The Big Bang Theory: 10 Best Wil Wheaton Episodes

Which Wil Wheaton appearance was your favorite on Big Bang? Odds are, it was one of these ten...

Wheaton Big Bang Theory
CBS

Wil Wheaton was one of many guest stars who strolled onto the set of The Big Bang Theory while the CBS hit was in production, and he ended up appearing in 17 episodes across the series' run. He wasn't the only Star Trek actor on BBT, but he was certainly the most important.

Wheaton played a fictionalized version of himself, which seems to be a bit like the actor, but mostly took aim at establishing him as a foil to Dr. Sheldon Cooper. In this sense, he saw quite a lot of character development over the years, and many of his episodes are beloved.

Of the 17 episodes he showed up in on the show, there are some that are far better than the rest. That's not to say every nerd watching the series didn't throw on a smile whenever Wheaton appeared, but it does mean that some appearances are better than others.

This list takes a look at ten of those appearances most fans consider to be his very best. He's not necessarily at the center of the plot, but that doesn't make him any less important for the other characters — especially Sheldon.

10. "The Gorilla Dissolution"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The Gorilla Dissolution
CBS

After Wil's advice helps Penny take an acting job on Serial Ape-ist 2, they begin working on a laboratory set, where Penny is stuck in a cage. As they are filming their scene, Wil's character begs with Penny's not to shut him out, but she's still a little upset about the time he mixed her DNA with a killer gorilla's.

After some back and forth pleading, the scene comes to an end, but Penny isn't happy with her performance, so she asks for another take. The director isn't having any of it, admitting that the film is garbage, and if it weren't, she wouldn't be in it.

Things go from bad to worse when Leonard is ordered off the set by the director. When Penny objects, he fires her. Wil stands up for his friend and co-worker, and it's beginning to look like he might be able to save her job.

The next scene sees them all drinking in a bar, where Wil comments that their job situation fell apart really quickly. That's the bulk of Wil's performance in the episode, which was important in Penny's development. She turned away from acting after the incident, which ultimately changed her life.


9. "The D & D Vortex"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The D & D Vortex
CBS

Wil Wheaton's love for the nerdiest of nerdy games, Dungeons & Dragons, is well known, so he was perfect for "The D & D Vortex." In the episode, Sheldon learns that Wil hosts a regular D&D game featuring celebrities. His regulars include William Shatner, Joe Manganiello, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, and Kevin Smith.

Sheldon learns all about it after a vomiting incident with Shatner (He puked all over him, of course). When he arrives at Wil's house to apologize, he sees everyone playing D&D, including Stuart. Wil denies that he saw what he thought he saw, but that doesn't work.

After some pressure on Stuart, he quits the game, leaving an open seat coveted by everyone, though it ultimately goes to Leonard. Things devolve from there when Penny, Amy, and Bernadette learn that Joe Manganiello was there, though they refer to him as "Magic Max," and invite themselves to the next game.

The final scene shows the celebrities (and adoring fans) playing D&D, but it's mostly just the women fawning over "Magic Max" and the rest of the celebs. The episode ends with a group shot of the ladies and celebs, which they send to the guys.


8. "The Spock Resonance"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The Spock Resonance
CBS

In "The Spock Resonance," Wil invites Sheldon to appear for an interview in his documentary about Spock and the character's cultural impact. The movie is being done alongside Adam Nimoy, Leonard Nimoy's son, who makes a guest appearance in the episode, where he pretty much plays himself.

Sheldon's love for Spock is well-known to Wheaton and anyone who's watched the show, so he's a perfect subject for the documentary. His feelings on the character are both touching and hilarious at the same time. During the interview, Sheldon shows off the napkin that Penny got Leonard Nimoy to sign for him.

He retrieves it from a safe, which contains important collectibles and a ring box Penny asks about. He calmly explains that it contains the ring he planned to use to propose to his girlfriend, Amy. This causes Penny to burst out with a loud "WHAT?!?"

He and Amy were broken up at that time, but the proposal reveals how much he was progressing. On top of that, his feelings and emotional response to the breakup were all analyzed via his love for Spock, which tied everything together perfectly for Wil and Adam's questionably titled "Spockumentary."


7. "The Wheaton Recurrence"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The Wheaton Recurrence
CBS

"The Wheaton Recurrence" is the second episode Wil Wheaton appears in on the show. In his first appearance, he and Sheldon establish their rivalry, which is entirely one-sided on Sheldon's part. Regardless, Will picked it up and ran with it when the two met for the second time.

Their meeting comes when the guys are bowling opposite Stuart's team, which includes Wheaton as a substitute. At the time, Wheaton was seen as an evil character... at least, he did in Sheldon's eyes, and Wil was having fun with it, so they traded words a bit.

When they meet to bowl a second time, Sheldon reveals his team shirts with the name "The Wesley Crushers." It's a great play on Wheaton's character from Star Trek: The Next Generation, but Sheldon saw it as a diss — It wasn't, and everyone loved the shirts.

Wil throws off Sheldon's game, telling him to embrace the Dark Side while pushing Leonard to force Penny into an "I love you" box, which predictably ends badly. Sheldon confronts Wil about sabotaging a couple to win a game, and when he realizes what he did, he looks to the sky, screaming "WHEAAATOOOOONNN" in pure Wrath of Khan style.


6. "The Russian Rocket Reaction"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The Russian Rocket Reaction
Warner Bros. Television Distribution

Wil's fourth appearance on the show managed to reshape his character considerably, moving from Sheldon's enemy into the role of his best friend. Again, this was largely one-sided, but it managed to plant a seed that would see Wheaton return somewhat regularly throughout the series' run.

In "The Russian Rocket Reaction," The guys are at the comic book store when Wheaton arrives to purchase a rare Batman comic. He invites them to a party, which includes other Star Trek actors. Leonard happily accepts, but Sheldon walks out on his nemesis, as he's not the forgiving type.

Leonard and Raj end up heading to Wil's party without Sheldon, who couldn't be persuaded despite the fact that Brent Spiner would be there. Ultimately, he does show up, and when he arrives, Wil comes up and apologizes to him for skipping the convention years before, which established Sheldon's hatred for Wil.

He hands him his very last Ensign Crusher figurine, which he signed, and Sheldon instantly relents, declaring that Wil is now officially his friend. Just when everything looks like it's going to end well, Brent Spiner snatches the action figure and pulls it out of the packaging, enraging Sheldon, and landing him on his "list."


5. "The Indecision Amalgamation"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The Indecision Amalgamation
CBS

Wil's part in "The Indecision Amalgamation" wasn't one of his longest contributions to the series in terms of screentime, but it was nonetheless important. In the episode, Penny spends a great deal of time deciding if she should accept Serial Ape-ist 2: Monkey See, Monkey Kill.

Her dream was to become an actress, but it's not a job she's especially excited about, and the title doesn't help. Still, it's an acting gig, so she decides the best thing to do is talk to a professional actor and get their advice. Fortunately, she's friends with Wil Wheaton.

She, Leonard, and Wil get coffee together, and she asks him about taking the job, so he recounts that he's taken some jobs he might call embarrassing. After a joke about how she didn't think Star Trek was all that bad, he explains that after Stand By Me, he took on some bad jobs.

This leads him to look off in the distance, clearly depressed about his past. Eventually, she decides to take the job despite the way Wil recalled his past experiences. When she arrives on the set, she's surprised to see Wil on the set, having also agreed to take the job.


4. "The 21-Second Excitation"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The 21-Second Excitation
CBS

Wheaton's third appearance on the series came in "The 21-Second Excitation," when he and Sheldon were still one another's nemesis. The episode centers around Sheldon, Leonard, Howard, and Raj's excitement about attending a screening of Raiders of the Lost Ark with 21 seconds of never-before-seen footage.

Everyone gets to the theater a bit later than Sheldon would have liked, leaving them to stand in an incredibly long line. Wheaton walks right up to the front of the line, and when Sheldon sees "the Jar-Jar Binks of the Star Trek universe," he's none too happy.

This is made worse when the bouncer recognizes him and immediately lets Wil and his friends (from the comic book store) into the theater. Soon after, Sheldon reads a Tweet from Wheaton, saying, "Best seats in the house for "Raiders" screening. Suck on that, Sheldon Cooper."

Eventually, the line is cut right before the guys, but Sheldon sees an open door and steals the print of the movie, saying, "If I can't see it, no one else can see it!" Seeing this, Wheaton leads a mob of moviegoers after Sheldon in a manner reminiscent of Indiana Jones' race to the pontoon plane — with appropriate music, of course.


3. "The Creepy Candy Coating Corollary"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The Creepy Candy Coating Corollary
CBS

"The Creepy Candy Coating Corollary" establishes what has to be one of the strangest rivalries on television. In the episode, Sheldon reveals that he hates Wil Wheaton when learns that the actor signed up for an upcoming Mystic Warlords of Ka'a tournament.

Sheldon explains that he idolized Wesley Crusher on Star Trek: The Next Generation because they both had an eidetic memory, but everything changed in 1995. That's when he rode a bus for 10 hours to a sci-fi convention in Jackson, Mississippi to meet the actor who played his favorite character.

He wore his Starfleet Cadet uniform and wanted Wheaton to sign his mint, in-package Wesley Crusher action figure, but Wil didn't appear. This led to Sheldon's pledge of eternal hatred for the actor, so he teamed up with Raj to take him on in the tournament.

Sheldon confronts his nemesis, quoting Wrath of Khan. He explains why he hates him so much, so Wil explains that he missed the convention to attend his grandmother's funeral. This causes Sheldon to relent, but it was all a ruse. Will beats Sheldon and cements their rivalry as Sheldon yells "WHEEEAAAAAATTTTTTOOOONNNNNNNN" while the camera pans out to a global shot of the Earth.


2. "The Bow Tie Asymmetry"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The Bow Tie Asymmetry
CBS

Wil's role in "The Bow Tie Asymmetry" is a bit of a ding on the actor, though one could hardly blame Sheldon for what happens. This episode features the wedding of Sheldon and Amy, so it was a big deal for fans of the show and Wil Wheaton fans.

Amy manages to get Wil to agree to officiate their wedding, which is a treat for Sheldon, as he considers him to be one of his best friends. Everything progresses towards this end as the episode moves toward the ceremony, but through some sitcom-only logic, Mark Hamill ends up owing Howard a favor.

Of course, he asks if he can come to the wedding as a treat for Sheldon, and he ends up replacing Wil Wheaton as the officiate. Wil approaches his replacement, saying, "So, we finally meet," but the man who played Luke Skywalker didn't know who Wil was.

This ends up bumming Wil out pretty hard, as he stayed up the whole night, working on the ceremony. Much of the rest of the episode centers on people asking Hamill as many Star Wars questions as they can think of before the wedding finally commences.


1. "The Opening Night Excitation"

Big Bang Theory Wil Wheaton The Opening Night Excitation
CBS

"The Opening Night Excitation" is the Wil Wheaton episode that everyone pretty much loves for the way it mixed franchises in as funny a way as possible. It's all thanks to Wil's clothing choice in a key scene involving the premiere of the new Star Wars movie.

The bulk of the episode is about Sheldon's decision to skip the premiere to be with Amy on her birthday (followed by them finally consummating their relationship). Sheldon decides to skip the premiere, which lands Wheaton in his seat, as the tickets were hard to get.

Raj, Leonard, and Howard were ready to give Sheldon's ticket to Stuart, but the prospect of attending alongside Wil was far more appealing. He happily accepts, and a little later in the episode, the guys are gathered, waiting for him to arrive.

When he does, he's dressed as Spock from The Original Series and enters while displaying the Vulcan salute. The Star Wars fans see this and boo at his offensive incorrect-franchise clothing choice, but he eats it up, loving the rejection. When someone yells that Star Trek sucks, he replies, "Live long and suck it."


The Ultimate Big Bang Theory Quiz

Sheldon Cooper The Big Bang Theory
CBS

1. How Old Was Sheldon When He Started College?

9

10

11

12

Contributor
Contributor

Jonathan is a graphic artist, illustrator, writer, and game designer. Jonathan retired from the U.S. Army in 2017 and enjoys researching and writing about history, science, theology, and many other subjects. He writes for ScreenRant, CBR, NerdBastards, Listverse, Ranker, WhatCulture, and many other sites online. You can check out his latest on Twitter: @TalkingBull or on his blog: jonathanhkantor.com