The Simpsons: 8 Episodes We Never Got To See

The Springfield misadventures that never made it to air...

Simpsons Homer Marge Bart Lisa
20th Television

The Simpsons aired its first season back in 1989, and since then has become one of pop culture's most iconic and beloved TV shows, recently tying up its 32nd season and airing over 700 episodes of content.

Despite this insane statistic, though, there are several major episodes that fans never got a chance to see. Whether they were written through or simply pitched and never pursued, these long lost adventures were cancelled or left alone for a myriad of reasons, including legal issues, poor timing and behind-the-scenes tension.

Of course, making a TV show - even one as long-running and popular as The Simpsons - is far from an easy task, and it's never guaranteed that every idea will have its time to shine, but as is the case with the majority of these unproduced episodes, you can't help but wonder about what could have been.

From sequels to controversial classics, episodes mocking Scientology, potentially dramatic instalments that would have shed some light on the town's issues with racism, and an infamous, possibly mythological episode about death, here are 8 episodes of The Simpsons we never got to see.

8. Lisa The Scientopteran 

The Simpsons Lisa
Fox

The Simpsons has been no stranger to controversy over the years, having poked fun at everything from organised religion to Hollywood, and government officials to billionaires, but this could-have-been Golden Age episode was apparently a step too far for the showrunners to go ahead with.

Originally meant to air during the show's eighth season, "Lisa the Scientopteran" was written by frequent show writer George Meyer, and would have found Lisa joining a movement strikingly similar to Scientology.

Despite some of the much more taboo topics The Simpsons have tackled over the years, Meyer's script was never picked up for production, left behind because of "legal ramifications" and the fact that "at least a couple of the staff/cast would've felt personally attacked by the episode."

Given the fact that Bart voice actress Nancy Cartwright is a Scientologist, it was probably a good move to leave the episode behind. We all saw what happened with Isaac Hayes on South Park, after all.


7. Homer Tells Bart He Loves Him Best

Homer Bart Simpson
Fox

Not too much is known about this Ken Keely-penned episode, but the title speaks for itself.

"Homer Tells Bart He Loves Him Best" sounds, at its core, like a classic Simpsons episode, full of witty satire that balances its outlandish humour with a great deal of heart and family drama.

Basically, the episode would have found Bart succeeding at something he'd often failed at - an exam is a safe bet - only to then have Homer tell his son he loves him more than his other kids. The rest of the episode would have been dedicated to Homer seeking forgiveness from Lisa and Maggie.

With a write-up like that, one can't help but think the episode would have been reminiscent of "And Maggie Makes Three," another personal odyssey into Homer's relationship with his kids that is the perfect balance of hilarious and heartbreaking.

Why "Homer Tells Bart" was never produced hasn't been revealed, and given its potential, that really is a shame.


6. Military School

Bart Simpson
Fox

In the early years of The Simpsons, Bart was the show's break-out star, a rebellious daredevil whose behaviour was both controversial and beloved.

Over the course of the show, Bart has done countless terrible things, including killing a bird with a BB gun, ruining Christmas (more than once), and destroying Groundskeeper Willie's life with an over-the-top "prank."

This episode, simply titled "Military School," would have seen Bart take his delinquent behaviour too far, resulting in him being shipped off to a strict military school, where he'd realise the error of his ways and vow to straighten up.

Though it's not known why this episode was scrapped, "Military School" was partially re-vamped years later as the Bart/Lisa-centric episode "The Secret War of Lisa Simpson," which found the siblings working together to beat military camp and combat gender norms. So at least it wasn't a total waste.


5. Homer The Narcoleptic

The Simpsons Mr Burns Homer
Fox

Written by David X. Cohen, "Homer the Narcoleptic" would have taken one of the show's most famous recurring gags and turned it into a concept for a full-length episode.

In it, Homer - often seen sleeping at work, at church, at home and everywhere in-between during the day - would have been diagnosed with narcolepsy, a very rare condition that causes people to fall asleep without warning or reason, usually in the middle of important tasks.

Needless to say, this premise would have led to some hysterical mishaps, especially when you consider all the public places Homer visits on an episode-to-episode basis, and that one of the best treatments for the disorder is exercise - something Homer has proven on more than one occasion is far from his favourite thing.

Though it could have been a slapstick masterclass, the episode was only tentatively pitched and then left on the cutting room floor.


4. Thirtysimpsons

The Simpsons
20th Television

A planned episode meant to be a part of the show's third season, "Thirtysimpson" was written by David Stern and would have found Homer - forever and always the impressionable goofball - falling in with a group of local yuppies (young urban professionals) and attempting to adopt their lifestyle.

Meant as a crossover with the cult drama series Thirtysomething, former showrunner Mike Reiss has gone on record to say the episode would have found Homer disillusioned with his life and desperate to change his ways, only to realise his life is pretty great and his wife and kids are enough for him to be happy.

Though this sounds like classic Simpsons through-and-through, Reiss said "Thirtysimpson" went unproduced because the story didn't quite work and apparently wasn't "the style of the show."

Elements of the episode were adopted over 10 years later in the show's 24th season instalment "The Day the Earth Stood Cool," wherein Homer befriends some hipsters who move in next door.


3. The Prince Episode

The Simpsons Michael Jackson
Fox

Unofficially titled "The Prince Episode," this early season could-have-been was originally imagined as a sequel to the infamous Michael Jackson-centred "Stark Raving Dad."

The episode would have seen Leon Komposwsky return to Springfield, only this time he believes he's Prince, not Michael Jackson. Whilst in town, he gets everyone to loosen up, try new things, and cut loose sexually, leading - one assumes - to some top-tier ensemble comedy from the town's easily manipulated residents.

The original script was written by Conan O'Brien, and when it was sent to the actual Prince for proof reading, the late singer hated it and the way Leon's impression of him had been written.

Prince sent the script back with numerous notes, many of which were said to be focussed on the clothes Leon was wearing, and basically demanded the writers to make another script. As a result, the whole thing was dropped and Prince never came to Springfield. Cue the tears.


2. Homer Vs. Dr Hibbert

The Simpsons Dr Hibbert
Fox

The Simpsons has seemingly done it all. It's made fun of entire nations, religious communities, celebrities, actors, Hollywood, gangsters, addiction, musicians, capitalism, vegetarianism, superheroes, comic books and everything in-between.

But for all its clever assessments of American culture, it's never really tackled the theme of racism.

Back in season seven, writer Greg Daniels pitched an idea that would have seen Homer and Dr Hibbert - one of the show's only major Black characters - clash over the intricate issues of race and intolerance in Springfield.

Under the working title "Homer vs. Dr. Hibbert on the Issue of Race," the episode was worked and re-worked in hopes of fitting it into the season, but in the end it was dropped because "the topic was just too incendiary to be dealt with effectively."

Whilst it's a shame we never got to see the premise play out, the episode is still unquestionably one of the most interesting unproduced Simpsons on offer. Even if it probably wouldn't have been that funny...


1. Dead Bart

Dead Bart The Simpsons
Fox

Where to start with "Dead Bart"?

Well, it's probably worth noting that the episode isn't real. For years, there was an incredibly dark rumour cruising the Internet that claimed that Matt Groening - going through a tough time in his personal life - wrote an episode that saw Bart Simpson die, and followed his family and friends as they grieved.

Originally appearing on a Creepypasta site, it's very safe to assume that "Dead Bart" doesn't exist, but it's become such an important part of The Simpsons' mythology that it deserves a shout-out.

The Simpsons has touched on death rarely over the years, with few characters being entirely killed off the show (Maude Flanders, Bleeding Gums Murphy and Frank Grimes being some major exceptions), but "Dead Bart" would have taken things to new extremes, killing off a key member of the family in an episode with no real comedy.

Thankfully we've never seen it, but you can't help but wonder what such an episode would have looked like on-screen.


In this post: 
The Simpsons
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/