The Sopranos: Ranking Every Main Character Worst To Best
The Sopranos Characters Ranked: Running down New Jersey's finest.
The Sopranos secured its status as the de facto greatest TV drama of all time through great plots, daring darkness, and a distinct world view among many other aspects, but more important than anything else is its deep cast of amazing characters.
The show is full of guest and recurring stars, but the core cast alone is stacked with some of the greatest creations in TV history. The main characters of The Sopranos are varied in most ways, but all make up a great piece in the puzzle of this inimitable show.
It’s tough, therefore, to say that one of the main characters of The Sopranos is the “worst”, but if we’re tasked with doing so, there are undeniably some characters that stand out more, contribute a greater amount to the overall story, or otherwise entertain us in a way lesser characters don’t quite manage.
Each of these characters has plenty to offer, but when it comes to The Sopranos, the weight of expectation can mean that an otherwise very good character can’t help but pale in comparison to some of the others.
15. Artie Bucco
Artie is that one guy in a friendship group who gloms onto the tougher kids to keep himself insulated - the Richard Hammond of The Sopranos, if you will. The restaurateur and wannabe Casanova starts the show as an important connection to Tony’s life pre-mob, but his efforts to carry himself like a gangster while staying out of any real trouble make him a grating presence.
A walking midlife crisis, Artie can’t help but fall in love with the various young women he employs at Vesulvio. More often than not, these women are involved with the mobsters who frequent the restaurant, and frequently result in humiliation for Artie.
His nadir comes when he gets involved loaning money to an acquaintance. He tries to handle his business like his good pal Tony, but ends up making a major fool of himself, and a botched suicide attempt leaves him in debt to the mob and firmly in Tony’s bad books.
It seems the writers run out of Artie material as the show rolls on and becomes increasingly serious; with all the other drama going on, Artie’s self made problems seem impossibly minor.
14. Janice Soprano
It’s worth noting that Janice is supposed to be an irritant for Tony and those around her, and she’s perfectly portrayed by Aida Turturro as a vain, spiteful, opportunistic woman who’s just as big a thorn in her brother’s side as any of his actual professional rivals.
Sometimes, though, her grating qualities are just a little too successful. Janice has a propensity for shacking up with the show’s least sympathetic side characters - Richie, Ralphie. When she has her fill of that, she weasels her way into Bobby’s life, shaking up the family of one of The Sopranos’ sweetest figures. That she does so by way of a ouija board, frightening Bobby’s kids following the death of their mother, makes her all the more villainous.
Janice is often presented as the kind of antagonistic figure who somehow always gets away with everything by virtue of her statement. When her reckoning does come, it’s brutal beyond belief. While it would be unfair to say she deserves it, with Janice the other shoe was always going to drop eventually.
13. A.J. Soprano
A.J eventually becomes a worthwhile character capable of carrying dramatic storylines. The last couple of seasons, in which he reckons with the violence of the world around him, struggles with his mental health, and eventually finds peace, sees A.J at his most engaging, and some of his scenes with Tony are truly moving.
Prior to that, though, A.J is little more than a prop, a piece of the puzzle that is Tony Soprano, who fears first that his boy will turn out like him, and later that he’s raised a lazy good for nothing.
Early seasons see A.J listen to early ‘00s nu metal, throw tantrums about food, drink Snapple, and under perform at school. The writers evidently needed the character to have a presence beyond being a kid you sometimes see in Tony and Carmela’s house, but they didn’t give him a great deal to do.
As he slowly comes to understand his father and then embrace the nihilistic side of young manhood, he becomes far more compelling, but for much of the season he’s not developed far beyond a joke.
12. Salvatore "Big Pussy" Bonpensiero
Season two’s finale is one of The Sopranos’ high points. Tony and co cornering Big Pussy on his boat, finally outing him as a rat, and then assassinating and dumping him in the ocean, is a game changing moment for the show, an underscoring of the fact that anything can happen, anyone can die.
Big Pussy was never the most engaging of Tony’s crew, though. The rest of his associates all have far more interesting or entertaining hooks - weird quirks, familial connections and personal demons. While Big Pussy gets perhaps the most screen time out of any of the gang in the early days, he’s a fairly vanilla gangster comparatively speaking.
It would be a couple of seasons in before the entire mob had been properly developed, and accordingly Big Pussy is more of a plot device than a fully fledged character by the time he takes that ill advised trip on The Stugots. His memory haunts Tony for a while after, but most of the impact comes from the fact we’re told he’s such a close friend of the boss - we don’t actually get to see it all that much.
11. Meadow Soprano
The arc of the elder Soprano child is an underrated piece of the puzzle, a seriously dark piece of storytelling. Meadow starts life as a precocious and ambitious kid who wants nothing to do with the family business and aspires to a career in medicine. By the end, she’s taken the easy way out, switching to law and marrying the son of a Soprano family soldier.
In between, though, there are plenty of moments in which her character is far from the most engaging, particularly around the middle of the series. Her season three dalliances with Noah (one of the most irritating Sopranos characters ever) and the idiotic Jackie Aprile Jr are slow points, and her repeated fallings out and reconciliations with Tony can become tiresome.
The subtle downfall of Meadow Soprano is certainly intriguing and well handled, but it’s hard to imagine that she’s a favourite character of many if any Sopranos fans. With everything else going on, we’re not pining for any more time to be spent on Meadow’s occasionally rocky relationship with Finn.
10. Silvio Dante
One of The Sopranos’ great strengths is its ability to mix the deadly serious with the deeply silly. Some of its finest episodes like “Pine Barrens” are as funny as any great sitcom, and as dramatic as the show gets, it was never afraid to get weird with an extended dream or fantasy sequence.
That said, consigliere Silvio Dante is at times so odd as to seem like he’s drifted in from another show. From his slick, rockabilly look to his permanent upturned mouth and bizarre mannerisms, Silvio is by far the least naturalistic character in a show that for the most part aims for realism.
It doesn’t help that, if we’re honest, Steve Van Zant is by a way one of the weaker actors on the show. The E Street Band guitarist came to the profession late and lacks the craft of many of his colleagues, He’s great fun in the part but his relative inexperience can be starkly exposed in a cast of this quality.
Silvio is a likeable and capable character in the Soprano crew, but is so riddled with peculiarities as to stand out, not always in a good way.
9. Bobby Baccalieri
Everyone could use a pal like Bobby Bacala. He’s kind, warm, and friendly, a great dad, and eventually becomes a vital part of the Soprano organisation. Bobby starts life as a joke, a schlubby, less than bright peripheral gangster, but winds up married into the family and a high ranking member of the crew before his untimely death.
He’s, relatively speaking, one of the more morally upstanding characters, tasked with looking after an ailing Uncle Junior and carrying out collections rather than perpetrating acts of violence. All the same, Bobby is not to be trifled with. A dedicated family man, he confronts the hot tempered Paulie after the latter endangers his kids’ well being, and defends Janice’s honour in a winning effort, fist fighting with Tony.
An even tempered mafioso whose laid back vibes belie his voice of reason qualities, Bobby is one of the few Sopranos characters you could imagine having a beer with and living to tell the tale. His arc takes him a fair distance from where he started, but he retains his basic humanity.
8. Jennifer Melfi
While The Sopranos would evolve into a wide ranging drama that investigated crime, the modern family, and America itself, its initial hook was simple: a gangster goes into therapy. For the first few seasons, no relationship was more important than that between Tony and Jennifer Melfi, one of the most complex and ever-evolving on TV.
Goodfellas allum Lorraine Bracco plays Melfi perfectly. She’s simultaneously fascinated, repulsed, frightened, and intrigued by Tony. Their initial scenes see the two feeling each other out, Tony seeking a quick fix to his panic attacks, Melfi figuring out how - and if - she can help this man.
Melfi gradually becomes less prominent in a manner that feels entirely natural. Her goal is to help Tony change and improve as a man; ultimately, though, it becomes all too clear that he has no interest in doing any such thing.
The two part on fairly acrimonious terms, but more than any other character it’s fascinating to muse on what Melfi did next. While she never waded into the storm of Tony’s criminal existence, few characters can have been changed so thoroughly by entering his orbit.
7. Paulie Gualtieri
Paulie is, ultimately, comic relief, a character with little in the way of complexity for the first several seasons. He’s a violent, neurotic career criminal, prone to jealousy, petulance, and showing off for the boss. In filling this role, though, he’s an absolutely vital presence, allowing the viewer to wade deeper into this murky world by virtue of this silly (but believable) man.
Unlike Silvio, Paulie is a completely recognisable figure. He’s the veteran worker who feels that his time served makes him a shoo in for any promotion. His bitterness towards young up and comers, most notably Christopher, is the bedrock of some of The Sopranos’ funniest material. The two form a double act of immense comedy quality, whether they’re getting stranded in the woods or accidentally murdering a rude waiter.
Tony Sirico’s magnificently adolescent performance is rewarded with heavier material towards the show’s end game, including a moving arc involving his birth mother, a challenge to which he eagerly rises. You wouldn’t ever want to meet Paulie, but as an on screen presence he’s a brilliant one off.
6. Livia Soprano
Nancy Marchand only appeared in the first two seasons of The Sopranos before her death led to a regrettable CGI constructed goodbye to the character, who similarly died in season three. Even limited to a relatively brief chunk of the show’s overall run, though, there can be few characters whose presence hangs as heavily over proceedings as Livia Soprano.
As Melfi and Tony dance around in various therapy sessions, the secret to unlocking our protagonist is his parenting, particularly the flighty, volatile stylings of Livia. Though she’s a frail old lady by the time we meet her, she’s no less terrifying for her lack of physical presence. She has a man with the power of Tony Soprano jumping through hoops, and winds up conspiring with his uncle to have her own son whacked.
She no longer dominates the storylines following season two, but her ghost is always there to haunt Tony, influencing his decisions and appearing in dreams and flashbacks. The very mention of Livia is often enough to send Tony into a blind rage - now that’s real power.
5. Adriana La Cerva
The closest thing The Sopranos comes to having a truly innocent character, Adriana La Cerva endures one of the most tragic arcs in the whole series, living in fear and misery for the best part of three seasons. With her iconic wardrobe, endless reservoir of sass, and heart stoppingly tense storylines, she’s one of the show’s finest creations.
Drea de Matteo first appeared in a bit part as a hostess, but her screen presence was such that David Chase expanded her role into Christopher’s girlfriend and eventual fiancee. Unlike some of the other mob wives, Adriana doesn’t shy away from the life she’s marrying into, but neither does she luxuriate in it. She doesn’t love Christopher for his money or power - she just loves him, making her downfall all the more tragic.
When Adriana is eventually outed as an FBI informant and whacked, fans prayed for a twist in the tale, for the reveal that she had been spared, but it wasn’t to be. Adriana has her less than noble qualities, but she stands as the moral centre of this show, relatively speaking at least.
4. Christopher Moltisanti
Few characters in The Sopranos, and by extension TV drama at large, can boast as rich and dramatic an arc as that of Christopher Moltisanti. One of the most important characters on the show, his journey is a hubristic tragedy, as he evolves from a promising young worker to a burnout and finally a burden.
Michael Imperoili is given the scope to put on one of the showier performances, with Christopher almost a romantic lead at first, the dark, brooding princeling who wants to prove himself to father figure Tony.
And then it all goes wrong. Christopher gives himself over to mob life and his addictions, in the process giving up all his humanity - he chooses his mafia career over Adriana, and eventually gives up all chance of living a normal, put together life.
The tragedy of Christopher’s demise is that it’s so small time. He was once the third or fourth lead of the show; he’s mercy killed by Tony after turning to drugs one time too many. It’s a beautifully executed slow burn of a decline.
3. Tony Soprano
One of the overriding questions of The Sopranos is whether a fundamentally flawed man is capable of change. The ever-cynical styling of David Chase comes up with the conclusion: no, he is not.
Tony Soprano anchors the entirety of the show, and his is a presence like few characters before or since. As portrayed by James Gandolfini he’s one of the most watchable figures ever seen in the media. He’s a fully fleshed out human being, with wants and desires, a complex backstory, the total package.
But he’s no static presence - Tony evolves throughout The Sopranos, constantly for the worse. We see Tony given chance after chance at salvation, near death experiences and other wake up calls that could see him change course - but he never, ever does.
By the end of the series Tony is more monster than man, and Gandolfini masterfully moderates his performance accordingly. While Tony was once capable of energy and enthusiasm, now all he can do is hate, consume, and accumulate more. It’s a bold move to make for your show’s protagonist, and one you could only do with a character so well established as Tony.
2. Junior Soprano
Junior Soprano takes the archetype of the dignified elder statesman mafioso and turns it on its head over and again. A character equal parts tragic and hilarious, he’s a cantankerous, often downright villainous figure who through it all is simply too funny and entertaining to truly dislike.
We first meet Junior as he vies for leadership of the family in the wake of Jackie Aprile’s death. A lifelong sideman, Junior has neither the cunning nor the stomach to topple Tony, and after a brief stint as a figurehead boss, reverts to his familiar role of grumpy old man and occasional voice of wisdom.
The decline of Junior’s mental health is terrifyingly realised, unflinching and totally believable, but with his later years comes some of the show’s funniest ever material. He forms a ludicrous double act with Bobby and seems to live only to make other folks’ lives that little bit less enjoyable.
It’s a testament to the character that you can feel so sorry for Junior by the end after all he’s done. The depiction is that harrowing, and his antics that entertaining.
1. Carmela Soprano
More so than Tony or any of the mafia characters, Carmela Soprano is the most fascinating presence the show has to offer. There can be few creations with such a rich internal life, such complex morals as Carmela, who strives to convince herself that she’s a good person in the face of mounting evidence that she’s anything but.
The show makes no bones about Carmela’s complicity in everything Tony does and has done. As her cutting psychiatrist puts it in season three, she lives on blood money. She’s fully aware of her moral culpability, but makes no effort to change her ways because she’s far too used to the good life she enjoys.
Carmela’s arc of corruption is more subtle than Tony’s. Over the course of six seasons we see her come to accept more and more of the dark side of her existence, to question less, to go with the flow. She makes a token effort to push Tony in the right direction and clearly loves her kids, but other than that she’s every bit as amoral as her murderous husband.
Without the flashy storylines and action sequences, Carmela manages to be the most fascinating character on the best TV drama of all time.