Supergirl Season 4: 3 Ups & 2 Downs From ‘Fallout’
When they go low, you go up, up and away!
Contains spoilers for Supergirl Season 4, Episode 2.
Last week, Supergirl returned to The CW with its impressive season premiere, setting up an interesting narrative revolving around the perception and rights of aliens in the United States of America, kick-starting a powerful conversation between some of is characters (and its viewers). It also teased us with the season's new threat, Agent Liberty, who spearheaded the anti-alien initiative along with his colleagues Mercy and Otis Graves.
However, the time for teasing was over in this week's outing, which saw President Olivia Marsdin (Lynda Carter) face the music as the world discovered that she was actually an alien. In a rather shocking turn of events, she willingly stood down to avoid chaos as a new president was sworn in. Unfortunately, Agent Liberty loves chaos and was willing to use Mercy to spread it for him.
With more powerful conversations, important messages and good old fashioned logic laced into its storylines, Supergirl once again proved that it's a force to be reckoned with and, aside from a minor issue here and there, it was a solid followup to its strong premiere. First, let's talk about the positives.
Contains spoilers.
Ups...
3. Brainy Finds His Humanity
We saw last week that Jesse Rath's Brainiac-5 was an incredibly pleasant full-time addition to the show. The 12th-level intellect's inability to comprehend human interaction has always been a source of comedy gold, and it's wise of the writers to continue giving us these hilarious moments. However, this week's episode allowed us to get to know Brainy in a completely different way.
When his image inducer was hacked, Brainy's true form was visible for all the world to see. While all the world did not see, the staff at his regular Pizzeria did, and they didn't react too well. They branded him an Earth traitor and even threatened violence until Nia Nal stepped in to diffuse the situation.
Brainy was visibly shaken and, it was only later that he realised he was genuinely hurt. He was hurt that somebody would judge him by his outward appearance. He was hurt that humanity turned on him because of who he truly is. He was hurt that his friend didn't accept him.
Not only was this another genius way for the writers to convey how important acceptance truly is, it gave Rath a chance to experiment with a different side of Brainy - and he truly excelled. Perhaps for the first time in his life, the character was experiencing genuine human emotion, and it was a well-executed development.
2. Nia, The Great
It's only been two episodes, and Nia Nal is already proving to be one of the standout aspects of Supergirl's fourth season. Having previously channelled her inner-Kara to become every bit as quirky and intuitive as the Girl Of Steel in the season premiere, this week's episode saw her steal the show altogether.
Outraged by the pizzeria's treatment of Brainy, she went to James Olsen and asked him to write an editorial about the importance of accepting aliens because acceptance is right. She then revealed that she was a transgender woman and recalled some of the instances in which she suffered from attacks and denials simply because of who she was, telling him that the hate-mobs and bullies needed to see what they had become.
It was a deeply personal moment that Nicole Maines delivered with perfection and it highlighted that nothing should prevent someone from being treated with respect. Through her words, she ensured that we all understood that being different is not an excuse to bully someone and that acceptance is everything.
Speaking of which...
1. Supergirl's Message Of Hope
At the episode's conclusion, Supergirl issued a touching statement that also delved into the importance of acceptance. She reminded her audience that where anyone was born doesn't matter because "we are all the same". But she wasn't just talking to the citizens of National City, she was talking to the show's entire audience. She was talking to us.
This is the perfect example of the writers tackling issues far deeper than just the show's main narrative. On the surface, Kara's statements were referring to aliens, but in reality, there are so many people who could identify with her words. She is reminding us all that it doesn't matter where you are from, who you are or who you love because these factors do not determine your character - your actions will do that.
Supergirl is undoubtedly one of the most socially relevant shows on television. Having already covered the importance of universal love and gun violence, it's now tackling what it means to be different in today's society and why we, as humans, should be accepting towards each other. Kara's message is one of hope and it challenges us all to overcome stereotypes and, in effect, make the world a better place.
If Supergirl ever wants to get a real message across to the viewers, all it has to do is get its leading lady in front of a camera. Melissa Benoist was as alluring as ever onscreen and it was impossible not to feel every single word she said.
And now to the negatives...
Downs...
2. Cat Grant, Where Are You?
Olivia Marsdin's resignation from her position as president certainly switched things up in this week's episode. As some of the anti-alien brigade were outraged by the fact that there was an alien in office, Nia Nal rightfully felt it was important to do something about it and went to CatCo Media's CEO, James Olsen. However, this only shone a light on an issue that was becoming increasingly obvious: where was Cat Grant in all of this?
The former CEO of CatCo is, in her own words, Queen of all media, and last season, it was revealed that she left her business behind to officially become President Marsdin's Press Secretary.
Thus, with the episode's emphasis on how the media should speak out for aliens, and Nia's belief that CatCo should do so, wouldn't it have made sense to at least refer to Cat? Is she even still the Press Secretary, or did President Baker choose a new one? If so, where is she?
While it's well-documented that Calista Flockhart is no longer a series regular, there were various ways to cover up this major plothole. Whether it was a video message or just a throwaway line about Cat's whereabouts, we need to know why she hasn't made her voice heard on the matter. She's the almighty Cat Grant, for goodness sake! Of course she has something to say about it.
1. Agent Jensen's Betrayal
"Maybe if I stare at Brainy real intense, people will understand my motivations..."
Perhaps Agent Jensen was thinking something like that when he betrayed the D.E.O and freed the associates of the anti-alien brigade. Or perhaps the writers were thinking that, by making Jensen overhear Alex's conversation with Brainy, his motivations would seem more relatable. Whatever the reasoning, Jensen's heel turn was a major misfire.
It's not that his betrayal lacked motivation - the episode had already informed us how fear can make good people react differently - it's that we just didn't know him enough to care. Agent Jensen was simply created to give this episode another purpose and allow the writers to free Mercy and Otis Graves. Before now, he didn't even exist.
It's commendable that the writers have used Jensen's betrayal to start conversations about differing views, but it would have been far more effective if it the betrayal came from a more significant character, or perhaps if they had even spent more time introducing the character subtly. The minute he began receiving prominence in the episode, it was pretty clear that he was going to have something to do - and it made the whole thing rather predictable.
Agent Jensen is nothing more than a plot device. His betrayal wasn't heart-breaking, earth-shattering or even remotely shocking because we, quite frankly, didn't care about him.
-
Did you enjoy this week's episode of Supergirl? Tell us in the comment section below.