The Flash Season 6 Review: 7 Ups & 1 Down From 'Liberation'

The Flash trades in its costumes for a character-driven affair in one of the season's best episodes.

The Flash Season 6 Barry Allen Iris West-Allen
The CW

Contains spoilers from The Flash season 6, episode 17.

It's been the question on everyone's minds since The Flash returned from its post-Crisis hiatus. It's the question that has plagued fans of DC TV's number one couple since the year practically began. And it's a question that was finally answered in this week's installment.

That question: When will Barry Allen figure out that the Iris West-Allen looking him in the face since the week after Crisis hasn't been his lightning rod?

In the aftermath of its promising return last week, The Flash's latest episode placed the spotlight on the Arrowverse's most elite couple (in a way) as Barry finally confronted the faux Iris standing before him, calling her out for the poor imitation that she was.

All in all, 'Liberation' was another exceptional offering from what has been a strong season; but what sets it apart is the fact that it ultimately drove the narrative forward, helping it out of the ground it's been stuck in for slightly longer than it needed to be. And it was elevated further by some absolutely divine performances from Grant Gustin and Candice Patton.

First, the negative...


Down...

1. Timing Is A Little Convenient

The Flash Season 6 Iris West-Allen Harrison Nash Wells
The CW

As great as 'Liberation' was (and believe me, we will get to that), it did leave this writer feeling like a lot of the events taking place relied solely on certain things conveniently happening at a certain time.

After spending so long inside the Mirrorverse, Eva's plan to escape just so happened to coincide with Barry's plan to expose faux Iris in front of everyone - both of which just so happened to coincide with the real Iris' discovery of Eva's plans. And to top it all off, faux Iris just so happened to suddenly start developing feelings now. You see the problem here?

It's not a huge thing if you don't think about it too much, but it just felt like all of the major events in the episode could have only gone down that way if certain hoops were jumped through all at the same time. And that just feels a little too convenient at this stage.

Now, for the positives...


Ups...

7. The Truth Is FINALLY Out

The Flash Season 6 Iris West-Allen Candice Patton
The CW

Fans have understandably taken issue with the fact that Barry hadn't recognised the fact that his own wife was missing, especially when you factor in just how unusual her replacement has been behaving and that both Joe and Wally noticed it before he did.

In spite of that - and the fact that Barry's head has understandably been on everything that happened during and after the Crisis - it's hard to deny that it's been dragging on a little too long.

With that in mind, 'Liberation's decision to just dive straight into the issue (by having Barry realise what was happening and accuse faux Iris of, well, fraud) was a refreshing change, because it finally allowed the pieces of the puzzle to start moving again.

As compelling as these past few episodes have been, it's important to keep things moving as the end of the season approaches, and Barry's realisation of the truth - and the subsequent confrontation that came from it - allowed that to happen. And the same goes for Iris' confrontation with Eva in the mirror dimension.


6. Barry and Cecile's Team-Up

The Flash Season 6 Barry Allen Cecile Horton
The CW

One of the episode's unexpectedly pleasant surprises came in the form of the alliance we got from Barry Allen and Cecile Horton, as they teamed up to prove that Iris wasn't Iris.

Barry and Cecile have been together during a number of the show's biggest moments over the years, but they rarely interact on a one-on-one basis, so it was nice to see Grant Gustin and Danielle Nicolet share the screen together for such an extended period of time. Moreover, the pair worked really well together - both characters and actors - so it goes without saying that it would be nice to see this dynamic develop further.

The show doesn't always make the best use of Cecile, but this right here, this was golden.


5. Creative Writing

The Flash Killer Frost
The CW

Another one of the episode's unexpected moments came when Cisco and Ralph entered Caitlin's apartment expecting to find Killer Frost resting as her wound (from her battle with Sunshine a few episodes ago) healed, only to find Caitlin in an ice coma.

The arc was brief and only progressed over two scenes, but long story short, Frost apparently put Caitlin in an ice coma to heal them both - meaning that Danielle Panabaker didn't have to leave the sofa.

With Frost's injury, both her and Caitlin's absence last week and now this, you have to hand it to the writers; they're doing a very creative job of writing around Danielle's pregnancy and, in doing so, using those creative methods to build towards some rather exciting developments for her character - especially because it seems like Caitlin's mother is set to return in the coming weeks. And the veteran Flash star brought it all to life with a very strong performance.


4. Bringing It All Together

The Flash Bloodwork
The CW

Would you believe me if I said there were more unexpected moments in the episode? I sure hope so because, in a moment that certainly caught this writer off-guard, Ramsey Rosso (a.k.a. Bloodwork) returned when Eva's mirror children visited him in the hopes of obtaining some of his blood - which he gave to them willingly after hearing their proposition.

It was undoubtedly great to see Sendhil Ramamurthy reprise his role and, given that he was the Big Bad for the first half of the season, his return is actually an effective way of bringing the sixth season's story full-circle.

We knew heading into this season that it would adopt a two-narrative approach, with showrunner Eric Wallace referring to each half as a separate graphic novel of sorts. Bloodwork is clearly the key to joining those two narratives, and that came as a pleasant surprise.


3. Faux Iris' Sacrifice

The Flash Season 6 Barry Allen Iris West
The CW

As convenient as it might have seemed, it was oddly intriguing watching the faux Mirrorverse version of Iris West-Allen begin to long for more than what she was.

Perplexed by both Barry's genuine love for the real Iris and Kamilla's willingness to follow Eva's orders - even to death - the replica Iris underwent something of a moving character journey throughout the episode, and that suddenly made her feel like a much stronger character.

Her noble sacrifice in the final few moments felt like a fitting conclusion to both that arc and the character's journey on the show, and it really was a powerful and moving way to bow out - one that certainly made this writer feel sorry for her.


2. Mirror Master Lives Happily Eva After

The Flash Eva McCulloch
The CW

Like the aforementioned faux Iris arc, Eva McCulloch and the real Iris' imprisonment felt like it was beginning to drag a little just because they'd spent so long in the same place. And that made the conclusion of the episode - in which Eva finally emerged from the Mirrorverse and confronted Barry - all the more satisfying.

She may only have been on the ground a couple of minutes, but Eva has already given us a glimpse of what she's capable of as she moved from mirror to mirror and set off in search of her husband Joseph Carver - and what an intimidating glimpse it was.

The Flash has given us many a great villains over the years, but it struggled with its original interpretation of the Sam Scudder Mirror Master. The show's chance to right that wrong revolves around the writers giving Mirror Master II an arc worthy of the comic book counterpart. So far, so good.


1. Grant Gustin and Candice Patton's Performances

The Flash Season 6 Iris West-Allen Candice Patton
The CW

Can we take a moment to appreciate the way that Grant Gustin and Candice Patton absolutely slayed with their performances, please?

The pair are no stranger to putting on a great show - especially whenever they're together - but the on-screen couple were nothing short of electric here, bringing every ounce of frustration and desperation to life before our eyes as Barry and 'Iris' clashed over who was actually who.

Patton once again had to pull double-duty as both versions of Iris, and she once again pulled it off, while Gustin was just brilliant by giving us a very determined Barry Allen. And it's really quite hard to pick a standout performance because all of them were so amazing.

Barry's monologue about the real Iris? Faux Iris' death scene? Barry and Iris' emotional declarations of love to each other? All of it was pure bliss and it highlighted why these two are some of the strongest performers you'll find in any medium. Bliss.

-

What did you make of 'Liberation'? Tell us in the comment section below.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.