Superman & Lois Review: 5 Ups & 2 Downs From 'Pilot'
The Man of Steel returns to TV in a triumphant premiere that takes the Arrowverse to new heights.
The Arrowverse has been a fixture of television for almost a decade, but the arrival of Superman and Lois ushers in a new era for it, allowing it to mature in a way that we haven't quite seen from The CW's shared universe as of yet.
A long overdue starring vehicle for Tyler Hoechlin's Man of Steel and Elizabeth 'Bitsie' Tulloch's Lois Lane, the show was years-in-the-making, with rumours of a Hoechlin-led series starting as far back as his first apperance on Supergirl in 2016. But Superman and Lois' arrival took what was expected and evolved it into something that none of us saw coming: A family drama with the Man of Steel at its heart.
The premiere set out to tell audiences a new side of Superman's well-documented story and it succeeded in doing that. But that's not all it did. Superman and Lois offered up a mature and surprisingly heartfelt reinvention of the Man of Steel's story that outshone much of what we've come to expect from these kinds of shows. And it proved that Hoechlin and Tulloch's long-awaited series was worth every second of that wait.
First, the negatives...
Downs...
2. A Heavy Intro
The premise of Superman and Lois revolves around the Kent family moving back to Smallville because things aren't going well for them in Metropolis and a tragedy ultimately forces the heroes to re-evaluate their lives in the city. Though that comes across incredibly well, it would be hard to deny that the opening act of the premiere leans pretty heavily on the emotional threads.
It does add a great deal to the plot and none of its feels superfluous in any way, but the amount of obstacles that the Kents must endure in the first 18 minutes of the episode does leave you a little emotionally exhausted quite early in. Sure, it hammers home the notion that life - and this show - doesn't always turn out like you expect it, but if it all transpired over a longer period of time, it might be a little, well, less heavy.
But that is the aim of Superman and Lois and it all paves the way for much more hopeful moments to come later in the premiere. So if those first 20 minutes do leave you feeling a little overwhelmed, it's definitely worth sticking with it because there's so much good after that.
1. Continuity Crisis
Non-Arrowverse fans unsure of whether or not they should start Superman and Lois out of fear that they might not understand it can rest easy knowing that it's easily accessible for anyone who hasn't watched the previous shows. The premiere doesn't make any reference to the wider Arrowverse (in spite of the fact that it now exists on Earth-Prime with the rest of the shows) and this allows it to stand on its own two feet right out of the gate.
While that, no doubt, makes watching it easier for non-Arrowverse fans, it does make it a little more difficult for those who are familiar with The CW's umbrella of superhero shows. Though it would have been nice to hear at least one reference to Supergirl, the real issue is the fact that it treats the post-Crisis On Infinite Earths timeline as canon without any actual reference to the change. So, instead of hearing about how Lois and Clark had their baby son Jonathan on Argo (like we saw in Supergirl), we see how they had twin boys on Earth instead.
Again, this made it so much easier for those unfamiliar with the complicated storytelling of the Arrowverse to enjoy the show but it does create the odd head-scratching moment for those of us who have been keeping up to date with the previous shows.
Now, for the positives...
Ups...
5. It Feels (And Looks) Like A Film
It didn't take long to notice that Superman and Lois has a drastically different look from the rest of the Arrowverse shows. If you watched the trailer, you probably already noticed it. From the black panels that give it a widescreen presentation to the more experimental cinematography and colour palette, the show looks like it belongs more on the big screen than the small one - and that absolutely works in its favour.
Superman and Lois Lane are larger-than-life characters but Superman and Lois tells something of a more contained story, so the fact that it's juxtaposed against this unexpected cinematic look results in that contained story feeling every bit as larger-than-life as those characters. And it imbues it with a presentation similar to that of the DCEU's Man of Steel while still maintaining all of the important qualities of those nostalgic Superman tales of old.
Superman and Lois looks like a movie and that sets it apart from most of the shows in its genre and it also highlights that family stories can be every bit as captivating as the heroic ones.
4. Impressive Visual Effects
Another major factor that instantly sets Superman and Lois apart from most of the offerings under that CW umbrella is the incredible visual effects that it boasts - and the show wastes little time showcasing them, with Superman swooping into action in both the opening and closing acts in scenes that make full use of the show's larger budget.
While previous Arrowverse offerings have certainly had impressive effects over the years, they are rarely able to sustain them because of the simple fact that they have more episodes and a smaller budget. That doesn't stop ambitious stories but it does often leave some of the effects looking a little lacklustre.
That's not an issue here because, like DC's Stargirl, The CW aren't the only ones contributing to the budget. With the help of HBO Max, they are able to produce a large-scale show befitting its titular superhero, providing amazing visual effects along the way. And it's just a shame that Supergirl was never given the same treatment because there is no doubt about it: Superman and Lois' special effects and CGI are out of this world!
3. The Performances
Superman and Lois may be titled after its primary duo, but if we're being completely honest, it's more of an ensemble piece. The show does, after all, center on the Kent clan, so that means that all four of them need to shine in order for the show to fully succeed. The cast ensures that is exactly what's going to happen.
We'll get into Hoechlin and Tulloch's offerings in more detail a little bit later on but it really must be said that they lead this pilot episode incredibly well. Of course, Hoechlin has the most to work with and he turns in a layered performance that is both powerful and subtle, convincingly painting a picture of a Superman that struggles with the normal aspects of life. But Tulloch gives him a run for his money at every opportunity, giving us a performance that is firm and captivating but also reserved and heartfelt - all the things that the show's voice of reason needs to be.
Jordan Elsass and Alex Garfin both hold their own too as the heroic pair's sons. The former's confidence as Jonathan shines through in every scene, ensuring that the character walks the line between overconfident and arrogant really well without ever stepping too far in one direction. Moreover, Garfin gives us a powerhouse performance as Jordan that will undoubtedly evoke emotions from the viewers as the show goes on.
If Superman and Lois is the sum of its parts, it's destined to succeed because right now, its parts are all really strong.
2. Lois And Clark
The relationship between Clark Kent and Lois Lane is among the greatest that DC has to offer. It's up there with Batman and Catwoman, The Flash and Iris West, Green Arrow and Black Canary and, on most of those lists, it's at the very top - that's how iconic the pair are.
We've seen a lot of legendary interpretations on the big and small screens too. From Christopher Reeve and Margot Kidder to Tom Welling and Erica Durance, Clark and Lois' chemistry is known for setting the screens alight. With that in mind, fans have been intrigued to see if Tyler Hoechlin and Elizabeth Tulloch could follow in those legendary footsteps. Thankfully the answer is: Yes.
The pair were fun during their appearances in the crossovers, but here they shine like the main event players that they are. There's a maturity in their performances that hasn't been seen in other portrayals - which figures considering they are telling a new side of the story - and yet there is that familiar spark that is so definitively Lois and Clark, you would think these two had been playing the roles for years beforehand.
It's too early to say that Clark Kent and Lois Lane could end up being the defining performances of Hoechlin and Tulloch's careers, but the truth is that if they carry on the way they performed in that pilot episode, that will come to pass. And, in the process, these two could very well become this generation's definitive Superman and Lois Lane.
1. A Thoughtful Reinvention Of A Familiar Old Tale
Superman has been a staple of Hollywood for decades now and during that time creative forces have tried their hardest to reinvent him for generation after generation without having to lose what made him so great in the first place. As Superman is such a traditionally heroic character, these reimaginings have had varying degrees of success and it's gotten to the stage where some have even suggested that the character is no longer relevant in this modern world.
Superman and Lois instantly disproves that theory because it is the property that somehow managed to keep the character relevant. It's a property that, on paper, shouldn't have worked because, in a way, it overlooks all of the elements that made a Superman show in the past. But that's exactly why it works, because it dropped the traditional superhero TV elements we see on offerings like Supergirl and The Flash and opted to give us a family drama more in-line with the likes of Friday Night Lights.
It's a bold move - one that understandably raised eyebrows when the premise was revealed - but it's one that absolutely pays off. Superman and Lois isn't a 'Superman show' but it is very much a show about Superman that, by doing something different, rediscovers what made him so great in the first place.
As a result, Superman and Lois achieves exactly what it sets out to do: Reintroducing the Man of Steel in all his glory and reminding us all why he remains such a revered hero. And after that, the sky is the limit for this show.