Supernatural: 10 Most Cringeworthy Moments

Paris Hilton as a shape-shifting Pagan God? Yikes!

Supernatural Paris Hilton
The CW

Supernatural is a show that doesn't need to prove its legacy. The CW series ran for a whopping fifteen seasons, and in that time, it produced some of the most compelling TV of the era. It was kick-ass, funny, full of great music, and, unfortunately, cringeworthy as hell at times.

It's fair to say that with the multitude of episodes Supernatural produced, there were going to be a couple of dud scenes every now and again. You can't create something for that long and expect the whole journey to be a smooth ride, and, sure enough, the show tripped up on those hurdles quite often.

The thing is, as with most aspects of Supernatural, when it went wrong, it did it to the max. This led to a host of moments throughout the series that left even the most die-hard fans sweating a little and having to look away from the awkward display in front of them.

These ten coming examples are the epitome of Supernatural at its most cringe. There's still a self-aware joy to be found in all of them, but that doesn't make them easy to sit through.

10. The Racist Ghost Truck

Supernatural Route 666
The CW

The title says it all; a racist ghost truck, a truck that is a ghost that is also racist. Who on Earth signed off on that idea?

This one came from the early days of Supernatural, that being the first season. No one is debating that it must have been tough to develop a new monster of the week for so many episodes, but that's no excuse for this dreadfully cringe moment that came at the hands of the episode "Route 666".

In this outing, Dean is contacted by his first love (Cassie) and heads down with Sam in tow to investigate a string of racially motivated murders. It soon becomes apparent that the killer is a truck possessed by the spirit of a racist man seeking revenge. Not your average Supernatural villain, that's for sure.

If Steven King's Maximum Overdrive has taught us anything, it's that possessed vehicle stories often run out of gas pretty quick. That's certainly the case here, as it's so tricky to take the premise seriously, leading to a slew of awkwardness as the characters try to sell the severity of this racist phantom vehicle.


9. So, Apocalypse Castiel Is A Nazi?

Apocalypse World Castiel Supernatural
The CW

Castiel is, of course, one of the best things about Supernatural, so when the concept of an alternate universe version of him arose, it was cause for great excitement. The more, the merrier, right? But then, Apocalypse World Castiel made his debut, and things got uncomfortable real fast.

This version of Cas was a torturer, he wore a long black trench coat that looked like a Gestapo uniform, and he even spoke with a German accent to boot. There wasn't even an apparent reason why this version of his vessel (Jimmy Novak) had a different accent. Overall, the Nazi symbolism felt uncomfortably forced for no real reason.

Even though Misha Collins did his best to wrangle this performance - as he always did - it still came across as painfully insensitive and baffling. His lip-twitching, for example, was an interesting choice, but it felt a little too cartoonish compared to the shockingly oppressive atmosphere.

Overall, this was a strange take on an alternative Castiel and ruffled a few more feathers than it needed to. Some fans enjoyed it, and to each their own, but the awkward implications easily gave it the cringeworthy stamp.


8. The Amelia Flashbacks

Amelia And Riot Supernatural Heartache
The CW

Supernatural was a show that happily dipped its toes into romance, despite the horror/action-centric focus. John & Mary, Sam & Jess and even Castiel & Meg are all shining examples of love done right. However, it wasn't all sunshine and rainbows.

During season eight, Sam found himself conflicted after being reunited with Dean. It was revealed that during Dean's time in Purgatory, Sam had gotten into a relationship with a vet called Amelia after almost killing a dog - what a meet-cute. After that came to an end, he was struck with thoughts of quitting hunting while looking back on his time with her.

The core relationship between Sam & Amelia in season eight was perfectly fine, pleasant even. But did they have to make the flashbacks so cringeworthy? There's a goofy glossiness to it with smeared lenses, shiny filters and overly cheesy dialogue that almost feels like an intentional parody of romantic movies.

Plus, the chemistry between the pair often comes across as forced or uncomfortable, likely because of the strange creative choices. The idea of Sam getting a taste of a "normal life" seemed great on paper, but these flashback scenes led to some of the corniest and most cringeworthy moments in the show.


7. "Pudding!"

Supernatural Dean Sam Pudding
The CW

Comedy is a very subjective thing. For many, a scene like this is agonising to sit through, but for plenty of others, it's one of the funniest things Dean has ever done. Whichever side of the boat you sit on, however, there's no denying that it is cringeworthy to the max.

This moment came during the episode "Sam, Interrupted". After examining a corpse in a morgue, Dean and Sam are caught red-handed by a nurse. What is their genius way of getting out of the situation? Well, Dean whips his pants down, yells "pudding!" in a goofy voice and, let's just say, gives it a little jiggle.

The logic behind this was to act crazy because "crazy works", and it paid off for them. But that doesn't make the moment any less bizarre. It's a miracle that Jensen Ackles was able to pull this off to the extent that he did.

And then there are the sound effects; oh god, the sound effects. Someone probably had to put painstaking work into making the sound of Dean's *ahem* manhood flopping about. Let's hope they were given a decent payday for that one.

DO NOT try this yourself the next time you're in a bind.


6. "Bugs" - The Whole Thing

Supernatural Bugs
The CW

You don't get a reputation for being one of the worst Supernatural episodes without some cringeworthy moments. In fact, this whole outing counts for an entry here as it's a wall-to-wall example of how much cringe can be contained in a 45-minute format.

"Bugs" was the eighth episode of the first season and was still a baby step in the direction of Supernatural. It showed as Dean/Sam ventured to Oklahoma to investigate a string of deaths related to insects in a new housing estate. There, they discovered that the creepy crawlies resulted from a Native-American curse. Cue the facepalms.

The first issue with "Bugs" is the woefully cliched set-up, with the curse feeling like a tacked-on and lazy attempt to replicate horror tropes. But then came the monsters themselves, as watching the brothers tackle these beasties was an exercise in groaning at poor visual effects.

Supernatural was hardly Avatar when it came to VFX, but the cheap monsters often had a quirky charm. That wasn't the case here, as these bugs were gross little images that didn't even look convincing. It was hard not to see right through to the actors swinging around at nothing on-set, making this one incredibly awkward episode to sit through.


5. Lucifer And Michael/Dean's Air Fight

Dean Vs Lucifer Wires Let The Good Times Roll
The CW

Supernatural had some genuinely pulse-pounding action scenes in its time. Unfortunately, it has also had its fair share of awful ones, and it won't take long to figure out where this one sits on that spectrum. This was a fight with so much build-up and excitement, and what it delivered was difficult to sit through.

This "epic" battle came at the climax of the season 13 finale ", Let The Good Times Roll". It showed as Dean - now acting as the vessel to Michael - took on the dastardly Lucifer, and if there's one word to describe what happened, it's wire.

During the clash, Michael and Lucifer ended up flying into the air, ready for a battle above the onlooker's heads. However, the obvious wireworks made the flying look incredibly fake/amateur. There was no reason for them to be fighting overhead in the first place, so it stank of a cheap attempt to make the conflict more exciting.

Unfortunately, being in the air also meant the combat between them was limited, turning it into an incredibly dull fight with no weight to it. Fans wanted a showdown for the centuries, not a cringeworthy mess. But, the latter is what they got.


4. No, Not The Fingernail!

Sam Winchester Fingernail A Very Supernatural Christmas
The CW

It's time for a little departure now. While it's easy to pick on the sillier moments throughout this series, it would be unfair not to reference some of the times it made you cringe on purpose. If there's one thing it did well in that regard, it was with the gore factor.

There are plenty of cringeworthy moments made up of body horror and pain, with some great examples including Isaac chugging drain cleaner ("The Magnificent Seven"), the infamous hand in a blender scene ("After School Special") and more. But this one worked hard to get you recoiling in your seat.

During the episode "A Very Supernatural Christmas", Dean and Sam found themselves at the mercy of two pagan gods, The Carrigans. After tying the brothers up, this dastardly flesh-eating duo began a ritual, starting by slicing The Winchesters' wrists. But the fun didn't stop there.

To take it to the next level, Edward Carrigan tore off one of Sam's fingernails. It was depicted in agonising detail causing viewers to clutch their fingers in horror. That's one hell of a way to set someone's cringe alarms off.


3. Paris Hilton's Cameo

Supernatural Paris Hilton
The CW

Celebrity cameos are as common on TV as Charlie Bradbury delivering pop culture references. The rub, however, is that hiring the wrong person can completely tank a scene. Let's just say the reality TV star/socialite/notorious rich girl Paris Hilton wasn't the best choice for Supernatural.

This infamous moment came during the climax of the episode "Fallen Idols". After investigating local disappearances, the Winchesters discovered that a shapeshifting Pagan God (Leshi) had been devouring its followers. Leshi lured people in by shifting into celebrity idols, taking the form of Paris Hilton in this climax.

This actor (?) can work well if given the proper role - she did a solid job in Repo The Genetic Opera, for example - but here, taking on the part of a human guzzling God wasn't quite in her wheelhouse. Her lacklustre performance also wasn't helped by the slew of references to House of Wax, which felt like a forced attempt to make her seem relevant.

Hilton's acting chops weren't up to scratch here, with no weight to anything she said and zero intimidation factor. Unfortunately, this sank the whole ship, as the decent concept was lost, and the entire thing felt like a cheap ploy for attention.


2. Old Man Sam

Sam Winchester Carry On Supernatural
The CW

It's not about the destination; it's about the journey. That's what people say to themselves when a TV show enters the hall of bad finales. Sadly, Supernatural fans saw their beloved series fall into that pothole, with an ending that was bittersweet at best and indifferent at worst. Weirdly, one of the most awkward moments came from costuming.

During the divisive final episode, Sam found himself in an emotional montage that saw him grow old alongside Dean Jr, his son. It should have been an iconic moment, but unfortunately, instead of crying, many fans found themselves wincing at the poor attempt to age Sam Winchester up.

The first notable problem was the gosh darn awful wig he sported. This grey mess of fabric looked cheap as a penny and was oddly static, making it very obviously fake. To make matters worse, he was dressed in a hilarious brown cardigan/glasses combo that looked like a twelve-year-old's attempt to draw an old person.

It just goes to show how much damage a bad choice can make. This moment should have been filled with emotional catharsis, but instead, it was an unintentionally hilarious mess.


1. Becky Drugs Sam And Marries Him Without Consent

Supernatural Becky Rosen
The CW

Ah, yikes, this one has not aged well. To be fair, it was outdated and uncomfortable even at the time. You can easily argue that was the intention all along for Becky as a character, but that doesn't make this moment any easier to sit through.

Becky Rosen was introduced in season five and made it very clear, right off the bat, that her intentions with Sam Winchester were far from platonic. As a fan of the in-universe Supernatural books, she had an obsession with him, even using the online username samlicker81 - a great first impression.

Still, what was at first a mostly harmless gag ended up turning into a magnet for uncomfortable scenes, with one of the worst coming during the episode "Time For A Wedding."

In this outing, Becky drugged Sam, forced him to marry her and then knocked him out once the spell wore off, tying him to a bed and removing his pants. It was, without a doubt, one of the most awkward and uncomfortable storylines to grace Supernatural.

The series worked hard to redeem her in season 15, even giving her a family, but for many, this was too little too late, as her creepiness was etched into their brains.


Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!