashamed. It's not just the worst crossover episode, but a contender for the worst episode of the franchise, period. Join us next time as we continue to count down the crossover episodes of Star Trek, as we hit the top 10. There's plenty of quality episodes to count yet - Trials and Tribble-ations, Timeless and Unification just to name a few.

Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm a pop culture addict. Television, cinema, comics, games - you name it, and I've done it. Or at least read the plot synopsis on Wikipedia.