Stranger Things Season 4: Volume 2 Review - 8 Ups & 2 Downs
Stranger Things' fourth season wraps up in thrilling - if overlong - fashion.
Though Netflix subscribers are used to their binge-worthy all-at-once season drops, the streamer decided to experiment with the fourth season of their biggest breakout hit, Stranger Things, by releasing it in two separate batches.
Season 4 Volume 1 landed back in late May, and while suffering from an outrageously over-extended runtime, largely delivered the goods. Barely a month later Volume 2 has dropped, which despite consisting of just two episodes clocks in at almost four hours in length.
And so, it won't surprise many to learn that this conclusion to season four suffers from many of the same pacing issues of Volume 1, but as a more-than-feature-length capper to the season, it certainly lives up to the hype.
Fan reaction is likely to vary wildly on just how good these two new episodes are, but it's tough to imagine many coming away disappointed, especially with the show now driving towards its set-in-stone end point, what with the fifth season already being confirmed as its last.
But before we get into all the praise in this spoiler-free review, first here's what doesn't quite work...
Downs...
2. The Excessive Runtime & Uneven Pacing
This shouldn't be terribly surprising to anyone who tuned in for the fourth season's first volume, but Volume 2 once again suffers from an absurdly undisciplined runtime and all the egregious pacing issues that this entails.
The two episodes clock in at a combined total of around 3 hours and 50 minutes - almost an entire hour long than Avengers: Endgame, for reference - and while there's a lot of great material packed into those hours, some editing wouldn't have gone amiss.
It's clear that the Duffer Brothers had nobody breathing down their necks telling them what to cut, which while great in theory also ensures that there's nobody challenging them to "kill their darlings" and deliver a more refined piece of work.
Too often over the course of these four hours the narrative goes around in circles, new subplots and additional minor antagonists feel like padding, and hilariously self-indulgent monologues from heroes and villains alike make it a rather exhausting sit.
In the vein of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, this is a season that feels like it's about to end several times before it actually does, proving to be perhaps the most blatant example of streaming TV's increasing tendency for stamina-sapping, bloated storytelling.
1. The Plots Vary Wildly In Quality
Much like Volume 1, the show's massive ensemble cast continues to be portioned off into a number of disparate, tangentially related plots, which again are of wildly variant quality here.
While the Hawkins kids dealing with the villainous Vecna (Jamie Campbell Bower) is the primary motivating thread and by far the most compelling one, Hopper (David Harbour) and Joyce's (Winona Ryder) journey back home continues to be only sporadically involving, and the road trip with the Byers brothers and Mike (Finn Wolfhard) again fails to do much interesting with them.
It's not much of a spoiler to say that there is eventually a convergence of these plots, yet it comes far too late in the season to change the perception that splitting the cast up for so long harmed the overall story's consistency.
While it's fair to say that Will (Noah Schnapp) and Jonathan (Charlie Heaton) are among the least-interesting characters on the show, it's still a shame that so little is done with them.
Aside from one great heart-to-heart scene together, they basically feel like furniture here, and Mike doesn't fare much better either.
If you can accept these gripes - and you surely can - Season 4 Volume 2 is absolutely worth your time. So, here's what it gets right...
Ups...
8. Vecna Cements Himself As The Series' Best Villain
Though Volume 1 did a stellar job of introducing us to the terrifying new antagonist Vecna, Volume 2 confirms him beyond any doubt as the series' strongest villain to date.
Between Jamie Campbell Bower's sublimely creepy performance and some fantastic effects work, Vecna is a legitimately terrifying presence whenever he's on screen, differentiating himself from the more conventional, beastly antagonists in prior seasons.
If Volume 1 proved the horrific damage he was capable of causing, he's elevated to full-on supervillain status in Volume 2, basically serving as the Thanos of the Stranger Things world - a seemingly unstoppable tyrant mercilessly committed to his destructive cause.
One of the few benefits of this season's expanded runtime is how much room it gives Vecna to breathe and be developed as a distinct villain in his own right.
That carries through to these two new episodes, which shed further light on his backstory and motivations.
7. The Satisfyingly High Stakes
Even though we all know that Stranger Things has been confirmed for a fifth and final season, season four's life-or-death stakes feel positively palpable after being built up so successfully in Volume 1.
Throughout Volume 2 there's a pervading feeling of danger and unpredictability, that just about any of our favourite characters could die.
This is aided by the Duffer Brothers quite sensibly giving almost every major character a dramatic chip on their shoulder - be it a traumatic backstory or unresolved personal conflict - which would make their death poetically tragic.
While the decisions made in this regard won't please everyone, they nevertheless prove the show's commitment to keeping the audience on their toes and invested in the survival of these very mortal, very vulnerable characters.
6. The Cast Knocks It Out Of The Park (Again)
Perhaps the single strongest aspect of Stranger Things throughout its entire run so far has been the casting - there's not a single weak link among the bunch, and the Duffers clearly know how to get the best out of their colossal ensemble.
It's tough to pick obvious standouts from the pack, though as usual Millie Bobby Brown is fantastic as Eleven, Sadie Sink kills it as Max, and Maya Hawke is a hugely disarming comic relief presence as Robin.
Elsewhere Jamie Campbell Bower is exceptional as Vecna, and David Harbour and Winona Ryder clearly relish the opportunity to play off one another once again now that Hopper and Joyce have been reunited.
Though the show is straining to juggle all of its characters and cast members at this point, it's undeniable that everyone involved is giving it their all, no matter how scant their screen time might be.
5. The SUPERB Production Values
It's been reported that the budget for Stranger Things' fourth season was an eye-watering $30 million per episode, and while much of that went to the cast's renegotiated contracts, it's still plainly clear that a pretty penny was spent on the actual production itself.
Volume 2 confirms this to be one of the most lavishly produced seasons of TV ever made. Basically every single scene, even the most basic, dialogue-driven ones, have all the glossy sheen of a cinematic event.
Yet the show once again comes into its own where its atmosphere and set-pieces are concerned: the cinematography, visual effects, makeup, and sound design are all absolutely first-rate.
Given the apocalyptic extent of Vecna's crusade, it wouldn't have surprised anyone if there were some wonky VFX moments, yet from start to finish this is a supremely polished four hours of TV.
4. The Fantastic Needle Drops
What would any season of Stranger Things be without some insane needle drops? And while Volume 2 doesn't deliver any iconic musical moments on the level of Volume 1's beloved invocation of Kate Bush's "Running Up That Hill," there are still some outstanding musical selections throughout.
Without giving too much away, the soundtrack runs the gamut from Credence Clearwater Revival to Journey, Metallica, The Police, Ella Fitzgerald, and even Siouxsie and the Banshees.
And yes, you'll also get a few more chances to hear Kate Bush before the season is over - don't worry.
Several of these songs are integrated into the story in clever and unexpected ways, with some of the more iconic tracks even being remixed with the show's own distinctive synth score.
3. It's Packed With Meaningful Character Development
As overstuffed as Volume 2 absolutely is, that larger canvas does allow the Duffers more room to explore and develop their characters.
Numerous major character dynamics - namely Lucas (Caleb McLaughlin) and Max, Hopper and Joyce, Steve (Joe Keery) and Nancy (Natalia Dyer), and the Byers brothers - are given far more room to breathe than they were in Volume 1.
Perhaps the highlights character-wise, however, are Max reflecting on her guilt over her brother's death, and Eddie similarly reckoning with his failure to prevent Chrissy's (Grace Van Dien) demise.
Again, it's a difficult balancing act to do justice to such a huge roster of characters without undermining the overall narrative momentum, and while Volume 2 is far from perfect in that regard, fans should enjoy getting a greater glimpse into the interiors lives of its heroes.
2. The EPIC Action Sequences
Netflix promised that Volume 2 would deliver an epic conclusion to season four, and they certainly weren't lying.
Without going into too much detail, Volume 2 boasts some of the most mesmeric and downright thrilling action beats that Stranger Things has ever come up with.
If you thought seeing Eleven flip a van was something, just wait and see what she does to another type of vehicle here.
Elsewhere there's a magnificent set-piece involving Eddie and a guitar that's sure to turn a lot of younger viewers onto a certain classic heavy metal banger, and the inevitable showdown with Vecna more than lives up to the substantial hype.
Stranger Things has never been explicitly about action, but after so many hours of build-up in Volume 1, it's safe to say that the Duffers let loose with their most ambitious high-wire thrills to date.
1. It Delivers An AWESOME Setup For Season 5
No spoilers here, but rest assured that Volume 2 concludes with quite the spectacular setup for the fifth and final season.
The stakes and scale feels so high throughout season four that it's tough to consider where the Duffers could possibly take things for the future, but they've come up with an idea that's immediately compelling and feels like an organic extension of the story so far.
One suspects season five might rectify at least a few of the biggest issues fans and critics had about season four overall, and given the show's track record to date, it's looking likely that Stranger Things will end up going out on top - or close to it.
It's just a shame that, with season five not yet filming, we'll be waiting a good while for it.
Though with the Duffers already confirming that the final season will most likely feature a time jump, at least the cast's noticeable aging should be less of a distracting issue.