The Simpsons: 10 Giant Plot-Holes You Probably Missed

Dr Nick It's hard to imagine a television institution more beloved or venerated than The Simpsons, the ridiculously long-running animated show with a staggering 530 episodes plus a feature-length movie to its credit, as well as an enormous cast of supporting characters easily numbering into the hundreds. Beginning in 1987 with its crudely drawn shorts on the long-forgotten Tracey Ullman show, to the present day merchandising juggernaut it has evolved into, the Simpsons has grown into a massive cultural force, whose influence can be seen from South Park to Adult Swim. Having such a long and convoluted past, with many different writers and producers, there are inevitably many continuity errors within the series that you may not be aware of. Here's your chance to brush up on some of the more absurd plot-holes of the series history before the 25th season begins on September 29.

10. The Existence Of Armin Tamzarian

Armin Tamzarian

The episode "The Principal and the Pauper" from the 9th season is one of the most contentious among fans, many of whom pinpoint this episode as the beginning of the end of the so-called "Golden Age" of the show (and I would tend to agree.) In it, we learn that the person we know as Springfield Principal Seymour Skinner is actually Armin Tamzarian, a street tough who stole the real Principal Skinner's identity during the Vietnam war. The show attempted to deal with this by running the hog-tied real Skinner (voiced by Martin Sheen, incidentally) out of town on a rail, and by having Judge Snyder threatening anyone in the town who mentions anything about the existence of Tamzarian with torture. This has lead to many confusing jokes in later years such as the one from "Boy Meets Curl" showing Agnes Skinner complaining about how Seymour kicking her in the womb at the 1952 Summer Olympics at Helsinki made her lose the Gold Medal in pole-vaulting, leading one to wonder if she actually believes that or is just trying to avoid being waterboarded.

9. The Location Of Springfield

Springfield It has been the longest running joke in a series loaded with long running jokes that the actual location of the Simpsons home town, Springfield, remained a mystery, despite the series offering up numerous confusing and often contradictory clues. Series creator Matt Groening once let it drop in a Smithsonian interview that the town was named after Springfield, Oregon, but later backtracked, claiming the TV version is not meant to actually be that town. Longtime showrunner and producer Al Jean claims the actual location borders "Ohio, Nevada, Maine and Kentucky," so yeah, there's that. Wherever you as a fan think Springfield is, it's often overlooked in these calculations that the town actually moves physically at the end of the 200th episode, "Trash of the Titans" as a direct result of Homer becoming Garbage Commissioner and flooding Springfield in rubbish from neighboring towns. Therefore, whatever location you think Springfield is in needs to be adjusted by at least a few miles.

8. The Simpsons' Computer

Simpsons Computer In the Season 12 episode "The Computer Wore Menace Shoes" Homer decides that it is time for him to buy a computer after he misses a work e-mail informing him the power plant is closed for maintenance, which causes him to miss a potential day off work, all because he has no idea what an e-mail is. But the Simpson family have already been shown to own a computer in the earlier episode "Das Bus", in which Homer declared himself the "King of the Internet" and founded his own start up Internet company, Compu-Global-Hyper-Mega-Net. True, Bill Gates then quickly swooped in and bought out his empire, but it seems a bit off that the self-declared King of The Internet would never have heard of something as basic as e-mail.

7. The Island

The Island Simpsons Also, the bizarre ending of "The Computer Wore Menace Shoes" leaves the Simpson family trapped on a mysterious, LOST-like island in a state of drugged stupefaction due to constant mysterious gas attacks from random unexpected objects including family dog Santa's Little Helper, in a thorough parody/homage of the British cult 60's series The Prisoner. This unresolved cliffhanger was never mentioned again by the series, which leads inevitably to the outlandish but just as plausible as everything else theory that the entirety of events since this point on the series has been in fact nothing more than a mere gas-induced hallucination. You can't disprove it, can you? Well, there you go.

6. Homer's Sterility

Homer Sperm Marge takes birth control in the 21st season episode "O Brother, Where Bart Thou?". We see Bart replace her pills with Tic Tacs in his attempt to get a little brother. However, the show has firmly established since the 3rd season episode "Brother, Can You Spare Two Dimes" another long-running gag that Homer has been rendered irrevocably sterile by his prolonged radiation exposure at Springfield Nuclear Power Plant, so this seems like an uncharacteristically futile effort from Bart. In a more recent example, Marge's desire to have a fourth child was the plot point behind last year's episode "Adventures in Baby Getting", which is rather baffling if Homer's still shooting blanks.

5. Smithers' Changing Race And Homer's Changing Voice

Black Smithers Due to an initial animation error, Mr. Burns long-suffering, sycophantic lackey Waylon Smithers was shown as black (with blue hair!) in his initial appearance in "Homer's Odyssey", changing to his normal yellow makeup with his next appearance. Voices on the program have changed as well, most notably Homer's initial "Walter Matthau" voice, only present in the very early episodes before voice actor Dan Castellanetta decided to abandon this version as being too difficult to sustain over the marathon length of the recording sessions. The most well-known example of this version of the voice being Homer's quote "Let's all go out for some chocolate frosty milkshakes", said mainly in the Tracy Ullman shorts and The Simpsons 1st season.

4. Changing Allergies

Allergy It's clearly established in the episode "Please Homer, Don't Hammer 'Em" that Bart is allergic to shrimp, and to confirm this, we see his face and body swell up disturbingly when he is exposed to them during his battle with Principal Skinner. Also, in "Blood Feud", Marge plainly states that Bart is also allergic to butterscotch and imitation butterscotch (as well as glow in the dark monster makeup). However, Bart boasts at the end of "The Frying Game" that "I ate so much free shrimp" in the green room for the reality show the Simpsons are on. And in the episode "A Milhouse Divided", Marge, pleased by the results of Bart's dental checkup showing only three cavities ("Your best checkup yet!") plans to cook Bart her "specialty", (wait for it)..... Butterscotch Chicken.

3. The Resurrected Dr. Nick And Dr. Monroe

Dr Nick Dr. Nick Riviera, Springfield's most friendly incompetent doctor (say it with me now, "Hello Everybody!" "Hi, Dr. Nick!") was impaled by a large shard of glass from the destroyed dome in The Simpsons Movie, but showed up in the regular program again in "Lost Verizon", with his character's apparent demise going completely unmentioned by the citizens of Springfield. Ditto the unloved character Dr. Marvin Monroe, psychologist to the Simpsons family in the 1st season episode "There's No Disgrace Like Home", who despite having a memorial hospital named after him in "Who Shot Mr. Burns (Part 2)" and his grave being clearly shown in "Alone Again, Natura-diddly", reappears in "Diatribe of A Mad Housewife" with no other explanation than a throwaway joke ("I've been very sick."). Other characters who have died over the course of the show, like Maude Flanders and Bleeding Gums Murphy, have remained dead, so what's so special with these two?

2. Marge and Homer's Changing Backstory

Bart Pregnant One of the most egregious examples of the series' retconning came in the Season 19 episode "That 90's Show", in which Marge attends Springfield University in the 90's and Homer quits his job at his father's laser tag warehouse to become a wildly successful grunge singer. His band "Sadgasm" score a big chart hit "Shave Me," but glorious achievements aside, this blatantly contradicts the third season episode "I Married Marge"(as well as many other episodes) where Homer worked at a mini-golf course in the 80's and knocked up Marge with Bart there after hours, after their romantic date of watching The Empire Strikes Back. To the show's credit, this bizarre alternate timeline has never been mentioned again. Here's hoping it stays that way.

1. The Ever-Changing Florida Ban

Florida At the end of the Season 11 episode "Kill The Alligator and Run", a Florida court judge bans the Simpsons from entering Florida ever again, and every other state besides Arizona and North Carolina, as punishment for their treatment of the state's beloved alligator mascot Captain Jack. However, the Simpsons have returned to Florida twice since this episode aired (they visit Epcot Center in "Special Edna", and Marge and Homer go to Miami in "Catch 'Em If You Can") as well as many other states. And in an utterly meaningless yet fascinating development in real life, in 2013 Universal Studios opened a brand new theme park replica of the Simpsons home town Springfield...in Orlando, Florida. What part of "never come back" don't they get?

In this post: 
The Simpsons
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Hi there, What Culture-ers! I'm William Graff, a 40-year old freelance writer from the wilds of Capitol Hill in beautiful Denver, Colorado. I enjoy many things such as beer, Doctor Who, The Simpsons, record collecting, stand-up comedy, long aimless walks, and of course the Broncos, which is required by law if you live here. I appreciate all feedback for my writing, but I prefer cash and/or deleted Smiths singles in lieu of praise. Rock on!