The Simpsons: 10 Most Controversial Moments Ever

From insulting countries to angering the church, the Simpsons never shy away from controversy.

The Simpsons Strong Arms of the Ma
FOX

The Simpsons and controversy pretty much go hand in hand. The show’s no holds barred approach to controversial topics meant it was always inevitable that it would get on the wrong side of quite a few people.

Over its three decade plus run, the show has taken aim at conservative leaders, Catholics, foreign governments, and pretty much everyone and anyone of social importance, quite the approach considering it airs close to prime time. Now this is certainly not a bad thing. Art should be allowed to express its views, especially when it comes to the rich and the powerful.

However, there have been plenty of occasions when this car was driven a little far into uncomfortable territory. From rape to inaccurate representations of countries, these were the moments when it became increasingly difficult to maintain the subjectivity of art banner.

A lot of these scenes went on to kick up a storm of controversy, though not enough to prevent the show from crossing similar lines in future episodes. Before getting into it, some of these scenes can be quite uncomfortable for certain viewers, so some discretion is advised.

10. Indirectly (Or Directly) Calling Fox News Racist

The Simpsons Fox News
Fox

This was hilariously bizarre because of the fact that Fox owned the broadcasting network where Simpsons aired. Still, it didn’t stop the showrunners from, in the words of Fox anchor Bill O’Reilly, biting the hand that feeds it.

In the episode titled, “Fool Monty”, we see a brief shot of a Fox News helicopter passing over New York. It was right at the beginning of the episode and kept very brief. Pretty normal filler scenery right? Nope.

Because said helicopter was painted with the now infamous words, “Not Racists, but #1 with Racists”.

Of course, there was no way this would go unnoticed. It raised the kind of media storm you would expect. Though, if anyone thought this would curtail the showrunners’ willingness to target powerful entities, they would be in for a nasty surprise the very next episode, which opened with a similar helicopter. This time, it took aim at the aforementioned O’Reilly, saying, “Not suitable for viewers under 75. How do you like them apples, Bill?”


9. Frank Grimes' Death

Simpsons Frank Grimes
20th Television

TRIGGER WARNING: MENTAL DISTRESS, DEATH

This was one downright hard to watch. In this episode, titled Homer’s Enemy, a new employee joins the Springfield Nuclear Power Plant. The newcomer, Frank Grimes, is the polar opposite of Homer.

Instead of being goofy and inefficient at work, Grimes strives for perfection and is horrified at the way Homer conducts himself. Eventually, Homer’s actions go from a source of botheration to a major source of distress for poor Mr. Grimes.

By the end of the episode, he is all but driven mad. In his frenzied state, Grimes causes himself to be electrocuted, leading to his death.

The episode has drawn a lot of criticism, citing its extremely dark tone as being too much for viewers. At the end of the day, people tune into the Simpsons to have a good time. No one needs their comedy shows to give them extra depression.


8. Offending Australia

The Simpsons Australia Flag
Disney

You can count this among the really weird ones. On the face of it, the episode shouldn’t have been anything too complicated. Bart was accused of fraud by the Government of Australia over claims of how the water is supposed to drain Down Under. In order to clear his name, the Simpsons travel to Australia. It’s utter nonsense, but of the Simpsons kind.

Unfortunately, this little trip ended up offending the real Australian government, along with scores of other people.

During their visit, the Simpsons put on a supposedly Australian accent that viewers pointed out wasn’t accurate. In addition to that they used references such as baby eating dingoes and invasive amphibians, which did not sit well with the Aussies either.

Things got so bad that this episode was actually brought up in the Australian parliament. While the potential sight of parliamentarians arguing over a satirical show is absolutely spectacular, it still wasn’t enough to give the writers any second thoughts, whose only response was to joke about the whole fiasco.


7. Offending New Orleans

Simpsons New Orleans
Fox

From ticking off foreign countries, to ticking one of their own famous cities, in the episode, “A Streetcar Named Marge”, the Simpsons managed to make an enemy of New Orleans.

The episode was centred around Marge getting a role in a musical. It was basically a modified version of the play A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams. Unlike the original however, the Simpsons version involved some rather unpleasant references to New Orleans.

More specifically, it calls New Orleans a haven for pirates and wh*res. Needless to say, anyone would be angry at their city being insulted in such fashion. The Simpsons incurred the full wrath of New Orleans. And unlike previous occasions, they had to take it seriously.

Jamie Kellner, then President of Fox, issued a formal apology, followed by a segment at the beginning of the next week’s episode where Bart scribbles, “I will not defame New Orleans”, during the usual blackboard bit.


6. “We’re Just Like The Waltons"

The Simpsons Bush Gag
Fox

The Simpsons have made plenty of political enemies over the years. Given the nature of their content, it would have been more shocking if they hadn’t. Among their famous foes and critics, was the late President Bush Sr.

Their feud was kicked off proper by Bush’s wife Barbara, who described it as one of the worst things she had ever come across. The man himself took a further jab at the show by suggesting American families need to be more like the Waltons and less like the Simpsons.

Of course, there was no way the showrunners would let this slide without a response. In a subsequent episode, all of five of them are seen watching Bush’s speech, with Bart retorting that they are not all that different from Waltons. Because after all, they were praying for an end to a depression too.


5. Stewie's Rape Prank

The Simpsons Stewie And Bart
Fox

The Simpsons have done the odd crossover here and there with other shows. While a lot of them weren’t well received, they were generally deemed to be controversy-free. That was not the case for their crossover episode with the Family Guy.

There was always the potential for this to get problematic, owing to Family Guy’s more adult oriented content. That potential was fully realized during the scene where Bart and Stewie get together to have some fun at the expense of others.

It starts off as a run-of-the-mill prank calling segment where Bart is ringing up Moe's Tavern and talking nonsense. He then passes the phone to Stewie. In typical Family Guy fashion, it descends into to controversial territory in absolutely no time. Stewie’s idea of a prank call…was to tell Moe his sister is being raped. Yikes.


4. The Principal Skinner Reveal

Simpsons Seymour Skinner
Fox

This one is less offensive content and more offending the viewers’ tastes.

Principal Seymour Skinner had been one of the show’s most popular characters. An educational bureaucrat, he is always seen fighting to keep Springfield Elementary School from falling apart due to a lack of resources and zero enthusiasm among teachers and students. He is also a Vietnam War veteran and has both the physical and mental scars to show from his years of service.

All of which meant that when the show suddenly revealed the character to be a fake, fans were not best pleased. In The Principal and the Pauper, the Principal reveals that he was not the real Skinner. His true name was Armin Tamzarian, a war buddy of the real Skinner. He stole the latter’s identity after believing him to have died during the war.

This episode was supposedly based on the Tichborne case from Victorian England. Regardless, fans felt insulted and the episode went down as one of the Simpsons’ most divisive.


3. Portraying Rio De Janeiro As A Crime Infested Hell On Earth

Simpsons Homer Bart
Fox

If the Australia episode wasn’t bad enough, the Simpsons took it even further when they decided to focus on Brazil. The episode, “Blame it on Lisa”, tells us that Lisa had been secretly sponsoring an orphan boy in Rio. A short while ago, she stopped receiving any communication from him, after which she received a video message from the boy, named Ronaldo, about his decision to become a dancer.

The Simpsons then take it upon themselves to go to Rio and found Ronaldo. And that is where the trouble begins. We see a crime ridden version of Rio where no one is safe and everyone appears to get robbed. Homer himself gets kidnapped.

In the end they do find Ronaldo, who uses his dance earnings to help free Homer. Although even that ends on a contentious note when Ronaldo suggests the reason he has money is because he doesn’t have any family who would steal it from him.

This led to a strong condemnation from Brazil, where the tourism board threatened to sue Fox.


2. Mocking The Catholic Church

The Simpsons Catholic Church
20th Century Fox

Offending the Catholic Church is one sure-fire way of creating a major storm of controversy. Of course the Simpsons don’t really care, so in the episode, “Sunday, Cruddy Sunday”, they did just that.

The episode included a made-up Superbowl commercial, which featured three barely clothed women. Pretty normal, right? Unfortunately, if you are the Catholic Church, one of the women, had a crucifix nestled within her chest, in rather provocative fashion.

Still, this alone may not have caused that big of a stir. The only problem was that the show didn’t stop there. The visual was accompanied by a voice over saying, “The Catholic Church, we’ve made a few changes”.

That was more than enough to set off the church, who came down hard on the show and the network. In the end, this was one of the rare cases where the show actually buckled under the pressure, being forced to edit the scene and remove the direct reference to the Catholic Church.


1. The Panda Rape Scene

Simpsons Homer
Fox

This will range from uncomfortable to downright horrifying depending on the viewer’s state, all of whom will probably agree that something like this has no place on television.

This honestly needs to no introduction or background, it literally is it what it says. In the episode, “Homer vs Dignity”, Homer dresses up as a monkey for Mr. Burns, in order to make some extra money.

As part of his gig, he makes his way into Springfield Zoo. And that is where things take a turn for the absolute worst.

Homer encounters a male panda, who for some reason takes a liking to him. Then, the panda proceeds to manhandle Homer, before forcefully taking him to some kind of lair. From thereon, everything pointed to the panda supposedly raping Homer.

The whole scene was difficult to watch, and left audiences wondering what on earth could have been the reasoning behind putting it on the show. While it’s true the Simpsons got into the worst trouble for the things they said about other countries and powerful figures, nothing can compare to this in terms of making fans want to turn off their screens.


In this post: 
The Simpsons
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

After battling Galactus and pinning Hulk Hogan in the main event of Wrestlemania, I've taken a break from living in fantasy worlds, to focus on writing about them. I'm a comic book geek, a wrestling mark, a break dancer, and a scientist. One of those things may not be true.