The Umbrella Academy: 10 Biggest Changes To The Comics

An adaptation of a comic book making changes to the source material? Surely not!

Umbrella Academy Thumb
Dark Horse Comics/Netflix

The Netflix adaptation of Gerard Way and Gabriel Bá's excellent Umbrella Academy series has been a delight so far, with the first season featuring some great writing and brilliant performances to match. Factor in some pretty slick special effects, that being something small-screen outings usually struggle with, and you're left with one of the most compelling comic book TV shows of the last few years.

Though, while the show was very enjoyable, fans of the source material will be quick to point out that there are plenty of noticeable differences between both versions, much like any adaptation.

And while alterations to these elements may not have detracted from the objective quality of the show - with some of them even serving as improvements over the original or simply making more sense with it being a TV show as opposed to a comic book - they are changes nonetheless.

From the visual appearance of certain characters, to even the very nature of their powers and the world they live in, the Netflix series actually divested quite heavily from the original comic. Here are the biggest changes that Netflix made to the Umbrella Academy comic...

10. The Lack Of Abhijat

Umbrella Academy Abhijat
Dark Horse Comics

There are quite a few characters in both versions of the Umbrella Academy, but if you thought that there somehow weren't enough onscreen, then that may be because the TV show missed out one member entirely.

Over the course of the comics, Abhijat has been a recurring - if not especially vocal - character, one who has been making regular appearances since the first issue, being the bodyguard of Reginald Hargreeves.

Though, despite being in such a position for so many years, the Academy do not value him nearly as much as Pogo or their mother, most likely due to his more quiet, subservient role in their lives compared to the other two.

This is most likely why the character was not included in the Netflix adaptation, as casting someone to simply stand in the corner of shots while wearing a fancy uniform would have probably been a bit of a waste of the show's budget.


9. Allison's Powers

Umbrella Academy JFK
Dark Horse Comics

Another one of the slightly more minor changes on this list, Allison's powers seem to have been altered somewhat during the transition from the comics to live action.

You see, in the books, Rumour's abilities were a tad more substantial than the Purple Man-esque mind control displayed on-screen. In the original comic, each time she uttered the phrase that gave her her codename actually altered reality, as opposed to merely directing a single person.

Probably the most notable use of this version's powers is probably an event in the second volume, which saw Allison being forced to assist Number Five and the Temps Aeternalis to correct the timeline by assassinating President John F. Kennedy, by... well, you can read what she says in the image above.


8. Allison's Forgiveness Of Vanya

Umbrella Academy Allison & Vanya
Dark Horse Comics

Yep, it's another one on Rumour.

So, in the show, most of Allison's shared screen time with Vanya focused on her attempting to make amends to her sister, help her, or convince her of the fact that Leonard/Harold was not the nicest of men. Even after Vanya slit her throat, Allison maintained her supportive disposition, going as far as to risk the fate of the world in an attempt to save the violinist.

Though, in the comics, Allison wasn't exactly as forgiving as her on-screen counterpart. After the whole White Violin fiasco of the first volume was concluded, and the two were both awake (with Vanya having initially lost most of her memories as a result of being shot in the head), Rumour decided that she would put her sister in a room filled with screens monitoring the chaos caused by the characters prior apocalyptic actions, and strap her eyes open so that she would be forced to watch.

Granted, Allison does eventually come around, and help Vanya literally get back on her feet, but when compared to the show, you can see that there really is quite a massive difference in how the character acted toward her sister.


7. Diego's Romantic Attachment

Umbrella Academy Diego & Vanya
Dark Horse Comics

In the show, Diego (AKA Kraken) was depicted as having fallen for Detective Patch. However, this is not actually something that happened in the comics, with Detective Patch not even existing in the source material.

Instead, Diego follows the example of his brother, Luther, by falling for one of the girls that they grew up with.

In his case this was Vanya. When the pair were young, they were both members of the band Prime-8s, which their father gave them a grilling about after hearing that they got into a brawl at one of their gigs. This led to Vanya being given the chance to learn more classical music in Paris, but after refusing, Diego offered to run off with her to continue the band - something that never happened due to Vanya realising that Kraken was meant for saving people.

So, she left for Paris and then, years later, wrote Extraordinary, which infuriated Diego as much as it did in the show, meaning they never got together. Still, it was obvious that he had feelings for her, even amongst all the resentment...


6. The Commission

Umbrella Academy Temps Aeternalis
Dark Horse Comics

Somehow, despite how mysterious The Commission remained in both the comics and the show, Netflix sure did make some radical changes to their identity.

The time stream correcting organisation aren't even called The Commission in the books, being instead named the vastly more badass Temps Aeternalis, but the changes most certainly do not end there.

Even compared to the murderous lunacy of the on-screen incarnation, the comics depict a far more sadistic group, one which doesn't have cutesy, 1950s style rooms full of people using type writers (at least from what we've seen of their headquarters), but rather dark halls filled with men and women in red gas masks and suits, that repeat the mantra of their organisation as if they were a part of a cult.

It's not like the treatment of their employees encourages such dedication though, with Number Five having been forcibly plucked from time to join their ranks, and then (again forcibly), having undergone surgery that stripped him of his humanity by combining his DNA with that of several serial killers, turning him into the perfect killer.


5. The Handler

Umbrella Academy Handler Comics
Dark Horse Comics

As you may now expect from the massive changes to the Temps Aeternalis, the being that played a major role in its leadership in the show was also a bit of a departure from that of the comics.

While the show may have displayed the Handler as a woman dressed as though she is constantly attending a funeral, the comics followed a route that's a bit more out of left-field, with the character (who is yet to actually receive a proper name) instead being a goldfish.

Seriously.

Though, in spite of the very different approaches to the Handler's appearance in the comics and show, the character largely maintained the same narrative role in both, except for the fact that they were not at all involved in the whole Vanya situation in the books.


4. Hazel & Cha Cha

Hazel & Cha Cha
Dark Horse Comics

While the pair may have been depicted as murderous lunatics in the Netflix show, the development that they received did make them seem like actual human beings, and ones who could love and care. As for the comic book versions however, their personalities could be summed up in one word: sadistic.

In the source material, we only really see the duo doing three things, those being torturing people, killing people, and getting extremely hyper after eating a bunch of sugar, meaning that they weren't really much more than trigger-happy children in the books, and readers never even get to see their actual faces.

At least the comic book versions got a death actually worthy for the characters, with Klaus possessing Hazel and then blowing Cha Cha's brains out (literally) before turning the gun on his host body, unlike the engulfing by apocalyptic fire that they were stuck with on-screen.


3. Klaus

Umbrella Academy Klaus Versus Moon
Dark Horse Comics

While Klaus may have been one of the best elements of the show, due in most part to Robert Sheehan's brilliant performance, there was quite a large amount that was changed about the character during his jump to Netflix.

The most obvious difference is Klaus' powers, with the version in the show being vastly more underpowered than his comic counterpart. In the books, the character still retains the ability to commune with the dead, but also has access to some incredibly powerful telekinetic abilities, ones great enough to be able to stop a "forty-thousand-ton chunk of moon" dead in its tracks.

The other big change is simply how much better The Séance is at dealing with constantly seeing the deceased, as while the character is nowhere near sober in the comics, he is always much more composed, being the owner of a few successful businesses and becoming a father during his time spent in Vietnam.


2. The Origin Of Vanya's Powers

Umbrella Academy Orchestra Verdammten
Dark Horse Comics

Both the first season and first volume of the Umbrella Academy featured Vanya (AKA the White Violin) as the unlikely main antagonist, though her path to villainy is extremely different in the two versions.

Onscreen she is manipulated by Leonard Peabody/Harold Jenkins into turning on her family and unleashing her newly-discovered abilities on them, but, seeing as that character does not exist in the world of the comics, the story is quite different.

Originally, Vanya is invited to perform by the Orchestra Verdammten, despite her having given up on music in the books, being chosen as the one to play the Apocalypse Suite by its conductor. Initially she refuses, but after Diego berates her for "what she did", she returns, going under some dramatic body modifications and emerging as the villain in order to destroy her family.

Vanya ends up in practically the same place in both cases, the comic following a more fantastical route, while the show also stays true to its medium by staying far more grounded.


1. The World They Live In

Umbrella Academy Eiffel Tower
Dark Horse Comics

The Umbrella Academy universe depicted in the Netflix show wasn't exactly realistic, but in comparison to the comics, it was far more grounded.

Something that you would think would be a very obvious difference will be the time period that the comics are set in, that being the late 1970s, as opposed to the present day of the show. Yet, due to the vast array of futuristic technology available in the world of the books and the clothes that people wear, you could be forgiven for thinking that the comics were also set in 2019.

However, the elements that really make the comics more fantastical than the show are things such as the villains that the group face (with their introduction to the world being a battle against the Eiffel Tower instead of some bank robbers, for example); the fact that intelligent monkeys like Pogo are quite a normal sight; or even that the births of all forty-three children coincided with a wrestler knocking out a "space-squid from Rigel X-9" - you know, the usual.

So, as you now may be able to tell, the books stay very true to fantastical nature of the comic book medium, and are far more bombastic and colourful than their TV counterpart.

If nothing else, though, this should give you more reason to read the source material - and you should! Especially if you loved the show.

Read Next: The Umbrella Academy Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs


Contributor
Contributor

Lover of film and comics, and (according to a comment on this very website) a pulsating sack of worthless nothing!