Stranger Things: Every Main Character Ranked Worst To Best

Will your favourite Hawkins resident come out on top or are they nothing more than Demogorgon food?

Stranger Things
Netflix

Netflix already had quite a few hits under their belt by 2016. Orange is the New Black, House of Cards, Daredevil, Jessica Jones. But when Stranger Things first premiered that year, it was nothing like the streaming service had ever seen before.

This wasn't just a popular show in online circles. The story of the vanishing of Will Byers took the entire world by storm with its masterful blend of eighties nostalgia and otherworldly horror. Seasons two and three have also been major smash hits, both pulling in Netflix's highest audience figures in their respective release years.

But while you may come for the aesthetic qualities of the show, you stick around for the characters. From the tortured psychic Eleven to the gruff chief of police Jim Hopper, Hawkins is a town full of a wide array of people to meet, both good and bad.

So who's the favourite? Who's the least favourite? And who's just sort of...okay?

15. Billy Hargrove

Billy Hargrove
Netflix

Nobody likes a bully and as much as Billy Hargrove may have garnered our sympathies in season three by sacrificing his life to save his stepsister Max, that doesn’t change the fact that he was still a deeply awful person for much of his runtime.

His character in season two is pretty much exclusively defined by his cruelty, from brutally assaulting Steve Harrington to the point of unconsciousness to his racist attacks on Lucas Sinclair, a literal child.

There are reasons given for his mean streak throughout the show, in an attempt to garner our sympathies. The main one is his father, Neil, who is shown emotionally and physically abusing his son. This abuse is what prompted Billy's mother to abandon the family when he was about ten years old, leaving him with only fond holiday memories of her.

But this is not an excuse for his bad behaviour and while, again, his last stand against the Mind Flayer does not go unappreciated, he is simply the member of the main cast who has done the worst things on screen.


14. Will Byers

Stranger Things Will Byers
Netflix

Now obviously Will is a lot less morally bankrupt than Billy, and he’s not this low in the list for being an inherently bad person. Simply put, he's down here because he's the least developed member of the main cast.

Even Billy, for all his flaws, has some character development and personality. Will seems to be much the same in season three as he is in season one: nervous, quiet, and never one to take charge of a situation. In the first run of episodes, he was the inciting incident for the main cast’s adventures and barely appeared himself. In season two, while his screen time was drastically increased, he again didn’t have much more to do than act as a walking plot device.

Season three appears to be even less keen to utilise him, as for most of the season he is relegated to informing the other characters when the Mind Flayer is nearby by dramatically rubbing his neck.

Hopefully, poor Will gets a little more to do in the fourth season than just scream or look worried.


13. Jonathan Byers

Stranger Things Jonathon Byers
Netflix

Jonathan suffers from much the same problem as his little brother does. A lack of progression in his character from the first season. He does admittedly get a decent amount of focus in those first episodes, allowing him to show his caring side as he struggles to keep his mother sane as they hunt for their missing family member.

The problem is that he starts out as an unconfident outcast with a gentler side and then just…stays there. It’s been the same old Jonathan for three years now, to the point where you can predict almost exactly how he is going to act in any given episode.

His actor Charlie Heaton clearly shows he has range in the brief moments where Jonathan is allowed to break the mould a little, so let’s hope that season four lets the eldest Byers son explore a side of himself that we haven’t seen before.

And also, him photographing Nancy getting changed is still extremely creepy.


12. Nancy Wheeler

Stranger Things Nancy Wheeler
Netflix

Nancy was kind of annoying in season one, which, admittedly, was the point. Her arc focused on her learning to care about more than just superficial high school things through investigating the disappearance of her best friend Barb with Jonathan. It also made sense that her season two plot line would focus on her still feeling guilty about Barb and attempting to get some real justice for her, as the show’s fans cried for throughout season one.

Still, her relationship with Jonathan throughout seasons two and three just didn't develop interestingly enough to justify it’s continued existence and her investigative journalism plot line in season three also proved itself to be only tangentially related to what the rest of the cast were up to.

While it was nice to see Nancy grow up and come out of her shell, as well as come to terms with her harrowing experiences, let’s hope that she finds herself a little less pushed to the side in season four.


11. Erica Sinclair

Stranger Things Erica Sinclair
Netflix

Erica is a divisive character among Stranger Things fans, to say the least. In season two, she only appeared sporadically to taunt her older brother Lucas and to frustrate Dustin’s efforts to contact him about Dart’s ongoing mutation. Seeing as the latter action could’ve put our main characters in serious danger, this naturally didn’t earn her many cheerleaders.

Her reputation has increased with season three and it is somewhat deserved. She does still have her rather irritating moments, a bizarrely placed pro-capitalism rant earning her some further scorn, but she does prove herself useful in stopping the unethical actions of the Soviet military base hidden underneath the Starcourt Mall.

She is relatively low on this list because of her divisiveness. Ultimately, whether you find her constant snarky remarks and insults to be hilarious or off-putting is entirely up to you. It is perhaps worth remembering, however, that she's only ten years old, so any criticism of her personality should go easy on the vitriol.


10. Max Mayfield

Stranger Things Max Mayfield
Netflix

Max, or ‘MADMAX’ as she's known around Hawkins’ Palace Arcade, was initially cold towards the middle school gang of Mike, Will, Dustin and Lucas. To be fair, their way of asking her to join their friend group was stalking her from afar and then awkwardly asking her to trick or treat with them. Still, she accepted and soon became friends with the group. She was even eventually allowed to learn the truth about Eleven and the Upside Down.

Max was a welcome addition to season two who went from bullied little stepsister to someone not afraid to stand up to Billy when he was endangering her new friends. The only reason she’s not higher on this list is because season three largely didn’t allow her that same agency. She always felt like she was part of Eleven or Billy’s emotional arcs rather than having a true one of her own.

While these were compelling arcs, it’s a shame that Max couldn’t have taken a more active role in her own story this time round.


9. Joyce Byers

Stranger Things 3 Joyce Byers
Netflix

Winona Ryder is obviously one of the defining actresses of Gen X cinema and Stranger Things proves that she hasn’t lost her touch one bit. While some critics felt that Joyce’s constant state of hysteria in season one started to grate after a while, it made perfect sense for a mother terrified of losing her son forever to act that way and Ryder played it incredibly.

Admittedly, much like her sons, Joyce hasn’t exactly seen seismic shifts in her character since the first season, but her storylines in season two and three were still compelling, even if season two’s once again centred around her being worried about Will. Her obsessive quest to find out why the town’s magnets were losing their magnetism in season three offered a genuinely compelling mystery and made an excellent detective duo out of her and Jim Hopper.

Still, it wouldn’t hurt to see her actually calm and content with her life for once.


8. Mike Wheeler

Stranger Things 3 Mike Wheeler Finn Wolfhard
Netflix

Let the record show that Mike Wheeler gets more hate than he deserves. Yes, he can sometimes be a little overbearing and he has a habit of taking charge of situations whether his friends actually want him to or not, but it’s clear to see that this is all motivated by a genuine love for his friends and a desire to see everyone safe.

In season one, he’s the one leading the charge to find Will when most other people in the town, especially the adults, believe that he’s dead. In season two, he’s always right by Will’s side like a second big brother, making sure that he’s feeling alright every step of the way.

The way he cares for Eleven is also very sweet, even if them making googly eyes at each other for the entirety of season three does get a little annoying after a while.

Even though he’s growing up, Mike firmly remains the one in his friend group with the heart of gold.


7. Lucas Sinclair

Stranger Things Lucas Sinclair
Netflix

If Mike is the heart of the group, then Lucas is the head. While most of his friends will simply go with their gut while charging headfirst into danger, Lucas prefers to take a step back and actually think about things for a second. This is why it takes him a while to warm to Eleven in season one and you can’t really blame him for being wary of the bald girl with psychic powers who just stumbled out of the woods a few days ago.

It’s just a shame that as the seasons have gone on, Lucas has received less and less focus. In season one, he took matters into his own hands and discovered that the gate to the Upside Down was located at Hawkins Lab, but by season three, his sister is getting more screen time than him and he’s mostly there to get berated by his new girlfriend, Max.

Throwing fireworks at the Mind Flayer was still a highlight but Lucas taking charge of his own story in season four would be a welcome return to form for the character.


6. Eleven

Stranger Things Eleven
Netflix

If Stranger Things had to have a single main character, then it’s likely that Eleven would be the first choice. Who could forget the Halloween after the first season was released when bloody noses, shaved heads, and boxes of Eggo waffles were the must-have accessories? Watching Eleven go from a victim of abuse at the hands of the evil Dr. Brenner to someone willing to sacrifice it all for her new friends was one of the best parts of the first season.

Admittedly, her storyline faltered somewhat in the second season. A misunderstanding from an interaction between Mike and Max resulting in a season-long solo road trip to find herself wasn’t the most compelling thing to watch. The less said about that runaway gang episode the better.

But still, she’s Eleven. She’s the heart and soul of the show, and the reason why many of these people became such firm friends in the first place. Fingers crossed that she makes it to the end of the show in one place because god knows she deserves it.


5. Dustin Henderson

Stranger Things Dustin Henderson Gaten Matarazzo
Netflix

Stranger Things can be a pretty dark show. From young boys being kidnapped by Lovecraftian horrors from another dimension to more down to earth evils like child abuse, this show isn’t always easy viewing. So thank god that we have Dustin Henderson around to remind us that we need to just take a break and laugh sometimes. Dustin is the clown of the group, always ready to crack a joke to cheer his friends up when they need it.

In both seasons two and three, his relationship with Steve Harrington is second to none. In the same way that Dustin provides comfort to his friends, Steven provides advice to Dustin and helps him to be the best version of himself possible.

He’s also a dab hand at inventions, coming back from summer camp with amazing inventions like a homemade ham radio which he can use to communicate his new girlfriend, Suzy. It’s a shame that none of his friends really appreciate these inventions that much but don’t worry Dustin, we do.


4. Jim Hopper

Hopper Stranger Things
Netflix

Hawkins Chief Jim Hopper initially starts out as somewhat of an obstruction to the boys and their investigation into what happened to Will, but thankfully, he’s not the sort of authority figure that refuses to listen to reason. Once he discovers what’s really going at Hawkins Lab, he’s more committed to getting the truth than anyone else and even ends up venturing into the Upside Down himself to retrieve Will.

His commitment to keeping the town safe is truly admirable and, from season two onwards, his attempts to parent Eleven to the best of his ability. We can see how heart-breaking it was for him to lose his first daughter to cancer and how he doesn’t want to waste this second chance he’s been given.

Despite his apparent death by heroic sacrifice at the end of season three, he has been confirmed to appear in season four and showed up in a recent teaser trailer as a prisoner of the Soviet Union. How he got all the way to Russia from Indiana and how he’ll escape is something that we’ll just have to wait to find out.


3. Robin Buckley

Stranger Things Robin
Netflix

Even with the show on its third season, the Duffer Brothers still have the ability to bring in new main characters that steal everyone's hearts. One of these characters would be Robin.

Robin enters the show like quite a few characters before her have, initially sceptical of all of the odd goings-on around Hawkins and often rolling her eyes at the antics of Steve and Dustin. She soon proves herself however to be a worthwhile addition to the team, getting herself captured by psychopathic Soviet soldiers in order to keep her friends safe. Her hilarious antics with Steve while they’re both on Russian drugs and her tenderly coming out as gay to him are fan favourite moments, for good reason.

Robin is the kind of character that you wish had been there from season one. Hopefully season four will keep her at the forefront of the action.


2. Bob Newby

Stranger Things Bob Newby
Netflix

Speaking of characters that you wish had been there since season one, enter Bob Newby. He’s the perfect boyfriend for Joyce and the perfect surrogate father for Will and Jonathan. Caring, funny and just the right amount of nerdy.

So, of course he gets brutally murdered by a Demodog before the end of his first season. Apparently the Byers family aren't allowed to be happy for even one second.

Bob proved himself to be more than just a nice side character as well. When our heroes needed his help figuring out Will’s strange new drawings, he used his cartography skills to work out that they were all showing an underground map of Hawkins. Later, he also used his mastery of the BASIC programme language to restore the power to Hawkins Lab and reverse the lockdown procedures that trapped everyone inside.

Bob Newby only ever said that he was a superhero as a joke, but he proved himself more than worthy of that title. His brief flashback cameo in the third season proves how much he is missed by not only Joyce, but also by everyone else who knew him.


1. Steve Harrington

Steve Harrington Stranger Things
Netflix

Could it really be anyone else?

If you asked most Stranger Things fans back in 2016 who their least favourite character was, Steve would probably be a common answer. These days, you’d be hard pressed to find someone who isn’t absolutely in love with the high school jock turned bat-wielding hero.

Steve was something of a Billy Hargrove in the first season, although much less sociopathic. All he cared about was ditching school and getting with Nancy, then everything changed when he first swung that baseball bat full of nails at the Demogorgon.

In season two, the seriousness with which he took his role as child carer while the adults went off to Hawkins Lab earned him even more fan adoration. His brotherly relationship with Dustin especially is something that fans just can’t get enough of.

Steve and his amazing Farrah Fawcett spray hair have more than earned their spot at the top of this list and if anything happens to him in season four, Netflix will likely find themselves buried under a mountain of fan complaints. They have been warned.


Watch Next


The IMPOSSIBLE Stranger Things Quiz

stranger things season 3
Netflix

1. What Was The Show Originally Titled?

Contributor

Owen Davies hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.