The Daily Show: 10 Hosts Who Should Replace Jon Stewart

Next up: 10 Last Week Tonight Hosts who should replace John Oliver.

Shocking €“ well, if not the world, then the people in the world who get their left-leaning news from comedy shows rather an straight journalism, so long as they have access to the right cable package and/or can use Tunnel Bear €“ this week Jon Stewart announced he would be stepping down as host of The Daily Show. And, to be fair, he probably deserves a break after fifteen straight years in the job. During that time, he's barely had any breaks. Rob Corddry filled in as host for one episode, and Stephen Colbert took over for a handful before he got his own show, but Stewart's first extended sojourn away from hosting duties happened in the summer of 2013, when he was busy directing the political drama Rosewater. Perhaps the writing was on the wall even then €“ Stewart wanted to move onto different things. It's not quite the unprecedented blow for The Daily Show as it seems (Stewart wasn't even the original host; he replaced Craig Kilborn, who fronted the first two years of the show), but it was something of a shock. It looks like it was even something of a surprise to Comedy Central, who are know put in the unenviable position of finding a suitable replacement. Who should they go with, though? A veteran of the show? New talent? Or something completely outside of the box? Here are ten hosts who should replace Jon Stewart on The Daily Show.

10. John Oliver

For many, John Oliver is the obvious choice. The British stand-up and long time Daily Show correspondent anchored thirty-three episodes the summer Stewart was off working on Rosewater, and did a ruddy good job with it too. So good, in fact, that HBO offered him his own satirical news show: Last Week Tonight With John Oliver, which recently started its second season. Last Week Tonight might even have pinched The Daily Show's satirical crown within its first season, when it tackled big issues in international news with a bolshy, strident point-of-view where most straight journalism would err on the side of caution. Also, they sang a song about saving Russian space sex geckos. The success of his fill-in for Stewart and Last Week Tonight make John Oliver a no-brainer, but also, is he necessarily going to abandon that show so quickly? The Daily Show hosting job is a prestigious position, but it's hard work €“ he almost certainly couldn't do both shows €“ so it'd be a big change.

9. Joel McHale

The Daily Show and Last Week Tonight took up so much of Oliver's time, in fact, that he was mostly absent from his other work during their duration. Which is a shame, because his supporting role in the cult NBC sitcom Community as unscrupulous Professor Duncan was a fun foil to Joel McHale's disbarred lawyer Jeff Winger. Community was finally cancelled by NBC, but is set to return as a Yahoo! web series. Oliver is probably still too busy to appear, but once filming's ended, perhaps Joel McHale might find himself with some spare time? Apart from Community McHale is best known for hosting the topical comedy show The Soup on the E! Network. Like The Daily Show, it airs every week day, and McHale has hosted pretty much every one of it's 500+ episodes. The topics are usually a little lighter than The Daily Show but the workload, sharp scripts and ad-libbing are all things McHale is adept at.

8. Aisha Tyler

Who says the new Daily Show host has to be a dude, though? In fact, it would be kind of refreshing for Comedy Central's longest-running series (besides South Park) to be fronted by a woman. Plus it would be an excuse to get Aisha Tyler's actual face back on screens, rather than just her voice as the eternally put-upon/yelled-at Lana in Archer. Before that, most international viewers probably knew Tyler best as Charlie, the €œhot palaeontologist€ from Friends. Which is doing her something of a disservice, because she a crazy-talented comedy performer who's especially gifted in the realm of improv. She's even the current host of Whose Line Is It Anyway? Which means that again, her workload isn't so heavy that she could easily €“ well, maybe not easily €“ find the time to host The Daily Show. She's also a known star, a razor-sharp whip, and probably even better at the ad-libbing than even Stewart. Which is saying something..

7. Aasif Mandvi

Still, the smart money's on Comedy Central promoting somebody from within The Daily Show to the hosting seat. It makes sense, rather than gambling on an unknown quantity €“ there's loads of performers who have all the skills, but they're not all familiar with how the show works specifically. Luckily, they have a buttload of correspondents to chose from. The Daily Show has never just been €œWith Jon Stewart€. The show lives or dies on its supporting cast members, with the €œcorrespondents€ usually relied on to be more larger-than-life characters than Stewart's relatively straight role, doing pre-recorded interviews and the like. One of the best current correspondents on the show is Aasif Mandvi who, along with frequently producing some hilarious and insightful work for The Daily Show, also affects actual political change: one interview, on voter ID laws, got a racist Republican county chairman fired.

6. Samantha Bee

But, then, the current crop of The Daily Show correspondents it's difficult to pick just one who should step up to hosting. Maybe just having somebody who will follow the example of Jon Stewart isn't what they want. Maybe they want something new. In which case, surely Samantha Bee would be ideal as a host? Her "Are You Prepared?!?" was a recurring segment, and even when she's not giving enlightening and very, very real advice about preparing for potential disasters, she's a mainstay of The Daily Show. When Stewart came down with the flu, Bee and fellow correspondent (and husband) Jason Jones filled in. Bee is the longest-running correspondent, surpassing even Stephen Colbert's record back. That said, she's one of the correspondents with the €œbiggest€ character, meaning that bringing her down to Earth a little might spoil the magic.

5. Trevor Noah

Maybe there's a reason Bee was passed over for the guest hosting spot in favour of John Oliver. She's the longest-running correspondent, her place within the show is kind of established. So why not go with one of the newer correspondents, who's had enough time to make himself known, but not just as a supporting cast member? Step forward, Trevor Noah. The South African comedian has since made a name for himself on both sides of the pond, with stand-up tours and guest spots on the none-more-British panel show QI before taking up the mantle of Daily Show correspondent. As well he should, because he's equal parts hilarious and incisive. Noah only became a full-time correspondent for the show this past December, but he's already left a lasting impression with reports on his home continent and the mainstream media's ignoring of Boko Haram.

4. Hari Kondabolu

If you want a talented comedian who is switched onto international and race issues, though, you could do worse than Hari Kondabolu. The stand-up has been making a name for himself with appearances on The Late Show with David Letterman, and has shown up on countless Comedy Central specials in the recent past as well. Last year he released his first stand-up album, Waiting for 2042 €“ a reference to far-flung future date when White Americans may be a statistical minority in the United States €“ which was pretty great, and between 2012 and 2013 he was on the writing staff for the observational comedy show Totally Biased with W Kamau Bell. A show which frequently drew on recent news stories and current events, much as Kondabolu's stand up does, with most episodes being recorded the day they aired...much like The Daily Show. And Kondabolu occasionally made appearances as a correspondent....much like The Daily Show.

3. Dara O'Briain

If Comedy Central really wanted to think outside the box, however, they'd go for a performer who's a relative unknown in the states. A stand-up who is famed for his improvisational skill. A TV host who has fronted a satirical news show for the better part of a decade. A man so intelligent that he can host another programme alongside actual science boffin Brian Cox and not look like a complete imbecile. Irish comedian Dara O'Briain has a lot going for him that would make him the ideal replacement for Jon Stewart. He's inarguably the best part of Mock The Week, a frequently ropey panel show he fronts and gets all the best jokes in, and he's equally at home with live and pre-recorded television. He does also, admittedly, have something of a thick accent €“ and for a country where Trainspotting and Guy Ritchie films come subtitled, that may be an issue. He's also not so much on the peripheries of public consciousness in the States as totally absent, meaning he's the definite wild card.

2. Wyatt Cenac

John Oliver has gone off to pastures new, but might be too busy with his new job. The news that The Daily Show is looking for a new host must've gotten the attention of some of the other correspondents who started their career there, however, who perhaps wouldn't have to contend with abandoning their own award-winning satirical news show. Somebody like Wyatt Cenac? Besides Oliver, he's probably the best-known of the recent Daily Show performers who left in search of new challenges. His drawling, poker-faced delivery whilst tackling important, often forgotten news stories made him one of the best correspondents the show's had. He has an idea of how both the behind-the-scenes and hosting sides work €“ he also previously worked on the writing staff of King Of The Hill €“ and starred in some of The Daily Show's all-time best segments. He left in 2012 and has been somewhat quiet since €“ perhaps it's time Cenac came home.

1. Jessica Williams

Undoubtedly the fan favourite to take over from Jon Stewart is Jessica Williams. And rightly so: like Trevor Noah, she's a relatively recent addition to The Daily Show's roster of correspondents, and at 25 is the youngest to join the cast in the history of the show. But in that short time, and with relatively less experience, she's already become one of the main reasons to tune in. Offering a perspective on current events that many of her older colleagues can't, along with first-hand experience as not only a woman but a black woman (two particular demographics who have not been having a great time in recent American politics and society), her segments have often gone viral, inspiring viewers both for their content and their jokes. Williams is really, really funny. Her star is rising, thanks to guest appearances in HBO comedy Girls and the aforementioned sharing of her segments through social media. She's a fresh voice, an incredibly talented, smart, insightful, and engaging performer. She's everything that Jon Stewart is and, to be honest, a bit more besides. Plus her appointment is already a forgone conclusion.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/