The Simpsons: 10 Underrated Episodes No One Talks About

The Simpsons has loads of classic episodes, but what about the underrated tales of Springfield?

The Simpsons Marge on the Lam
20th Television

Over the last 30 plus years, The Simpsons has become more than just a TV show. It is a staple of modern pop culture, and an iconic creation that is recognisable even to those who have never seen the show. Everyone knows who Homer Simpson is.

The decline in quality of The Simpsons is legendary, and not every episode is a winner. That said, on the other side of that coin we have the episodes that don't get as much credit as they deserve.

With hundreds of episodes to the show's name some are bound to fall through the cracks, and this could happen for a number of reasons. Some strong episodes in the later seasons are automatically written off without even being given a chance, while some are surrounded by some of the most popular, classic episodes that divert attention elsewhere.

There are so many episodes from The Simpsons that deserve to be talked about more than they are currently - even if they don't feature Sideshow Bob, a monorail, or a murder mystery that would keep the world guessing for months and months.

10. Barthood

The Simpsons Barthood
20th Television

There's no denying that season 27 is a poor one for The Simpsons. The show is at this point way past its prime, and it opens with one of the worst episodes of all time in 'Every Man's Dream'. However, there is one diamond buried in the rough that deserves better than to be thrown in with the rest of season 27.

Barthood is based around the life of arguably the second greatest character in the history of The Simpsons, from childhood through the awkward teenager phase, all the way to adulthood.

The episode touches on why he is the way he is as a 10 year old, as he is somewhat forced to live in Lisa's shadow. We've really only looked at Bart as a rebellious kid before, but when we see why he does what he does as a child starved for praise, it really is quite heartbreaking. Equally though, his reconciliation with his sister at the end of the episode is wonderfully wholesome.

Bart's relationship with Grandpa is also explored as something with real substance, which he haven't really seen since they retrieved the treasure of the Flying Hellfish together. For the majority of the show, Homer's dad is seen as an annoying inconvenience for the family, but how he is with Bart in this episode is quite sweet, and it's genuinely emotional when Bart goes to visit his grave to talk to him.


9. The Debarted

the debarted
20th Television

No show has ever suffered such an infamous decline in quality as The Simpsons (with the possible exception of Game of Thrones), but that doesn't mean that every single episode after the golden age is necessarily bad. Barthood isn't the only diamond hidden in the post-season ten rough.

The best entries that come after this are usually spoofs of some popular movie or story. Building on a framework that has already proven to be popular gives the writers of The Simpsons a better chance of putting out a decent episode. This is exactly what happened with The Debarted in season 19.

People will look past this episode because of the show's general quality around this time, but it is genuinely great. Principal Skinner and Superintendent Chalmers bring new kid Donny into the school with the sole purpose of getting a mole inside Bart's operation, sparking an elementary school version of The Departed.

The rest of the episode plays out with Bart trying to find out who the rat is, and even features The Dropkick Murphy's classic 'I'm Shipping Up To Boston' from the movie. While Homer's B story around getting a loaner car is entirely forgettable, Bart's arc is strong enough and fun enough to carry the entire entry.


8. Eternal Moonshine Of The Simpson Mind

Eternal Moonshine of the Simpson Mind
20th Television

A lot of the episodes on this list have a gimmick of sorts, or are a clear rip off something, much like with The Debarted. Seemingly this was the only way to craft strong episodes after almost 20 years, and season 19's Eternal Moonshine of the Simpson Mind is no different.

Based on 2004's Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, this episode sees Homer go on a mysterious journey, trying to remember what had happened the previous night, and why his family had seemingly abandoned him. It may not have the classic Simpsons comedy of the golden age, but it is a genuinely compelling story.

With only patches coming back to him, since he had Moe fix him the lethal forget-me-shot, the story comes together slowly over the course of the episode, keeping the audience guessing from start to finish. Surely we all knew that Marge would never have had an affair (apart from with Jacques), but it was still a fun mystery.

It wasn't until Homer jumped/was pushed off a bridge that his life flashed before his eyes and he remembered that his loving wife was just planning a surprise party for him. This is a strong, unique episode that gets overlooked simply because it lies within season 19.


7. The Blunder Years

Waylon Smithers Sr The Simpsons
20th Television

By season 13 of The Simpsons the golden age was well and truly in the past, but there were still a handful of great episodes to be enjoyed. The likes of 'I Am Furious Yellow' and 'Papa's Got a Brand New Badge' are regarded as the best of the bunch, but 'The Blunder Years' is just as good as either of them.

Admittedly, the episode does get off to a relatively slow start with Marge's obsession with a paper towel mascot, but once we move past Homer's Chad Sexington prank, it becomes a lot better, and develops into a strong episode overall.

Similarly to Eternal Moonshine, it is based around a genuinely compelling mystery as the family embark on a journey to discover what traumatised Homer when he was a child, concluding with the reveal that it was that he stumbled upon the rotting corpse of Waylon Smithers Sr. It's actually quite a sweet ending, and goes a long way to explaining the relationship and loyalty Smithers and Mr. Burns both share with each other.

As part of the mystery, we also get to see the young Moe Szyslak Experience featuring Homer, made so much funnier by the inclusion of a young Fat Tony, Legs, and Louie. The writers even found time to take a shot at the overplayed 'memory' of Homer jumping over Springfield Gorge.


6. Behind The Laughter

The Simpsons Homer Behind the Laughter
20th Television

Depending on who you talk to, season 11 could be considered the first season outside of the show's best years. Though not terrible, it is disappointing compared to the magic that had come before it.

The season still managed to finish strong however. 'Behind the Laughter' is unlike any of the other 700 or so episodes of The Simpsons, and features some of the most wonderfully meta humour the show has ever offered. This spoof of Behind the Music that looked at the 'behind the scenes' was easily the best episode of the season, and is above all else fun to watch.

Even before things got really bad for The Simpsons, the show proved that it was able to poke fun at itself, from Homer having to take over the Springfield Gorge stunt, to Lisa having to take growth hormones to prolong the series, and calling out the ridiculous plot of 'The Principal and the Pauper' as nonsensical.

This is such a unique episode, and genuinely full of laugh out loud moments, but it currently barely cracks the top 200 episodes on IMDb. It deserves to be much, much higher.


5. Marge On The Lam

The Simpsons Marge on the Lam
20th Television

The fifth season of The Simpsons falls right in the middle of the show's golden age, and thanks to being surrounded by the likes of 'Homer's Barbershop Quartet', 'Cape Feare', and 'Rosebud', people often seem to forget about 'Marge on the Lam'.

The episode centres on Marge, and though she is rarely shown to have any close friends, her relationship with Ruth is wonderful and refreshing. It's a pity the Simpsons' neighbour seemed to just disappear from Springfield until season 14, as there was a real relationship that could have been explored here.

Even though Homer takes a bit more of a back seat in this episode, with his wife taking centre stage, his idea of what the ballet is, getting both arms stuck inside two different vending machines and his time with Chief Wiggum are all funny.

We also get treated to a lot of Lionel Hutz in this episode, and he is every bit as funny as you would imagine. In the earlier seasons of The Simpsons, before his tragic death, Phil Hartman was easily one of the show's best guest stars, something that is demonstrated perfectly in this episode. And never forget, sticking together is what good waffles do.


4. Dancin' Homer

Dancin' Homer The Simpsons
20th Television

While some would argue that The Simpsons' best years didn't really kick in until season three, season two is packed full of great episodes. The one that falls under the radar however is 'Dancin' Homer', which somehow finds itself as the joint lowest rated episode of the entire season according to IMDb.

This is a real head-scratcher, as it is a simply brilliant episode. From Homer and Burnsy getting drunk together and Bleeding Gums Murphy's ridiculous 25 minute rendition of the national anthem, to the heartbreaking end to Homer's mascot career, there are tonnes of laugh out loud moments and genuinely touching moments too.

Usually, the situations Homer finds himself in are the result of his own idiocy or a dumb mistake he has made, but here he genuinely tried to be the best version of himself, and still wound up as the loser in Moe's telling of how he became such a loser.

Ending with his family's unconditional love and support, this episode managed to strike a perfect balance between classic Simpsons comedy and really empathising with our favourite character in a way that isn't always so easy.


3. Marge Gets A Job

Marge Simpson
20th Television

This is the second episode on this list that is based around Marge, and it's easy to get the feeling that she just isn't appreciated as much as she should be. Though her best role is arguably as a supporting character to Homer's crazy adventures, she does have the ability to step up and carry an episode on her own.

When she gets a job at the power plant to bring some extra money into the house for the family, it is nothing short of classic Simpsons comedy. Her dynamic with the enamoured Mr. Burns is something that we've rarely seen otherwise, and is incredibly entertaining - not to mention Tom Jones' excellent guest appearance.

But that's not to say that Homer isn't on top form in this episode as well. His attempts to fix the sinking house with a Troy McClure video is Homer at his absolute best, and his idea of showing Marge a good time is exactly why we love him so much.

This is genuinely a top season four episode, and though not quite on the same level as the legendary 'Last Exit to Springfield', it certainly doesn't deserve to rank second to last on IMDb, ahead of just the Simpsons clip show episode.


2. Homer Vs The Eighteenth Amendment

Rex Banner The Simpsons
20th Television

This episode suffers a similar fate to 'Marge on the Lam', in that it is surrounded by so many classic episodes, it manages to fall under the radar when it's truly fantastic. Season eight is highlighted by the likes of 'You Only Move Twice', 'Homer's Enemy', and 'The Springfield Files', but 'Homer Vs the Eighteenth Amendment' deserves far more recognition that it gets.

The look at how the likes of Homer and co. celebrate St. Patrick's Day is wonderful, as he's upset that he's not already drunk by 9am, and the entire drunken mess that is Springfield, including Bart, hilariously leads to prohibition being reinstated.

This paved the way for speakeasies popping up all over town (including the best darn pet store in town), and the subsequent introduction of one of the show's greatest ever one off characters, Rex Banner. The no nonsense police chief who replaced Chief Wiggum and whipped the department into shape seemingly came out of a different era, but even he couldn't beat the mysterious beer baron in a game of wits.

This is without even mentioning Homer's methods of making beer and 12 year old scotch in a bath tub in his basement, and the fact that all ducks in Springfield are by law required to wear long pants.


1. Simpsoncalifragilisticexpiala(Annoyed Grunt)cious

The Simpsons musical Shary Bobbins Mary Poppins
20th Television

Whenever The Simpsons has toyed with a change of format, like a musical episode or a clip show, the quality has tended to be quite poor. This particular episode (that absolutely will not be typed out in full again!) however, breaks that trend.

Though not a full musical like season nine's 'All Singing, All Dancing', there is still enough singing in here from Homer, Shary Bobbins, and even Barney Gumble to class as a musical episode, and it is wonderful.

The Simpsons have always been shown to be something of a typical, albeit dysfunctional family, and this is perfectly summed up at the beginning of the episode before it becomes too much for Marge. There are some truly hilarious moments that come from this throughout; from the image of Marge with Homer's hair, to Willie's reaction to seeing Miss Bobbins again, it really is a laugh a minute ride.

Season eight may well be the best the show has ever produced, but this certainly doesn't deserve to be one of its lowest rated episodes as it is according to IMDb. Shary Bobbins and Grandpa taking her umbrella by mistake simply deserve better than that.


Watch Next


The Simpsons: You'll Never Get 100% On This True Or False Quiz!

Bart Simpson
Fox

1. Bart Thinks Arizona Smells Funny.

In this post: 
The Simpsons
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.